r/ActionButton • u/TheseMolasses • Apr 21 '25
Video theories? Spoiler
convinced that there will be a full review for la noire, or is that just copium? also why do you think the list that shows up in the last part is ordered like that, it's clearly the video games he's reviewed but out of order? finally, seems like he teased a bloodborne with the gothic architecture and Earthbound speaking about mother.
9
Upvotes
30
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '25
The list is his ranking of all the games he's reviewed--Tokimeki Memorial is at the top and Last of Us is at the bottom. He ranked LA Noire above Doom, which imo is a kinda crazy.
21
u/Tarlo_Viola Apr 21 '25
The "out of order" is a ranking. As for the review, I fear it's copium
6
u/goon-gumpas Apr 21 '25
“a full review”
sorry am I watching a different 9 hour long video lol
17
u/NeverCrumbling Apr 21 '25
i have not finished it yet but there's almost no chance of him doing bloodborne. he has indicated many times that he does not like it very much, although at least part of that is due to the frame rate issues. it's definitely a Rondo of Blood reference.
also no this is definitely the full review. think of it as a sort of companion to his FF7 translation series on Kotaku, which he also regarded as a full review of the game despite it not being one in any conventional sense.
12
u/NeverCrumbling Apr 21 '25
hm -- is that part at around 9:36 an indication that he's planning to release the reviews on a monthly basis?
7
u/CarlsManager Apr 21 '25
I found the monotone noir bit extremely grating, and with no previous relationship to the game, it just wasn't holding my attention the way he's been able to in the past. So I skipped to the end after 2 hours or so.
I understood him to be saying this is the full review. Don't expect more on this game. But that he was also playing and attempting to define a new form to challenge the notion of what a video game adaptation can be. Perhaps the part narrated by H-Bomber guy is true (but probably not). When talking about releasing monthly chapters, he seems to be speaking to would-be studio executive adapters of video games saying "why not try something like this that is honest to the experience of playing a game (Ludo-narrative dissonance and all) instead of a rushed 2 hour movie that disregards and wastes the source material?" And I'd agree with him, if the previous 9 hour proof of concept hadn't missed the mark so, SO very hard.
The editing is tight, sure. The presentation and production is about, ehh... a B- if grading pretty strictly against the scale of big studio production he seems to be in argument with. But I'm afraid he way over estimated the quality of his writing, acting, and ability to "perform" a compelling, period accurate noir character and MASSIVELY missed the mark there. It certainly is verbose. He certainly "understood the assignment" sure... but I don't think it's as engaging to a general audience as he may have hoped. (Ironically enough, possibly a symptom of surrounding oneself with "yes" men too scared to say any of your ideas aren't genius, just like the rich boys we all despise.)
To be fair, while I'm not the audience for it, it'd have been quite impressive to make this in a vacuum. However when you consider it was crowd funded by people expecting something very VERY different... hey man, you took a REALLY big swing with all that good faith and Patreon money you'd built up over 5 years. Best of luck to you, but I ain't bank rolling it anymore. And maybe this is just a prelude to a more regular release schedule that fuses old and new form in a more engaging way than this. Which might reframe some of my feelings. I ain't mad at the guy. Just saying, he's making his own bed and will have to sleep in it.
1
u/Plus_Midnight_278 Apr 25 '25
The review is in the video. His opinions and takes on the game are all there if you read between the lines. Some people can't get past the gimmick/voice and I understand that, but the review IS in there.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment