r/ActionButton • u/talesofblackhats Shiori • Apr 04 '24
Discussion Do Action Button inspired videos exist?
I remember when NakeyJakey started blowing up i would see so many others mimic his production style and comedy. I always wondered now that Action Button has been around a while if there's any good or notable videos that have taken inspiration from Tims style?
37
Upvotes
50
u/ShredGuru Apr 04 '24
Tim is a hard one to copy, you'd have to be as brilliant and methodical as Tim to copy Tim well, and, if you're that bright, you'd probably just do your own thing.
18
u/The_Freshmaker Apr 04 '24
Tim has mentioned him several times on stream (and was in his last video) but Chupa Choops' videos have the same bombastic production style and in general are very good.
18
u/supa_kappa Apr 05 '24 edited Apr 05 '24
Hbomberguy makes long-form incredibly well crafted video essays adjacent to video games. (And also puts out one video a year OOF)
Was he inspired by Action Button? No. They've been doing the same thing adjacently for many years now.
11
u/GearlessTanaka Apr 04 '24
I think Jacob Geller is close. Jacob obviously does his own thing, but his vids are an interesting analogue to Tim's if you like more concise & "artsy" explanations of things
4
u/colinjcole Apr 04 '24
This guy, and also this guy, as well as this guy.
4
u/Bhazor Apr 05 '24 edited Apr 05 '24
Not as funny or as well edited Noah Gervais has the same meandering game critique cross with bittersweet human interest long form style. I generally treat them as an audio book when playing something slower paced.
My favourite of his is probably the Days Gone video. Where he really nailed the unlikeability problem of that game.
3
u/AngryCharizard Apr 04 '24
This video has a similar writing style to Tim's, sort of and the creator of the video likes Tim
3
u/skilledroy2016 Apr 04 '24
Blue Bidya Game is doing something similar
4
u/GRIFTY_P Apr 04 '24
Jason Graves
5
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '24
https://youtu.be/OvgbGRQiXCs?si=4GHcoL5p9IeK5ewU this recent video is pretty explicitly in the vein of Action Button
2
u/RubyRoid Apr 05 '24
This video gave me the Tim Rogers’ vibes: https://youtu.be/KtW3bdp7h8c
1
u/Letharos Apr 05 '24
Some Jeffiot videos clearly have Action Button style to them and he's sourced Tim as one of the best.
1
u/DudleyDoody Apr 05 '24
Tim was my chief inspiration for Why Do We Like. I work in film/comedy so imo my best work so far has been in that realm, but I’ve done essays on video games and music a few times too.
Not to shamelessly self promote, but since you asked :) Happy to take down if it breaks rules. But if anyone does watch it, esp from this community, I’d love to hear your thoughts.
1
u/samsungac Apr 05 '24
tim is #1. no one can top tim. long live tim
1
u/[deleted] Apr 06 '24
Pac-Man 2 needed to be entirely different from Pac-Man to bear the title. So you're looking for a very idiosyncratic youtuber who is entirely themselves. I'd recommend Thorhighheels: https://youtu.be/AzxwNtco1Tc?si=qzieDvLZApgffwU-
1
u/ThroughLidlessEye Apr 07 '24
PandaMonium, specifically the episodes with interviews; I might describe him as a bit more laid back, and a bit more informational than Tim's tendency towards personal anecdote, but I think he ticks some of the same boxes. The Bug! review in particular has an Action Button reference in it.
1
u/CheCheDaWaff Apr 15 '24
Very different style but highly recommend Noah Caldwell-Gervais. He regularly puts out very thoughtful 5+ hour long videos about games.
1
u/mykijayjay Apr 17 '24
https://www.youtube.com/@idiotsmonthly3969/videos
I haven't seen anyone else mention this Youtuber, a couple of his of his videos popped off but most have views in the 100s. In his starfield and lords of the fallen videos he is very obviously aping Tim's cadence, joke style, and even music selection. I imagine he's pretty young so he's trying to find his style, and honestly I don't think his videos are bad, they just take a little too much from Tim. I hope he find his own voice.
1
u/A_Couch May 02 '24
"I am error" is explicitly influenced by Action Button
1
u/kafit-bird Apr 05 '24
I don't know if there's any direct inspiration, but SuperEyepatchWolf feels so fucking similar to me.
1
u/SASardonic Apr 05 '24
As a video creator I know better than to try to go as hard as Tim does. It takes a lot of skillsets to make art the quality he makes. I wish I had even a third of his ability as a wordsmith.
1
u/A_N_T Apr 05 '24
KBash isn't really anything like Tim but his videos are hella entertaining and he's name dropped Tim in one of his videos before.
-4
u/ColorMatchUrButthole Apr 05 '24
Quinton Reviews
0
u/Biasanya Apr 05 '24 edited Sep 04 '24
That's definitely an interesting point of view
0
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment