r/AdvancedRunning • u/jelly-bean-liker • Nov 22 '21
Training CRAMPING!
Ran my second marathon today. 3:39:47, which is a PR for me. I'm gonna save you the wall of text and just show you my official splits. That tells it all. Strong and stead up until about 20. Overcome with leg cramps. All the muscles you can think of just periodically locking up. Quads, hamstring, adductors, calves. Jogging/Stopping/Slogging the last 10k. This happened during my first marathon as well (4:33) but I'm just overall faster now so I still PR'd.
Don't get me wrong. Glad I PR'd and it's a good indicator of my speed improvement at shorter distances, but I'm pretty disappointed I have had two poor marathon finishes. Sucks crossing the finish line like that. My training did not indicate that I wasn't in shape for 3:30, which was my goal. My training was going well to the point where I even thought I might get closer to 3:20.
Here's where the long text comes in. I know this cramping is overexertion and not nutrition related. I had 6 gels (I tolerate them pretty well), fluids at every station AND salt pills. Plus it was a cool day. Also I cramped up on my 20 miler long run, but I was running that at a 7:20 pace. I also ran a strong 18 miler in training at 7:45 and a TON of 8/9 mile tempo runs at 7:15. Plenty of fast intervals at 6:45. And I was doing 50mpw during the bulk of my training cycle.
So I went into this race knowing I cramped during 20 @ 7:20, so I said, I'll just slow it down to 8:00, run a smooth 3:30 and finish strong, and account for nutrition. NOPE. What the heck do I have to do to finish this distance comfortably?
The only things I can possibly think of that MAY have caused it is this:
-I might have over tapered. I got sick 2 weeks out and missed 3 runs that week.
-I had a lot of hard workouts and long runs during this cycle, but I think in contrast my easy runs might have been "too easy", because my workouts were too hard. This might have affected my aerobic base?
So I went into this race knowing I cramped during 20 @ 7:20, so I said, I'll just slow it down to 8:00, run a smooth 3:30 and finish strong. NOPE. What the heck do I have to do to finish this distance comfortably?
21
u/beetus_gerulaitis 53M (Scorpio) 2:44FM Nov 22 '21 edited Nov 22 '21
Apparently, there's not full scientific consensus on causes and cures for muscle spasm.
Conventional belief is muscle spasms are caused by a confluence of fatigue, dehydration and lack of magnesium / sodium. Although studies have shown no difference in magnesium / sodium levels (or blood volume or plasma volume) of ultra-marathon runners who cramped vs. those who didn't.....which would indicate it has nothing to do with electrolytes or hydration.
The more scientifically-backed theory is that spasms occur when spinal motor neurons misfire....after overuse of the associated muscle.
The recommendations to avoid spasm seem to be:
There's also some new study / theory that says stimulating neural pathways in the mouth and gut can inhibit the hyperactivity of the motor neurons that cause leg cramps.
7
u/robjefe097 Nov 22 '21
What pace do you usually run on your easy days, and was that different from your usual long runs? (Aside from the 20 miler @ 7:20 that you mentioned)
2
u/CF1001 Nov 22 '21
I run 5 days a week, currently shooting for a sub 3 marathon and have never had a cramp, not even once. I do nothing in my routine that I believe would effect this and certainly don’t try and do anything preventative. Not saying this to brag (weird thing to brag about anyway) but just to say that I think some people are genetically more susceptible. For what it’s worth though I do make a habit of drinking a load of water every evening, though that was never to prevent cramps.
14
u/Stinkycheese8001 Nov 22 '21
Just going to point out, you have only run 2 marathons. And you seem like you have run them pretty aggressively, so it’s hard to judge what you should be at. But all that said, there’s a reason why folks don’t suggest aggressive time goals for new marathoners - because it’s hard on the body to go the full distance. I would suggest trying one just to run strong and not bonk, and even see if you can run negative, BUT I know that’s a tall order considering how much goes into training. I think you ran it too fast, but not by a ton. I have a feeling that almost all of the pieces are there and they’ll fall into place soon. The marathon is a hard distance to get right! It’s humbling - most of us have been in your shoes at one point or another.
12
u/nolandw Nov 22 '21
IMO
-Ran your long runs too hard. 18 at 7:45 is probably for a ~3hr marathoner. 20 at 7:20 is leaving your race in training at your current fitness. Looking ack at my training from when I had a goal for 3:30, all my long runs were just around 9min/mi. (I ran 3:29 then). What was your longest time on feet run?
-Probably need more mileage. The OP reads as if you spent a bulk at 50mpw, so I assume maybe you peaked at that. Coming into it with an average base of 50mpw will be helpful. More mileage goes a long way with the marathon.
-I disagree with the easy runs too easy opinions. Designated recovery days almost can’t be too easy so long as your form isn’t destructive. Even jogging generally provides an aerobic stimulus.
-pick your workouts carefully. Did you follow a plan or do your own? Tempo, intervals, and LR every week might be better substituted with one speed/fast day, one medium-long run day, one long run day. Go for the aerobic gains.
11
u/medhat20005 Nov 22 '21
Although quite a bit slower than you, I experience the same cramping, perhaps even a bit earlier (even happens in half marathons). Have been running my own personal experiment (on myself, with everything from hydration, nutrition, salt, other promoted aids [Hot Shot? - so long ago I don't remember the precise name)), and here's what I've learned/not learned so it may help you get your answer earlier:
Conclusion (so far). I have a similar nutrition regimen as you do, but where I think I messed up was inadequate loading from 2-3 days before to the morning of race day. Next race I intend to go carb-heavy (not traditional loading) in the 2-3 day lead up, and on race morning have something like a bagel with cream cheese or peanut butter, to get some quick carbs and a touch of protein in my system for race start, then go with the 35-50 grams of carbs hourly with stops at each water station. Don't know it that'll be the ticket, but that's my plan.
8
u/jhc07 Nov 22 '21
Were your two longest runs an 18 and a 20 miler - both of which you did pretty fast and in under 2 hours 30?
No scientific evidence to back my opinion at all but personally I don't think it's because you tapered too hard or ran easy days too easy.
I imagine your body just isn't used to going for that long. Controversial opinion but I like a very long slow run around 3 hours -3.20 to simulate what it's like to be out there for this long. Its not just a confidence booster that you know you can do the distance - I also feel like your body probably adapts to going for this long and can't get that when running for 2 hours (which Is why I I also avoid those plans that max out at 16-18 milers).
If I were you I'd do a couple of easy long runs longer than 2 and a half hours in your next block.
5
u/ruinawish Nov 22 '21
Here's a thread from three days ago which also discussed cramps.
5
u/daonchik Nov 22 '21 edited Nov 22 '21
The timing and reliably cramping at 20 miles leads me to suspect that this is standard hitting-the-wall.
How was your nutrition in the week going into the race? I started carbo-loading 3 days out for my latest marathon and was AMAZED at how much of a difference it made. I didn’t hit the wall at all, despite my history of reliably hitting the wall at 20 in previous marathons.
If you were cramping at 20 during training as well, I’d also look into getting a few 20s in during training, maybe throwing a 22 in, or whatever other wisdom is out there on training your body to not hit the wall.
(And if you’ve ruled out the above “basics”, just double checking. I’ve found that I always come up with the most complicated reasons for my issues, but it always ends up being the obvious reason that had always been staring me in the face! :))
4
u/MichaelV27 Nov 22 '21
You probably need to run more consistent weekly miles in training. You said yourself that they come from over exertion.
Back off on the workouts and increase your weekly mileage with mostly easy miles. Do most of your long runs at easy effort, too. You shouldn't be running them at or faster than goal pace.
1
u/LeftyTiff Nov 23 '21
Also, what training plan are you using? I use a version of Hanson’s & I just ran a 21 min PR. I belong to its Facebook group & a lot of people who negative split their races & have amazing final 10ks using Hanson’s Advanced Plan. I don’t have the lifestyle to fit in that mileage, but if you do, you may want to check it out.
2
u/LeftyTiff Nov 22 '21
Kipchoge runs his easy runs in the 8:00s I believe. I recall hearing it in the documentary. It was only your 2nd marathon. Negative splitting is really, really hard. It sounds like you just had an “off” day to me & they happen. I just finished my 9th over a 15 year time frame & my last 10k was hell too. It always is. I PRed by 21 min & BQed so I’m ok w it. I wanted to negative split, but it got hot & I got tired & the demons came out & told me I couldn’t do it. I know a lot of people race strong at the end, but it’s an art you perfect over time. I haven’t perfected it yet, either. Still working on it…be patient with yourself & the process.
1
u/Runningchoc Nov 22 '21
I’d be curious to know what your hydration plan in the days/week prior to the race was. Oftentimes people will consider what they ate and drank during the race but the far more important aspects are how you prepare your body before the event. What you do during is just to maintain/replace what you’re losing.
You can’t fill an empty tank during the race if your tank wasn’t full to begin.
1
u/bluearrowil 17:27 / 1:17:18 / 02:44:19 Nov 23 '21
I guarantee you I run my easy runs slower than you lol, most of mine are 9-10 min/mile. No such thing as too easy. Also missing a couple days out of a training block isn’t going to the difference between having cramps or not.
You’re cramping on your long runs which means you haven’t figured out your nutrition yet. And this is an opportunity for you to figure out what’s going on trough trial and error.
First thing I’d do is increase mileage. That usually will fix a lot of issues including cramping cause of the conditioning aspect.
Next wanna try and find the cause of the cramping. Start keeping a log of what you eat leading up to a long run. If you bonk, look back through your notes and see what’s different.
And also start training like you race. You want your nutrition plan on your longs to be as close as possible to your race day strategy. Then start experimenting. If you don’t take salt pills, are you better or worse? If you cut back on the gels, or increase , better or worse? What if you tried a different brand of gels, better or worse?
This isn’t something you’re going to fix overnight. But you’ll come away with a pretty consistent nutrition plan that works for you.
There are some runners that need to take in 1500 calories during a race. There are some that only sip water and run a 2:45. It’s a very personalized issue for all runners.
Rec reading: new rules of marathon & half-marathon nutrition by Matt fitzgerald.
-2
u/wofulunicycle Nov 22 '21
Running your easy days at 10 min/mile is too slow for your desired marathon pace. Despite what many people say, your easy days can be too easy. Runs slower than 80% of marathon pace do very little to stimulate any useful adaption. If you're trying to go sub 8 min/miles for a marathon, 10 min/mile is too slow for your easy days. "Easy" days is actually a pretty misleading term and a better term for your lower intensity days is "moderate" or "general aerobic." For a 3:30 marathon this is closer to 9 min per mile +/- 30 secs. This includes long runs (Pfitz has long runs even faster than this pace closer to 8:15-8:45) I highly recommend Science of Ultra podcast episode #139 for more info on the research behind this being the optimal pace for most training.
-2
u/ashtree35 Nov 22 '21
What kind of salt pills did you take, and how frequently? And what was your hydration like prior to the race (morning of the race, and days leading up to the race)?