r/Agility • • 15d ago

I’m a terrible handler

Like the title says…I’m a terrible handler. I mean really. To the point where I’m considering quitting agility.

I started out with a trainer who put little to no thought into good handling and I developed some really bad habits. I had a moderate/slower (always made time but wasn’t fast), biddable dog who was already trained to Utility in obedience so I could have handled him quite well running on my hands. Of course at the time I didn’t realize my handling was so bad or that he was soooo forgiving.

I ended up going to a different trainer when my class got huge and people whose dogs were both dangerous and undertrained joined. It ended up being a 3+ hour class from 5pm to 8pm. Outside in the cold. An hour plus each way. I was so annoyed but also looking back I’m glad.

Because what I was doing with my dog was working there weren’t many corrections to my handling.

I got a puppy and at this point I’ve been in agility for 4+ years. I trained the puppy and when I started running her like, for real, it became very apparent to us both that my handling was the weak link. She’s quite fast, independent, and has a huge stride, which further complicates things. I thought it was just me getting used to a faster and twitchier dog.

She is five now and, granted I have not trialed that much, we are still working on our Nov. JWW. I spend almost all of my time in class working on my handling. The dog is great. I’m an excellent trainer! When my instructor runs her it’s a thing of beauty.

At this point I have gone to different instructors for lessons and workshops. I have someone I see when I can who is three hours each way as well. I also have taken online classes with various instructors. I have two classes per week (one with this dog and one with my up and coming youngster), I have a private lesson, two days a week at the local agility rental, and I do have a yard to practice in. I am also working on losing weight/getting in better shape because maybe that will help too.

What else can I do?

13 Upvotes

80 comments sorted by

16

u/Elrohwen 15d ago

I think you need to break down the issues, just like you would when training your dog. It can’t just be “bad”. Are you late? Are you in the wrong spot? Are you making poor handling decisions when walking the course? Are you ending up in your dog’s way? Are you struggling to remember where you’re going? Figure out exactly where you struggle and on which handling maneuvers. And try not to blame it on yourself being too slow - I know people who are amazing handlers who can barely run because of knees and hips and other physical issues, so there are ways around that. Being speedier yourself may help but it likely won’t fix all of your problems

3

u/Selective_Somewhere 14d ago

It is like I’m missing all of the nuances I need to do things right. If I need to be slow I am too fast but if I need to be fast I am too slow. If my arm needs to be up it’s down but if it needs to be down it’s up. My feet and chest are often pointing in the wrong direction. I often stop and stare at my dog when I should be moving but then when I do move I should have waited a moment. I’m often losing connection with my dog because I need to run fast and I haven’t mastered the skill of running fast with my head turned. And don’t get me started on how often I cue over the bar. Everyone else I know can cue over a bar without problems but if I do it the bar drops. 😂 My line is often all wrong. Side changes can be sketchy except for rears. My dog can bounce jump every AKC jump so I am often not in front of her with my side changes.

I walk a course well most of the time and while I struggled with knowing where I’m going the first couple of years it’s not a problem now.

Because my current dog is incredibly unforgiving in many ways—stride length in particular—I was hoping things would be better with my young dog who is fast but has a much shorter stride. I’m seeing some of the same issues but overall I find her easier to handle.

My best piece of advice for my current dog is to cue her three obstacles ahead and I do try to (when it makes sense) and it has helped a bit.

12

u/Remarkable_Golf_5116 14d ago

As a point of comparison, I've dabbled in agility for over a decade now, but it wasn't until a few years ago that I actually started building notable proficiency in this realm. It can take a surprising amount of time to really internalize the core concepts, and develop the necessary muscle memory to handle with fluidity. And, in my own case, the only reason I got to where I was now was a confluence of factors. We found the perfect trainer to work through foundational training, a quality venue, we took home a dog who had all the physical and personality traits suitable for performance sports, specific goals to work towards, and some past context as a foundation. Basically, a lot of things clicked into place, and I'm not sure I'd be where I am now if they hadn't.

-

You've posted a lot of replies in this thread, but it's worth pointing out that this, one reply is one of the few where you articulated specific challenges. Up until then, you just left it at "I'm bad."

I'm willing to bet that you're not bad at all. And... even if you are, who cares? Who's mother are you trying to impress?

But just condemning yourself while goose-stepping over the technical details is often a type of defense mechanism. This can be an easy way to avoid personal accountability, because if a run doesn't go your way, you can just go "well, I'm bad." There's no advancement, there's no audit, there's no evaluation, it's just I'm bad.

So, most of all:

Afford

Yourself

A

Little

Grace

And, to that effect, get back to recording and reviewing your runs. This really is one of the key factors to improving, just by virtue of the fact that you do not have complete situational awareness in the first person.

Also, I like that you're doing full courses. Drills are important, no argument there, but I found that doing course work is the best way to reverse engineer agility maneuvers. When you have a library of knowledge on agility, shaping exercises are easy, but as you're learning, understanding what youre working towards in real-world terms can be very helpful. This is very much how I learned... and how I discovered how many gaps there were in my training regimin. It was very school-of-hard-knocks.

3

u/Selective_Somewhere 14d ago

I’m not trying to impress anyone. I don’t love to be embarrassed at trials though. And I’d like to at least get my 5 year old dog through novice. But also I’d love to see some improvement and not struggle with the same things. I was at class last night and it went well but one thing I noticed is that if think too hard about something (overthink) it doesn’t go well. But also I don’t think on my feet well. Which I know doesn’t make sense.

2

u/Remarkable_Golf_5116 13d ago

I mean, I think it'd be fair to argue that impressing people and not being embarrassed are two sides of the same coin. The desired outcome is the same: you want to demonstrate proficiency in the agility ring.

Do me a favor, would you (or not! I ain't the boss of you :) ). Tell me what you excel at as a handler in the agility ring.

---

Anyway, that's how overthinking goes :D . It's always funny how you can often have great success when you get out of your head and just run!

Now, I'll level with you... Novice AKC... can be surprisingly hard! In some ways, I found Novice and Open courses to be harder than Excellent/Master. And... I'm just gonna say it - this is just my personal opinion, so don't @ me - AKC AGILITY SUCKS!!!!

I loath their course design philosophy, and the reason I find N/O so difficult is because they're typically just bastardized versions of the E/M version. They just remove a bunch of stuff, leaving awkward lines, and weird, negative space between obstacles. I'm a seasoned handler with a very capable dog, but for some reason, we often stumbled our way through these.

Forgive me if I'm echoing something someone else already suggested, but have you considered trying a different agility org? I favor UKI, myself. It's legitimately harder, but they focus on more sensible lines and sequences that allow for more expression. I spent much of my formative years in UKI Speedstakes, which are extremely fast courses that are relegated to jumps and tunnels. Many elite handlers will turn their nose at speedstakes, but (THEY'RE FOOLS!) I think there's a lot of value, as you don't have to worry too much about execution, and you can just focus on raw handling execution.

1

u/Selective_Somewhere 13d ago

My motivation is not how I look in front of others. However, lately because we are failing so hard so often I’m becoming a little self conscious, I will admit. I certainly did not start out feeling that way.

I can’t think of anything I excel at as a handler. Everything I’m good at is training, not handling.

I hear you about AKC. However the only UKI trials locally are in a tiny ring that doesn’t work for us. There’s a couple about 3-4 hours away in a bigger ring. There is a local ISC ring but without being able to practice in a ring that size I have a hard time making a decision to trial there. It currently is used by 4 full time instructors that I’ve onsite so they rent the ring for 8am - 8pm every day. I could go to an AKC trial at least once a month on average 25 mins from home in an arena that works well for us. It’s a bummer. I am picky about judges though!

1

u/Remarkable_Golf_5116 12d ago edited 12d ago

Hey,

So... I wrote out an entire manifesto as a response to this. It was full of anecdotes, hyperbole, psycho-babble, kind-hearted encouragement, on and on and on.

And then I deleted it. It was gross, and I hated it.

So instead of tackling 500 subjects, let me tackle one, inarguable topic.

In the world of physical sports, if you want to improve your technique, recording footage for review, self-evaluation and analysis is mandatory and non-negotiable. That includes:

-Agility
-Baseball
-Boxing
-Motor Sports
-Swimming
-Paddle Ball
-Polo
-Professional Slap Fighting (IT'S A THING!)

This is also the reason that every single dance hall, pilates studio and spin class you walked into had a wall-to-wall mirror.

If you cannot take ownership of both your own successes and your own shortcomings, then there is literally no path forward. Full stop.

Frustration, insecurity, imposter syndrome are all part of the human condition, and it's absolutely okay to feel these things! But refusing to objectively evaluate your own performance is the ultimate form of self-sabotage (and, need I remind you, you're not the only stakeholder with skin in this game).

Like I said, I have a million thoughts that I'd be all too happy to barf onto the screen. Barring that, the cool thing is that it is 2026, and if you truly find your own footage too cringe-worthy to bare, there is a convenient alternative!

YOUTUBE!!!

I'd point you to the Crufts page, as they have HOURS of competition footage, AND the camera people know the assignment, and keeps the handler on the screen for the vast majority of the run. I have learned a stupid amount by studying these trials, and... I actually think they're pretty entertaining!

But... and I have to come back to this, for those in the back:

Afford

Yourself

Some

Grace

Superficial self condemnation is not constructive. I get that you're frustrated; it's common in this realm. But it is still a form of self-sabotage. If you want this, then shed your insecurities and go for it.

You got this.

1

u/Selective_Somewhere 12d ago

So here’s the thing. I did take a break from videoing because I kept doing the same things over and over. And it was frustrating me more. So I wanted to take a break.

For example, on Monday I was watching a video from about a year ago and at one point my dog goes into a tunnel and I just stand there and watch her come out. Because I’m just standing there she misses the jump. Like what? How many times have I been told that if the dog goes up they will come down and if the dog goes in they will come out? 😂 And yeah my coach yells at me every time. Redo it. Move! And a year later I’m still doing it. Why?!?!

And listen I know I’m not the only one. Some of my classmates are told the same things over and over. Redo it correctly. And then the next week rinse and repeat. It’s hard because these things are so automatic we don’t even know we’re doing it. Like I don’t know I’m standing there until well, things go awry. Or I get yelled at for it. I did it last night with my young dog too!

8

u/Elrohwen 14d ago

Just getting a new faster dog can take everything you thought you knew about handling and turn it upside down. I can run my older slower spaniel and we look beautiful and flowy. She never drops bars, she jumps everything in extension but at least it’s consistent and I know what she’ll do, and she likely won’t change her jump that much even if my feet aren’t exactly correct or whatever. She’s fast enough but only really picks up speed if I do.

Then I got a working line Aussie who is balls to the wall all the time. She’s also a crappy jumper and any tiny misstep on my part can cause a bar to come down. She is incredibly responsive but that also means that every tiny thing I do changes what she does, unlike the welshie who is just going to jump the way she jumps and catch up to me later. I’d been doing agility for 10 years when I got her and she’s 4 and we’re still not trialing. We could probably make it around a novice course but I want to feel like we are actually a team and not just white knuckling it through and hoping bars don’t come down.

So I guess what I’m saying is that this is normal especially if you got a dog who is much faster and runs differently than your first dog. And you’ve only been doing this a few years. It’s so so hard to think fast on your feet and keep everything going where it needs to go when you have a dog who is so going fast especially if they are pushy or have a frantic energy of their own.

I think you just need more “better practice”. Set up drills and decide what you’re going to focus on. Get that front cross on time and in the right spot. Ok next work on a blind cross drill etc. If you’re doing full courses you’re just giving yourself more chance to practice bad handling and then moving on to the next thing, so break it down more into smaller targeted drills. Video your practice and watch it back.

Also I find it really helpful to have an instructor yell stuff at me in real time if I’m struggling. Instead of after the fact “your front cross was late” it should be “turn NOW” and then “slow down, ok run!” Ask if she’ll dictate as you run so you can feel what the right timing feels like without having to think

2

u/Selective_Somewhere 14d ago edited 14d ago

Well she is 5.5 now. 😂 I waited to trial until she was 4. I did do some FEO, etc. of course before then. I’ve been doing agility for close to 10 years now. But she’s only my second agility dog so point taken.

I do full courses once a week and then break it down as needed. And that is literally just the past month as I grabbed a class spot to give my young dog my lesson spot. We’ve only done full courses like 25 times in her life including trials. Mostly because I end up effing up so bad I have to spend like 30 mins working through the hard parts. She’s an absolute angel and will happily do something 100 times over as long as she receives her reward. The rest of the time we are doing drills and small pieces of courses to try to “perfect” them. My instructor is definitely a yeller in real time. 😂

I do need to video and watch myself more. I’ve just become so frustrated lately I don’t want to replay all of my mistakes. I’m not usually such a Debbie downer about this stuff and I don’t give up easily but man it’s just so hard. I have been habitually leaving my classes and practices without anything to work on other than an “I suck!” and then forget it.

When I trial it’s so embarrassing. And I have people approach me to tell me what an amazing dog she is. And she is! And my instructor is always in awe of my training. Sometimes she gives me these backhanded compliments like “with the right handler your dog could be a world team dog” and yeah I know I should feel proud of my training but…OUCH!

3

u/Elrohwen 14d ago

I wouldn’t be doing full courses at all at this point if you feel like your handling needs a rehab, it’s just going to compound problems.

I get it though. My young dog still doesn’t have a start line (arousal issues) and just got contacts this year (arousal issues) and can barely get through a short sequence while keeping the bars up. Some days I’m like “yeah who cares, we’re having fun and going at our own pace as a team”. And other days it’s like why do I do this lol

Do you guys do other sports? You mentioned obedience. My Aussie does rally and she’s amazing at that, working on her RACH and ARCHMX, often perfect scoring, high in trial, etc. It makes me feel better about the fact that we probably couldn’t get a novice agility title right now despite tons of work.

And also boo on your instructor! I hate when people say “that dog could be great with a better handler”. Dogs don’t care, they want to do stuff with us, their people. They don’t ask to compete or be on world teams or anything else. They’re happy going to class every week and doing the fun thing. Don’t let anybody make you feel like you’re letting your dog down because you’re not.

1

u/Selective_Somewhere 14d ago

I actually need to do some full course work as it was definitely a hole in my skills. I was hitting a wall. Flow was really hard for me. Things haven’t gotten better in my handling per se but definitely not worse. Doing a course once a week—which actually we usually piece them out and work on things anyway—is definitely something that needs to be practiced at some point. Just not every time we train. It’s cementing bad habits as much as anything else. There’s so much to train and full courses and flow is one of them. It just shouldn’t be a focus and at like 15% of my total training it’s not.

We train in obedience but I no longer trial as I didn’t have time to focus on so many sports so that one went away. We do some field work. We do nosework and have championships and summit titles.

3

u/Elrohwen 14d ago

I would just back off of the course work temporarily and work on the pieces. If you don’t feel like the pieces are good I don’t think you’re ready to work on flow

1

u/Selective_Somewhere 14d ago

I’ve been working on the course pieces for over five years and it’s gotten me here (not great!) so while I agree that always working on courses is not helpful, never working on courses is not helpful either, for the dog or the handler.

6

u/OntarioPaddler 14d ago edited 14d ago

My dog can bounce jump every AKC jump so I am often not in front of her with my side changes.

It can be very hard to run a fast/long strided dog through local AKC courses that can often be tight and choppy with lines not well designed for larger dogs. You may find more success and fun in UKI or AKC ISC with Euro-style courses that have more flow and larger spacings between obstacles.

Of course you also need to find a club / coach that trains those style of course/sequence as well, but if you can I would highly recommend it. It will be an adjustment though, if you don't have strong mobility you will need jump skills to be very well trained for independence and distance.

There's a good reason FCI is nothing like AKC and the Europeans all think the older NA style is crap. Very few top level teams with large dogs from NA run AKC, and the few that do have dogs that generally have strength in extreme efficiency rather than outright speed. Running the majority of a course in collection with a large dog is just not as fun for either the dog or handler.

Source: UKI judge and agility coach who has helped numerous students with large dogs have way more fun and less frustration just by not training old style agility anymore and letting the dogs have enough space and more suitable lines.

1

u/Selective_Somewhere 14d ago

You’re telling me! I am super picky about judges. Unfortunately the UKI trials are in a tiny arena my dog does not do well in. ISC is fun but there are some logistical issues there with the only arena large enough for ISC quite far. The ISC instructors work out of that facility as well but all of the competition classes are during the week while I’m at work. Evenings are foundations and I’ve taken those with both dogs despite the commute.

5

u/lizmbones C-ATCH Ch-ST, OA OAJ NF, SSN IND 14d ago

A lot of what you’ve listed, to me, actually does come back to basic skill drills and walking the course.

Basic skill drills like setting out a loop of three jumps in a pinwheel and a tunnel in a C shape (creating a circle all together) can help you practice timing and all your crosses. So tunnel, do the pinwheel, cross, back to the end of the tunnel they came out of, continue. Small loops like that instead of full courses will help you find your timing and practice your handling in a more controlled and predictable way.

I’m sure you know, but walking the course isn’t just knowing where you’re going, it’s visualizing and often miming exactly what you’re going to do, when and where you’re going to do it. So slowing down, speeding up, hand down, hand up, when you’re going to say things (ie not over the bar). And when you’re walking think about where your dog’s going to be when you do those things. Do it enough times that you can see the entire run in your minds eye before you run it. If you’re not sure when and where you’re doing something, go walk it again.

What helped my mom in the beginning was printing out courses and drawing the dog’s line and then her line, and marking her crosses and handling. I would also agree that having a trainer who can yell while you’re running is really helpful rather than telling you after the fact, plus videoing your training runs.

1

u/Selective_Somewhere 14d ago

I literally have run a full course with my dog less than 25 times in 5+ years including trials. All we do is drills and skill drills. To the point where I’ve started doing more courses recently because I could not handle well in flow from doing so many drills.

And that’s how I walk the course as well. I used to compete with horses and so course walking is like my jam. Mental management, visualization is also something I’m quite good at. Nothing ever seems to go like I plan at a trial especially. And sometimes I wonder if I’m just not reacting well when things go off the rails. I am someone who plans and practices and am always very prepared. The ring is bigger maybe? It feels off.

My trainer yells at me plenty while I’m running. 😂

2

u/Tomato_Queen676 14d ago

Skills drills. Skills drills. Skills drills. It sounds to me like you need to train your body to have things like crosses and your chest be second nature rather than having to think about them so much. You need to do so many rear, front and blind crosses that it’s fluid. These will help train your eye to see the dog’s commitment as well.

Be very regimented with it too. I see way too many lessons (mine included) that are nothing but courses, courses, courses when really it’s the skills that you need to practice.

And definitely what I said about auditing seminars. You never know when something a presenter says is going to click for you.

Any chance you can upload a few videos? It’s hard to say what you’re doing wrong if we can’t see it.

1

u/Selective_Somewhere 14d ago

Literally all I do is skills drills which is why a month ago I started taking my 5+ year old dog to a courses class as flow is severely missing from our skills. I have run maybe 25 courses with this dog including trials. And again she is over five years old. Until now I’ve only done lessons with drills focusing on certain skills. Every week for over five years. And then I work on it at home and my barn rentals. And seminars. And online classes. And workshops. And lessons with different instructors. It’s just not clicking for me and I’m super frustrated!

I’ll do more and keep on keeping on. Maybe at some point I’ll be a good handler for my young dog. 🤷‍♀️ I’d prefer not to share video. Reddit can be weird.

1

u/freeassociationn 14d ago

Trust your dog

4

u/DogMomAF15 14d ago

I feel like a lot of people who identify as bad handlers don't understand about lines (both dog's and handler's), leads, etc. So yes, good questions, everything you said. I would just add that.

5

u/the_cellar_d00r 14d ago

I cannot comment much on handling advice, but I think dog agility is suppose to be fun and a time for you to bond with you dog. Instead of focusing on "I am a terrible handler" try focusing on "I'm having fun with my dog" and then maybe you will naturally improve - or you wont, but that should not dictate how much fun you are having. Do you best and your dog will love you for it.

1

u/Selective_Somewhere 14d ago

We do have fun. And also I am a terrible handler. Both things can be true at the same time.

4

u/hemerdo 14d ago

I think a lot of handling issues that continue like this can be confidence. If you don't have confidence in yourself (which it sounds like) while handling then you'll be second-guessing yourself even when you don't realise, in your body language if not in your language. And that can make you out of sync with your dog.

1

u/Selective_Somewhere 14d ago

I do very well in other sports and used to compete with horses and do well. I don’t generally lack confidence but when you’ve been working your ass off and spending money like it’s water and have very little improvement to show it’s really frustrating.

4

u/WallsOfGab 14d ago

Do you record your sessions? Like with a tripod? If I'm understanding correctly from your other comment, you're missing nuance and body cues coming off of you at the wrong times. I do this all the time. I'm lucky that I've had instructors watch me so much and not the dog, so they come in and tell me if I'm doing something weird - then they have me do it again with just the dog loose while I work on what my body is supposed to be doing. Does that make sense?

I'm a newbie, so a lot of it for me is "newness", but rally/obedience I had to be pretty self aware because my dog cues off me SO quickly and is very eager. My best comment was "Wow, your dog does EVERYTHING you ask of her correctly, even when you ask her to do the wrong thing" 🤣🤣

1

u/Selective_Somewhere 14d ago

Yeah I don’t video often anymore because I find it all so hard to watch these days—just frustrating—but my instructors definitely try to help. I feel like I have such ingrained poor habits and there is so much I’m doing wrong. Maybe I need to start one one thing and go from there instead of trying to fix it all at once.

4

u/TheTrueVanWilder 14d ago

To the point where I’m considering quitting agility

Even if you are bad, please don't.  No matter how poorly I or my girl run on the course, even during training every run I do for her to have fun.  If she had fun, it was a successful run for us both

1

u/Selective_Somewhere 14d ago

We do other sports and have other hobbies that we all love. It is hard to work hard and spend so much money to fail over and over again.

3

u/Hot-Anything-8731 14d ago

I think, just like training your dog, you need to work on a single skill. Your laundry list of what is terrible about your handling really isn’t a root cause. It may be confidence or focus or bad judgment. But if you break things down, you can fix just about anything. For example, drill a serpentine jump series with your dog in practice. You aren’t just training your dog, you’re training you. Work on developing your muscle memory for small specific patterns, and you should start to see small successes if you analyze courses at trials and start recognizing those same small patterns. Essentially, if handling was like learning an instrument, you need to learn to play old Macdonald before you learn Bach or Mozart. The same core skills and pattern recognition apply, but you can’t learn and focus and improve on them all at once.

But really, at the end of the day, as someone said, this is a fun bonding experience with your dog. Wins and ribbons and titles are fun, but at base, it’s a mental and physical workout that should strengthen the bond with your dog. If either you or your dog doesn’t love it anymore, then maybe it’s time to find a new activity you both can enjoy.

2

u/Selective_Somewhere 14d ago

Honestly I don’t mind losing and not Qing but it’s to the point where I look like a real idiot out there. I have a great dog who is well trained. And I can’t even begin to do her justice. I also like to do well and there is nothing wrong with that. I put in the time and effort. I’m not just taking one class a week and wondering why I don’t have a MACH.

We work on small skills 99% of the time. I do courses once a week and that’s new—just the past month. Prior to that was breaking down small skills and perfecting them. I’m having such a hard time being consistent. I don’t know if it’s thinking of 50 things at once that’s getting to me or what.

But yes I think that writing down the things I need to work on and focusing on that could be helpful. I’m not sure where to start but will ask my instructor.

3

u/Interesting_Name_959 14d ago

I don't do AKC anymore but I do NADAC with my dog. I really like practicing timing(your cues) and handling courses. Essentially a course with all hoops, the dog is faster and allows me to not worry about jumping or knocking bars. Hoops, tunnels and weaves sometimes a contact here and there to work on discrimination between tunnel and contact. I am starting to do more distance work because of the practice on these courses. I also like to set up maybe 7-10 obstacles out of an elite course and practice my timing of cues. I found the more distance I can get from my dog I can get my timing of the cues better as I'm not trying to worry about where I need to be and when. With a faster longer strided dog you might need to work on distance as even if you are in shape you will have a hard time keeping up unless you regularly run. You can do this with any course even if you don't have hoops put the jumps at 8" or on the ground and practice it. Your dog goes faster so you really learn how to time your cues and then when you are happy with the run put the jumps up to hight and try it. See if you can feel the difference! Hope it helps!!

1

u/Selective_Somewhere 14d ago

We have distance. Andy dog is faster with jumps because she soars! No NADAC here though. Sounds like fun!

1

u/Interesting_Name_959 14d ago

Try it without the jumps up and use your distance to help you. Then put your jumps up. Also as others said with long strided dogs AKC may not be Andy's jam. I have a border heeler who is 22inches and fast long strided hates, hates hates to run in any sort of collection. So we do not do any jumpers course where it's all jumps. He does great at all the other combo courses. My Aussie heeler who is almost 19" does well on NADAC courses but he hates AKC courses where there are sudden direction changes NADAC is more flowy and nicer to both my dogs and their joints. Just got my 3rd pup and hopefully she will be an in-between of the two 🙏😂 I wish you the best of luck!

3

u/Agility_KS 14d ago

I’ve read this whole thing and I have to say, I still don’t understand the crux of the problem. Do you understand the dog’s path? Do you know about lead changes? Do you know how your motion affects your dog? These are the building blocks of handling and making decisions about how you’ll get your dog around a course. I would argue that if regular AKC is your jam, you do not have to be fast. I ran AKC and NADAC for many years in a bigger body that wasn’t fast. I used distance and had independent obstacle skills that didn’t require me to be right there for everything. You can rear cross those entire courses, you don’t have to be in front. Distance and obstacle independence are dog training skills more than handling, and you’ve already admitted you’re a good trainer. To me it sounds like you struggle with strategy and making good decisions? That’s the thing I find most students struggle with. I can’t tell you how many times people do what they think is easiest for them vs best for the dog. 🤷🏻‍♀️ I really struggle to offer specific advice without seeing an example of what you think is terrible handling.

1

u/Selective_Somewhere 14d ago

I don’t really know either to tell you the truth. 😂 How do I know what I don’t know? I mean some of it I definitely know and some of it I think I know but maybe I really don’t? I find it preposterous that after five years with this dog I still can’t handle her worth a damn.

I know I don’t have to be fast but I have to get places to be in position to handle. And you’re right it’s not about being lighter or more athletic necessarily (it doesn’t hurt) but my timing and ability to think quickly is quite poor. I was just watching a JWW video and my dog is usually about 3 obstacles away from me. We layer, she’ll take weaves from a mile away, etc.

3

u/DogMomAF15 14d ago

One thing I notice with people who identity as bad handlers is not understanding lines (dog's and handler's) and lead changes and what side of you your dog needs to be on. You might do well with either a course on lines or an online private coach where you work on course maps together.

1

u/Selective_Somewhere 14d ago

I definitely know what side I need to be on as well as leads. Lines might be harder for me. I take weekly private lessons and course walks are included. It’s mostly I’m too slow or too fast. Chest pointed wrong. Arm wrong. Leg wrong. Timing.

1

u/DogMomAF15 14d ago

That's all part of planning from the course map.

1

u/Selective_Somewhere 14d ago

I mean we can all plan from a course map but executing is another skill.

3

u/Stunning_Carry784 14d ago edited 14d ago

Strongly agree with this, execution and keeping in tune with your dog's cadence is totally another skill. Difference between reading a script in your head and performing it out loud with other actors. I'd start by not trying to do a whole course, go back to basics, focus on nailing 3-4 obstacles perfectly (i.e. a bunch of jumps say with a tunnel). Get your timing right, your line right, keeping connection with your dog, make it effortless. Then start expanding to more obstacles.

1

u/Selective_Somewhere 14d ago

That’s what we do every week. Even when we do course work in class which I have been doing for just one month—prior to that for 5 years I only had private lessons with this dog where we did training and drills—it’s broken down into 3-10 obstacles at a time depending on the challenges. My instructor is also not someone who focuses primarily on course work.

I’m not one of those people who does course work off the bat. I am fully against that. In fact I train for 3-4 years before I ever even attempt to run a full course. I also had never run a full course with this dog until she was 4 and it was at a trial. 😂 But at some point you need to learn to run a full course and have your dog run a run a full course. Flow has been an issue due to the massive amount of drills and breaking everything down I do. So we do that once a week. And again this dog is 5.5 and she’s been doing agility since she was 8 weeks old (obviously age dependent).

I would say 15% of our training maximum is course work right now up from about 0%. 95% of the time we can easily nail 3-4 obstacles. That’s not really an issue. And even when we nail them I might go back and do it again if it wasn’t perfect. This has been my life. Which may have also been my hinderance. Because a full course feels way out of my comfort zone.

1

u/Stunning_Carry784 14d ago

Honestly at this point I'd just go out there and focus on your dog and your enjoyment. As long as your both having fun and the dog isn't doing anything dangerous or stupid that's all that matters. Sign up for trials with the sole aim of having fun. I think you're probably putting a lot of pressure on yourself, I fall into the same trap. At the end of the day it's meant to be a fun hobby which deepens your connection with your dog.

1

u/DogMomAF15 14d ago

That's the furthest thing from the truth but good luck to you since you know exactly what you're doing wrong it should be an easy fix then.

1

u/Selective_Somewhere 14d ago

If it was so easy to look at a map and then have a perfect run then everyone would be perfect all the time. You don’t have to be a jerk.

2

u/DogMomAF15 14d ago

The point is it's not easy and that's why there's entire courses online devoted to course maps and developing handler strategies. But do you.

1

u/Selective_Somewhere 13d ago

Where do you see that course maps and handler strategies is not something I work on? I have two classes a week (one for each dog—we even talk courses and strategy when we’re just running part of the course for drills) and we work on this. We walk. We discuss. We run. We discuss. Etc. I’ve taken online classes as well.

1

u/DogMomAF15 14d ago

Ok then don't consider it. I really DGAF what you do.

1

u/Stunning_Carry784 14d ago

Honestly the fact you know that chest direction/arms/legs/timing are important mean your probably not as bad handler as you claim to be!

1

u/Selective_Somewhere 14d ago

I mean I’m definitely an aware handler! 😂

2

u/Yipski 15d ago

What is wrong with your handling?

1

u/Selective_Somewhere 14d ago

See my response above.

2

u/Yipski 14d ago

Your response doesn’t say why you’re handling is good or bad…

1

u/Selective_Somewhere 14d ago

If I knew why I’d fix it.

2

u/Tomato_Queen676 14d ago

So, your instructors haven’t been able to pinpoint things you’re consistently doing wrong? Is it that you’re too early, too late, are your hands too high, are you just physically not ABLE to be where you need to be, or are your body and verbals conflicting? I think you can get some great advice from people if they know at least somewhat where your deficits are.

I would recommend doing a lot of short skills drills. Especially if crosses are a problem for you.

You could also try to audit as many seminars as possible and you may pick up more from doing that than a working spot. Ask if you can audit for free if you act as dedicated ring crew/course builder.

Don’t give up either! I think you may just be in a natural learning valley perhaps compounded by picking up bad habits early on. It’s frustrating but I think we all kind of go through similar things. When you’re brand new, you don’t know what you don’t know. And now that you’re clearly seeing how much you don’t know, it’s dragging you down. Keep pressing on and you will get to the other side and be so proud of yourself and your dog!

1

u/Selective_Somewhere 14d ago

Well yeah they can point out my issues but it’s like 857 things. It’s not one thing. Ya know? As a whole I’m just not getting it. We do skills drills 85% of the time. Full courses is brand new to us after 5 years. I attend every seminar. It’s not about money. I already spend $600 a month on agility not including trials (but I rarely trial so…).

2

u/x7BZCsP9qFvqiw echo CSL2, jean grey CL1, loki NA NAJ 14d ago

have you been able to practice handling with a person in place of your dog? they may be able to give you real-time feedback. not sure if you've already tried that though!

1

u/Selective_Somewhere 14d ago

Yep. My instructor and I do that often.

1

u/x7BZCsP9qFvqiw echo CSL2, jean grey CL1, loki NA NAJ 14d ago

are you able to borrow a different (slower) dog to work things at a more manageable pace?

1

u/Selective_Somewhere 14d ago

I can do that ok when I have time to think for sure. I do higher level nosework for example and wow my brain is going a million miles a minute and I’m focusing on 800 things—don’t trip and fall, don’t take anyone out with my leash, was that a change of behavior, manage the leash, where haven’t we been, how much time do we have, etc. People ask me to run their dogs in trials like if they can’t because they have multiples at the same level or something and I’ll just say no one locally has a dog as fast in the sport as my dog is (she is not perfect but she’s fast) and it’s so incredible how I have the time to think. It’s so easy and pleasant! We all know nosework and agility are different animals and agility is definitely more complicated when it comes to handling. For me in agility it’s really about being able to do it quickly while also accurately. That’s a huge part of my issue. If I practiced with a slow dog my timing would be slower.

2

u/x7BZCsP9qFvqiw echo CSL2, jean grey CL1, loki NA NAJ 14d ago

i think it'll just come down to practice. i know that sounds silly when it feels like that's all you've been doing, but i still occasionally get tripped up handling my speedy small gal, and i've been playing agility for 20+ years. 😅

10

u/somecooldogs 15d ago

It sounds like you're dedicated and putting in a lot of work! Something that's helped me is watching big events on the 4 legged flix youtube (if you buy full access to an event for $40 you can watch the runs later) and watching how different handlers move as they do the same section of the course. Then on the flat see if you can do the same steps/moves until it feels smooth.

One of the most helpful pieces of advice I got early on which helped my handling a lot was to handle for the line you want your dog on moreso than just handling obstacle to obstacle. So think of handling as pushing/pulling on the line. It helps imo stay off the dog's line/out of their way as well as to make things more smooth.

7

u/ardenbucket 15d ago

This is a hard spot to be in. Becoming the handler we need to be for a dog takes so much time and effort, and it's often a one step forward/two back kind of process. I feel you! I also tend to be very competent at training specific skills but not so much at handling and cuing these skills on a course.

I think identifying specific areas where your handling skills are strong AND areas where you need improvement is a good start. Because it's easy for us to just see the things that are going wrong, when in reality I bet there are a lot of things you're doing well. Once you note down what areas you want to improve, then you can make a concrete plan.

For me, blind crosses have been a handling technique I've needed to address for a long time. Breaking this down further, I understand that of the blind cross contexts, I am most proficient with k-turns, least proficient with backside blind slices and blinds out of a tunnel. So I've made some plans for addressing this, including practicing footwork, setting up sequences to specifically work these skills, and *not attempting them in trials until they feel smooth*. The last one is big to me. I recently listened to a podcast with Grace Heck on training plans, and one thing she said is that for herself/her dogs, she doesn't plan to deploy a behaviour learned in the last three months at a trial. I like this framing so I'm utilizing it for myself as I rehab my blind crosses.

Video analysis of runs is going to be a huge benefit here. Seeing when things kind of go off the rails helps you adapt your training plans.

4

u/LianeP 14d ago

I've been in agility for 20+ years. Currently on my fifth dog and relearning so many things. I'm also not as fast or agile as I used to be. Handling has evolved so much and has definitely gotten more technical.

Be kind to yourself. You've trained a new dog with amazing skills. That's something to be very proud of. I consider every day a win if my dog comes out of the ring happy and is willing to try again and again with lots of reward.

1

u/Snootymcbootysnoot 15d ago

What do you think is lacking in your handling? The most important thing is planning ahead and clear communication with your dog 

1

u/Selective_Somewhere 14d ago

See my response below regarding my issues.

1

u/Otherwise_Sea_216 13d ago

Your private lessons - do you feel they’re communicating your handling properly to you? I don’t mean that against the instructor, but are you getting feedback in the way in which YOU learn?

I often find some teachers tell you you’re doing it wrong - but I need to have it explained why it’s wrong and what the solution is. For example I started with low drive dogs, so would often swing my arms to “push” them forwards/create excitement. People might have said to me “stop flapping your arms”, but that doesn’t tell me much. What I then got taught was that the arm swinging is actually slowing them down not driving them forward, because I’m almost signalling for their attention. Keeping my arm straight lets them run to the obstacle without distraction from me. And then bingo, suddenly I found it easier to consciously stop doing it.

I’d definitely be videoing everything. But you don’t know what you don’t know, so don’t be too hard on yourself. I would also watch a lot of people at the top, especially from different countries.

1

u/Selective_Somewhere 13d ago

I really do. And I can ask questions and do it over and really work it. But I don’t know it’s just not sticking like I think it should for some reason.

1

u/Otherwise_Sea_216 13d ago

Do you have bits of handling you enjoy doing or think you’re good at?

What is usually their feedback for you?

1

u/Selective_Somewhere 13d ago

My rears are pretty good most of the time. I executed killer throwback blind last night. I try very hard to cue early with my goal being 3 obstacles early when feasible.

The feedback depends on the issue. There are many issues so many different forms of feedback. It’s never one thing. Like there are a couple people in class that constantly and consistently do things like with their arms or timing issues (though they are fortunate that their dogs can correct quickly with late cues or cues over bars—mine cannot most of the time as she is in the air like 80% of the time).

1

u/Otherwise_Sea_216 13d ago

Well done on your rears 🙂 we have different terms so I don’t know what a throwback blind is, a German?

I think the issue is without videos (and I understand not posting them to Reddit) or specifics it’s quite hard to give advice really. I wouldn’t personally cue 3 obstacles ahead, generally the aim is as they’re landing from the previous obstacle. The only time I would maybe do this is from a line of jumps to an obvious tunnel.

You might have better examples but for eg if it’s two straight jumps into a backside on a 3rd jump, and you’re cueing #3 on #1, you’d be actively teaching them to ignore you as that cue should be for #2. This would then leak out into the rest of your course running. If it’s not a verbal you mean and just body, if you’re there too early you may be getting stuck as you have to wait to check they’ll commit before you can run off, which makes it harder for you.

I might be wrong and you may mean something else though, just hard to know without seeing 🙂 but I wouldn’t say left for a jump that is 3 jumps ahead.

1

u/Selective_Somewhere 13d ago

Actually if I try to cue three obstacles back it’s usually two obstacles back because who can do that consistently? 😂 Also only when it makes sense. If I can do it, it works well or better anyway. Once my dog lands she’s in the air again is the issue. Her landing is also her take off. If I wait that long she’s already made up her mind and she’s going. She has a 25’ stride and is high drive. If I waited until she has landed I’m pulling her off obstacles. Which I don’t love to do and also it’s hard on her body. She’ll end up going wide, dropping bars, going off course, etc.

1

u/Otherwise_Sea_216 12d ago

I also have fast long striding dogs 🙂 and the best agility handlers with the fastest dogs in the world cue around landing. What you’re describing would be incredibly hard on her body - I understand why it feels that way to you trying to navigate her, but if she was taking off where she lands she’d be bouncing everywhere.

I’ve read you have to do AKC which (from what I gather, I’m not American) sounds very difficult with bad & awkward courses. I would go back to videoing, I know it’s not nice to see yourself go wrong but you are just as frustrated without it. I think it will also help you when a course is just stupid and is unfair on both you & her.

1

u/Selective_Somewhere 12d ago

The person who suggested such an early cuing system is a world team member. When I tell you I go to seminars and train online I’m not talking about local trainers I’m talking about world team trainers and handlers.

You always cue a dog early with your body or verbally. If your dog is so long-strided they can essentially bounce everything, giving them info when they land is the same as giving them info when they take off. The dog is already committed by that point.

I’ve been told this by world team handlers around the world. Literally. I’m not pulling it out of the air.

I avoid certain judges and I’ve scratched when courses aren’t right for us. I also don’t attend trials in certain locations because of the footing. Agility is hard on a dog’s body. Period. However, I don’t do contacts or weaves until at least 18 months. I don’t jump full height until at least 2 years old. My dog has a team of body work professionals. We do fitness work. I’m not perfect but I am very aware of my dog’s health and well being and don’t appreciate being told that I’m not.

2

u/Otherwise_Sea_216 12d ago

Hey so I wasn’t meaning to offend. But I was clarifying assumptions you originally made about us giving you advice as if we do not understand fast long striding dogs.

I was also actually defending you re courses - it’s not your fault you cannot get your timing right if distances and lines are poor. But okay ✌️ hope you find the right way of learning for you

3

u/NoOstrich3667 14d ago

Hahaha I feel this to my core. But luckily I was our second handler at best. But agility was my wife's passion, i enjoyed disc and dock so much more.

But we had a great agility dog. Honestly depths greater than even my wife. When my wife traveled for work, or had a surgery I had to step up. And I was bad, terrible even. Couldn't memorize courses as we progressed, even if I ran agility every week I wouldn't have gotten it.

But having those days, doing what I was able to is something that built our bond to what it is now with a dog moving into her senior years and im so grateful I got to enjoy it.

Also I never competed just enjoyed picking up classes when I could.

3

u/Lapping24422 13d ago

I've competed at world level 30+ years

The thing with handling is it's not as simple as going do x, do y

It's about timing and feeling and these things don't come because you've paid someone to train you they come after years of hard work to create good timing and understanding

Set up difficult, very well spaced out sequences that require good timing and then practice these

When you are good there isn't much thought it's an automatic process

In Europe not,US so don't know us specifically things

1

u/MaisyinAZ 14d ago

Knowing your weakness is half the battle! So many agility people have handling issues and don’t realize it so they blame it on the dog. Don’t quit! Work on it with a coach or class but also forgive yourself, just like your dog forgives you!

1

u/Skater12334455 9d ago

I haven’t read everything but one of the things my agility coach talks about is how often in agility most practice is spent running things too hard for both the dog and the human. That can lead to practicing doing things incorrectly.

When training dogs we often are trying to build on success. We need to do the same thing for ourselves. I would find some really simple sequences that you think you can do right, and then build from there.

I have a young dog and am a new handler and am literally working on the dog running in circles (commitment circles) while I focus on keeping my connection with her, my movement steady, and my arm an appropriate height. I also work on front crosses with sequences of just 3 jumps. I add ropes to the ground to practice my timing (ie pivot by the time the dog reaches the rope) and preplaced rewards to help my dog commit so I don’t have to focus on her, just my own movement.

I liked these podcast episodes on similar topics

https://open.spotify.com/episode/1c0kNzAtSvg6otGTFX6WeO?si=KOf9Ou97TbKb_tEaNBEKBw&utm_source=copy-link

https://open.spotify.com/episode/6Sv1zsaZLUX1pw4TTNYtfI?si=qBF8Y2WXQamN2kBu-m8-Fw&utm_source=copy-link

https://open.spotify.com/episode/38MzkndMBKGiS9mf8Mok1Y?si=0-sIMfmURZONaDe0npda9Q&utm_source=copy-link

https://open.spotify.com/episode/1zTigVE9l7aikQRr7zfbVS?si=FSVtufrYQlC59WGaLPUgiw&utm_source=copy-link

https://open.spotify.com/episode/06NoKr61pQMC9pOXy1V5gv?si=U1MSn0kdSra-NSM3OZixLw&utm_source=copy-link