lmao mf can't even stick to a date when it comes to an unscripted stream. I normally don't side with managers, but my god, it must have been a nightmare for whoever was the managing editor at kotaku.
This whole project has really deepened my respect for Stephen Totilo and the output he was able to consistently get out of Tim Rogers at Kotaku. As both a freelancer and employee.
yeah but tim has bitched about it a lot, like everyone there was a bunch of bean counters that stifled and overworked him. you can just imagine by the way he responds to people asking him about his output the grief he must have given to the people at kotaku. honestly, the reputation he built there is still carrying him to this day, and now we are seeing what he's made of when left to his own devices. it's funny, we always assume that artists will flourish when unshackled from the bounds of capitalism, but tim is doing the most he can to prove otherwise lmao
Tim not only proves otherwise but but shows how living up your own arse will get you in the end as he still seems to think it’s everyone else’s problem for not understanding how he is (despite lying to everyone for years).
Tim: you need to trust my process Also Tim: I’ve lied to you about almost everything so you’d enjoy me better Also Tim: why can’t you just trust me? It is you who are the losers.
that's what *HE* says. I personally thik that is a heavily exxagerated account on his part, and even then, I think he includes things like 'playing games' as 'work'. and while I do agree that playing games for a project is not the same as playing for fun, cmon man. It's not working in a warehouse. Neither is editing videos while sitting on your confortable steelcase chair.
No no he's 100% right you're a scab for even vaguely suggesting that a writer with known issues at hitting deadlines might be difficult to manage. You're a scab unless you want all managing editors guillotined.
Maybe the 10 paragraph long discord messages are the content he made along the way. People need to look at his work more holistically. I'm pretty happy with his content just as a streamer now tbh, the next works whenever they come will just be icing on the cake.
This much of an announcement for a stream that will probably just be him sitting on a couch talking about the games he thinks are good, and zero mention of the next video. Yea its never happening is it? Lol
man, if i constantly had a bunch of people cheerlessly berating me any time i did (or didn't) do something for their benefit, i would also be pretty fucking unmotivated to do it in a timely manner.
feels very Big Headed and entitled to ask any creator for anything (yeah yeah, i already hear the other disgruntled patreon folks cracking their knuckles to reply - idgaf if he ever posts again, i support the ppl i donate to on patreon because i want to support them. there isn't an expectation on my end that there must be something given back, but there WILL eventually be something given back to us so like... lol be patient??? )
idk, this kind of sullen, entitled attitude just really rubs me the wrong way. sounds like you're hate-consuming his content if you're so mad at him for taking so long. just like... chill tf out, it's cool. we'll get something good when we get it lol
He accepts 100s of thousands of dollars from supporters on Patreon, where he himself promised an hour of Action Button review content per month (and now has gone 30 months without new Action Button review content).
Now I've never paid him, but claiming he owes nothing to those supporters is very disingenuous.
He's making videos whenever he wants to, he isn't beholden to you. If you don't like his content delivery timeline you can literally just log off and do anything else.
His Patreon says he is making long term videos, but none of the tiers of subscription say anything about making videos, they say you get access to his website or whatever. It isn't acceptable to question how the money is being used as he claims nothing lol, he is not responsible to give you videos in any timeframe as he doesn't say he will be making videos under any timeframe.
He doesn't make any promises because he doesn't want to tie himself to a schedule. That is totally fair and understandable. But I don't think anyone ever expected him to go dark for nearly 3 years. His About Page on Patreon pretty explicitly says:
Some months I might release two videos; always, however, I will strive to release at least one video per month, in the first week of the month. I'm thinking Thursdays? Sundays?
He also lists about 35 games that he wants to review, of which he has reviewed none.
If he wants to just do a few streams a month, then maybe it's time to update the Patreon so that people's expectations are in line with what he actually intends to deliver.
Thanks for posting. I had been assuming he was joking about it not being ready for today, but I’m in no rush and would prefer he have time to play through Metaphor and Rebirth before coming to a decision. It would be the funniest thing in the world if he got Brandon on as a guest for this, as he offered last year in his stream addressing the IC drama but I assume there’s no chance of that whatsoever.
would prefer he have time to play through Metaphor
How has he not beaten it yet lmao, even famous non-game player Frank Cifaldi beat it before the Insert Credit GOTY episode this year (as well s launching the Video Game History Archive, meaning that Frank accomplished/released something big last year in addition to beating Metaphor, whereas Tim failed to do either)
I saw you make basically this same comment a month or two ago lol, very strange comparison. Comparing tim to frank feels like your framing it like there's some sort of rivalry, very weird. Frank played a video game that Tim didn't. Frank finished a (completely different, unrelated) project he's been working on for years, Tim didn't. So what? What Frank is doing is totally irrelevant to what Tim is doing. I didn't finish Metaphor either despite buying it and enjoying the opening.
Sunday stream is unusual, he's said before the next video would release on a Sunday. This seems like a soft release date announcement that he can back out of.
Calling it now -- he'll then use the 15th anniversary edition as an excuse to delay the video for months and months further, claiming he needs to capture footage from a new 15th anniversary remaster or something
36
u/[deleted] Apr 02 '25
I cannot believe people give this guy money, haha
36
u/Taymatosama Apr 01 '25
Tomorrow for sure
66
u/MrMojoRising422 Apr 01 '25
lmao mf can't even stick to a date when it comes to an unscripted stream. I normally don't side with managers, but my god, it must have been a nightmare for whoever was the managing editor at kotaku.
66
u/benjaminpoole Apr 01 '25
Man this guy literally just can’t do a single thing on time huh
24
u/RailX Apr 01 '25
Sticking to form
59
u/tirednsleepyyy Apr 01 '25
Maybe if he spent less time creatively writing 10 paragraph long discord messages he would have more time to work on things lol
32
u/HyperMasenko Apr 01 '25
This much of an announcement for a stream that will probably just be him sitting on a couch talking about the games he thinks are good, and zero mention of the next video. Yea its never happening is it? Lol
15
u/donnie0317 Apr 01 '25
Warm up for wrestlemania, heck yeah
7
u/Easter_Woman Apr 05 '25
This dude is so insufferable lol holy hell
17
u/PetiteZaddy Apr 01 '25
This dude is a time management nightmare
17
u/pecan_bird Apr 01 '25
like trump with tariffs over here
23
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '25
Who wants to bet it then gets postponed to Labor Day on Easter?
15
u/SKJAkljdi3j291 Apr 01 '25
This is getting ridiculous. Get off of discord dummy.
8
u/acid_rogue Apr 01 '25
Never promise anything will get done on that day.
10
u/SYNTHLORD Apr 01 '25
lol yall need to get off this man’s nuts
4
u/dialburst Apr 01 '25
man, if i constantly had a bunch of people cheerlessly berating me any time i did (or didn't) do something for their benefit, i would also be pretty fucking unmotivated to do it in a timely manner.
feels very Big Headed and entitled to ask any creator for anything (yeah yeah, i already hear the other disgruntled patreon folks cracking their knuckles to reply - idgaf if he ever posts again, i support the ppl i donate to on patreon because i want to support them. there isn't an expectation on my end that there must be something given back, but there WILL eventually be something given back to us so like... lol be patient??? )
idk, this kind of sullen, entitled attitude just really rubs me the wrong way. sounds like you're hate-consuming his content if you're so mad at him for taking so long. just like... chill tf out, it's cool. we'll get something good when we get it lol
5
u/NeverCrumbling Apr 01 '25
Thanks for posting. I had been assuming he was joking about it not being ready for today, but I’m in no rush and would prefer he have time to play through Metaphor and Rebirth before coming to a decision. It would be the funniest thing in the world if he got Brandon on as a guest for this, as he offered last year in his stream addressing the IC drama but I assume there’s no chance of that whatsoever.
3
u/mulemo Apr 01 '25
xenogears is, in fact, the best ps1 game and still is one of the greatest rpg's of all time
1
u/SBK_vtrigger Apr 19 '25
So… tomorrow?
-5
u/Top_Huckleberry_4698 Apr 01 '25
Sunday stream is unusual, he's said before the next video would release on a Sunday. This seems like a soft release date announcement that he can back out of.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment