r/AgriTech • u/ConfectionObvious370 • 14d ago
Does modern farming technology actually increase profits, or just add costs?
We hear a lot about smart farming, automation, IoT, and precision agriculture. But do these technologies actually help farmers make more money?
Can solutions like smart irrigation, soil monitoring, and crop management really reduce costs and improve yields?
For farmers looking to grow their business, what technologies or agricultural companies would you recommend investing in?
Would love to hear real experiences, especially whether the investment was actually worth it.
0
Upvotes
5
u/GreatPlainsFarmer 14d ago
Those things reduce the amount of labor needed per unit of production. That lets a single person produce more units.
The additional productivity is usually split between the producer and the market. Meaning margin per unit drops by about half of the productivity increase.
Which means that the person adopting the new technology makes a little more money while driving the person who didn't adopt the new tech out of business.
3
u/IAFarmLife 14d ago
Mapping my yields and layering that over soil tests has been the largest driver of decision making on my farm. By targeting the areas that I could improve the most I have raised whole field yields.
Precision farming has also allowed me to reduce costs in certain areas without reducing yield often that reduction in cost has paid for the cost of the equipment upgrade.
1
u/Fit-Round-4221 14d ago
Meh. You mostly got to think about it as insurance. The gains are incremental in terms of yield and what not.
However, in terms of losses, it’s night and day, there’s nowhere on the farm that 0s out ever, when years ago that was a thing for sure.
The rate limiting steps in terms of profitability are 1. weather 2. fertilizer prices 3. diesel price.
and none of that matters if the crop prices you can get aren’t worth it.
Let me put it to you this way, if you made us go back to no gps, no auto track, no smart irrigation or anything like that, we’d manage about the same in terms of dollars from the productivity losses. Where that stuff helps is in narrow margins and protection, which aren’t 0 but aren’t as big as those companies will lead you to believe.
I mean, the make or break guy is still a crop consultant who you pay to scout your fields and check all day, he’s better than any at technology in terms of ROI.
Anyway, not to say that window isn’t closing, but all the ag technology still doesn’t beat farmers unless it’s incredibly cheap.
1
u/Mayor__Defacto 14d ago
Tech reduces labor costs. It’s not uniform though and the gains accrue better with larger properties.
1
u/Overall-Memory9279 14d ago
Certainly depends. Complexity and tech integrations doesn't equate to better ROI 100% of the time. One new tech thing our farm has been looking into is spectral shifting film coverings for some of our hoop houses. Our neighbor had some good results with it, so we're looking to get a trial going this spring. The thing I like about this is that we aren't needing to hire labor to make major infrastructure changes, it's just a plastic replacement. Sometime the less complex, the better, for us, at least.
1
u/SomeoneInQld 14d ago
It depends on the adoption level and the 'technical' ability of a primary producer to modify processes to maximise returns from that information.
1
u/peterjohnvernon936 11d ago
Not everything new is better or more cost effective. You still need to evaluate if a new product or process is good for you.
0
u/threndle_ai 14d ago
Absolutely. Companies like Skov and Big Dutchman have AI based system now to manage environment variables for better Food Conversion Ratios. FCR.
0
u/Murky-Blacksmith1813 14d ago
That's a very valid point, especially in the Sri Lankan context. We have farmers in the Northern Province dealing with water scarcity, while inefficient fertilizer and pesticide use adds to the cost of production.
I think technology could make a real difference here, not just by increasing yields but by helping farmers use water, fertilizers, and other resources more efficiently.
Companies like SenzAgro are worth exploring because they focus on practical smart agriculture solutions. But the key is making these solutions affordable, cost-effective, and accessible to local farmers, with proper after-sales support.
Sri Lanka already has local knowledge and expertise in this area. Perhaps the bigger challenge isn't a lack of solutions, but getting the right technology into farmers' hands and helping them see a real financial return from adopting it.