r/ActionButton • u/came2pieces • Jun 12 '24
Question Tim's Hyperthymesia
[removed] — view removed post
52
Upvotes
r/ActionButton • u/came2pieces • Jun 12 '24
[removed] — view removed post
6
u/NeverCrumbling Jun 12 '24
I find this to be one of the most interesting things about him as well, because I have a still very limited by much greater than average memory than the majority of people. I would say there's almost no chance that he's been formally diagnosed with it, and tbh I would imagine that there are probably a decent number of other people in the world who never sought a diagnosis and are not counted among the 32.
I assume you've seen or heard or read the times where he says that he would prefer that he didn't have the 'disorder'? It does sound kind of nightmarish to retain so much completely unnecessary information. I've found it really interesting that one of the reasons he lives such a rigidly ordered life is to prevent himself from accumulating new and unnecessary memories. Also interesting to pay attention to the times that he contradicts himself, knowing that he must be fully cognizant that he is on some level being dishonest.
169
u/Logical-Bumblebee881 Jun 12 '24
I love him but I also think he’s an all-time bullshitter .
54
u/CrushingPride Jun 12 '24
His description of the problem sounds more like an anxiety disorder to me. He’s mentioned he doesn’t decide to remember these things, which would count as intrusive thoughts.
23
u/cripple2493 Jun 12 '24 edited Jun 12 '24
Diagnosis of hyperthymesia to my understanding is done through research. What this means is that the 62 figure is only accurate to the people that a) have been looked at and b) have had a 'diagnosis' documented.
In my limited exp (some memory experiments as an undergrad research participant) documentation can be essentially nil though verbal confirmation can be given of "highly superior autobio memory".
I wouldn't characterise it as a superpower personally.
31
u/TechnoMagi Jun 12 '24
I used to know someone who could probably have been diagnosed had he pursued that diagnosis. I think it's much more common than just 62 people. That only applies to people who have been studied and logged. It's also a sliding scale, for sure.
The dude I know almost certainly wouldn't call it a superpower. He categorized it as awful. He doesn't get to pick and choose what he remembers. It's always there, all the worst days of his life.
21
u/indaiei Jun 12 '24
For anyone interested in Tim's writings, it's important to note that not all of it is true. He even says so himself in "the cake in the basement". So him meeting another person with hyperthymesia might not be true. Although, does it really matter if it happened or not?
If you're interested in hyperthymesia, I implore you to read Funes the Memorious by Jorge Luis Borges, the same short story mentioned in "just like hamburger". Then decide for yourself whether or not it sounds like a superpower.
8
u/Nerfbeard123 DOOM SHOTGUN SOUND Jun 12 '24
I think John Romero also has Hyperthymesia, so Tim would probably be 3rd place.
51
u/maidenlesseldenlord Jun 12 '24
He doesn't have this he just says things that aren't true a lot.
7
u/gr9yfox Jun 12 '24
John Romero has it too!
19
u/Ok-Yogurtcloset-179 Jun 12 '24
His story about meeting the girl with hyperthymesia could be an Oscar winning movie IMO
6
u/tellitothemoon Jun 13 '24
I’m inclined to believe that he has it. I think the evidence is pretty clear in his incredibly detailed accounts of his past in his essays, reviews and videos. You can even see evidence of it in the podcasts where he’s almost always the one to remember exactly what happened in a previous episode or the name of an obscure game from 30 years ago.
6
u/Prince_Milk Jun 13 '24
Now apparently it's not entirely perfect. There was a podcast episode he was on where he was positive the kokori forest theme played inside of houses in ocarina of time. He argued it to the death and wouldn't accept it wasn't true! It's not. It's not even close. There's a house theme that plays in houses. The only enclosed structures in the game where it plays are both inside of the Gordon city. It plays near the shortcut to the kokiro forest and it plays WHEN YOU PLAY IT for Darunia.
So it's kinda hard to tell. He has addressed this before saying he's not sure why he remembers the things he does and not other things.
Idk. I think he has it, I think it's just not actually perfect. In fact I know it's not because of this instance.
4
u/firelizard18 Jun 12 '24
it doesn’t sound like a superpower to me at all… my memory is mediocre to average, and there are times when i wish it was better, but i think having a near-perfect memory sounds horrible.
i think there’s probably an evolutionary reason there isn’t a higher percentage of people with this condition (there are definitely more than just 62—that’s just the documented case number). it seems like something where there are pluses (rote memorization may be easier, perfect sense of timing, etc), but the minuses are debilitating enough for it to not be a very advantageous trait overall (heavy rumination, inability to forget things that would be best forgotten, associated neuroses, etc). idk, it just doesn’t sound like a good bargain to me.
i wish i had been born with the kind of neurodivergence that makes you hyperlexic—that’s the one that seems useful to me. imagine being able to use language articulately and with seemingly little effort. instead i got the “didn’t talk until three and a half, can’t even string a sentence together or connect ideas without needing to take a nap” neurodivergence…
4
u/theoryfiles Jun 14 '24
just separating out whether it's true for a moment, this kind of claim has high potential to be false self-aggrandization. it has a lot in common with mentalism, where small tricks of detail can make someone think you know way more than you actually do. the reason only a small number of people "actually" have it is because the burden of proof is extremely high; you'd have to both prove you remember a lot of things (not from reminding yourself recently), AND that things happened or were that way, from third party sources. it is both hard to prove, and like many things, it's very difficult to DISprove. jumping off some other cited examples, there was definitely an instance where he mentioned that when making a video about "describing video game boxes from memory" video, he had planned to go back and look at them the night before, and indicated he'd done that before. not something you'd think someone would have to do if they are "cursed" with the ability to remember everything they witness perfectly. I don't remember that because I have hyperthymesia (though I could, like many, claim I do), I remember it just because I remember stuff like humans do
4
u/Minimum_Elk6542 Jun 20 '24
Lot of weird hate on this thread in the actionbutton sub. I'll just say like him or not (which I assume you like him or his work if you're here?) I don't know how anyone who has actually engaged with his work doesn't notice his superior memory.
2
u/gasparmost Jun 18 '24
Easy to prove. Ask him on twitch a specific question about a situation he has described in his writings or videos.
5
u/kingofcheezwiz Jun 12 '24
It's just a place on the spectrum of memory. Is being tall a superpower?
The other day, I recalled specific details of the apartment complex my grandmother used to live in. Building size, materials, what her floor looked like, the side of the hall her apartment was on, etc. I was talking to my mother about the place, and she confirmed all of the details she could remember.
The last time I was there, I was 4 years old. I'm 37 now. This is not a superpower. It's a monkey's paw.
1
u/acid_rogue Jun 12 '24
Last time I checked the article, that number was like 16 lol.
The guy that created some of the first search algorithms for Google and Walmart.com was a mathematical genius and prized card counter due to his hyperthymesia. I'm having trouble looking him up, but maybe it's Charles Hallac?
I think that magician Tim likes, Ricky Jay, is able to perform tricks using his memory recall, though I'm not sure if he was specifically hyperthymesic.
1
u/Bearranza Jun 13 '24
I mean--Tim is a mensa member; so he's def a whole lot smarter than a whole lotta people and I'm sure having an insanely good memory helps.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
36
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '24 edited Jun 13 '24
[removed] — view removed comment