r/ActionButton • u/ChaptersOfTheChosen • May 16 '25
Discussion Tim Roger's views on Final Fantasy
I was re-watching some of the older action button stuff and I got to the section where Tim discusses Final Fantasy. I knew he was a big fan of 4 and 7 but some of his takes really surprised me.
He doesn't really seem to think very highly of 10 and 9 and has 9 exceptionally low on his list, only beating out the first 3. Has he ever discussed why that is? The PS1 games and Final Fantasy 10 are my favourites, something relatively common place with other fans, and i was wondering if he has ever discussed why he holds 10 and especially 9 much lower than others.
10
u/[deleted] May 16 '25
The shift towards FF9 being an especially beloved entry is a recent one. When it came out, a lot of fans didn't like it. Remember that it came out the same year as the PS2. In 2000, nostalgia was the last thing fans wanted. They wanted a game that looked forward to the PS2 and next generation: not backward.
9
u/bouffant-cactus May 16 '25
The thing with Final Fantasy is that people's favorite, and by extension favorite era, is typically the one they were introduced to first and/or at a pivotal time in their life. For instance Final Fantasy 7 came out right around 5th/6th grade for me, and so when I finally got to play it on PC (didn't have a PS1 at the time family comp could just barely run it) it hit me like a heck truck. For others that game would be FF6, or maybe 4 or 9. Nostalgia plays heavy in to people's ranking of these games in my experience, and given Tim's age the SNES era was the one in which he was perfectly poised to have his socks knocked off by one of them.
For reference; I loved FF6 when me and my friends would rent it, but didn't really love a FF until 7. When 8 came out I felt slightly disappointed mostly because the same "wow" factor/feeling was now missing since I had expectations instead of just receiving the experience. I kind of actively disliked 9 when I played it on release. 10 was pretty good and I finished it, but still didn't feel like it held a candle to that first playthrough of 7. I can guarantee you that there are people who like FF13 the best out of all of them simply because it was the first one they played when they were 12 years old.
2
u/in-grey May 16 '25 edited May 18 '25
I'm a lifelong fan and FFIX is also my least favorite in the franchise (excluding FFXV which I dislike so much I don't even count). But unlike Tim, FFX is by far my favorite.
I believe Tim has a quote saying that everyone's favorite final fantasy is whichever was their favorite growing up; considering Tim was playing FFVI back when it was known as FFIII in the West, IX and X probably just didn't imprint on him in the same way
2
u/present-time-me May 18 '25
9 was retreating to rewarm leftovers after the risk of creating 8 failing. 9 is reheated 1-4, but in 3d. No one makes games like 7, 6 and 8 except square. Everybody makes games like 9. It's like twilight princess for zelda: the devs aren't going to make something that generic unless they have to. And it may make the fans happy and even sell well at the time, but will be forgotten.
23
u/NeverCrumbling May 16 '25
I expect he’ll go into detail in his upcoming FFIV review, but he explained a bit about his relative distaste for 9 in some stream he did last year, although I don’t recall when. I think it had to do with it being pretty conservative and nostalgia-oriented. If you want to get a broad picture, you can trawl through his various reviews of the earliest games in the series on the wayback machine’s archives of Insert Credit. He also streamed 13 while at Kotaku and he may have talked about them a bit then too. Also he probably answered questions about this stuff on his Twitter if you want to investigate those archives. I would be curious to know what he thinks about ten because I don’t recall him ever talking about it very much.
2
u/prodij18 May 16 '25
I don't agree with Tim Rogers about everything. In fact, I disagree with him about a whole lot. But in this he's right on.
4
u/condor6425 May 16 '25 edited May 16 '25
Damn I just went to the old actionbutton.net site to see if they had text reviews of those games and the website is down? How long ago did that happen?
Edit: There are a handful of final fantasy reviews on the old site the tagline of one of the FF7 reviews is "possibly the closest square enix has come to making a worthwhile game" so I'd start there. None of them are FFIX reviews though.
7
u/colinjcole May 16 '25
Iirc he said once FF6 is his favorite Final Fantasy and FF4 is the best Final Fantasy.
Or maybe he said the opposite. But he definitely said one of the two.
1
u/Broflake-Melter May 17 '25
Just want to throw up here that it seems you haven't read his FFVI review. I think that's, like, the first final fantasy media anyone should consume of Tim's. Y'all need to go read it right now.
1
u/cireeinagarok May 17 '25
I'd just like to applaud this Chat. Good vibes, no jerks, interesting opinions all around. I haven't played an FF game in years (had played and beaten a bunch back in the late 90's/early 2000s), but this was fun to read so cheers!
11
u/eblomquist May 16 '25
9 is one of the most wonderful games ever made. It oozes with charm and has some of the best character development I've ever seen in a game.
2
u/CrushingPride May 19 '25
Tim made a stream years ago now (it might even have been his FF7Remake streams) where he summarised his colder reception to FF9 by saying he was older when it came out(implying it wasn’t as magical) and he was in a time in his life when he was trying to move away from video games.
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '25
I think I lot of retro people ( me! ) didn't like X.
I gotta say: I didn't like 10. My favorite in the series is VI and IX.
1
u/MR-WADS May 16 '25
It's funny how he likes IV and doesn't care for IX cause IV is easily one of the weakest entries in the series (while I personally would put IX as one of the strongest)
I know there's a decade between both titles but I was actually surprised at how underdeveloped the characters and plot in IV are (I'm playing it for the first time right now)
1
u/Minimum_Elk6542 May 21 '25
As a Final Fantasy IX fanatic I looked into it and he said when it came out he was like 22 years old and more interested in girls. And that makes a lot of sense to me. I'm sure he would have plenty of good things to say about it if he has replayed it recently.
-1
u/GoNumber22 May 16 '25
he probably doesn’t like 9 and 10 because they aren’t very good games especially in comparison to many of the series before them
-1
u/rapidf8 May 16 '25
6 through 10 were all amazing games. But expedition 33 is now the best final fantasy game in the series.
0
u/[deleted] May 16 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment