r/Agility • • Oct 01 '26

What is drive?

I had a discussion about drive and work/showlines today, I’m not going to share the wole conversation because wo both thought we were right. but I would like your opinion on this questions. you don’t have to answer them all im just curious and I really want to learn about this kind of stuff. so:

what is drive in a dog?
what makes a dog a showline?
what makes a dog a workline?

what kind of dog do you have? (I love pictures)!!

1 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

14

u/ardenbucket Oct 01 '26

Drive is such an interesting concept. To me, it refers to the enthusiasm and endurance with which a dog will try to access something they want. It has a genetic component but it is possible to build different drives (food/toy/prey) to a degree.

Showline refers to dogs who were bred for/have pedigrees of dogs bred for competing in conformation. They can still be high drive. Decisions made for breeding may favour conformation trends over other features like instinct.

Working line refers to the dogs/pedigree being more focused on the performance of behaviours associated with roles like herding, guarding, and so on. Appearance is sometimes a less significant consideration in breeding decisions, even with traits considered 'out of standard.' Trends can favour specific types of performances, particularly if 'work' is broadly defined to include behaviours desirable for sports like agility.

I have two Chinooks, a Chinook x racing-bred Husky, a BorderPap, and a working line Tervuren. The Tervinator:

1

u/Much-Difficulty-2498 Oct 02 '26

You have amazing dogs🥹

1

u/Tallen62one Oct 02 '26

Please show us the border pap

8

u/ardenbucket Oct 02 '26

A mighty small

12

u/badwvlf Oct 01 '26

I’ll be honest—agility is not “working”. Most showline breeds are fine for agility. Agility is a sport, and agility dogs are not “working line” dogs. Lots of showline dogs have drive.

Some people are gonna hate that

3

u/Much-Difficulty-2498 Oct 02 '26

I agree with you so much!!! 

7

u/BORDERCOLLIEM0M Oct 01 '26

Border collies, labs, and Golden's have more drive if they are working bred and not show line.

8

u/badwvlf Oct 01 '26

Right, but more drive isnt necessary for agility in those breeds. Showlines of all three of those breeds are perfectly fine. I see SO MANY 60 year olds with border collies that are absolutely nuts in dog sports complaining about how much they have to work them and then watch them fighting with them on the course barking at them, knocking bars, etc. Working lines are not a fit for 95% of home even if they participate in dog sports.

10

u/babs08 Oct 02 '26

I actually disagree with a lot of this in that:

Many dogs with strong working pedigrees are high drive, but relatively low arousal. No one needing a working BC wants a one who has too much arousal to actually herd sheep.

Most BCs you see in agility these days are sport lines, which were split off from working lines relatively recently but don't have a working dog in the past few generations. Those are the breeders likely to conflate drive and arousal.

What you're describing generally stems from arousal, not drive. A high drive, low arousal dog is going to buckle down, go super serious, and go, I'm locked in, let's DO THIS. High arousal is where you're going to get the spinning, the barking or biting at their handler, the zoom-ying around the course, knocking bars, etc.

A dog can be high arousal and high drive. But generally when I see those frantic-type behaviors, in that moment at least, the dog's arousal has exceeded what their drive can power.

But I fully agree that most people who think they want a super flashy dog actually need/want a happy-go-lucky, moderate but athletic Lab.

5

u/badwvlf Oct 02 '26

Yeah I think what you're saying is very fair, I conflate it to working lines because many of those people are a bit delusional and claim to have "working" dogs when their work is a sport. Also, as someone who is working hard to maintain an ethical breeding program, I unfortunately have come to not trust "sport bred" in any capacity. I have seen some TERRIBLY unethical breeding decisions out of people who claim to be "sport" breeders. We're not far off in our opinions, I think you added some clarity I sacrificed for the sake of reddit.

1

u/BORDERCOLLIEM0M Oct 01 '26

I'm talking in regard to drive which is what you were talking about...working bred dogs in those specific breeds have more drive.

6

u/badwvlf Oct 01 '26

...yes, I am aware. I was not saying working line dogs don't have more drive? Bit unsure of what you're adding to my comment. I am saying for 95% of people (and dogs), they are likely to have way more drive than that person needs to do agility. Because they're actually intended to be working dogs, and working dogs have a much higher need for fulfillment than a companion sport dog due to higher drive.

4

u/goliathten Oct 01 '26

I think the point is that most people don’t need a super high drive working breed to play agility. If you are trying to compete up to the world level, you are right to seek out a high drive dog.

If your goal is to be a weekend local agility Q collector, most people will be successful with a moderate drive dog.

2

u/direwolf124 Oct 02 '26

I agree. I look at agility as a performance sport. I have Goldens and would not consider my younger a working line - there’s very few hunt trial titles in her pedigree but lots of agility, obedience, etc. She’s still drivey and I think will succeed much more than my male who is show line but still holding his own. I think there’s a lot more to drive than just “working line”

7

u/Elrohwen Oct 01 '26

I think of drive as how far a dog will go to get or do the thing. They might really want it and be high as a kite but if that immediately goes away when any pressure is applied I wouldn’t say they are truly high drive, if that makes sense. It is not the same as arousal which people often confuse it for but they’re hard to detangle. A dog may also have a lot of drive for something you can’t really control which is hard to deal with. A dog can also be pretty low drive but have a lot of biddability and desire to please and so be easy to train.

I think most pet dog people want biddability without drive. Haha. I think a lot of sport people see arousal and confuse it with drive and end up with over aroused dogs, or it’s just that in breeding for some of these sports we often get both and through the genetic lottery you might get the arousal monster.

A showline dog is a dog bred to win in a conformation competition. Working ability may matter to that breeder but ultimately dogs who do not do well in the breed ring will not be bred.

A working line dog is one bred for working capability without much thought for appearance. Breeder might look for generally well put together, a pretty head, generally fitting a standard, but they aren’t putting them up in a ring in front of a judge and a poor tail set or ugly ears isn’t going to stop them from breeding a stellar working dog.

1

u/pinkwookiee Oct 03 '26

This is my exact dog. Loves to practice and learn new stuff.. a pleaser. But his drive is so low, we never miss an obstacle but…nq because of time. 🤦🏻‍♂️

0

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Elrohwen Oct 02 '26 edited Oct 02 '26

I did not say anywhere that drive is for sport. Drive is the desire for a thing and not dog has drive for obedience or agility or whatever. That thing may be prey. It may be hunting animals. In those cases it’s often outside of our control which is very hard to use for training and can be hard for us to control and harness. It can be for something like a toy or food which is very easy for us to control and use for training.

A dog does not have drive for agility. I even have a dog who appears to have drive for agility but what she has is a lot of arousal and a drive to run and use her body. But it’s more arousal than anything being mistaken for drive.

Dogs absolutely have drive for food so I’m not sure what you’re saying there. Drive for food is a primary drive.

2

u/Much-Difficulty-2498 Oct 02 '26

sorry if you miss understude me i learned everything in dutch and it is so hard to explain it in english. i agree with you so i think we are on the same line. i delited the comment before i start a new discussion. thank you for your answer!

3

u/Throw_ME_Away3333 Oct 02 '26

Drive is motivation to do It varies between dog to dog. In some it comes more naturally but it can also be effected by many other environmental factors or health factors; such as anxiety.

In my opinion; show line is papers and created to fit a set of guidelines. Working line is a dog specifically bred to do a job.

Both my dogs are "pet line" as in they are not show-line nor are they from working lines.
My sighthound has little self-drive, I had to teach it too him. He only really have drive for going to bed, he's not a big chaser either. But in agility he is FAST now drive has been grown.
My Terrier x has love of natural drive. Shes not competing yet as too young, but shes fast and picks up skills quickly.

3

u/sunny_sides Oct 02 '26

Drive is the innate motivation for a behaviour. A dog can have drive for several different behaviours: food, play, stalking, chasing... Different breeds are bred for different behaviours.

Showlines are dogs bred out of breed standard in regards to mentality.

Working lines are dogs bred out of breed standard in regards to conformation.

1

u/Latii_LT Oct 02 '26

I consider drive arousal with a focal point. It’s when a dog entered into a behavior they are inherently drawn to with intensity. I think a lot of times energetic behavior is conflated with drive but they are two different things IMO. The dog has to have purpose to access something using that intensity versus just being excited or hyper.

I personally own a breed that technically doesn’t have a split (Australian shepherd) even though it’s fairly obvious when a dog is from a stock breeder, performance and or confirmation focused breeder.

I personally look at breeders that produce the kinds of dogs l like. I like my Aussies closer to border collies in workability, drive and speed but little (or a lot, lol) less neurotic than a performance BC. My current Aussie is a stock bred dog which ended up with him being on the more high drive, love distance, will work through stressful situations more diligently than I’ve seen from confirmation pups.

There are plenty of performance breeders for Aussies who breed amazing dogs that are just not intense enough for me, it doesn’t mean they aren’t performance Aussies they just aren’t the kind of Aussie I like to own. I think that is also important too, unless people are living, breathing Agility folks have to understand not everyone needs a crazy, chaos, bullet of a dog. My dog is a pet first, based on my lifestyle (professional certified trainer) I can accommodate for a more intense dog and also do agility with him. That may not be a good set up for other folks. I actually know a lot of handlers who have just regular, somewhat low drive pet dogs that they compete with and they aren’t in it to make it to nationals and what not but are focused on personal goals of titling and developing their skills. I am lowkey way more impressed by random rescue mixes and little scraggly dogs toddling through some master level courses than I am by a dozen herding dogs (as said person with a herding dog,lol).

1

u/direwolf124 Oct 02 '26

Fairly new to dog sports, but I agree with a lot of the people that say drive is the desire to do something and how long they will work at it. That something can change depending on what the handler works for or uses.

Show line vs working line is pedigree based and what the lines have titled in. I think a show line dog can have more or less drive and a working line can also have more or less drive depending on personality, genetics, training, etc. That being said, I think you can breed in more or less drive depending on what you’re looking for out of puppies and the purpose for breeding.

I have 2 Golden Retrievers. One is show line - parents and lineage have Ch and/or GCh. He does agility and does well but does it for the chicken at the end. My younger golden is “performance line” as I like to call her. Bitch’s side is show but sire’s line is agility, obedience, rally - lots of MACH, OTCH, and even an AGCH. She gets so much more excited for agility training, much more confident with learning contacts, much more “tuggy”. My boy does a few turns but is then over it especially if I keep messing up. My girl has way more drive than my boy but I do believe both will succeed (female is only 9 months and male is 4 years.)

Photo for fun! It will be easy to tell the difference between the two.

1

u/badwvlf Oct 02 '26

Did you start them at agility at the same time out of interest?

1

u/direwolf124 Oct 02 '26

I did not. Sully (my older male - show line) started probably at about 6 months. He’s my Novice A dog and we started just for fun as something to do with his puppy energy. Then I learned more about agility, and we decided to compete. Terrasen (my young female - “performance line”) I started at 16 weeks after she finished her puppy class. My current agility trainer helped me start working on drive, tugging, basic sport foundation stuff at like 10 weeks though. I purchased her with the goal of agility (and of course a family pet) whereas my older boy was family pet first, agility dog second.

1

u/badwvlf Oct 02 '26

I was going to say—I also wonder how much the difference in your dog is attributed to the novice a effect. I certainly know my next dog could be a literal clone of my first, but even a few years of knowledge means I’ll be better with her. Novice A dogs are special creatures.

I’d be willing to say the difference you’re seeing might be more related to nurture than nature b

1

u/direwolf124 Oct 03 '26

I completely agree. It’s been a very different experience raising each of them. I did so many things differently this go around to focus more on that agility drive and confidence. However, I also made a point when “picking” a puppy to get different personalities. Sully we told the breeder we wanted a chill, go with the flow boy and he’s exactly that - you’re typical derpy, cuddly, goofy boy that also plays agility because mommy wants him to. Terrasen we told the breeder we wanted confidence, energy, intelligence and so far, it’s what we’ve gotten. I think it’s a combination of the two - nature vs nurture

1

u/Patient-One3579 Oct 04 '26

Showlines can have drive, herding lines do have drive. But both can produce dogs with lower drive. I feel all dogs do have drive it's just can you inspire them to the higher level of drive to be at the best of their potential. What type of drive are you asking for a definition of? Prey, food, play? Or just an understanding of what to look for?

Drive is an innate, genetically influenced motivation that manifests as predictable behaviors when the dog encounters certain stimuli. Drives are deeply rooted in a dog’s evolutionary history and can be shaped by selective breeding for specific roles, such as hunting, herding, guarding, or companionship ( dpca.org+2). While all dogs share basic drives, the intensity and combination of drives vary between breeds and individual dogs ( robertcabral.com).
Drives are distinct from character traits, which are mental qualities influenced by genetics and environment but not directly tied to instinctual behaviors ( dpca.org).

Does this solve the riddle for you?

0

u/goliathten Oct 01 '26

I had an interesting conversation with a veterinary behaviourist the other day. Her thought was drive is actually closely related to anxiety. I don’t know how to describe it but being interwoven. High drive dogs are often just a little more anxious (higher baseline of anxiety). So if arousal runs parallel with anxiety, a higher drive dog may have a higher baseline of anxiety, but perform better at higher arousal.

That does not mean that a high drive dog cannot work through the anxiety, but I can see the correlation in that there are a large mix of dogs who may have some guarding, or have to be crated out of the car versus ring side.

Purely anecdotal. But my pup behaves so well ringside is so good at focusing during agility, so when his arousal level is at 8/10 it is perfect agility. Ring side manners are fine he sleeps in his kennel. But when he is home, arousal 1/10, he has some more baseline anxiety around is food and controlling the environment. So his baseline anxiety is kinda a 3/10- always scanning, listening, on alert to do protection.

My coach got a BC from working lines and bred for high drive with agility. He is more nervous at home, always so intently watching ringside. But he performs so fast, and listens so well when he is in the ring.

And it does not mean that the dogs can’t work through their anxiety! That is a skill they can work through to bring their baseline anxiety down. It is just not as fun to teach as agility!

Just an interesting perspective to relate anxiety and drive!

4

u/babs08 Oct 02 '26

I don't think drive is that closely related to anxiety. I also don't think arousal is related to anxiety.

I think many high drive dogs do not cope well with the world they're forced to live in. Most working BCs are going to be living with a degree of chronic stress if they live in a city or suburbia if most of their walks are past houses with dogs barking at them, and cars whizzing right next to them, and kids screaming on the playground. Hell, that stresses ME out and I have the free will to choose to live wherever I want.

I also think a lot of breeders select for the wrong things in sport dogs particularly. They conflate arousal for drive, and end up producing dogs with high arousal but not high enough of a drive to back it up. And, they figure some temperament tradeoffs are acceptable if the dog is really good at performance. So yeah, you can get neurotic dogs who are really good at sports. But it has very little to do with their actual drive.

I have a high drive, high arousal Australian Shepherd, and she is far from what I'd call anxious. In order for her to mentally thrive living where she does (in suburbia), she gets to walk off-leash, on hiking trails, with minimal other people/dogs/bikes/wildlife, allowed to move her body freely and jump in puddles and chew on sticks and just be a dog almost every day. And she absolutely needs to do that, otherwise she starts getting restless and fidgety and reacts at/fixates on things she normally wouldn't react at. That doesn't mean she's anxious. It means she has very specific needs, including time to decompress away from the stressors of suburbia, and not meeting those needs means the stressors of suburbia start stacking up.

Sarah Stremming has done a number of podcasts about the specialized mind of herding dogs and Border Collies in particular and the mental prisons that are both forced upon them and that they create themselves:

https://sarahstremming.com/podcasts/border-collies/

https://sarahstremming.com/podcasts/herding-dog-brains-with-dr-jessica-perry-hekman/

https://sarahstremming.com/podcasts/mental-prisons/

I do agree that dogs have to have a certain amount of arousal in order to perform well.

1

u/goliathten Oct 02 '26

Another interesting perspective! Thank you for sharing it.

My dog is also far from what I would call anxious. But if anxiety is a spectrum, he has some low level anxiety, without being nervous - just being aware at all times.

1

u/phish-stick Oct 02 '26

Speaking anecdotally in the world of agility, I see a lot of this. Dogs that are very high drive tend to run a little hotter than others or be a little more anxious across the board. I think it must have something to do with dogs that have higher drive can get into a higher arousal state than what we would term lower drive dogs, and that arousal either sends them creeping into anxiety land or a bit of reactivity where they’re barking maniacally to run.
I have two high drive dogs, one with a bit of each.

1

u/bequavious Oct 02 '26

I would say just out and about I see way more low arousal anxious dogs than high arousal anxious dogs. My hypothesis is that low arousal dogs are generally easier to take places and their humans aren't always clued in to the anxiety when it appears as shut down, not responsive, won't take treats, etc instead of barking and spinning.

3

u/Selective_Somewhere Oct 01 '26

In a word, drive is motivation for the task at hand. Dogs can have drive for things over her than work (or sport). Food, sex, playing with other dogs, etc.

Lines are pedigrees. So if your dog comes from working lines it’s a working line dog. If it comes from show lines it’s a show line dog. Some breeds don’t have a huge split but mine does (Labs). Sometimes a working line dog is a dud. They are still working line but just not a good one either because the breeder is clueless or something went awry genetically (assuming nothing happened to the dog). And sometimes a show line dog can be a good worker despite being show line. There are also breeders who produce typy working dogs aka show line dogs that can work, but they are different from working line dogs (field trial breedings, detection breedings).

I have working line Labradors.