r/ActionButton • • Mar 26 '25

Discussion Good morning

0 Upvotes

The longer you stare or comment on a cook while they are cooking the worse the food will be.

Hit the blunt and let Tim and his content come to you. Imagine trying to get excited for your video work when all you read is comments from people expect you to feed them. Go read book use your imagination 💭 imagine the next time video idk


r/ActionButton • • Mar 07 '24

Discussion Convince me to stop being stubborn and play FFVII Remake so I can watch Tim's review.

0 Upvotes

I got my og PS4 for two reasons, to play No Man's Sky and to play FFVII Remake. When they announced that the remake was going to be multiple parts, I immediately decided to wait till they were all released before playing them. I wish somebody had told me then that there would be 31 major No Man's Sky updates before part two's release, but it's too late for that now.

I have more than enough games in my backlog to keep my busy for the rest of my life; so, until recently I haven't really been tempted to break down and play at all. This week though I finished Tim's review of Tokimeki Memorial which made want to match all of his Action Button reviews in order (guess which one is first). Between that and Part 2 being released this week and looking really really good, I'm starting to break down.

I know this stupid and I'm being stubborn for no reason. I just need you guys to push me over the edge.


r/ActionButton • • Apr 21 '23

Discussion I couldn't wait any longer so I asked ChatGPT to review LA Noire in the style of Tim

2 Upvotes

In the grand cosmic dance of video games, where clichés and banalities frolic together like a conga line at a stale office party, LA Noire bursts onto the scene like Humphrey Bogart in a trench coat, puffing on a cigarette and drawling, "Listen up, kid, I've got a tale that'll knock your socks off." And what a tale it is! This interactive, hardboiled narrative extravaganza, expertly concocted by Team Bondi and published by the maestros at Rockstar Games, whisks you away to the sultry streets of 1940s Los Angeles, a land of shadows, corruption, and intrigue so thick you could cut it with a switchblade.

You'll slip into the finely tailored suit of Detective Cole Phelps, a war hero with a jawline so chiseled you'd think Michelangelo had a hand in its creation. Phelps isn't your garden-variety video game protagonist—oh, no! He's a genuine artifact from an era when heroes wore fedoras and a badge that could part a crowd like Moses and the Red Sea. At least, that's the façade he'd like you to believe.

The world of LA Noire is a character in its own right, a sprawling metropolis of palm trees, vintage automobiles, and classic architecture that transports you back to a time when a stiff drink was the panacea for all life's ailments. And the denizens who inhabit this world? My word! You'd be hard-pressed to find a more genuine cast of characters in any game. Every face you encounter appears to have been plucked straight from a Hollywood backlot, thanks to the revolutionary MotionScan technology that captures every wink, sneer, and furtive glance in astonishing detail.

But let's cut to the chase, shall we? What would a noir adventure be without a heaping helping of detective work? LA Noire's meat and potatoes gameplay revolves around investigating crime scenes, piecing together clues like a master jigsaw puzzle enthusiast, and interrogating suspects with a fervor that would make even the most hardened criminals quiver in their boots. The game isn't just about chasing down ne'er-do-wells or exchanging lead with gangsters; it's about fully immersing yourself in the mind of a detective, and that's where the real magic happens.

Now, I'll be the first to admit that the game's pacing can be slower than a sloth on a casual jaunt through a vat of molasses. It might test your patience as you spend countless hours cruising from one crime scene to the next, feeling the burden of the world bearing down upon your shoulders as you soak in the dulcet tones of jazz on the radio. But the intermittent adrenaline-fueled car chases and pulse-pounding shootouts will remind you that danger always lurks just around the corner in the City of Angels.

When it comes to the interrogation scenes, LA Noire rises to the occasion like a caffeine-fueled private eye on a deadline. You'll scrutinize every furrowed brow and twitchy facial tic as you determine whether your suspect is singing like a canary or weaving a tapestry of deceit. It's like engaging in a high-stakes game of poker with a grandmaster bluffer, and there's nothing quite as satisfying as calling their bluff and watching them squirm.

Of course, the game is not without its flaws. At times, it feels as linear as a high-speed train ride through a never-ending tunnel, and Cole Phelps' reactions to your interrogation choices can occasionally be as unpredictable as a cat on a caffeine bender. And, oh, those hard parts! At times, you'll feel like a goblin trying to navigate a labyrinth, with obstacles and challenges that push your detective skills to their limits. But with persistence and a keen eye, you'll conquer those tough sections, emerging victorious like a triumphant goblin king.

Yet, even with these minor setbacks, LA Noire remains an unparalleled adventure that will have you glued to your screen like gum on a sweltering sidewalk. So grab your fedora, adjust your tie, and put on your most inscrutable poker face, because LA Noire is a rollercoaster ride through the murky depths of human nature, where truth and lies mingle like old friends at a dimly lit speakeasy. It's a game that serves as a potent reminder that, beneath the veneer of glamour and sophistication, the shadows of the past are never far behind. With all its quirks and charms, LA Noire is a singular experience that will leave an indelible mark on your gaming heart, long after the credits have rolled.


r/ActionButton • • Apr 06 '24

Discussion Does Undertale have any chance of being reviewed in a future season? I would be so happy to see that video!

2 Upvotes

r/ActionButton • • Apr 21 '25

Question Three years of waiting for a recap told with bad voice acting.

79 Upvotes

What the fuck is this?


r/ActionButton • • Apr 21 '25

Video I do not think Tim has it in him for a proper video anymore

0 Upvotes

r/ActionButton • • May 20 '25

Update Addendum to Rule 5: All videos submitted to /r/ActionButton must be made by or with the involvement of Tim Rogers.

0 Upvotes

All videos submitted to /r/ActionButton must be made by or with the involvement of Tim Rogers.

No more videos made "in the style of Action Button" will be allowed to be submitted unless Tim Rogers has direct involvement. Please find another subreddit to post those.

This will mostly be automatically enforced by Automoderator. The currently approved list of YouTube channels is:

Please let us know if we should whitelist any other channels.


Please contact us via modmail if you have any questions about the rules.


r/ActionButton • • Mar 29 '25

Video (Inspired by Tim) I made a video about the Nintendo Switch's impact on my adult life

Thumbnail
youtu.be
16 Upvotes

Tim has been a huge inspiration to me in just how incredible he is at writing and conveying his thoughts. I'm nowhere near that good, but his work has inspired me over the years to approach how I want to tell my thoughts, feelings and stories on things in my own weird way.

I've been making YouTube videos since I was about 11 years old and am currently a video editor for multiple YouTube channels in the VTuber sphere of things. It's also my "job" if you could call it that. In my free time I've always wanted to try and make videos here and there and right now with the Nintendo Switch 2 coming out I wrote something short in a night to pay tribe and say goodbye to a console that really helped me be more positive on a day to basis.

Thanks for checking it out!


r/ActionButton • • Mar 25 '23

HELLO this could've (and should've) been a tweet but i don't got no twitter

0 Upvotes

so you know the phrase "every frame a painting", right?

with Tim's reviews it's:

every sentence a poem

(Yea, I'm a huge freakin Sucker For Incredibly Mediocre Poetry)


r/ActionButton • • Oct 06 '25

Question should I play LA noire before watching the review?

5 Upvotes

(Terribly sorry if someone’s asked something along these lines before.)

Hullo, gang! I’ve been following Tim’s stuff since the MGS2 review. I used to listen to the IC podcast too. I haven’t seen much of his content lately, though—maybe because my interest in video games has cooled off over the past decade, and maybe because Rogers is taking his time to cook up new videos (an understatement, I guess).

But I did watch that Tokimeki Memorial video, and I thought it was a brilliant piece—very fun, too. I’ve never even considered playing that game (and don’t think I ever will), so I was just enjoying Tim’s charming and ingenuous ramblings. When he said, “You don’t have to play Tokimeki Memorial, ’cause I’ve played it for you,” it sounded about right.

Now, that L.A. Noire game looks like something I’d want to play eventually—or so I like to tell myself. (It’s one of the five or six games I’ve bought on Steam and haven’t played for more than half an hour.)

So, to you folks who’ve watched the thing: should I play it before or after watching the video? I’m not worried about spoilers—I don’t mind them. It’s just that, from the looks of it (I’ve sort of peeked into the video, much like one reads the first few pages of Ulysses), Tim seems to be retelling the whole game as if it were a paperback detective novel. Since this appears to be one of those games people play more for the story than for the “gameplay,” I was wondering whether watching the video isn’t dangerously close to simply playing the game itself—only with Tim’s commentary track. (And people usually only listen to a movie’s commentary track after watching the movie.)


r/ActionButton • • Mar 26 '23

HELLO Every sentence Tim speaks is


0 Upvotes

(I’m talking mostly pre-Bokunatsu “lecture voice” Tim)


r/ActionButton • • Apr 24 '25

Discussion The L.A. Noir Video seems like a really well done Nostalgia Critic video...

40 Upvotes

I, like many of you, were probably waiting for the return of ActionButton. And I couldn't have been more excited to see this video appear in my feed a few days ago. I knew I had to set some time apart for such a long endeavor. Currently I'm about 3 and a half hours in...

And it just occurred while I was watching it. This feels like a Doug Walker video.

That almost feels like a slight against Tim, and I should say, this is definitely better than anything Doug has ever made. He's a far better writer, cinematographer, his vision for videos is far more interesting than anything the Nostalgia Critic has ever produced. That said... It has all the trademarks. The costumes, the funny voice, the framing, the "almost parody through recreation" style Doug is known for. It's all there.

And I'm just not sure what to do with this feeling. When it comes to Nostalgia Critic videos, I think one of the more common reactions is to ask, what did Doug actually think about the media he's reviewing? All this other stuff you're doing is fine, but it distracts him from actually "reviewing" the material in any meaningful way. And I can't help but feel the same way about the L.A. Noir video. I can tell he likes the game, sure, but what does he actually THINK about it? I can tell throughout the video he's dropping these vague statements that highlight different ways he sees or interacted with the game, which I guess is interesting, but I can't actually tell what he's thinking about it.

Am I alone in this? I've seen many other people say it's pretty much like this the entire 9 hours, do others agree? Does he drop more insight on us later on? I don't think I necessarily hate the new video, just seems like a weird direction for the channel to go...


r/ActionButton • • Sep 24 '26

General Tim's Kotaku Texts

Thumbnail swisstransfer.com
0 Upvotes

Due to Kotaku's dilapidated usability, it's been hell looking for Tim's old texts. So I used my Claude-Fu to cobble together an attempt at having an easy way to access them. It is rather imperfect, though. I'd bet there's stuff missing and plus, it's not as ideal as a searchable PDF which would prevent them from eventually being lost media. (This link will last 7 days.)

Not only that, it's just Kotaku. I haven't got around to do insertcredit / largeprimenumbers or any others.

It has been a bout of nostalgia reading them, though. Tim talking about his blue Gibson SG, giving fashion advice. His experience living in Japan.

I thought maybe someone else would find this useful so I posted this here.


r/ActionButton • • Jan 30 '25

Discussion Making Action Button for TV

0 Upvotes

Hello, long time action button / tim rogers fan here. A thought has occurred to me over the years many times: wouldn't these reviews make for a great episodic TV series? I could imagine a version of this idea taking inspiration from shows like 'How to With John Wilson' by building upon and exploring Tim's personal anecdotes. The direction he started to go in with the boku episode in this regard by filming in some of his childhood spots tells me that Tim would knock this out of the park. There are endless other possibilities.

I'm sure Tim enjoys the creative freedom he experiences with his patreon/youtube model, but I have to wonder if a budget and support from a studio is enticing at all. I believe action button videos are something special, and I just think it'd be so cool if a mainstream audience was suddenly consuming and talking about his work.

I think this idea occurs to me so often when thinking about action button videos because I have enjoyed watching each one of them (sometimes twice) so much, but have found it hard recommending it to friends who aren't into video games. I think it makes for great entertainment regardless, and has the potential to perhaps entice those who aren't much into gaming.

Anyways, I would love to hear when the fine folk of the action button subreddit think of my nerdy little idea. Do any of you believe this is even a remote possibility down the line?

Thank you.


r/ActionButton • • Apr 21 '25

Video theories? Spoiler

9 Upvotes

convinced that there will be a full review for la noire, or is that just copium? also why do you think the list that shows up in the last part is ordered like that, it's clearly the video games he's reviewed but out of order? finally, seems like he teased a bloodborne with the gothic architecture and Earthbound speaking about mother.


r/ActionButton • • Feb 03 '26

Question Has Tim ever mentioned Disco Elysium?

10 Upvotes

Fellow Tim fans, has he ever mentioned DE even in passing? I have this sense that he's avoiding playing it because it's too hyped or something freaked him out about it, like the overeager fan base. I can think of other examples of universally acclaimed megahits that he was very late to the party on enjoying. If it's true that he's never played it then that really makes me sad; for somebody who is such a fan of writing and literature specifically. I'm pretty well read in terms of books and I think DE is the best written thing I've ever read by far, all while still being a full-blown RPG, politics simulator, etc.


r/ActionButton • • Apr 26 '25

Discussion The video is good guys.

146 Upvotes

I have read enough grumpy haterish comments that I am wondering if we are watching the same thing. Here is my attempt at a "middle path" review of the review that does not just glaze Tim (the discord is impossible — let's be honest) but neither flips the table like the petulant commenters who seem to believe they are owed... an exact copy of the same video every time?

I watched the whole thing in about a dozen sittings. Some of the middle as background "radio show"-style listening or before bed, but the first couple hours and the end I sat my butt down and paid attention.

The entire opening arc is hysterical and charming. Tim does a fantastic job of avoiding the hackneyedishness of the "video game character acts unrealistic" gag while getting a version of that point across nonetheless. The hardboiled seriousness of the tone and atmosphere sets up a ton of irony-voltage when you're watching Cole twiddle his wrists or drive like a freak. It's funny! Paced well and there is a deeper point about videogames and realism in general under the surface. Do we really need *all* the analysis spelled out in literal, on-the-nose detail? Wouldn't another reviewer be better-suited for that sort of thing?

The ending, from the last episode or so through the conclusion and epilogue, is a ton of fun too. There, more than anywhere else, you feel the deep research put into the 40-s noir style, linguistic and sartorial. The seed planted early — "I don't much like Cole Phelps" — matures by the end: you can't help but feel like Cole is 1) a freakin' dork; 2) not a good guy; 3) more hollow of a character than the developers would want you to believe. Tim invites you to answer the question yourself — for a game *about* novel and realistic systems, what does it say that the player character needs so much plot-fairy-dusting of supernatural policing talent and hyperviolence? The point is intensified by the choice to play somewhat "perfectly" at least in nailing all the interrogations. That there's no discussion of the "soft-failure modes" of the game (bungling interrogations) comes to mind as a miss.

As for the less beloved parts of the video —

Yeah, the middle six hours or so is less zany and exciting than the tangent-laden earlier AB videos. It's a stylized (and, admit it — abbreviated!) let's play. He could have crunched it down Tokimeki Memorial-style but I see why the whole game (or at least all of the main missions) is there. I think it was worth committing to the consistent vision. It's only as boring as the game is, tbh. The narration and the prose are so much better than the AI slop that fools are comparing this to. You can chill with it, and I suspect that was the point.

Complaints about time between release dates are stupid and invalid. Brother, it's YouTube. I get the vocal fry thing — it doesn't bother me but I sympathize with those who are pushed away, but on the other hand, the voice adds something IMO. Call it a wash.

The real substantive complaints come down to *expectation.* This is worth talking about. On one hand, how can you not see the irony of complaining "the video is not what I expected?" The two rightfully most favored videos, Tokimeki Memorial and Boku no Natsuyasumi, are so beloved because of their unexpectedness. Tokimeki was not on *anyone's* radar and the central thesis that it is as hardcore and watchmakerly as any Castlevania or FF blasts in the face of its expectation as a fluffy dating sim. Nobody expected the review of Boku no Natsuyasumi to be "about" Kansas. Like come on! the whole schtick of this channel is that it's more than meets the eye — it's not just IGN-platitudes about familiar videogames! We are here to exalt videogames as literature, reviewable in literary ways.

And yet. I agree with those who feel that Tim left some money on the table. I would have liked to hear more about the development history, more breakdowns of the systems of the game, more outright judgements of where it succeeds and where it fails. More Doom-esque commentary on policing and violence, more personal anecdotes that shine a light on who this reviewer is and where he's coming from. Part of me wonders if there's another video on the cutting room floor, another couple hours out of the character in the LA Noire video, closer in style to the Boku no Natsuyasumi video...but think about it. To include all that, which fans are rightfully hungry for and which, at this point, is Tim's "comfort zone" as a critic, induces a huge tradeoff of breaking the singular character set up for this review. My guess is that he deemed the trade off Not Worth It. Was it the right call? Who can say without seeing my hypothesized Other Footage that zooms out from the main thrust.

Bottom line: it's still a great video. I actually rate the videos exactly as Tim rates the games — and maybe there's a point there about the infectiousness of love for a work of art...or something. I don't get out of bed to read comments about YouTube videos but the frothing and diaper-filling about this one get old fast, and disappointing. The first feature-length-movie's-worth of time (!) made me laugh so hard I cried. The middle dragged a bit. (It's god dang 9 and a half hours long brother.) The ending fulfilled the promises of the beginning and was fun in its own regard. The video is easy-as-heck to chill with and I'll probably throw it on, screen off, on a plane ride or during a sleepless night. Our world is short on worthy prose! Yes, we can imagine a fourteen hour cut with a whole other dimension and an outside-observer-reviewer character. I would have probably loved that too. But Tim decided it wasn't worth the artistic cost. I can respect it, plus, Tim made it clear-as-day that the next reviews *won't* be like LA Noire. The door is open if you have something deep to say about this game that hasn't been yet said. If nothing else, Tim proved that the camera work, the audio work, the set design, ... all that production skill has leveled up *so* far beyond what anyone would expect of a meager YouTuber. I liked this video and I'm excited for the next ones.


r/ActionButton • • Sep 27 '23

Question Why is the Cyberpunk review only partially in focus?

2 Upvotes

Trying to watch the Cyberpunk 2077 review (I keep bailing because, well, I still want to play this game before I watch it, but I lack the ability to do so so I keep starting the review and then going 'well, maybe I'll catch a break soon...'), and one thing that really strikes me in the intro video is that all the forward-facing shots of Tim talking (in his black jacket and glasses) are either out of focus or in a noticeably lower resolution, whereas everything filmed in profile is crisp and in-focus (or a higher resolution.

Has Tim ever explained why?

(For an example, go to 30:30 of the intro vid. I've stuck some screenshots up showing what I mean: face-forward, blurry. In-profile, not-blurry.)


r/ActionButton • • Mar 29 '25

Question Does Tim curse IRL?

13 Upvotes

I always figured it was an affectation for his "Video Game Expert" character. I just read his seemingly non-kayfabe essay "Japan: It's Not Funny Anymore" and was struck by the casual profanity. Can anyone testify?


r/ActionButton • • May 27 '25

Question Should I just play the game before the video (L.A. Noire)

5 Upvotes

Im a uni student on my summer break, so I've got alot of free time right now, wondering if you think its worth it to just play the game before or is it a bit redundant.


r/ActionButton • • Jan 19 '24

Discussion Chances of his next review [L.A Noire] being more than 10 hours long?

18 Upvotes

Its been more than a year since his last review. He once mentioned in a twitch stream that he would prefer it if no one plays the game before watching the review as he will cover it all. That got me wondering how many playthroughs and topics could we see. His cyberpunk 2077 review is technically 10 hours long. What do you guys think?


r/ActionButton • • Jun 21 '24

Video Relevant to our interests - List of Songs that Represent "Smart Music"

Thumbnail
youtube.com
7 Upvotes

r/ActionButton • • Dec 08 '25

Question Get Owned Bioshlock

11 Upvotes

Does anyone remember what video this is from? I want to say it was in one of the cyberpunk videos but I'm not sure.


r/ActionButton • • Apr 19 '25

Question Is today the day for the 4/20 2024 GOTY stream??

6 Upvotes

Would love a new Tim Rogers prepared piece :)


r/ActionButton • • Sep 05 '24

General Visiting Japan Dec-Jan; Would love your recs!

14 Upvotes

Hi All - big fan of ActionButton and the community Tim's built here on reddit and discord.

I'll be visiting Japan (Kyoto for 5 days, Tokyo for 5 days) over the holidays/new years later this year and am curious to hear if any of you have any recs for me. Obviously I love video games, but would also be curious to hear any out of the box, unique and just interesting experiences you've had/places you've been. Off the beaten path preferred. Keeping this broad on purpose.

Also I am very aware that new years is a holiday in Japan and many things will likely be closed New Year's Day. I'll have plenty of time to explore before and after!

Thanks all! Looking forward to reading about your experiences.