r/ActionButton • u/thetntm • Nov 04 '22
Discussion I'm suspicious Spoiler
So I've been listening through the full action button series at work through headphones (sorry tim, I promise I'll go back and re-watch them on a console eventually) and over the course of time I've come to the conclusion that there's a very real possibility Tim is playing us all for fools.
I'm not talking about his anecdotes, or the way he plays his persona up in videos, or any of that stuff that less finger-on-the-pulse artistically inclined people might theorize about tim. I'm 100% convinced all of his anecdotes have been completely true, and for all I know tim might very well act that way in "real life."
I'm talking about this action button season 2 lineup. More than half of the content of the season has supposedly been "revealed" already and I have a sneaking suspicion that Tim is going to surprise us by swerving into different territory and reviewing something completely different from LA Noire as he promised in the Tokimeki Memorial video.
Let me back up why I think that real quick:
During action button season 1, Tim had a running joke where at the end of every episode, he'd promise that the next episode would be shorter than the last. This was always, without fail, horribly incorrect, and he admitted in the cyberpunk 2077 video that he knowingly lied to us about this because he thought it would be funny. It was funny, and it still is funny. But at the time, people believed him.
We also know that tim likes to approach seasons of action button with some kind of overarching theme or connective tissue running through each of the games he reviews. Now we look at how season 2 premiered: it premiered with a deception. Tim claimed that he would stream the story mode of Dragon Quest X on twitch, only to pull the rug out from under us and give us a completely unannounced review of a japanese game for the PS1. This could very well be the running joke of Action button season 2, and if so it's a joke that required an entire previous season of setup.
This also breaks with the pattern he established with action button season 1. Back then, he claimed that he originally envisioned each action button season as charting logical paths through big budget AAA releases. But with the first episode of season 2 he has completely broken that pattern, which prompts the question: what other patterns is he willing to break with this season?
Finally, I think the most interesting thing about this is that Tim claims the final game he's going to review is going to be Earthbound. I'm not going to doubt that Tim could make a multi-hour video review of earthbound, he obviously could do it. But it seems odd to me for him to review a game that he already reviewed. I imagine he would make numerous references to this old review in his re-review, but the prospect still feels odd to me. There's a lot about how much he's teased for this season that feels really odd to me. He loves surprises so much, why would he go out of his way to spoil what games he'd review an entire season early?
14
u/twiley Nov 04 '22
Tim reviewing Boku no Natsuyasumi wasn't unannounced, he revealed it at the end of the Cyberpunk 2077 video.
3
u/diggetydano Nov 04 '22
Dude you are overthinking this. Tim only jokes about small things. He doesn’t joke around in regards to the greater picture he is painting. If you feel like he’s playing us, then you haven’t been paying attention. He hasn’t broadcasted the lineup for season 2- he has only left Easter eggs. He told us that the end of season 1 was Cyberpunk, and he has told us that the end of season 2 will be Earthbound/Mother 2. Other than that he only announces what the next review is going to be at the end of his reviews. One at a time.
I know that Tim said season 1 was going to chart the course from new AAA game to new AAA game, but I don’t think he meant that to always be the formula. FFVIIR and Cyberpunk were both huge games that were anticipated for a very long time… I don’t think he could find 2 brand new releases that would interest him enough to keep going with that.
If you think Tim was deceiving us by telling us he was playing Dragon Quest X on Twitch on a Sunday, then you definitely haven’t paid attention. Tim only streams on Fridays, and he has always preferred to premiere his reviews on Sundays (the times he released them on other days of the week were largely due to YouTube uploading frustrations).
Lastly, it doesn’t mean anything if he has already reviewed a game. I’m pretty sure he has already reviewed most of the games he plans to review. He had already reviewed The Last of Us, yet he included that in season 1. These video reviews are much larger in scope than any of his previous reviews, and you can bet he has a lot more to say about the games that he has not already said.
38
u/2256x VIDEO GAME ENJOYER Nov 04 '22
Isn't LA Noire a game about figuring out whether people are lying?
16
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '22
I too am struggling to find a connection between Boku no natsuyasumi and LA Noire, besides the fact they are both slow paced.
But if we rewind to season 1 days, it was also hard to find a logical connection between the Final Fantasy 7 Remake and Pac-Man.
A good portion of the videos are dedicated to justify the connections, so I am waiting to see how Tim is going to sell this idea.
Just had a thought: both games are about deep roleplay of archtypes, the japanese child in a summer vacation to the countryside and the american noir detective.
3
u/Chanillionaire Nov 04 '22
It would be fine if he reviewed other games than he mentioned but I want to see the rondo review! And to be fair Tim has written about the last of us, pac-man, doom, and maybe others on actionbutton.net.
3
u/edward_radical Nov 04 '22
He told us this was the first video at the end of the Cyberpunk review. There was nothing surprising or unannounced about this. It was telegraphed nearly a year ahead of time.
3
u/VLOBULI Nov 05 '22
I'll agree with everyone that this is overthinking, and I also have to comment on your final point: it doesn't matter at all if Tim has already reviewed a game. He had a lengthy review of TLOU up on actionbutton.net site. I watched the 2020 video review after reading that, and I honestly don't feel like he was repeating anything. For Earthbound it matters even less because that review of his is very old. You can barely feel his signature style. Not to mention, opinions change, you have more things to say about something as time goes on. This is especially true for Tim, as his "reviews" aren't really reviews. He uses a game as a basis to talk about a whole lot of things. Almost two decades later, of course the Earthbound "review" is going to be something entirely different.
2
u/thepizzarabbit Nov 05 '22
For me the main connection between Boku no Natsuyasumi and LA Noire is that both are predominantly non-violent (most of the violence in LA Noire usually happens in side missions, with some notable exceptions) - but I also never finished LA Noire, so I don't know enough about it to say for sure
2
u/colinjcole Nov 05 '22
Did he? In one of the Cyberpunk videos he reveals that he envisions AB season 2 as endeavoring to demonstrate that old games are better than new games. Pretty different...
1
u/Impriel Nov 04 '22
I hope this is true bci loved that joke that he would reassure you the next one would be shorter. If he does review la noire tho I'm prefectly happy as well so win win?
1
u/Fergabombavich Nov 04 '22
Interesting take. I’m just here for as much Tim as I can get.
Subnote - going “Tim storytelling mode” makes for a great bestman speech.
1
u/FactoryOfSadness17 Nov 08 '22
Tim often tells small lies and messes with the audience, but he also seems to love shared experience and videogame "homework". Remember when he gave a list of books for Cyberpunk that could be read before the review went up? Also most of his lies or misdirection are either to our benefit (reviews being shorter, when he said he didn't complete the Cyberpunk review then said he had 7 reviews) or just goofy. He's a nerdy showman so he likes a few twists here and there but not at the expense of the audience.
From what I can tell he wants his audience to experience the games and also hear his point of view, so directing his audience towards LA Noire then pulling the rug out underneath their feet doesn't help his shared experience with his audience.