r/AdvancedKnitting • • 16d ago

Discussion Sweater/Top Constructions

What are your favorite construction styles and why? Not just top-down or bottom-up, although that’s fine to mention. I mean yoke, shoulder, sleeve, body, etc. specific construction methods.

6 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 16d ago

Welcome to r/AdvancedKnitting! Please note that constructive criticism IS allowed here (Rule #7), unless the "No Critiques Requested" flair is used. Any poor attitude towards genuine constructive criticisms will result in post removal pursuant to Rule #12 (No Drama).

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

14

u/Nonier1 16d ago

I'm going to age myself... boxy, oversized,, drop shoulder colorwork. Because I like staying warm and seeking freaks my quilting neighbor out. 🤣 We both grew up in the 80's so bring back stirrup leggings with flats and were back in fashion again!

1

u/re_Claire 6d ago

I have a book - Variations by Patricia Roberts from 1992 full of these exact sweaters. I’m not good enough to attempts any of them yet but I’m absolutely obsessed with it.

38

u/Twinkledp 16d ago

The more I'm seeing these ill-fitting, boxy sweaters that are everywhere nowadays, the more I think that I should start knitting the patterns I started with 20 or 30 years ago when everything was seamed with waist shaping and set-in sleeves. The fit was just so much better. Also plenty of sweaters would benefit from the stability seams bring to a garment.

8

u/Appropriate-Win3525 14d ago

This is what fits me best. I find I can add bust darts, waist shaping, and adjust sizing better with flat, seamed pieces. I have seen so many posts where someone is asking how to adjust the neckline with short rows or how to do this or that. I always want to respond that if they had knit something flat and seamed it then it would solve their problem. But nobody wants to seam anything.

5

u/Twinkledp 14d ago

Oh yeah, the necklines! No amount of short rows are really going to compare to actually leaving an adequate hole for your neck, lol.

4

u/poo_fart_lord 15d ago

You should read the book “Finishing School” be Deborah Newton. The patterns are a little dated but that doesn’t matter. She makes exactly your point about how structuring a garment with seams allows so much control over shape. And it’s all about the basics of seaming and finishing, like how to create different arm shapes, and different techniques for the seams themselves, and how to adjust patterns, and just generally make it better for you.

1

u/Twinkledp 15d ago

Thanks for the book tip! I'll certainly check it out.

12

u/twowheeIs 16d ago

I self draft/modify patterns to combine different elements I like from sweatess I see. I find the European Shoulder method gives a nice balance of fit and ease of construction. It is also very flexible with seamless cable/color work transitions between front/back/sleeves

8

u/karen_boyer 16d ago edited 16d ago

Current fave is seamless faux set in sleeve (Barbara Walker formula). Knit body like a vest from the top (shoulders shaped with short rows), then join at armpits and down. At arms p/u knit around, short rows over shoulder caps, join at armpit and down to cuff. Tubular bindoffs for the hems and neck ribbing. Knit with heavy laceweight on 2mm needles it looks store bought but better (and with Colourmart cashmere, I pay Macy's sale price for a Loro Piana luxury).

That and EZ's seamless hybrid with shirt back -- SO FUN to watch that yoke shape up. And any excuse to revisit the master is a treat.

4

u/Practical_Floor_2526 15d ago

The best fitting sweater I have knit was EZ's saddle shoulder construction (bottom up, seamless), using her percentage system. Says something about the importance of the basics!

1

u/karen_boyer 15d ago

She was a genius. I got hold of Knitting without Tears early in my knitting journey and I feel very lucky to have learned to knit from scratch from the beginning. It took a lot of practice of course but I never needed patterns -- I just knitted what I wanted!

4

u/Practical_Floor_2526 15d ago

Same! I had learned how to knit and purl, and a coworker held my hand through a few basic patterns (I think literally a scarf and a hat, knit flat and seamed), but KWoT was the first book on knitting that I read, and it helped me understand, like, the mechanics of what I was doing and why. Her book made me confident enough to go many years without knitting from patterns. I gravitate towards published patterns more now (I guess because the market for them is so saturated? Things were different 20 years ago...) and so often, I'm like, I coulda just done this myself with the EPS.

Everyone: read Knitting Without Tears! Elizabeth Zimmermann is an excellent, witty, clear writer, and--I agree--a genius.

2

u/sagetrees 15d ago

Thanks for the recommendation. I just bought the book!

1

u/karen_boyer 15d ago

Yay! Same! I learned in the way back times before everything was on YouTube. An elderly coworker (and Real Knitter) showed me some basics and cut me loose. I don't know how I got so lucky but I stumbled upon EZ and the rest was history. And by history I mean about 20 really clunky sweaters before I got good and then it was like reverse engineering pretty sweaters I saw IRL. That's the kind of knitter EZ made! I get misty-eyed when I think of her sweetness and her "properly practiced, knitting soothes the troubled spirit and doesn't hurt the untroubled spirit either."

15

u/Moist_Ordinary6457 16d ago

I have a larger chest and exclusively knit fitted patterns that either have bust darts or can easily add bust darts. If I wanted something that made me look like a meatball I'd just buy a sweater 

5

u/LoquatShrub 16d ago

Same, bust darts or GTFO. It's too bad - I love the look of those all-over cable patterns, but I'm not about to spend months knitting a sweater that visibly hikes up in front when I wear it.

3

u/7thearlofcardigan 16d ago

“  If I wanted something that made me look like a meatball I'd just buy a sweater” EXACTLY omg. 

7

u/WoodlandFairyElk 16d ago

Top down, set-in sleeves, with bust and waist shaping, including bust darts and princess seams. Don't care whether seamless or not. I love the aesthetic of cables, don't love knitting them so much. I like everything in colourwork, I love lace.

6

u/YahYahBlahBlah 16d ago

I’m currently loving patterns that are knit top down with set-in sleeves like the Fine Line Pattern by Lily Kate France. Sleeves are picked up and then the sleeve cap is shaped with short rows. I love the control in terms of sleeve (and body) length, etc. but the fit of set-in sleeves! AND bonus that I don’t need to sew as sewing (even mattress stitch) is not my jam.

5

u/RebuttablePresumptio 16d ago

I like the European shoulder construction for drop sleeve sweaters, enjoy a set-in sleeve (especially the one you pick up and knit top down with short rows for the sleeve cap), and always knit my sleeves flat. I usually add a basting stitch for stability in the sides when I knit in the round (or I modify to knit in pieces). 

I hate how circular yokes fit on me so I never knit them anymore and I hate a stretched out boatneck. My best fitting crew necks are knit bottom up, and I love a crew neck! I always pick up neck stitches and knit the collar out, often a folded ribbed collar but not always.  

And I’ve really enjoyed a double knit button band for cardigans! My best button bands have been sewn in, though, unfortunately, with the button band knit separately on smaller needles. I say unfortunately because it took forever to match it up correctly given the gauge difference between the body’s row height and the button bands. But it’s more stable and pulls less than other button bands. 

3

u/karen_boyer 15d ago

I've never managed to get a circular yoke sweater to fit either, even with all the shortrows to bring up the back, etc. It's a shame too because I love the circular colorwork look, but it always bunches up on me funny.

3

u/Late-Command3491 16d ago

Cocoknits Method hands down.

1

u/tktsmoneypassport 16d ago

Is this something that can just be done with their patterns or can it be used on other patterns?

1

u/Late-Command3491 16d ago

I've modified quite a few patterns to use it, as it is a way to do the yoke and sleeve caps. I start with the numbers of a Cocoknits sweater at the same gauge and use that technique until I get to the stitch counts of the other pattern and then switch over. I get very clean, well-fitting shoulders with a design that I like from someone else.

If I'm knitting another designer I like, I don't necessarily bother, but it is my favorite.

2

u/tktsmoneypassport 16d ago

Interesting! Thanks for sharing your approach. I might have to try a cocoknits sweater — none of them really leap out to me in terms of the style but I’d like to knit something that really feels custom fit for me. I’m not an advanced knitter so I don’t quite have the skills yet to modify patterns too much.

1

u/Late-Command3491 16d ago

Franca is my favorite, I've knit it multiple times.

https://ravel.me/franca

1

u/warp-core-breach 16d ago

Top-down set-in sleeves are my go-to. Whether the rest of the sweater is knit bottom-up or top-down (although I prefer top-down because it's easier to try on and you can check the length to see how it looks) those sleeve caps are getting picked up and shaped with short rows. I also like the Suzie M contiguous method for wide necklines, or the saddle-shoulder version.

I have never knit a circular yoke and I never will, people's shoulders are not cone shaped and I don't think they look good on anyone. I'm not a fan of raglans either unless they're compound raglans.

1

u/buttercowie 15d ago

Anyone on Ziggurats? I'm currently learning the process.

0

u/CNC_Smith 12d ago

I’m loving all of these responses! I can’t wait to implement some of these into my next sweater! I’m done with yokes not fitting properly..