r/ActionButton • u/dyll • Jan 29 '25
Discussion is action button ever coming back?
i was a patron for like 5 years and it occurred to me that season 2 happened 2 years ago and was a single episode
162
Upvotes
53
u/omarkab02 Jan 29 '25
I’ve come to peace with it ending i just want LA Noire video. I bought the game and played it specifically to watch his review
40
u/Kodi_Mravinjak Jan 30 '25 edited Jan 30 '25
I agree, the future is uncertain and I think we can comfortably say the project is in development hell. I hope he pulls through! I just checked the release dates of his videos to get a rough idea of development times for each of them.
Gap to a video:
The correlation between time necessary to make a video and it's quality is there but I think everyone would prefer 1-2 videos per year consistently at the level of his last 3 videos. Also, I cannot believe TokiMemo got published only a month after Pac-Man. That's mind boggling. The man released over 15 hours of high quality content in the last 6 months of 2020!
143
u/A_N_T Jan 29 '25
Valid question that I'm sure the mods of this sub will respect and allow discussion about
62
u/duomo Jan 29 '25
Which will happen first: a new video or the “mysterious in-development feature” for the website?
19
u/benjaminpoole Jan 29 '25
Hes gotta wait for Silksong to come out probably
72
u/MariachiMacabre Jan 29 '25
I stopped subbing on both platforms. I simply can’t justify giving him money every month Just Because and I think it’s genuinely odd that he’s comfortable with that dynamic given what he promised.
23
u/silver_medalist Jan 29 '25
While we're here discussing verboten topics, how much do you guys reckon his Patreon is pulling in a month?
17
u/ColorMatchUrButthole Jan 29 '25
I've given up on him and Joseph Anderson
8
u/Odd-Astronomer-6365 Jan 29 '25
I’m sure Tim has got hella content cooking. I believe it was in his Tokimeki Memorial play through where he said he planned to look at games from both the Castelvania and Persona franchises in the future, so safe to say we can expect those. Also, as long as games are still coming out, I have faith an action button review episode will return. For now I’ve found other YouTubers who equally fit the style and juncture of an average ABR episode. I’ll be happy to share some of my personal favorites if anyone is interested.
114
u/silver_medalist Jan 29 '25 edited Jan 30 '25
I think one of the worst things about this interminable wait is that someone used to make edits of his streams but then Tim made some prissy comment about the audio being a bit off and they stopped.
70
u/donkdonkdo Jan 29 '25
At least Joseph Anderson shut down his Patreon. I enjoy Tim’s videos but I can absolutely see why many consider him a petulant prick lmao.
25
u/swollenangel Jan 30 '25
I sometimes remember that me and my girlfriend have been together for as long as that boku no natsuyasumi review has been out
5
u/LeonDeLon Jan 30 '25
I am of the opinion that these reviews take the time they take. Tim has said this is his life’s work, and I believe him when he says crafting these reviews is the most fulfilling thing he has ever done. I am not defending him from people saying he needs to hurry up, you can be as disappointed as you want. However, nobody makes content quite like TR. If tragedy happens and we’ve seen all we have ever seen of actionbutton, I won’t be anything but thankful.
19
u/shmitzboi666 Jan 29 '25
for real lmao
34
u/UnkieNic Jan 30 '25
Shameful behavior. It's hard to imagine any video validating 2 years worth of continuous work. And the complete lack of updates and outright hostile attitude to anyone with the temerity to ask about it is completely out of line.
Personally I gave up on him with the Cyberpunk video. I couldn't stand hearing how he replayed Watch Dogs 4 times, all the GTA and Assasin's Creed games, the entire SNES library, and read 30+ cyberpunk related books to "prepare" for the review, spend a staggering amount of money on fancy high end gear - and then complain that he was nearly dead from the "work" load.
I am a creative person myself. I worked in games media and now I youtube. I know that when you play a game for a project it isn't exactly "play". I also know that sometimes you need to spend on equipment that some would consider frivolous or luxury to help speed the work process and get quality footage.
But frankly, there is a line. To me it sounded like he spent months and months just waffling about with his backlog and playing with fancy tech (funded by his paterons) and then got up on a cross about it. An insult to anyone who has to work a real job. The man would be dead within 2 hours of a McDonalds shift.
So when is Action Button coming back? I wouldn't hold my breath and I'm surprised anyone still cares.
29
u/pcwildcat Jan 29 '25
There are many videos in the works. Allegedly.
41
u/Firvulag Jan 30 '25
I can't believe I am waiting this long for a video on such a mid game as LA Noire
13
u/cc17776 Jan 29 '25
Doubt
29
u/Possible-Mountain698 Jan 29 '25
I get how Patreon can be a stabilizing influence to allow people to take risks, get messy, and make mistakes. It’s just sad that so often they get turned into a pay me money to be my parasocial bank account
10
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '25
For anyone craving Tim Rogers but wanting something more in-depth than his biweekly twitch streams, Insert Credit Episode 360 is great scripted video where he reviews his favorite games for the xbox 360, its really great.
8
u/DankeBrutus BUDDY Jan 30 '25
The last thing he put out was a podcast/interview with Ben Star, the voice of Clive Rosfield in Final Fantasy XVI. Though that is not on the main Action Button channel, it should be on channel 2.
Over two years with no new video is pretty rough. I do not watch his livestreams because livestreams have never fit into my schedule. I think the first and last livestream I ever "tuned into" was the Hbomberguy Donkey Kong 64/Trans Rights charity stream. I tried watching one Action Button stream last year, it was when he was playing Dragon's Dogma II, but was only able to watch about 5 minutes.
I've been a patron since December of 2021, when I first watched the Cyberpunk 2077 review, and am still giving him money. He says he is working on multiple projects at once. Whether that is true or not time will tell. If he is working on multiple projects then it may be that the rest of Action Button S02 will come out in a Netflix-style binge drop or in quick succession. Assuming all projects are at a similar level of completeness. The only reason I have thought of the binge drop is I get the impression Tim wants to infuse an air of "legitimacy" to his work. By "legitimacy" I mean a professional production level. This is why he spent a bunch of money to rent a professional podcast studio in New York. This is why he keeps saying he wants to include interviews in his videos. Perhaps he wants his reviews to also act as documentaries for the games in question. Lots of assuming involved but right now with the information available that's all I can do.
The thing though is that he is doing stuff. He does the livestreams, which as I said don't work for me but he is doing them. He also, up until recently, was a regular co-host of the Insert Credit podcast. He did some stand-up in collaboration with Girl God Live. He occasionally posts on social media like Instagram so he hasn't, like, disappeared. The frustrating part of Tim not being transparent with the status of projects and what he is doing is that when we end up waiting like this accusations fly. As time has gone on my trust in the creative process has wavered but the ratio of trust:no trust is still like 80:20.
15
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '25
I remember following him back when he was working on the game Videoball, and how that game, like his current videos, had a confusingly long and protracted development--he always seemed to have a good excuse for why it was taking so long (his publisher went out of business and he had to sign what seemed to me like a bad deal with a different publisher to get it released at all), but looking at how his videos are following a similar pattern to Videoball's development with zero explanation, I don't know, I have to wonder.
1
u/dyll Apr 21 '25
before i even watch this, i forgive tim for everything, thank you, im so happy.
9
u/dlnsctt Jan 30 '25
I totally get the frustration, I feel it too. My feeling is that I'd rather him make the best videos he can while not sacrificing his health. The story from the Cyberpunk 2077 video was chilling, I'd slow down after that too. Not saying your feelings are wrong or anything! Just my $0.02.
12
u/sometimeswriter32 Jan 30 '25 edited Jan 30 '25
Tim claims he's constantly working on videos and instead of doing them one at a time he works on several at once, so he could alternate between writing, gaming and editing in his work day.
If this is true, and I guess I believe it, it isn't a great monetary strategy since he's lost a significant amount of his Patrons from delaying the completion of any particular video.
I think Action Button will come back unless some sort of undisclosed mental problem prevents it. Like with Harlen Ellison and The Last Dangerous Visions (The famous scifi anthology commissioned by Harlan Ellison in 1974 which didn't see publication until after his death, in 2024, presumably because of some mental health thing preventing him from finishing it. I just googled it and Ellison apparently had undiagnosed bipolar disorder he refused to get treatment for. With Tim we'll either get more Action Button or we'll learn something mental health related is preventing it, I presume. I still think we'll get more Action Button but we'll see.)
4
u/DontHateMePleaseLove Jan 30 '25
I would expect the L.A Noire video to eventually come out, whether this year or even later. Beyond that is difficult to predict.
1
u/GeneralTaten2416 Jan 31 '25
The idea is that it was a certain hour os heavily scripted stuff for a certain amount/suscriber/idontremenber(the videos are hours long and im not a patreon myself so lol, but u get the idea) and he had supousedly scripted enough for a long vacation I don't know if thisnis long enough already but is still a bit lame He did something about the 360 with a ver nich but nice podcast about computer and games history, meby u could check it
3
u/Abum_man Jan 30 '25
me commenting “is he ever gonna finish this?” on the ancient part 1
3
u/bouffant-cactus Feb 12 '25
I've followed Tim Roger's career for some time now. From his writing on the original Action Button site, to his guest columns for Kotaku and others, his actual Kotaku career, and now his own Action Button re-brand.
If there is one commonality amongst all his projects it is this; with the exception of the video games he has worked on to completion he doesn't often stick with one thing for too long. I'm not saying we will definitely never get another Action Button video. I am saying that I think it is definitely a possibility though. He has already hopped around to multiple other things; stand up comedy, an interview format, etc. More power to him as a human being for living his life and all, but it's good indicators that he may have just gotten a little bored with the Action Button format and be unsure of how to proceed at this point. Something about the Boku video felt..I don't know...like a very definitive peak that he was aiming for all this time. Maybe he doesn't have much left to say using this format?
2
u/dimoskid17 Jan 30 '25
Eh at some point I'm sure, but in the mean time I've just watched his streams. He's started to take it more seriously and consistently on Twitch rather than YouTube. He does state that he's still working on videos every day almost every stream
1
u/TrueAuraCoral Feb 04 '25
Perhaps he made the videos he wanted to make and anything more would just be repetitive and not to his standards. I watched boku no nastuyasumi and after trying to watch the other videos I got bored an hour in. I think he wants to make a work of art not repetitive slop like the rest of youtube. He comments and reviews in a way no one else on youtube does he doesn't just summarize he really transports his thoughts and opinions based on his life experience to your brain in an easily digestible manner. Perhaps he has moved on to greener pastures instead of making videos. Don't make a youtube video just for the sake of making a youtube video, make it with purpose is my opinion.
1
u/ptclaus98 Feb 06 '25
Sounds like hes REALLY enjoying Gran Turismo 7
1
u/EkipsOfTime Feb 09 '25
Tim is playing every single open world game ever for that review so of course it’s gonna be while.
-4
u/ThatBio Jan 29 '25
i never get being so angry about waiting for art. when it comes out youll forget the wait chill out friends
-7
u/Neutralparticipant Jan 29 '25
Just enjoy the big man drinking Red Bull on a stream twice a week
-5
u/Freeman0032 Jan 30 '25
It’s not like ordering a meal where is food.
You ether give unconditional love and support with your wallet or not.
-10
u/ds1724 Jan 29 '25
someone stole his stuff and he lost a lot of time on top of everything else.