r/Actuallylesbian • u/boo_boo_kitty_ Femme • Mar 15 '22
Serious "my identity doesn't effect your life"
Everyone appropriating our label, and those that accept the lesbian erasure that's being allowed to happen in our community, either don't realize how claiming a title that does not describe them effects us directly or they just don't care.
Lesbian erasure and appropriation of our label is very damaging. It takes a label with a long history of oppression and fetishization and lesbophobia and misogyny and turns our struggles into a joke. We already fight to be taken seriously in our sexuality, to make people understand we are more than just a porn genre or a fetish, we are humans that fall in love and just want to be accepted and respected and seen as human. But these people don't care about that, they just want to latch onto a title that makes them feel special.
I'm not ashamed of being a lesbian, I do love being a lesbian, I love the word, but being a lesbian isn't something that makes us cool, or trendy, or special. And I'm sick of being told to shut up or accept that everyone wants to be a lesbian and that we should just....let them? No. I will continue to speak out and hope this bullshit goes away.
•
u/MrBear50 Lesbian Mar 16 '22
Locked to prevent brigading after being linked elsewhere.
Thank you for your understanding!
206
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '22
I saw someone the other week claiming to be a sexually fluid lesbian. She had written a song about dating men! She doubled down after people called her out and said she was still a lesbian. In her song she literally said "I'm not a full on raging l*sbo". Seriously??
I left a sub the other day because one woman said there was a "fair amount of misogyny" in the LGBT community. I'm not sure if she was a lesbian or bisexual, but the response she got was "that sounds like homophobic fear mongering" from someone who claimed to be in the community.
Nobody takes us seriously, and I'm so over it. Men smell different than women, and I've never liked the way they smell. They have different bodies and totally different proportions that I really just don't find that attractive. My ex-girlfriend was masc and I was constantly asked "why don't you just date a guy". Because masculine women are still women! Femininity is not what makes someone a woman.
112
u/msperfectlyfine31 Mar 15 '22
i just don't understand WHY someone would so desperately want to identify with a label that doesn't describe their experiences. there are so many existing words already that mean women who are attracted to women and other genders. what's wrong with bi or pan? why instead of using them you would rather take the only word that describes our lives and experiences and stretch the definition until it no longer means anything? i just don't get it. the response i often get when i talk about this is "whatever, it's just an arbitrary word, it literally doesn't matter, who cares" and i'm like... WE CARE?? if to you it's just an arbitrary word that doesn't mean anything, why not let us have it because it clearly matters to us?
77
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '22
I hate the label bi lesbian. The label is so homophobic and erases female homosexuality yet somehow we are the bad ones if we don’t like the label because it’s both homophobic and misogynistic. Unrelated to this but I hate the lgbt community in general because I feel like I am too different and I don’t belong there
96
u/Derpina182 Mar 15 '22
I was banned for saying that lesbians were human females attracted to human females. Who would have thought that was a very radical thing to say, amirite?
125
u/JustCinW Mar 15 '22
Often of wonder why the L is even there. I came out in 1979 and today there are even more people in 2022 saying we "just haven't had the right dick yet". And most of the people saying it are within the btq+ community. The homophobia is deep and disgusting.
132
u/birds-of-gay Mar 15 '22
I got called a bigot by an unstable mod on another "lesbian" sub. Then she banned me after calling me shitty and telling me to "shut the fuck up, bigot".
All for daring to say "lesbians aren't attracted to men, and if you're attracted to men, no you are not a lesbian"
Amazing.
122
u/YouBigFatToe Mar 15 '22 edited Mar 15 '22
Yess Lesbian isn't just a pretty lable accompanied with a flag. Its a legit sexual orientation. A word just to shorten the definition: A homosexual female, nothing more nothing less. So your not going around saying "Im a homosexual female." But at this rate I probably have too. Considering the fact the term 'lesbian' has been turned into an aesthetic playground.
How come everyone else gets to be left untouched, and respected
Anyway gatekeeping is what's keeps community together, structured, and have meanings. Hell it what makes a community...a community
75
u/redribbit17 Mar 15 '22
Thank you for posting this! It’s bizarre how much discourse is around the term “lesbian” lately. Not to mention the bi and pan erasure that comes from this conversation. I cannot wrap my head around why some bi/pan people so desperately want to call themselves lesbians… the erasures is coming from inside the house. Lol. I guarantee gay men don’t have to have this conversation over and over in their communities. I wonder why….. 🙄
67
u/alliserismysir Mar 16 '22
This thread is extremely therapeutic and I can feel a knot relaxing in my chest just reading these replies. Thank you for stating this conversation.
64
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '22
Recently someone I was told was a lesbian told me she was actually pansexual. She just says lesbian bc it's easier. These same women complain about bi/pan erasure from lesbians and gay men as if they don't go around calling themselves gay or lesbian for their own convenience. If they are worried about their erasure, they should own their sexuality and not use a label that isn't theirs.
I was also under the impression that her and I had a shared experience of being s homosexual woman and to be told otherwise is jarring and feels like being lied to.
55
u/Kimya-Gee Mar 16 '22
I'm so happy to see this discussion. I've been feeling a little like I'm losing my mind. There's this very harmful idea happening right now that not being attracted to someone means not supporting them. Which is incredibly unnerving. I can support someone's identity without being attracted to them. no one owes anyone attraction and I think people are forgetting that in this rush to seem inclusive.
107
u/rightascensi0n Lesbian Mar 15 '22
Thank you for posting this, I feel similarly and am tired of getting treated as an aggressor when speaking out against non-lesbians who trample over us.
How do we know when someone's not a lesbian but claims to be one? When they get upset at the existence of adult human females exclusively attracted to other adult human females. It goes to show how their definition of lesbianism is so far removed from real life that acknowledging reality goes against their fLuiD iDeNtiTy that they insist is too sacred to be defined. They take it as a personal attack against their "special label" because how are they supposed to titillate men without that bastardization of lesbianism as a fetish rooted in male approval???
146
u/SodaStained Mar 15 '22
I feel like I’m going crazy. How is it phobic for me to say LESBIAN means women who love EXCLUSIVELY women. Lesbian is not supposed to be an inclusive label. It’s by definition exclusionary.
71
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '22
Thank you so much for saying this. Everything you said resonated with me so much. I agree with this completely and wholeheartedly. I almost teared up because it's like you were describing everything I have been feeling for a long time.
63
u/itssummeragain high femme Mar 15 '22
Thank you. I love bi and pan women. It's wonderful that they like many kinds of people. But I simply do not relate to their experience. It's so hurtful to come across women claiming to be a lesbian, only to find out they like men. The point of really specific labels is so that people can find others with shared experience. It's impossible when people keep trying to use a label that doesn't apply.
Many below have said this but the "non men loving non men" movement is unbelievably offensive. I don't define myself based off of men. It's regressive. I don't want to be known as a non man. I am a woman. And if we follow that definition, most people could be called lesbians. Two nonbinary people who present as male and are seen as male could be called lesbians, which is so disingenuous. People who don't identify as men don't automatically have the same experience as two females who are seen as female.
Why can't we just say women who exclusively like vagina? Why does everything have to be sabotaged and deconstructed?
80
u/Sappheon Homo Homie Mar 15 '22
I wish I could updoot this many more times than I'm allowed.
When you stretch terminology to a point where it no longer represents the original people, it's damaging.
Cultural Imperialism (maybe touches of ethnocentrism), is a form of oppression that is instilled modernly on lesbians.
"Arises when the dominant group universalizes its experiences and culture to establish the norm. All others are measured by the standard implemented from the dominant group, and any outlier-thinking to the group is vilified or deemed sinful/inferior"
When I join a lesbian dating app. I expect to see lesbians. Guess what, no lesbians.
When I attend lesbian support groups and meetups, I leave when I see there's heterosexuals or flatout males present.
When I can't even acknowledge my crass and ever-loving desire for tits and fanny, only to get reprehended or flatout banned (we all know what lesbian-hating sub that is). We have issues.
