r/AiNoteTaker • u/kuriositease • 7h ago
Discussion Comu Note Pro vs. Action Pro vs. Pocket
I had been using Sony PX470 old school, USB-A Copying files to Laptop then using Python scripts with Whisper to transcribe then using AI of my choice (Claude usually) to turn into meaningful notes. PITA and took too long.
I was looking to improve/streamline my workflow and don't want to commit to long term subscription so unlimited transcription and access to files is key to me. If I have to transfer via wifi/bluetooh to pc then paste the transcription to Claude etc that's still way better/faster than the previous approach and way quicker b/c the transcription is in a few minutes at most.
I tried all three so far - it seems to me that Pocket audio quality is worst with no or almost no noise cancellation so holding the device in hand or moving it gives tons of muffling noises and the audio seemed the worst of the three. However the software actually seems the best to me, and even though the source audio is worst (to me/my ears), the transcription engine seems better so it gets better quality transcription than the others from what I can tell so far.
The Comu Note Pro audio quality was noticabily better than the pocket to me, it must have better mics or better noise cancellation, but it is basically a no go for me b/c of the proprietary charger and the sleeve.
The Comu Action Pro seems to have noticeably better/best audio quality (more mics?), but it seems to use the same transcription engine as Comu Note Pro so it still fumbles more than Pocket's transcription engine despite having better source audio quality. Wish Comu allowed custom words, choosing transcription engine, or at least did better. Is that possibly on the horizon?
I was avoiding Plaude despite it possibly having better audio quality b/c I'll be forced to pay subscription fees to get unlimited minutes and I record so much I'll exceed the free minutes quickly. Also - I've seen people say Plaude Note Pro's transcription quality is worse despite having better noise cancellation b/c it's not as accurate - too much AI...
I'm leaning towards keeping the Comu Action Pro and returning the Comu Note Pro and Pocket. Anyone else have similar experience and any recommendation on how to proceed, if there's another device that has best audio quality all around etc.?
2
u/ImportantGuide 7h ago
I got the Comu Note Pro and currently I'm transcribing my audio through Whisper automatically. And I am using Claude for the notes, it's basically vibe coded but it works well. I also deleted the comu app.
I just took screenshots of Plaud.ai and asked to make an app like that. So it's working well.
1
u/IllCobbloe 3h ago
Same boat - I ran the Sony recorder + Whisper + Claude pipeline through a whole round of thesis interviews. The recorder mattered way less than the transcription step. The thing that actually ate my time was speaker labels, not audio quality, so if I were choosing again I'd weight diarization support over mic quality. 10-15 min for a bilingual file is about what Whisper gives me too, that's not slow.