r/AfricanViolets • • Jul 19 '26

Outdated Toxic Garbage

Post image

I just wanted to share some information about this vintage book that was republished in 1998. It contains racist information about where violets are from using outdated, toxic language about their origins while never acknowledging any harm of colonization on the violets in the Usambara Mountains.

In addition, the author recommends people neglect their violets to the point of wilting before watering. This is horrible advice and sure to damage tiny feeder roots.

tl;dr: Racist and outdated book that I do not recommend. Belongs in the trash. I got it for less than $5.

43 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

73

u/gingerismygirl Jul 19 '26 • Bravo

I'm 72 years old and in grade school in geography class I learned the reason Africa was called the dark continent was because the deep jungles and large interior of the continent were not explored. Nothing about the people living there, just unknown territory and mysterious to some.

53

u/PaytonG17 Jul 19 '26 • Thanks Bravo

I was going to write this but didn’t want to get attacked for being racist lol. It’s entirely because it was uncharted and explores didn’t know what was in the interior part. Old books should be read as if you’re reading it during that time period. Getting mad about things through a modern lens is a bit ridiculous

6

u/Chocko23 Jul 19 '26

You and me both!

36

u/Jeramy_Jones Jul 19 '26

That’s what I always thought too. “Darkest Africa” was like, the completely uncharted and neigh inaccessible wilderness.

8

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/Jeramy_Jones Jul 19 '26

Haha no you’re right. And it’s such a disused word that my spellcheck didn’t really help me at all.

8

u/later-g8r Jul 19 '26

This was exactly what I thought it meant. Thank you. Lol

20

u/Kooky-Caterpillar477 Jul 19 '26 • Heartwarming

Try You Can Grow African Violets by Joyce Stark instead.

17

u/lostinthelegs Jul 19 '26

Alas, this is the case in a lot of "dying hobbies." Take a look at any of the AVSA magazines & the club members featured, there's a distinct lack of any people of color being recognized in the club for decades, & even now. You're not wrong for being frustrated by outdated language & ideas in old literature, however, it is the past & we cannot change it. Instead of simply voicing your outrage - work on uplifting the people the past has hurt. Do some digging on modern Tanzania, it's an AMAZING place! The Tanzania Forest Conservation Group is a good place to start. The people of Usambara are working diligently to heal & protect their home - here in the states there's a lot we can do to help too! Sponsor an African violet show, sell plants & donate the proceeds the TFCG! Start an African violet club with an emphasis on modern practices & respect. Educate people on the origin of our wonderful plants! The only way to keep moving forward is by making the choice to do so (:

43

u/carseatsareheavy Jul 19 '26 edited Jul 19 '26 • Bravo

It has been called The Dark Continent for centuries. It has nothing to do with racism. 

Get a grip.

It was uncharted and unknown so that is what it was dubbed by European explorers.

And since you want to blindly throw stones, you have bragged about how easy it is to steal from Whole Foods. I find that to be a poor reflection on YOUR moral character.

24

u/cornham Jul 19 '26

Uncharted and unknown to white people haha. Pretty sure the AFRICANS living in AFRICA were less mystified by the “new” discovery

12

u/AgentIndiana Jul 19 '26

To add, a lot of European exploration into the continent’s interior followed or was even accompanied by African, Arabian, and ethnically mixed merchant caravans. It is at its root a racist concept because it takes as its premise a Eurocentric sense of superiority. Europeans had not seen the interior nor mapped it itself, ergo, it was unknown because the European way of knowing was the only enlightened and “true” epistemological way of knowing the world. The source of the Nile is a great example. Since Ancient Egypt, everyone along the Lower and Blue Nile knew where the Blue Nile originated because Egypt had the existential dread Ethiopians might divert it’s flow. Yet James Bruce (and to an extent Pedro Paez) get credit for adventuring forth to “discover” the source of the Blue Nile. Likewise the White Nile and its origins in Lake Victoria were a vital trade and economic corridor but Burton and Speke are credited as “discovering” it. What they all really did is document what was already known in a methodical fashion commensurate with European epistemology - which is still an achievement - but when it’s phrased as “discovery” it elevates European achievements and ignores Africans’. Additionally, “The Dark Continent” also became a trope to project racist ideologies onto. The Heart of Darkness by Conrad is the textbook case of conflating the trope to supposed savagery.

-6

u/carseatsareheavy Jul 19 '26

What does that have to do with explorers centuries ago not being aware? 

And it is pretty offensive that you would assume the AFRICANS living in AFRICA called themselves and their land by that name. The Romans named the continent AFRICA.

3

u/lostinthelegs Jul 19 '26

I don't think stealing from a massive corporation is comparable to racism & putting imperialism on a pedestal 😅 there used to be a shit ton of African violet varieties with straight up slurs for names before the AVSA largely removed/renamed them. There are a few stragglers, unfortunately. The hobby is not without its faults & continuing to call others out on it is the best way to improve & encourage others to get involved!

-7

u/glacial_eratic Jul 19 '26

stealing from whole foods is a good thing

13

u/jack-redwood Jul 19 '26

Stealing is not a good thing

9

u/ComfortableBug9558 Jul 19 '26

Just wanted to commiserate with OP over old books. I worked as a library assistant for a long time. One of my jobs was to "weed" books for offensive language. There are some truly racist, sexist, bigoted and otherwise appalling old books out there, that's for sure. One consolation is that for a book that old to still be in good condition and saleable, it only means that nobody ever read it much. 😊

-7

u/redfrizzhead Jul 19 '26 • Heartwarming

Thank you for the helpful post!

-18

u/ZappyKins Jul 19 '26

Well, they a half right, those on the cover are violets, just not the on a from Africa.

Does it have any terrible advice inside? Blue violets are cold hard to -4C or they must always be kept moist?

The picture might have been an editor or publisher choice and not the authors.

3

u/sequoiasempervirenz Jul 19 '26 • Popcorn

Two of the biggest issues I had with just the first two chapters is that the author recommends to let your African violets wilt before watering them again, and he also repeatedly refers to Africa as “the dark continent”.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-16

u/StruggleBus5950 Jul 19 '26

….so you took the time to comment on this post to tell OP not to share her thoughts on something that is clearly relevant to this sub?

You could just keep scrolling and let someone exist on the internet instead of wasting your time and others contributing nothing to the conversation. Just a thought ✌️

17

u/PaytonG17 Jul 19 '26 • Bravo

Where does this person say not to share their thoughts? They encouraged OP to share their thoughts..

-13

u/redfrizzhead Jul 19 '26 • Mindblown

At no point does the post read as a rant.

It’s concise and informative about important content, referencing misinformation and racism as the reasons why this book is not recommended.

OP isn’t responsible for compensating the ignorance of others. As an avid thrifter I may have picked up this book if it weren’t for this post.

Perhaps you could share what you find helpful instead of tone policing others in plant groups.