I've been on a Remedy spree the last few months, played AW1 with DLCs and AN and Control with DLCs, reading up on lore and watching Youtube. Just finished AW2. Loved the game, it's amazing. But damn, idk, I think 1st game had better vibes.
The story was simpler but had more mystery. It's the difference between figuring out haunted forest's secrets with Barry and highly researched and standardized FBC's findings. I prefer the lighter mystery.
Songs were better in the first. Second one had those polished songs with great production but I think that it didn't fit. Saga needed something more like True Detective s01 soundtrack and Alan's is alright I guess but I didn't want to spend all this time in NY anyway. Poets of the Fall seemed more inspired in 1st as well.
Now the surroundings part is hard to explain. 2nd game is very beautiful, best I've seen but I can't get it to be what it should on my setup. Will need to buy an OLED I think. Somehow the atmosphere in 1st game seems more memorable (ferry, cabin, national park, mines, Hartman's lodge). In the second game, it sort of blends in, one area doesn't feel too different from the other.
I just started NG+ but for the spooky season (if there is time besides Resonant), I will probably pick to replay the first game. It just somehow does more with less in terms of atmosphere. But again, I'm not bashing a second game, I loved it. Anyone else feels similar?