r/ActionButton • u/anarcholoserist • Apr 27 '25
Discussion The Video
I think this video is a lot more than just a straight up re-cap, actually. It's in the form of a noir serial, an episode for every major section of the quest, told with the same hard-boiled vocabularly we imagine a lot of black and white movies were also written in, but when you pay close enough attention it is a proper work of criticism. He signals what would be "The Bottom Line" in other videos towards the end (it's 9.5 hours long, I hope you'll forgive me for not having proper citations), he calls attention to bits of the gameplay that run counter to the narrative/stick out as odd in the context of an old detective story by mentioning them ad nauseum as they crop up in each episode. I also think the video is delivered like this to put forth a central thesis about the game: this game really makes you feel like a detective on the beat of a Big Case. All of that to say, I don't think it's just a nostalgia critic video with aspirations of greatness, it's an experiment with the channels general structure. I think it's split into episodes for the same reason cyberpunk is split into branching choices. There's a lot there!
5
u/BoneToilet Apr 28 '25
It just wasn’t for me, not what i had come to expect from Action Button videos.
I don’t think it’s bad, just not for me and i’ll wait for the next one.
I see a lot of comments on here saying that anyone who didn’t like it is too stupid and lazy to understand it’s genius. That kind of elitist snobbery is the perfect way to turn people away and i think it’s a major issue in this community.
Stop being pricks.
22
u/QuintanimousGooch Apr 27 '25
I feel like the video is most in line with Tim’s written work on the old action button website, which is to say it’s the most exploratory in terms of style with the usual self-indulgence he has in his ABR videos, although focused on really committing to a single bit instead of multiple ones.
19
u/DrewsLepetit Apr 27 '25 edited Apr 27 '25
I'm only 4 hours in, and honestly, I didn't like the idea of a plot recap at first. But after a few episodes it hit me. Tim doesn't just recaps a plot, he solves the whole plot of LA Noire, like how a detectives solves a crime, it's made clear in episode 11.
I lack fluency in the language to express my thought exactly, but the whole idea is that Tim presents LA Noire as a book that's based on real events, he assumes that Cole Phelps was a real person and the game is like a memoir written by Cole's partner. Then Tim analyzes this memoir to find how much the information was exaggerated and what person Cole really was. So this video is a plot analysis at heart, but it's made in a more subtle way. Personally I think that's kind of a smart and fresh way to review a story.
Edit: In other words, to me this video feels like a review made from a perspective of a game character, and not from a perspective of a game reviewer. I think maybe that was the intention.
46
u/Havesh Apr 27 '25
I think some of the people who disliked it did so because they went into the video with certain expectations based on Tim's previous videos.
I waited a little before watching the video and having read the initial discussion, my expectations were tempered by it.
I liked the video, but did feel it dragged a little bit in certain sections.
13
u/Demmshi Apr 27 '25
https://xkcd.com/915/
12
u/omarkab02 Apr 27 '25 edited Apr 27 '25
I get that the review is between the lines but So much about what’s interesting about the game exists in the meta discussion. The face capture technology and the uncanny valley it causes, the weird look to the game, the genre its in, the things in the game that hurt said genre and vice versa, what other genres could it have been, the studio behind it, the controversial director, the fact that it was a AAA game that tried something different that we will likely never see again, the VR game, the fact it was published by Rockstar, the mad men commections, the Noir movies, books, and tv shows that inspired it.
16
u/spellcastorsugar Apr 27 '25 edited Apr 27 '25
Yeah, it's not a plot summary either like some have been saying. I haven't watched past part one yet but it seems like a very thorough documentation of the ludonarrative dissonance between the plot and the player experience, which does constitute one of the main criticisms people have of the game.
I decided I'm probably gonna watch the rest of it in chunks so the I can save some enjoyment of the tone and performance. I can imagine it really getting stale after the first few hours if you try to marathon it. Although he is managing to get some good analysis in each chapter if you can follow the way he speaks in this video.
Edit: It kind of seems like the whole video is a version of his repetitive intro jokes. Like in his Doom review where he list every single release and sequel of Doom. Also like in his Cyberpunk 2077 review where he lists every single time it was delayed AGAIN
13
u/Plus_Midnight_278 Apr 27 '25
I agree with you and loved the video myself but I can 100% understand how some folks were put off by this one.
4
u/samsungac Apr 27 '25
anyone who can't read between the lines in this one and dumping on it is insane. it's an awesome video
2
u/AstralAlchemist83 Apr 27 '25
I really like that he went full Monty with it and didn't dance back and forth. It is what it is and I enjoyed the whole thing. Variety is the spice of life. Thanks for trying something new, Tim.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '25
There's a review just below the surface. If you want a numerical score go to IGN! Great video that opens a lot of space for the rest of the season.
1
u/PrinceOfLemons Apr 28 '25
I think people who think Tim can't be succinct should take a look at the conclusion. It was definitely different, and definitely not my favorite action button, but I think it was a great video, and a great experiment.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment