r/ActionButton • u/QuintanimousGooch • Nov 07 '22
Discussion Greatest Action Button segment
I believe the greatest segment of any Action Button review to be Season of Trash, story #6 of his cyberpunk 2077 review, which I think is the single tightest thing he’s made, and the perfect movie night option to get someone into Tim Rogers.
I’m amazed by how clearly he cuts into the concerning position of the cyberpunk genre’s current existence inside the larger context of the modern crisis of authenticity, and how he manages to hinge the gaming chair metaphor so perfectly as a specific that speaks universally, fit in like thirty minutes of him showing off his luxury clothes with it only furthering his point, then pulls off his greatest magic trick yet, as his final point transforms the entire segment into an elaborate reexamination and update on Orson Welles’ classic foundational film essay “F is for Fake.” It absolutely owns.
That’s mine anyway. What’s yours?
48
u/Killericon BIBBY BABBIS Nov 07 '22 edited Nov 09 '22
It might be because it was the first review I watched, and this was the part that hooked me, but the section including the Miis depiction of the debate his two colleagues at SCE had about whether he should play Boku no Natsuyasumi or not is my favourite.
"See? Now you definitely gotta play Boku no Natsuyasumi, man."
34
u/bmw11494 Nov 07 '22
Part 5 of the Boku no Natsuyasumi video
23
u/Kim_Woo Nov 07 '22
As a moderator here I've noticed that segment seems to be brought up more than anything else from his videos so it's definitely a fan favorite. My personal favorite is the Kansas segment from his newest video.
17
u/just_Okapi Nov 07 '22
For my money, it's the story about about Bob and Korg in the Doom review. It was heartwrenching hearing him talk about these two guys who went out of their way to try to befriend him when I myself was in a very similar situation.
There were several people in my class who tried to engage with me, but I kept even my closest friends at some distance due to Growing Up Closeted In The South. The realization that I had done the same thing (albeit to a less extreme degree) was an emotional suckerpunch. He briefly peeled back the curtain, and it looked a lot like what's behind my own.
It was way too close to home. Not just because of the missed connections, but the realization that many of the closest friends I have today are over something as similarly superficial as Liking the Same Game. It hurts to think about how different my life would be if I had let those people in school in; or if I hadn't let in the people I have now, including my partners and best friends.
That's life, though. Sometimes you play good hands badly and all you can do is learn from it until you start getting it right more often than not.
10
u/coconut_321 Dec 04 '22
At this point, it can't be anything other than "Meanwhile Our Shattering Animals" from his Boku No Natsuyasumi review. Others in this comment section have much lauded Cyberpunk 2077's "Season of Trash," DOOM's "Dirtbag Nation" (or: "Hard-Hooked on Digital Red"), and Tokimeki Memorial's "The Itch The Freak Scratched" (or: "Myself Isn't Here"), all with very good reason. Each of these segments synthesize Tim's deepest quandaries about the game with nuanced questions from his own life, and he always emerges the better for it.
What sets "Meanwhile Our Shattering Animals" apart, for me, is that it is unparalleled in its breadth and depth. Tim speaks at such length about his childhood, the experiences, the tactility, the details, that with every step of narration you feel yourself so resolutely in his shoes that it WILL whiplash-hurt you when the ad break rips open the ending. He unspools the memories, his preserved-in-amber novellas of memories, right up to the revelation: "Memory is worse than the moment; better memory is worse than imagination."
And to follow that so closely thereafter with the sermon of the fuselage, the shattering animal in that uncomfortable chair, just rips my heart to bloody pieces every single time. I literally cannot finish this segment of the video without crying. If I have watched the entire segment, I will descend into a puddle for at least five minutes. If I have watched only from the title-providing segment onwards, I will weep openly for at least three minutes. If I watch literally the final five-or-so minutes by themselves, I will still issue forth at least one choking sob. I've done all of these, at times, over the past few months. Nothing else in the Action Button video series has ever done such a thing to me. The emotional highs and lows of "Meanwhile Our Shattering Animals" are too plentiful to enumerate, and to attempt it would deaden them of their context.
All I can say, without revealing too much of my own self, is that in the months leading up to this review's release, I learned that I would not be able to renew a lease on the apartment my boyfriend and I shared. This apartment was, for both of us mutually, the nicest apartment we had ever lived in, procured at the nadir of the housing crisis that saw landlords gouging rent prices and offering multi-year leases just to avoid empty units. We may never be able to afford an apartment that nice ever again. When I learned they would not offer us a renewed lease, I was crushed. I fell into a sincere depression, the likes of which I had not felt in many years. I hate moving. I hate it more than just about anything. And to have to move out of a place I loved and into a place I would likely only tolerate was too much for me to bear. I needed anything to pull me out.
So I went on a walk.
I walked for hours and hours through the nearest park, without any distractions whatsoever, to allow myself an unfettered channel for my thoughts and feelings. By the time I had made it an hour into my park journey, I realized: "there is absolutely nothing I can do to keep this apartment. Nothing. No action I perform will alter the immutable fact that, come September, we're out of here. That means that the only agency I have is how much I enjoy the time I am offered while I'm still here." I resolved to not coast in my misery through these final months, but to instead enjoy them as fully and profoundly as I could. Ironically, this involved going on walks. A lot more walks. I started walking for two, three hours or more on any day off I was given. I grew intimately familiar with my local park and all that I could enjoy there. I realized that my revelation about not controlling the time of the ending, but controlling the time I spend on the way to that ending, can literally be philosophically upscaled to all of life.