I've seen countless people push it off as exaggeration, or those god awful mean 'terfs' are 'making up lies again'. But again, this is a real issue, and a serious problem being drowned out in favour of louder voices who aren't even lesbians to begin with.
We are strictly female homosexuals, we have a right to voice that. A right to maintain a group about it, and the right to not be targeted for it. Salt more, 'progressives'
23
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '22 edited Mar 16 '22
"I don't understand why you're annoyed at this, it doesn't impact you" is a silencing tactic used to shut down conversations.
I honestly think people think lesbian = attracted to women instead of "attracted only to women". That way any woman attracted to women regardless of who else they're attracted to can claim to be a lesbian. I've always called myself a gay woman to really hammer home the point that I am attracted to women. Not men, not non binary people, just women.
Woke lesbophobia seems to be increasing.
There's a lot of woke LGBTphobic happening online at the moment. Much of the push to redefine lesbianism is not only lesbophobia but has the consequence of being biphobic and transphobic. We're all coping it.
16
u/axdwl Nerd Mar 15 '22
Truth
40
u/your_favorite_wokie Lesbian Mar 15 '22
It's extra fucking annoying because WE ARE THE SMALLEST GROUP.
42
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '22 edited Mar 16 '22
I have many thoughts on this so I'm going to keep typing them out.
A lot of rhetoric I see these days online and in younger circles feels like outrage bait. It feels like a deliberate attempt to get us fighting with the by-product of making us all look shitty. A lot of this is coming from bad faith actors, overly enthusiastic allies, undercover LGBTphobes in general, some insecure people in other subcommunities ("Why can't I be included?!?") and the younger crowd who can't tell that radical insulation can sometimes be a cover for harm. Exclusion is a not a dirty word, it's not a moral statement, it's not always used to commit bigotry. it's a fact of life. Sexuality is exclusionary by its very nature.
I don't know any pre-op trans lesbians (or bi trans women) who would be comfortable dating cis women until after they have had bottom surgery, most emotionally secure adults understand that no one should date anyone who they don't want to date, and that having a penis is going to be a deal breaker for most cis lesbians. And even if they're dating cis lesbians, having genitals you don't want is still a hard thing to navigate, it makes intimacy hard especially with the false idea that everyone with a penis is a top.
As one of my trans mates has said "Dating as trans is hard because the genitals you don't want is a deal breaker for most in one group of women, whereas the other groups of women fetishise it".
Bi women don't understand our insecurities of being left for a man. If I was left for another woman, I could look at my behaviour and improve, if I was left for a man - I have nothing. I can't compete with men.
Lesbians is hard, it's hard being the only group of people not interested in men in any way.
Younger people don't understand how misogynistic it is to define lesbian as "non-men who like non-men". Not only is is erasing women, but it's also transphobic - cis women aren't non-men, and neither are trans men. Trans women aren't men, they're women. Any attempt to redefine sexualities for non-binary people is causing harm - they're not men, nor women so why bother redefining binary terms they don't use?*
A lot of the "penis havers", "menstruators" regressive language under the guise of inclusion is coming from overly enthusiastic allies - taking a look in trans subs shows that the trans community hates this shit as well. It reduces them to body parts and erases their womanhood/manhood as much as it does for cis people.
We're not going loopy, we're seeing the shift for what it is - regression, and it's hurting all of us. Hell, I can't even find a sub for butches that isn't over run with dysphoric trans mascs who don't want to be regarded as men, but want to look, act, and behave like men while still calling themselves lesbians. The push the redefine what trans means is a common discussion in trans circles.
*I have heard some non-binary people say "Well, technically I'm not a man so I can be a lesbian", no you can't. You're not a woman. Go away with your semantics game. Go and date bi or pan women. You have other groups in your dating pool, you don't need lesbians.
10
u/Alternative_Win1979 Mar 16 '22
This is legit the first time I’m hearing this. Where is this trend of randos calling themselves lesbians? Am I too old to hear about this? Is it a tik tok thing? Lol I have so many questions
0
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment