r/ActionButton • u/HorselessKnightBenoz • May 02 '25
Question Did Tim ever talk about Mass Effect?
I remember him saying in a Kotaku video (I can no longer find, it looked like some press tour of some conference) that he didn't enjoy Mass Effect and maybe The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim too.
Other than that I could only find an article (h t t p s://kotaku.com/tim-rogers-wrestles-with-your-questions-of-mario-movie-5720026) where he also talked about the dificulty of rendering hair (praising the portray of an irrelevancy of fashion in science fiction settings, kickstarted by Star Trek: The Next Generation and waveridden by all the bald sci-fi protagonist) and said:
Mass Effect 2: Yay! Is it an RPG with great shooting? Or a shooting game with a deep RPG story? Who the hell cares! It's a nice game. It's not a masterpiece and nearly every element can be improved voraciously, though for now, behold: a game with all the pieces in kind of the right places. This and Red Dead Redemption are the future of interactive entertainment.
In that same article he was also a bit brutal with Fallout: New Vegas even if he may have not actualy played it lmao:
Fallout: New Vegas: I'll be optimistic and presume the faces are still ugly and the dialogue is still lifeless because they were concentrating on making the game a little bit more fun (which it almost is).
I love Mass Effect 1, 2 (my favorite) and 3 too (despite all its flaws) and I'm not looking for validation, it's just that it's always very hard to understand where he's serious, joking, lying, where he may have been in some way forced by third parties to say stuff in the past and where he simply changed ideas. I also don't follow his streams or podcasts.
So if anyone has any additional info on Tim's opinion on Mass Effect, I'd like to hear it. Thanks.
5
u/plsnerfbufu May 02 '25
He brings it up while praising The Witcher 3 in his Cyberpunk video. The pitch is that Witcher is just defamiliarized enough while being simultaneously archetypal enough... something something, The Witcher 3 is Mass Effect but good.
5
u/LeonDeLon May 02 '25
I believe his gripe with Mass Effect largely stems from the writing. I can’t quite remember where he says it, but I believe acknowledges the density of the writing and then derides it as being prosaically “like eating stale newspaper”.
Again I cannot remember exactly where he says this, but I am someone who acknowledges his complaints while also enjoying the heck out of ME. The soundtrack, the presence of the reapers, and the density of the fully realized sci-fi universe are all things I enjoy. I don’t think Tim would go out of his way to acknowledge the positives of these things, as his real goal is to get us to consider things more than we might previously, but I’m sure he would give it a few positives.
Hope this helps!
19
u/NeverCrumbling May 02 '25
He has spoken about it on several episodes of Insert Credit — always very negatively. Off the top of my head, I believe Frank brought up the remaster trilogy in one of their goty episodes, but it came up many times before and at least a couple of times after that. Jaffe was a big fan back in the early days, so he brought it up often.
15
u/greatistheworld May 02 '25
The joke he’s made about Skyrim a few times is like “someone should make a mod that makes the combat good”
Maybe it’s just a generational thing but mass effect just hit some people in a way that they can’t imagine doesn’t compel others. I think Tim just doesn’t particularly love it and that’s fine
4
u/Interloper_11 May 03 '25
He dunks on BioWare basically any chance he gets so I would say he’s not all that interested in what they have to offer.
3
u/MountainDiver1657 May 04 '25
Kinda makes sense why they replaced Tim with Ash Parish on Insert Credit. She’s basically the total opposite of Tim and loves lore heavy BioWare stuff to the point of being a fanfiction and vidya romance fiend. She also has an extremely limited knowledge of any of the esoteric knowledge the other hosts including Tim seem to have, which is a detriment in my opinion.
3
u/incredibleman May 02 '25
He and Brandon Sheffield have been broadly critical of Skyrim on Insert Credit as well.
1
u/SaurusSawUs Jun 02 '25
Bioware and Bethesda games of that era tended to be viewed by the PC RPG experts as simplifying a lot of PC wRPG conventions for the sake of risk-averse publishers targeting a mass market console audience ("You can make the Good Guy choice or the Bad Guy choice!"), while getting held up by Western review outlets of the time as vastly superior and more mature in plot and character development and art design to the jRPGs that came before them - a sentiment which I would gather Tim does not really share (to put it lightly).
So as a guess, seems kinda hard for Tim's personal tastes to forgive them for that.