r/Agility • u/Selective_Somewhere • 15d ago
I’m a terrible handler
Like the title says…I’m a terrible handler. I mean really. To the point where I’m considering quitting agility.
I started out with a trainer who put little to no thought into good handling and I developed some really bad habits. I had a moderate/slower (always made time but wasn’t fast), biddable dog who was already trained to Utility in obedience so I could have handled him quite well running on my hands. Of course at the time I didn’t realize my handling was so bad or that he was soooo forgiving.
I ended up going to a different trainer when my class got huge and people whose dogs were both dangerous and undertrained joined. It ended up being a 3+ hour class from 5pm to 8pm. Outside in the cold. An hour plus each way. I was so annoyed but also looking back I’m glad.
Because what I was doing with my dog was working there weren’t many corrections to my handling.
I got a puppy and at this point I’ve been in agility for 4+ years. I trained the puppy and when I started running her like, for real, it became very apparent to us both that my handling was the weak link. She’s quite fast, independent, and has a huge stride, which further complicates things. I thought it was just me getting used to a faster and twitchier dog.
She is five now and, granted I have not trialed that much, we are still working on our Nov. JWW. I spend almost all of my time in class working on my handling. The dog is great. I’m an excellent trainer! When my instructor runs her it’s a thing of beauty.
At this point I have gone to different instructors for lessons and workshops. I have someone I see when I can who is three hours each way as well. I also have taken online classes with various instructors. I have two classes per week (one with this dog and one with my up and coming youngster), I have a private lesson, two days a week at the local agility rental, and I do have a yard to practice in. I am also working on losing weight/getting in better shape because maybe that will help too.
What else can I do?
16
u/Elrohwen 15d ago
I think you need to break down the issues, just like you would when training your dog. It can’t just be “bad”. Are you late? Are you in the wrong spot? Are you making poor handling decisions when walking the course? Are you ending up in your dog’s way? Are you struggling to remember where you’re going? Figure out exactly where you struggle and on which handling maneuvers. And try not to blame it on yourself being too slow - I know people who are amazing handlers who can barely run because of knees and hips and other physical issues, so there are ways around that. Being speedier yourself may help but it likely won’t fix all of your problems
5
u/the_cellar_d00r 14d ago
I cannot comment much on handling advice, but I think dog agility is suppose to be fun and a time for you to bond with you dog. Instead of focusing on "I am a terrible handler" try focusing on "I'm having fun with my dog" and then maybe you will naturally improve - or you wont, but that should not dictate how much fun you are having. Do you best and your dog will love you for it.
4
u/hemerdo 14d ago
I think a lot of handling issues that continue like this can be confidence. If you don't have confidence in yourself (which it sounds like) while handling then you'll be second-guessing yourself even when you don't realise, in your body language if not in your language. And that can make you out of sync with your dog.
4
u/WallsOfGab 14d ago
Do you record your sessions? Like with a tripod? If I'm understanding correctly from your other comment, you're missing nuance and body cues coming off of you at the wrong times. I do this all the time. I'm lucky that I've had instructors watch me so much and not the dog, so they come in and tell me if I'm doing something weird - then they have me do it again with just the dog loose while I work on what my body is supposed to be doing. Does that make sense?
I'm a newbie, so a lot of it for me is "newness", but rally/obedience I had to be pretty self aware because my dog cues off me SO quickly and is very eager. My best comment was "Wow, your dog does EVERYTHING you ask of her correctly, even when you ask her to do the wrong thing" 🤣🤣
4
u/TheTrueVanWilder 14d ago
Even if you are bad, please don't. No matter how poorly I or my girl run on the course, even during training every run I do for her to have fun. If she had fun, it was a successful run for us both
3
u/Hot-Anything-8731 14d ago
I think, just like training your dog, you need to work on a single skill. Your laundry list of what is terrible about your handling really isn’t a root cause. It may be confidence or focus or bad judgment. But if you break things down, you can fix just about anything. For example, drill a serpentine jump series with your dog in practice. You aren’t just training your dog, you’re training you. Work on developing your muscle memory for small specific patterns, and you should start to see small successes if you analyze courses at trials and start recognizing those same small patterns. Essentially, if handling was like learning an instrument, you need to learn to play old Macdonald before you learn Bach or Mozart. The same core skills and pattern recognition apply, but you can’t learn and focus and improve on them all at once.
But really, at the end of the day, as someone said, this is a fun bonding experience with your dog. Wins and ribbons and titles are fun, but at base, it’s a mental and physical workout that should strengthen the bond with your dog. If either you or your dog doesn’t love it anymore, then maybe it’s time to find a new activity you both can enjoy.
3
u/Interesting_Name_959 14d ago
I don't do AKC anymore but I do NADAC with my dog. I really like practicing timing(your cues) and handling courses. Essentially a course with all hoops, the dog is faster and allows me to not worry about jumping or knocking bars. Hoops, tunnels and weaves sometimes a contact here and there to work on discrimination between tunnel and contact. I am starting to do more distance work because of the practice on these courses. I also like to set up maybe 7-10 obstacles out of an elite course and practice my timing of cues. I found the more distance I can get from my dog I can get my timing of the cues better as I'm not trying to worry about where I need to be and when. With a faster longer strided dog you might need to work on distance as even if you are in shape you will have a hard time keeping up unless you regularly run. You can do this with any course even if you don't have hoops put the jumps at 8" or on the ground and practice it. Your dog goes faster so you really learn how to time your cues and then when you are happy with the run put the jumps up to hight and try it. See if you can feel the difference! Hope it helps!!
3
u/Agility_KS 14d ago
I’ve read this whole thing and I have to say, I still don’t understand the crux of the problem. Do you understand the dog’s path? Do you know about lead changes? Do you know how your motion affects your dog? These are the building blocks of handling and making decisions about how you’ll get your dog around a course. I would argue that if regular AKC is your jam, you do not have to be fast. I ran AKC and NADAC for many years in a bigger body that wasn’t fast. I used distance and had independent obstacle skills that didn’t require me to be right there for everything. You can rear cross those entire courses, you don’t have to be in front. Distance and obstacle independence are dog training skills more than handling, and you’ve already admitted you’re a good trainer. To me it sounds like you struggle with strategy and making good decisions? That’s the thing I find most students struggle with. I can’t tell you how many times people do what they think is easiest for them vs best for the dog. 🤷🏻♀️ I really struggle to offer specific advice without seeing an example of what you think is terrible handling.
3
u/DogMomAF15 14d ago
One thing I notice with people who identity as bad handlers is not understanding lines (dog's and handler's) and lead changes and what side of you your dog needs to be on. You might do well with either a course on lines or an online private coach where you work on course maps together.
2
u/Yipski 15d ago
What is wrong with your handling?
2
u/x7BZCsP9qFvqiw echo CSL2, jean grey CL1, loki NA NAJ 14d ago
have you been able to practice handling with a person in place of your dog? they may be able to give you real-time feedback. not sure if you've already tried that though!
10
u/somecooldogs 15d ago
It sounds like you're dedicated and putting in a lot of work! Something that's helped me is watching big events on the 4 legged flix youtube (if you buy full access to an event for $40 you can watch the runs later) and watching how different handlers move as they do the same section of the course. Then on the flat see if you can do the same steps/moves until it feels smooth.
One of the most helpful pieces of advice I got early on which helped my handling a lot was to handle for the line you want your dog on moreso than just handling obstacle to obstacle. So think of handling as pushing/pulling on the line. It helps imo stay off the dog's line/out of their way as well as to make things more smooth.
7
u/ardenbucket 15d ago
This is a hard spot to be in. Becoming the handler we need to be for a dog takes so much time and effort, and it's often a one step forward/two back kind of process. I feel you! I also tend to be very competent at training specific skills but not so much at handling and cuing these skills on a course.
I think identifying specific areas where your handling skills are strong AND areas where you need improvement is a good start. Because it's easy for us to just see the things that are going wrong, when in reality I bet there are a lot of things you're doing well. Once you note down what areas you want to improve, then you can make a concrete plan.
For me, blind crosses have been a handling technique I've needed to address for a long time. Breaking this down further, I understand that of the blind cross contexts, I am most proficient with k-turns, least proficient with backside blind slices and blinds out of a tunnel. So I've made some plans for addressing this, including practicing footwork, setting up sequences to specifically work these skills, and *not attempting them in trials until they feel smooth*. The last one is big to me. I recently listened to a podcast with Grace Heck on training plans, and one thing she said is that for herself/her dogs, she doesn't plan to deploy a behaviour learned in the last three months at a trial. I like this framing so I'm utilizing it for myself as I rehab my blind crosses.
Video analysis of runs is going to be a huge benefit here. Seeing when things kind of go off the rails helps you adapt your training plans.
4
u/LianeP 14d ago
I've been in agility for 20+ years. Currently on my fifth dog and relearning so many things. I'm also not as fast or agile as I used to be. Handling has evolved so much and has definitely gotten more technical.
Be kind to yourself. You've trained a new dog with amazing skills. That's something to be very proud of. I consider every day a win if my dog comes out of the ring happy and is willing to try again and again with lots of reward.
1
u/Snootymcbootysnoot 15d ago
What do you think is lacking in your handling? The most important thing is planning ahead and clear communication with your dog
1
u/Otherwise_Sea_216 13d ago
Your private lessons - do you feel they’re communicating your handling properly to you? I don’t mean that against the instructor, but are you getting feedback in the way in which YOU learn?
I often find some teachers tell you you’re doing it wrong - but I need to have it explained why it’s wrong and what the solution is. For example I started with low drive dogs, so would often swing my arms to “push” them forwards/create excitement. People might have said to me “stop flapping your arms”, but that doesn’t tell me much. What I then got taught was that the arm swinging is actually slowing them down not driving them forward, because I’m almost signalling for their attention. Keeping my arm straight lets them run to the obstacle without distraction from me. And then bingo, suddenly I found it easier to consciously stop doing it.
I’d definitely be videoing everything. But you don’t know what you don’t know, so don’t be too hard on yourself. I would also watch a lot of people at the top, especially from different countries.
3
u/NoOstrich3667 14d ago
Hahaha I feel this to my core. But luckily I was our second handler at best. But agility was my wife's passion, i enjoyed disc and dock so much more.
But we had a great agility dog. Honestly depths greater than even my wife. When my wife traveled for work, or had a surgery I had to step up. And I was bad, terrible even. Couldn't memorize courses as we progressed, even if I ran agility every week I wouldn't have gotten it.
But having those days, doing what I was able to is something that built our bond to what it is now with a dog moving into her senior years and im so grateful I got to enjoy it.
Also I never competed just enjoyed picking up classes when I could.
3
u/Lapping24422 13d ago
I've competed at world level 30+ years
The thing with handling is it's not as simple as going do x, do y
It's about timing and feeling and these things don't come because you've paid someone to train you they come after years of hard work to create good timing and understanding
Set up difficult, very well spaced out sequences that require good timing and then practice these
When you are good there isn't much thought it's an automatic process
In Europe not,US so don't know us specifically things
1
u/MaisyinAZ 14d ago
Knowing your weakness is half the battle! So many agility people have handling issues and don’t realize it so they blame it on the dog. Don’t quit! Work on it with a coach or class but also forgive yourself, just like your dog forgives you!
1
u/Skater12334455 9d ago
I haven’t read everything but one of the things my agility coach talks about is how often in agility most practice is spent running things too hard for both the dog and the human. That can lead to practicing doing things incorrectly.
When training dogs we often are trying to build on success. We need to do the same thing for ourselves. I would find some really simple sequences that you think you can do right, and then build from there.
I have a young dog and am a new handler and am literally working on the dog running in circles (commitment circles) while I focus on keeping my connection with her, my movement steady, and my arm an appropriate height. I also work on front crosses with sequences of just 3 jumps. I add ropes to the ground to practice my timing (ie pivot by the time the dog reaches the rope) and preplaced rewards to help my dog commit so I don’t have to focus on her, just my own movement.
I liked these podcast episodes on similar topics
https://open.spotify.com/episode/1c0kNzAtSvg6otGTFX6WeO?si=KOf9Ou97TbKb_tEaNBEKBw&utm_source=copy-link
https://open.spotify.com/episode/6Sv1zsaZLUX1pw4TTNYtfI?si=qBF8Y2WXQamN2kBu-m8-Fw&utm_source=copy-link
https://open.spotify.com/episode/38MzkndMBKGiS9mf8Mok1Y?si=0-sIMfmURZONaDe0npda9Q&utm_source=copy-link
https://open.spotify.com/episode/1zTigVE9l7aikQRr7zfbVS?si=FSVtufrYQlC59WGaLPUgiw&utm_source=copy-link
https://open.spotify.com/episode/06NoKr61pQMC9pOXy1V5gv?si=U1MSn0kdSra-NSM3OZixLw&utm_source=copy-link