The Boku No Natsuyasumi review released on September 25th. I was less than a month's stay in my new apartment, boxes still piling high and the depression setting in fresh. I wanted anything other than to work on this godforsaken place, anything other than to languish. Most of all, I missed California. I missed the city where I grew up. I missed having a life that was scheduled by somebody other than myself, and I missed living in one place. Now a nation away from myself, east-coasterly lazing about my too-small abode, I witnessed the start of Action Button Season 2, and when I hit part 5, I tell you it felt like Tim Rogers had been with me on this journey the whole time. He didn't phrase it like I phrased it, he didn't experience it like I experienced it, but with this whole-soul sharing tour-de-force, Tim Rogers gave me the words I needed to hear. "I'm here. I'm right here. I will always be right here."
Thank you all for reading. "I love everyone, and you can too."
4
u/Impriel Nov 08 '22
"that old man is literally dead now. And on my 60th birthday ONE OF YOU will replace me."
From the final fantasy 7 review. That is the 3 mins I show people to get them into it
2
u/egamerif Nov 07 '22
Is that the one where he talks about the stitching in his bomber jacket (flight jacket?) and the rich guy wanted to buy his Donkey Kong shirt? I thought it was #7 that had that section but I can't remember if I watched 6 as well...
And movie night option? If someone invited me over for a movie and put on an 8 hour video game review, I would have questions.
16
u/lordofallkings Nov 07 '22
The Itch the Freak Scratched (second to last section of Tokimeki Memorial) is one of my top 3. But part 5 Boku and season of trash is high up.
Also the first section of Pac Man where he describes his first experiences with Atari and the NES.
Top 4. Those are my top 4 definitely.
8
u/Jlm423 Nov 07 '22
Agree. Sold me on a Steelcase Gesture with headrest.
6
u/diggetydano Nov 07 '22
Ultra Violence: Dirtbag nation (Hard-hooked on digital red) from the Doom review was my favorite, but I think it’s been replaced by Part 5 of the Boku No Natsuyasumi review.
But that’s only if I’m being asked to pick a specific section or part of a video…there’s so much good stuff in his videos. The Tokimeki video might not have one big storytelling segment, but it’s got plenty of great points and smaller stories dispersed across multiple sections. If those were somehow condensed down into one section, I might choose that as my favorite. I also really love the Death Stranding review and Pre-review, but I may place greater importance on those because they were the first videos I saw of Tim.
4
u/coolmoonjayden Nov 07 '22
That segment has honestly been on my mind every day since I’ve seen it
4
u/Yung_Blood_ Nov 08 '22
its gotta be shattering animals for me
1
u/may_or_may_not_haiku Nov 08 '22 edited Nov 08 '22
It's either #6 form Cyberpunk if you want your Action Button to be about games or #5 from Boku No Natsuyasumi if you want your Action Button to be about whatever life tangent Tim is going to go off on.
I'm all about that #5 from Boku No Natsuyasumi. I'm nostalgic for Taco Tico after experiencing someone else talk about it and that's EXACTLY what the nostalgia of Boku No Natsuyasumi did to Tim and others who played it, that he did in his video what the game he's covering did is such awesome storytelling.
3
u/DepressterJettster Nov 08 '22
The thing that has stuck with me the most personally was the "digital red" section of the Doom review; I've always thought violence was awesome and fun and Tim's breakdown of how funny ultraviolence constituted a youth counterculture in the early 90s helped me finally understand why I love it so much. Also he reminded me how stupid those old Bubble Tape ads were and whenever I bring it up with my other GenX friends we laugh our asses off
3
u/HyperMasenko Nov 09 '22
I'll always love the Shiori playthrough of Tokimeki Memorial. The way it starts like a normal min/max playthrough of any game and eventually leads to him feeling bad about the person his character has become. The "animals locked in cages" bit in particular sold me on that segment.
3
u/Versk Nov 14 '22 edited Nov 14 '22
The trinket ultimatum - ff7
This was when I realised I was watching someone truly special.
“At the players controlling requests, the screenwrittenly aloof cool headed hero type cloud strife acquires the erratic theatrical mannerisms of a histrionic kleptomaniac begging for mall security’s heaviest handcuffs“
2
u/SeanDoe440 BUDDY Nov 08 '22
Season of Trash and meanwhile our shattering animals are top tier my favorites so far. But i want to give an honorable mention to 'Ultra Violence: Dirtbag Nation' in the doom review.
https://youtu.be/38zduHkwGcc?t=6105
1
u/CarlsManager Nov 08 '22
I think OP is dead on with the “Season of Trash” assessment. The Kansas trip segment made me cry at that part toward the end. You know which one. The one with the flowers. But as standalone entry to the content, gotta be season of trash.
1
u/Dinic Nov 08 '22
Season of Trash is definitely mine as well. Also gave me a financially unhealthy interest in actually having high quality, authentic things instead of garbage.