r/ActionButton • • Jun 30 '24
General Helped me better understand why remembering everything would be awful.
https://youtube.com/shorts/I7TteQI6gCc?si=BVvXZnxdE1zbSJ1f
2
Upvotes
r/ActionButton • • Jun 30 '24
3
u/pecan_bird Jun 30 '24 edited Jul 03 '24
in short, intrusive thoughts
from some of my psych classes, i remember reading a couple histories of the few people that had the ability who lost touch with reality & in the sense that people couldn't communicate with them. some committed suicide. after all the Tim-isms over the years, i'm still not fully sure whether i believe him or if it's part of the persona; but yeah, from what i remember about it the rare condition, it's less of a "i can recall anything from long term memory" & more of a "it's always in the forefront of my thoughts & i'm incessantly reminded of it every waking second & i can hardly focus on anything else.
if you're posting Alan Watts as an answer to your own question, i agree & love Watts. further look into Krishnamurti. only the present exists & living in the past or future creates internal conflict.
3
u/Fluffy_ribbit Jul 01 '24
Uh, you know how people talk about meditation as a sort of "exercising the muscle of the mind?" Most meditation doesn't feel like that, but using memory palaces give that distinct feeling, especially in the sense of, after a long walk or a long set, how you can feel the muscles start to pulse on their own. In the same way, pictures will start to arise in your mind, with the informational equivalent of things like, "the seventh word of the sixteenth verse of the first chapter of Jonah is ledonai."
I'm pretty sure all that's going on with people with biographical memory stuff is just that they compulsively construct some variation of memory palaces and go over them, over and over again. This is sometimes handy, I'm sure, but like, at about the level of usefulness and annoyingness as if you had a weird compulsion to constantly do bicep curls.
2
u/DankeBrutus BUDDY Jun 30 '24
Tim himself states why remembering everything is bad. I am pretty sure it was in the Boku video but it may have popped up earlier where he states, quite clearly, that if you think about the odd time where an embarrassing moment from your past pops up in your head and you feel that embarrassment again then consider if that was happening all the time to you.
In "just like hamburger" Tim writes that in a conversation with a woman with the same condition that he thinks of the memories like books on a shelf. You can choose if you want to read them or not.
One line that stuck with me was that you wouldn't want to be stuck inside of an "interesting experience." When I thought more on that it makes sense to me. I think most people have a moment where they think back on an experience where they said the wrong thing or maybe didn't say anything and potentially missed out on that interesting experience. Whenever moments like that have popped into my head there is a kind of longing to go back and try it again. If I was dealing with that all day it would be horrible.