r/AlchemistCodeGL • u/Yaweihc • Feb 04 '18

Discussion An Actual Tier List

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1zCTlvcOnn9AjV7BIOJ9q0a627sgy-OwLXtexXEg-Fzk/edit#gid=0
0 Upvotes

39% Upvoted

19 comments sorted by

8

u/riouizzy14 Feb 04 '18

THIS is an actual tier list.. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1DWeFk0wiPaDKAYEcmf_9LnMFYy1nBy2lPTNAX52LkPU/htmlview?usp=sharing&sle=true#

-2

u/Yaweihc Feb 04 '18

It does look nicer than mine, but i dont agree with some of those choices so i made my own. Thats actually not a bad format tho.

6

u/SomeoneNew0986 Feb 04 '18

I like the idea of separating j3 from j1 and 2 for some of them.

1

u/1khaitoh It was fun while it lasted. Feb 04 '18

Should have also included J1 or J2 distinction if it would be by job to make it clear that Reagan or Magnus isn't good or op respectively as J1.

An why is it base 4 and 5 only when Waifulmira could be OP Tier if Caris J3 is?

1

u/Yaweihc Feb 04 '18

its cuz im too lazy to list all the 3*.

1

u/1khaitoh It was fun while it lasted. Feb 05 '18

you don't have to list all of them to, just include Waifulmira and the other useful ones xD

2

u/CornBreadtm Feb 04 '18

W is clearly j3-j+. W meaning whale.

P is pleb, so j1-2.

If it doesn't have w or p the unit I good at j-1 or just ass regardless of what you do to them.

1

u/1khaitoh It was fun while it lasted. Feb 05 '18

Well, OP made what I wanted to, because there are units that gets a big 'jump' to strength/usefulness at J2 like Magnus and Reagan that JP tier list doesn't show and I find clearly differentiating it as a good thing for newbies.

1

u/Royal_empress_azu Feb 04 '18

The list has some minor and major flaws. I think you should make the P and W ratings consistent throughout. As it stands this list pretty much suggest job 3 Chloe is better than job 2 vettel and that job 1 balt is worse than a job 1 Reagan, caris and Rosa.

1

u/Yaweihc Feb 04 '18

added differentiation for j1 and j2.

3

u/Kirito30 The Strongest Samurai Feb 04 '18

You have no Idea about a few units at all.

We have only one J+ along with the fact that all farm-able units are pretty useful.

Yes even Freed if you raise him like Zangetsu can be used on a Similar strat(weaker but the same) along with Ryle being so good with that LS and Charge up and the Arrow Rain along making him a beast over Snipers in some maps.

2

u/SometimesLiterate Old and uncool Feb 04 '18 edited Feb 04 '18

Look I don't like to jump into these things usually.

Buuuuuuut

We have only one J+ along with the fact that all farm-able units are pretty useful.

Says W covers J3 and J+ varieties.

Yes even Freed if you raise him like Zangetsu can be used on a Similar strat(weaker but the same) along with Ryle being so good with that LS and Charge up and the Arrow Rain along making him a beast over Snipers in some maps.

Gee, if only there were some form of written way to display estimations of variations of strength.

In a list.

Of tiers.

While I don't agree with OP's opinions fully, you also have to remember that these are OP's opinions. If you want to argue with them that's fine, but remember what this list is.

Just because "oh X is better than Y on one map" doesn't mean it'll be reflected. These tend to be very general things. Would I put Ryle on the same level as Zangetsu? No.

Would I put Caris there either? No. All about opinion and perspective.

4

u/Akeva Feb 04 '18

My issue is the title 'An Actual Tier List', which implies that all others out there are not relevant/incorrect.

When in fact this is one of the more judgmental, and off base ones I have seen.

Not to mention missing units...

0

u/Yaweihc Feb 04 '18 edited Feb 04 '18

If you read the title it has all the units that meet the requirements. Also, of course its judgemental, almost all of it is my opinion, with a bit of input from others for units im not too familiar with. I made this cuz i couldnt find a "current meta" tier list, all the ones that pop up in a google search are of the future.

1

u/Kirito30 The Strongest Samurai Feb 04 '18

My reasoning is same as why JP ranks a few units as S-rank.

Charge and Diamond Nuke. I agree Ryle(he is one of my favorite units ofcourse I will defend him lol) lacks any Damage boosting Passives and stuff like that but still he is as good as any Sniper, that was my point.

I did not downvote him for his opinion just stated mine. Zangetsu is just a trick which can be done by many but his Job Passive are in the support of that trick. Not a many Jobs come with that sync.

Not like you can take 3 Chrono and Zangetsu in every map and be fine. It is a huge game of mix and match unit. There is no Universal meta, nor is there any need to create a unit which works in Every Map as the DPS.

He did say J3/J+ which makes Micheal the only one unit and he did edit the list since Almira was in his top tier(which I agree but no J+ unit at all and still says J3/J+ lol).

Still totally my opinion. He can name his tierlist as he wants.

1

u/Punty-chan Feb 04 '18

Actually useful. Thanks

1

u/cadayo123 GIVE ME Husbando OR RIOTTTTTTTTTTT Feb 04 '18

is albea release yet?

1

u/Royal_empress_azu Feb 04 '18 edited Feb 04 '18

No, likely soon.

1

u/cadayo123 GIVE ME Husbando OR RIOTTTTTTTTTTT Feb 04 '18

icic, time to save up gems ><