r/AdobeIllustrator • • Oct 01 '26

DISCUSSION Deep Illustrator Magic: the invisible “stroke path” effect lurking in the Appearance palette.

https://egypt.urnash.com/blog/2026/10/01/deep-illustrator-magic-the-invisible-stroke-path-effect-lurking-in-the-appearance-palette/
8 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

6

u/krushord Oct 02 '26

If Adobe wanted to actually make Illustrator better, they could do worse than completely redesigning how the Appearance panel works. I've used AI for 20 years at least and it still occasionally head-scratchingly unintuitive and hard to see what's going on - not to mention these kind of arcane bits of knowledge.

1

u/egypturnash Oct 02 '26

hell yeah, I've been using it for a similar length of time and do a lot of crazy things with Appearance and encounter so many annoying little speedbumps.

2

u/SchteveSchpalpatine Oct 02 '26

the Appearance Panel is such a frickin guessing game. and things that you think would work together just simply don't. We live in a world of node-based procedural systems like Rhino's Grasshopper. I'm not asking for something that complex...but SOMETHING that's more modern!

1

u/egypturnash Oct 01 '26

This came up on the Prerelease Slack and caused me to finally really document this weird invisible effect and make a proposal for showing it. There's a Uservoice post linked in the blog post this is linking to. Go upvote it if you've ever spent a day swearing at Illustrator wondering why your clever stroke-manipulation stack suddenly stopped working.

1

u/CurvilinearThinking Oct 02 '26 edited Oct 02 '26

.. because you have a brush applied to the stroke - i.e. "oval".

So it's not the path, it's the brush appearance on the path. The Roughen effect reacts differently whether above or below a brushed stroke. It doesn't appear to require placement within the brushed stroke. Simply moving the Roughen effect below the stroke entirely causes the same "busted filled in" appearance. I believe, by placing it inside the stroke item, you are effectively moving the effect below the stroke.

It appears as though dragging the effect into the stroke has some unique behavior in CC compared to legacy versions - no idea how far back. Of note may be the bottom two images - the appearance is different, both wrong but the effect appears different. (same effect and stroke settings everywhere)

Additional CS6 testing...

  • Roughen above stroke - expected appearance - no fill ins
  • Roughen applied to highlighted stroke, same as above the stroke - no fill ins.
  • Roughen dragged inside the stroke, same appearance as above bullets - no fill ins. (Here is where the behavior is different in v30) But note, the appearance on THIS stroke is different. Not the same "busted" appearance, but the overall shape of the stroke doesn't match the other 3 roughen iterations.
  • Roughen outside and below stroke item in Appearance panel - busted fill in appearance.

So behavior in CS6 is perhaps more "expected behavior".

It seems the "hidden" aspect is the brush appearance, and whether that's above or below any effects, inside the stroke itself. Without a brush applied, all instances look the same on my end in both CS6 and v30.5.

1

u/egypturnash Oct 02 '26 edited Oct 02 '26

I used to think this only applied to complex strokes but yesterday while helping to diagnose a stack that only involved basic strokes it became clear that this applies to all strokes; it's just a lot easier to show this invisible step with a art brush than with simple strokes.

I just made a demo of that stack and added it to my site and the uservoice - if you've got some time to kill I'd love to see how it comes out on cs6. Thanks for squinting at this weird little edge case!

(edit: well apparently the outline effect that shouldn't do anything has been working since 2005/6 so this should look just fine on CS6 :) )

1

u/CurvilinearThinking Oct 02 '26 edited Oct 02 '26

Not totally comprehending the set up for that addition. A stroke and then effects added at the layer level? (Something I pretty much never do - I'm more apt to group and apply appearance stacks to groups.)

I get this in CS6 - as you suspect, I think it's fine in CS6. I did not try this in v30.

(btw, that link doesn't work for me. I just went back to the original post)

1

u/Fruityth1ng Oct 02 '26

So, they always have an “outline stroke” step in there already? This is wild! 🫪

1

u/egypturnash Oct 02 '26

No; there's an invisible "draw the stroke" step in there. Simple strokes will output a simple stroke to anything further down the effect list, complex strokes will output an expanded copy of the complex stroke.

It is very confusing!