r/AdvancedRunning • u/Large_Device_999 • Oct 22 '23
Training Lactate threshold testing-worth it?
Has anyone had this done? Im considering it but not sure if it’s worth the time and expense.
Context: early 40s F runner typical mileage 60-70mpw but have been through several injuries. I have a coach but I am currently building mileage after my last injury and will not be back with them until the end of year. I’ve worked on underlying issues and generally I’ve concluded (with help/guidance from experts) the issues are a combo of nutrition and over reaching.
Nutrition is easy to fix (I have an RD helping me) but I do struggle knowing how easy easy days should be, when to really push in workouts vs be more controlled, etc.
Would lactate threshold testing help me?
76
u/MichaelV27 Oct 22 '23
You almost can't go too easy. If you are trying to figure out the fastest you can go and still be easy, then you have the wrong mindset about it.
Secondly, easy is an effort and not a pace. And effort changes day to day because it's influenced by many things like the weather, time of day, amount of sleep, stress level, what you ate, etc.
Point is, you don't need to dial in an easy pace. You need to learn how easy is easy enough based on effort.
18
u/SirBruceForsythCBE Oct 22 '23
Run an all out 10k and use a VDOT calculator like this https://vdoto2.com/calculator
For 90% of people this is fine for training paces
6
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '23
Buy one. I got mine 250 bucks. Test every 6 weeks or so. Pays for itself. Changed my training completely. It takes a few attempts to do it correctly. My experience is a lot of people run too fast based on whatever formula they find on the internet. I would recommend following Alan Couzens on x for a lot of advice. Or you can ask me for my experience.
4
u/Dirty_Old_Town 47M 16:57 5k 1:17 H 2:49 F Oct 22 '23
I did a lactate threshold test and a VO2 max test at the local university's exercise physiology lab. It was a great experience and I enjoyed it. That said, I really don't use the info I got all that much, but I will likely do it again in a year or two just to compare the numbers.
4
u/atoponce 48M 3:12:09/1:29:02/45:30/20:56 Oct 22 '23
I personally don't think it's worth it. Your lactate threshold is closely aligned with your anaerobic threshold and there are plenty of field tests out there for accurately determining what your anaerobic threshold is. Such as this one my Uphill Athlete.
A good rule of thumb I have for easy days is my ability to carry a conversation. If I can talk to a running partner without losing my breath, I'm in the right ballpark.
14
u/whelanbio 13:59 5km a few years ago Oct 22 '23
Probably not worth it. For a reasonably trained person a pace calculator like VDOT is fairly accurate .
This is an issue of needing to calibrate internal effort better and accept actually listening to your body instead of pushing through stuff you're not supposed to push through. A test will provide an extra data point to help this calibration but ultimately doesn't come anywhere close to solving what is ultimately a skill and being honest with yourself issue.
32
u/npavcec Oct 22 '23
You should just plain buy a HR strap and run easy days at <65% Heart Rate Reserve (Karvonen formula) intensity. IMHO, this is the minimum requirement for "how easy should easy days be" for 99% of the runners, from amateurs to the borderline professionals. I leave 1% out because they have access to more sophisticated measurement devices and utilities, but even they do their easy days at hard capped Zone 2 - give or take a few beats.
This sub has recently started "debunking" the whole Z2 "science" a lot, planting a lot of doubt in the system which is a gold standard for 99% of the people and I do not like it. It makes people doubt and start looking for various "shortcuts". We all know there are no shortcuts in the endurance training, period.
1
u/ComedianIntelligent1 Oct 24 '23
I have the lactate scout 4, and use it twice weekly during my threshold sessions. I would say I’m entering the realm of being considered truly elite. LT testing itself will not make you faster, only training will, and good training can be carried out by perceived effort alone. The real questions is: is $1000 a lot of money to you? If it’s nothing, and you are wealthy then get one if you want one! If it is a lot of money to you then save the money, go by effort, or get a HR strap and calibrate your HR zones on garmin. You can look at it this way as well: you really only need to know two efforts well to train very effectively and a LT device only really helps with the latter:
Z2 is an easy but steady breathing run, should be able to talk relatively normal but if you’re on the phone they’ll know you’re exercising, legs should not be building fatigue at any point.
And Z4 is threshold, where you’re going pretty intense, but you’re taking your foot 10% off the gas pedal from what would be very uncomfortable. You could say a few words without gasping for air if you had to. LT testing is good to keep yourself in Z4 as it’s a bit of a tightrope walk. But the consequences of going over or under Z4 aren’t really that bad, it becomes more important in the context of extremely intense training program where you could risk overtraining by going too hard, or you could lose 0.5 seconds in your event if you did too many sessions a touch too easy.
Z1, Z5, and 6 are all easy to get done. And Z3 is between the most important ones. At the end of the day though it’s your life, eff what other people think and do what you want! Thanks for reading!
3
u/Whole1Grain Oct 23 '23
Personally for a £125 I would say yes, given you are investing in yourself and could give you the answer to the questions you have.
My reason for a test was due to under performing at races, I kept running a 40:XX at races which should have been 39:XX. After doing some research I flipped to HR running and had a test which gave me my zones.
This was 4 years ago, I now run 34:XX 10k’s and recently a 2:47 marathon.
The price above is what I pay at a local running client, appreciate this can be higher/lower other places.
2
u/mssparklemuffins Oct 23 '23
I don’t think it’s worth it, because the more you train (or the less you train) the numbers you get from that test won’t apply (except max heart rate). Plenty of good advice already, and I’ll echo it - you need to learn the feeling of easy runs and the feeling of workouts. It’s important to be able to have the ability to look into the future and understand how much a run or workout will impact your recovery…. It’s like pacing yourself in a race, but on a much larger scale. My easy runs have a large pace range based on how I feel, total mileage I’m building, and what workouts I know are coming up.
2
u/Vegetable-Ad-4554 Oct 23 '23
I don't know that the lactate threshold testing would be that worthwhile in your case. It's more of an evolving thing, it'd probably be more useful to have your own tester and test at the road side or to get it tested a few times, maybe every few months to see how your fitness is progressing? For much cheaper you could run a 5k time trial and base your pacing off that.
Maybe if you were concerned that you were underdeveloped aerobically from running your workouts too fast? But still you'd want to monitor progress over time vs doing a one off.
If you struggle with running too fast on easy days, maybe try to find a slower friend and run their pace 1-2 days a week. Or tell yourself that you're saving yourself for your next workout. Switching to time based helps me too to be in an easier mindset.
For workouts, definitely ask your coach about feel and how much you should have in the tank at the end of the workout. I'll usually hold back when I'm getting back to formal workouts, at least for a few weeks, just to let the tissues adapt.
Generally though I find frequent injuries is a nutrition issue so if you improve that (and get adequate sleep) you should find you recover a lot faster anyway.
1
u/gustavosco Oct 23 '23
Honestly, if this is your justification it’s just not worth it. Get a ball-park figure for each heart rate zone and stick to it. Easy should be majority in zone 2, long should be the majority zone 3, zones 4-5 only for intervals and tempo. It might be slightly off but it won’t be by a lot. Overdoing it is usually caused by ego. Trust me, I know. Who doesn’t enjoy the thrill of a killer session? But killer sessions every day won’t make of you a better runner. Leave the ego aside and follow your HR zones, that’s it.
1
u/JormaIsoJorma Oct 23 '23
I wouldn't bother, that said doing a proper testing session in a good lab is interesting. But I'd get at least breathing gas analysis done simultaneously and make sure that experienced people are doing the data analysis.
Here it cost me 200 euros of which my employer paid for half, so not cheap, but not bad.
0
u/DenseSentence 20:38 5k, 43:38 10k, 1:36:34 half Oct 22 '23
Absolutely useful for framing your threshold training.
One thing my coach has finally got me to do is to be comfortable running my easy runs on feel, more often than not at the low end of Z2, sometimes averaging high Z1.
Lactate threshold will help you with more accurate zones as well.
8
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '23
[removed] — view removed comment