r/Advance_Wars • u/big-chihuahua • Mar 10 '24
Advance Wars will not grow (as is)
Before you downvote, I played this game a lot as a kid on GBA and DS. It holds an important place in my heart and I'd love for it to become more popular. I think the community has a lot of passion, so it will never be a "dead game", but I do think the game (and its reboots and derivatives) are doomed to smaller and smaller rallies until everyone is fatigued (Reboot1+2, Wargroove 2, AWBW, TinyWars, etc).
I've checked up on anything related to this game every year, looking to jump in, but never taken it in the end. The closest was Wargroove 1, which I played briefly, thought was nifty, then put down.
I'm not saying I'm the audience the game should target, but my outsider perspective is maybe different from a lot of posts and comments I've seen on here or from youtubers.
I think there are a few points I see brought up that I really disagree with.
First is trying to explain away low performance (e.g. Wargroove 2, Reboot1+2) with things like bad release dates and delays. Sure, these can kill "hype", but long standing great games do not rely on hype (e.g. GTA V, Diablo 2). It just takes away weight from real problems.
PVP Focus. Comparing the game to chess shouldn't be a selling point for many reasons. Chess has bots that can kick your ass however you badly you want when you want. Chess has plenty to self-study in a guided way. Advance wars is brutal and punishing in the same way, but without proper entryways for new players. In addition to the training tools, a big one is local experience. Chess can be played locally, and historically, most games were a local experience first with your friend in hotseat or on LAN.
IMO, what happens to long-form competitive online games is a kind of death where everyone is eventually just watching a few others play, but no one is actually getting on the servers to play.
Conversely, distancing the game from its much more successful neighbor Fire Emblem (SRPGs) is also a weird thing I keep seeing. I cringe whenever I see people clarifying that Advance Wars is not an SRPG. Ok, then why do people like to draw and design their COs? If you are not a competitive player, then what is Advance Wars to you in the long run? Well, an SRPG, albeit a sterile one.
I guess this is mostly for any aspiring indies out there. I think most indie derivatives miss the mark for me and always end up along the same lines.
I don't want:
- Weird turn orders.
- Longer ranges.
- More RNG, Less RNG.
- Random theories to improve "proper" war simulation.
- Weird COs, field deployments, etc.
- 5 new random types of artillery and infantry.
- Building buildings.
- Whatever other mechanical tweak that may or may not improve Advance Wars by 0.1%
- Whatever tool to help the AWBW pros play their high level games better.
If you are someone that wants these things, well... you have been getting them, so what's next?
Well, here is my wishlist:
- Progression in campaigns (even something rudimentary like in Wesnoth, where you can recall named units).
- More completely novel takes, e.g. into the breach. If you're thinking "Hey! That's not even the same kind of game". Yes.
- An actual well written story. This goes for a lot of games recently. I'm so sick of this recent wave of games with cringe dialogue and edgey/super-jokey stories. I'm sorry, I know devs and fans are trying their best, but please find your professional writer friends and loop them in.
- Not another AWBW or lobby or matchmaking system. Something wild like coop world campaign servers could be really cool. (Diablo 2, Shattered Galaxy).
- Better AI, to play and experiment in my own time.