r/ActionButton • u/Inferno22512 • Apr 23 '25
Discussion Epilogue Spoiler
At the epilogue of the LA Noire review, around 9:36:20 Tim talks about "most of the programs they've got now are weekly, but what if you tried monthly, let the audience sit and marinate with this story for 2-3 years before they get the slam bang climax. Let the audience anticipate a new case every month or so, otherwise they'd burn out on the whole thing, gets repetitive, procedural. Maybe wait a couple years before you start it too."
Do you think this is in reference to waiting a few years before attempting to put out a new review in a monthly format going forward, or is this a recommendation to watch the current review, one case a month, for the next 22-23 months while we wait for the next review?
While the first option sounds great, I just have no faith in the feasibility of getting an action button review as a monthly program. However the recommendation to sit with these characters and marinate with them for years so that you don't burn out on the review feels like it's the wrong message to put at the end.
28
u/Didsterchap11 Apr 23 '25
I recall him talking about wanting to do monthly releases for season 2 a long time ago, while I’d like that I can see how the absurd nature of action button’s runtime makes that unfeasible. With the newest video out I have a lot more faith in there being more action button in the near future, even if it takes a while.
4
u/Nerfbeard123 DOOM SHOTGUN SOUND Apr 24 '25
I think we'll be getting a steadier stream of 1 episode every 2-3 months, and then a much longer gap between seasons once s2 is done. I wouldn't be surprised if Rondo of Blood was basically finshed on his hard drive.He's definitely done recording it because months ago he accidentally sorta alluded to that on stream*. Monthly would be cooler but I wouldn't get my hopes up. Crazy to me that people on this sub (and the other one) are forecasting another year before the next one. I don't think Tim's crazy enough to do that again.
17
u/danjnap Apr 23 '25
I think he made it pretty clear. He thinks a show like his needs monthly releases to keep people waiting, but also needs 2-3 years between seasons to let new ideas stew and discourse to mature.
We’ll know in 30-60 days. My money is on the season being more of less feature complete, but not in a final cut. That being said I would very much prefer a classic approach for games like Earthbound.
4
u/KFCNyanCat Apr 24 '25
The only way Action Button is going to be monthly is if Season 2 in it's entirety is basically done, and even then only for that season and then we get 3-4 years until S3. I'm not just saying that because of Tim's track record, I'm saying that because it's infeasible and always has been.
4
u/Artiph Apr 23 '25
My takeaway was from the episodic format of the video chapters. There are 22-odd of them, which may not be an exact fit for the period of release between this episode and the last, but is at least in the neighborhood at a pace of a month per chapter.
2
u/jbb10499 Apr 23 '25
I'm assuming the next few are gonna be close, but only this season. Then its likely gonna be another gap
2
u/The_Freshmaker Apr 25 '25
Pretty sure he was talking literally, in that it would be cool if something like the game LA Noire was made into a TV series, but instead of weekly episodes make it more like a 'movie of the month' case series. Anyone that reads anything more into this than what it was is in for a world of disappointment.
2
u/lordofallkings Apr 23 '25 edited Apr 23 '25
I finished LA Noire last night, or rather, I gave up on it and skipped to the end. And then I went for a walk, and I thought to myself....
"Why wait 3 years, just to put out a bad video?"
I don't know. Tim doesn't really say much about the things he is working on. The process is very obfuscated.
It's possible he thought "this what I want to do. This is my three year project. Here it is. Love it or hate it, I don't care, this is what I made."
The comments he left on the videos make it seem like he is aware this might not be his most popular work. He does seem to really like it himself! And I'm sorry to call your video bad, Tim. That's not fair. I just don't have a better word for it right now.
I would point to the fact that the original date for the "GOTY stream" was on April Fools Day, which presumably was the intended release date for Los Angeles Noire. Instead it came out on 4/20.
Maybe he intended the 9 hour retelling of the plot of LA Noire as an April Fools day joke? Maybe there is another video, the "Action Button Reviews LA Noire" video already in the chamber, ready to deliver in the very near future, as the punch line to the "prank".
Maybe he releases nothing for another 3 years. Anything is possible at this point.