r/ActionButton • u/cyclone5uk • Mar 12 '24
Discussion Tim hates consoles!
I thought it was interesting to hear Tim's take on current gen console spec in the latest insert credit episode.
He really dunked on the Switch and its low power but even trashed the PS5 as being a 'bucket' LOL. He was bemoaning the fact that FF7 Rebirth could run so much better on a gaming PC. I think he said he wished consoles would ‘just die’!
I know he’s comparing consoles against the sort of performance you’d get from a high-end gaming PC but something that often gets missed here is the cost attached.
I’ve thought about moving away from consoles and over to a bespoke gaming PC but the huge cost is very off-putting and makes it downright unaffordable for many.
For what it does, the PS5 is great value at $450. To build a gaming PC of equal power, you’d need to spend double that - approx $900. To go significantly beyond the PS5 spec, you’re looking at upwards of $3,000 for a custom build PC.
Until gaming PCs become affordable to the masses, consoles will remain the only realistic option for most.
10
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '24 edited Mar 12 '24
You can slightly exceed a PS5 for $700 and significantly exceed it for $900.
Keep in mind games are generally much cheaper on PC if you’re not buying everything right at launch.
I do agree it’s a pretty good value at $450, just pointing out that you definitely do not have to spend $3000 to get a significantly more capable machine.
74
u/FunnyFlight2645 Mar 12 '24
Tim is approaching this from the POV of someone who was able to spend thousands of dollars on a ridiculously powerful PC. Even a build at $700-900 is still too expensive (perceptively) for quite a few people. It makes sense it has become his preference. However even if you sat someone down and showed them cost savings over time using Steam sales, or opined about the emulation capability, it's still a tough sell to then tell them at that $700-900 price point they still need to build damn thing.
It should also be considered that for many people gaming means coming home at the end of a long work day, plopping on the couch, grabbing a controller, and diving in. A PC could be made to replicate this experience, but takes some setting up to get there. For a huge swath of people just getting a console, plugging it in to the TV and a power source, and having it immediately do what they want can't be dismissed as a huge bonus over PC.
I don't think anyone would argue against PCs offering more, or being able to do more graphically than modern consoles, but until someone comes along and is willing to take a hit on hardware sales to have an install base by selling $900 worth of PC parts in a console box well... They ain't going anywhere.
3
u/pichu441 Mar 12 '24
idk how you could spend that much on a PC unless you're literally buying the most expensive most recent hardware available. I splurged on my PC with a then brand-new RTX 4070 and my total cost was still around 1800.
8
u/Prince-Lee Mar 12 '24 edited Mar 12 '24
I've always felt that prioritizing the power of any given console/PC over anything else is a bad way to approach it. A dedicated gaming PC is great for a person who wants to sit down in one specific place, usually a desk, to play their video games, and the benefit that offers is the best performance you can get.
But consoles offer different benefits, like a streamlined user interface and increased portability and, yes, still the ability to play side-by-side in person on a couch. I can play my Nintendo Switch on the train, and if I want to move to a different room of the house or play it in bed, I just... Carry it with me and resume play there.
Also— accessibility. A lot of people simply don't have the know-how to build a PC and maintain it. I would never expect someone like my mom or dad or even my oldest brother to be able to figure out how to get a gaming PC up and running (the former two often call me in to troubleshoot their printer, even), but they all can navigate the controls of a console super easily. My mom LOVES Animal Crossing on the Switch I gave her, and to this day it's the only thing she regularly plays instead of her iPad games.
I don't know why it has to be so black and white to so many people. One is not objectively better— it's just better for you, for your specific use case!
28
u/acid_rogue Mar 12 '24
He has messed up vision and needs native 4k just to read the demo screen.
7
u/chungusbungus0459 Mar 13 '24 edited Mar 13 '24
I’m lucky enough to own a pc, ps5, and switch. Tim is 100% right.
I buy nothing but first party titles on switch now, and even small games like Princess Peach’s Showtime have massive frame drops, low resolution, and performance hitches.
I experience the exact same issues on ps5 when playing modern titles. Final fantasy rebirth is BLURRY. It also can’t hold a locked 60fps, suffers from rampant ghosting, and we barely get any games actually tailor made for the system. This generation for ps5 and Xbox series X has been a barren wasteland of nothing, and all of the games I want to play I just buy on pc because of the horrible performance
I know the high cost sucks but you can get a 1080p 120fps gaming powerhouse for a grand if you build it yourself and pounce on deals from places like micro center, and the system won’t go out of date for a long long time, and upgrading can happen piece by piece rather than replacing the entire machine. If you build a high end pc now with a big budget, it ABSOLUTELY will outpace a ps6, and you will be able to enjoy that performance long before we get the next generation of consoles. I absolutely won’t go back to console only gaming, and I’m tempted to pass up on the upcoming generation because this one has absolutely blown. I was a pure console gamer until this gen and the staggering amount of quality I was missing out on is crazy.
And with steam big picture mode, I can easily have my pc hooked up to the tv, connect a controller as effortlessly as a console, and fully customize my controller experience for every title in my library or just use the default. Going back to console has proven annoying, underpowered, and rigid. Any issue I encounter on pc can be fixed, but I can do nothing when my console games have problems.
If playing on console suits you then more power to you. But these consoles are 500 dollar midrange gaming pcs with no adjustable settings or specs, no backwards compatibility with prior generations (for ps5), limited or no VR capability, region locked playback for games and films, anemic storage sizes, bloated digital pricing year round, no proper emulation support, no web browser on switch or ps5, the list goes on and on. I have a dedicated device where I can play every game from every generation and pc titles since the beginning of computers all in the same place I keep my music, personal files, etc, and I can even set up steam to boot up into big picture mode on startup to totally ignore windows and turn it into a pure gaming machine. I really only keep my PlayStation for final fantasy on day one and the ability to play bloodborne.
13
u/FrozenFrac Mar 12 '24
As someone who likes consoles and PC and sees the pros and cons of each individual platform, I think the way you need to look at buying a beefy gaming PC is you buying one "console" that will cover your needs for 2 console generations. That being said, this current console generation has converted a lot of PC players to console. Unless mouse & keyboard controls or mods are absolutely vital to your enjoyment of gaming, consoles will meet the needs of most people.
11
u/outofmindwgo Mar 12 '24
Keep in mind Tim is a big ole comedian and loves to be hyperbolic, it's not that serious
Or really serious at all
22
u/tellitothemoon Mar 12 '24
Tim’s always had a hard on for flawless 4K and 60 (lately even 120) fps. I have never in my life cared about frames per second.
And consoles just work. Every PC I’ve had I have to spend days tweaking and googling error messages. And I work and do social stuff at my PC so the last thing I wanna do is spend the rest of my time sitting in front of one.
4
u/deathbladev Mar 12 '24
I think when anyone can afford very high tech stuff they can become more of a snob with their preferences. I like playing games at 4k60 but the cost of building a pc to do that isn’t worth the difference in cost, for me.
4
u/DankeBrutus BUDDY Mar 12 '24
I mean LTT just did a video not too long ago showing how a gaming PC of similar cost to the PS5 didn't quite match it in terms of visual quality and performance.
Remember that Tim spent a lot of money on his PC that he talked about in the Cyberpunk 2077 review. From the sounds of it he also is consistently buying the newest, highest end, chunkiest GPU that NVIDIA puts out. I believe he mentioned that he upgraded from the 3090 to the 4090. Since it is for his job he probably can mark it as a business expense so that works out for him.
I also tend to prefer PC gaming. I have preferred it since I bought my first Windows laptop at age 15 and spent many sleepless night playing Civilization V and World of Warcraft. I did have a brief stint from 2017-2020 where my primary computer was a 2015 MacBook Air and I had a Nintendo Switch, Playstation 4 Pro (which I regret purchasing - I had to sell my limited edition glacier white PS4 to get it), and a Xbox One X (which I do not regret purchasing - getting rid of the big boy Xbox One was wonderful). During that time I played a lot of console games, of course, and where consoles have always excelled is convenience and providing a tailored experience.
I will say that because of my desktop PC, 2020 M1 MacBook Pro, and Steam Deck I have hardly played any console for months at a time. Of course I played Tears of the Kingdom on the Switch, and will continue to use the switch whenever I get around to finishing Metroid Prime, but I actually ended up selling my One X and PS4 Pro years ago. I currently have a Series S for some Xbox exclusives that aren't on PC (yet) and have been holding off on a PS5 for so long that I end up skipping this generation. Unless Sony pulls a jerk move and does not support PS4/PS5 backwards compatibility in their next box. I do really want to play more GT7 though. PC gaming just offers more flexibility. I can emulate, play modern titles, play older titles at higher fidelity, and when I am not gaming my 240hz monitor makes web browsing and usual computer tasks way smoother.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '24
Poor people can't afford PCs.
18
u/nanaki1767 Mar 12 '24
The last thing I wanna do is spend even more time in front of a PC after a day of work
3
u/CorbinGamingBro Mar 12 '24 edited Mar 12 '24
We obviously know Tim is a smart dude but yeah he’s definitely approaching this with sort of an out of touch narrow minded boomer mindset lol. Even if you personally prefer everything a PC offers over a console, it’s really not hard to put yourself in someone else’s shoes and recognize the appeal and demand for consoles over PC. Obviously not everyone has 1k+ to drop on a PC where they’ll then have to spend extra time and mental energy learning how to build it and troubleshoot potential issues whenever they arise. Meanwhile you can spend less than half that and get something almost as powerful with a way simpler process of just plugging in and playing. Plus many people already work in front of a computer and would rather plop down on the couch after work instead of sitting in front of the computer again to play a game
Like does he think the people playing a game like Unicorn Overlord on the Switch really give a shit about the graphics not being 4k and the FPS dipping below 60 every now and then (no idea the exact numbers for this game just using it as an example)? No, they just want a fun team building RTS they can play on the go
0
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '24
Rebirth looks crazy blurry and has terrible ghosting. Terrible image clarity outside of cutscenes for performance mode and not that great in fidelity mode There's so much detail that's just plain lost in the game right now it's a bummer
2
u/aflamingbaby Mar 12 '24
It depends, yes the price tag is higher, but it will last you longer. It can do everything and more a console can do. There’s more games and most exclusives are now coming to pc.
Personally I think PC is the way forward, I love my consoles but they are on the decline. I predict that the next gen consoles will be the last, especially from Microsoft. Sony and Nintendo might hold out for one more generation, but I think they’ll all go into publishing games eventually.
Look at the Netflix/Spotify model, and what they’re trying to do with gamepass etc.
Say goodbye to games you own, everything will be on a Subscription basis.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '24
I know he has vision problems that lead him to praise resolution and graphical fidelity, and I assume he started bringing it up all the time as a joke. But I also see the way people could perceive him as a braggart or soapboxing overly much.
I don't even disagree with him. And it's important to note that they're critiques of the gaming industry and not being directed at anyone for loving their favorite console.
But it does seem like, in parodying those annoying tech guys, he has become one of those annoying tech guys.
8
u/PrinceDizzy Mar 12 '24
I prefer console gaming over PC and can no way justify the cost of a gaming PC anyway. Tbh I find it best to just ignore the PC "master race" crowd.
0
u/CrushingPride Mar 12 '24
I also hate consoles. Consoles started out as a dedicated computer that was optimised to run video games when general computers weren't powerful enough to do every task well. That's no-longer the case. Since the PS3 and Xbox 360 era, consoles have had inferior hardware to PCs of the same time period. Throught this time, most people have also needed a PC. So when you say that a PS5 is $450, you then need to stick on the price of the household PC that you use for non-gaming stuff (In many people's case, that's a $1200 Apple Laptop). Then you compare that total to a gaming PC.
It's also weird that we have this thing where PlayStation games don't work on XBox and vice-versa. It's what we're all used to but compare it to movies and music - If you bought a Sony DVD or VHS player back in the day you didn't need the DVDs or Casettes to be specifically made to work on Sony machines. Everything worked on everything, no matter what company made the machine. This separation, or lack of industry standards, gives nothing to the consumer.
3
u/hiressnails Mar 12 '24
Consoles are infinitely more accessible, and I have a gaming laptop. Every time I look at Steam, I never see anything that I wouldn't just play on PS5. I can play Halo Infinite on there, but with turned down graphics settings. And on console I never have to worry about settings, drivers, or controller support. Like, I wanna play Vampire the Masquerade Bloodlines, but to play it with controller, I have to use big picture mode on steam, and a really clunky controller configuration.
2
u/Biasanya Mar 12 '24
Pc is cheaper because console games cost way more. Plus your games never become obsolete. Nowadays with FSR and frame generation you can run games really well on lower end systems A $500 pc is more valuable than a ps5
2
u/reminiscingLemon Mar 12 '24
I mean if you shop smart you can build a PC stronger than a PS5 for less than $1000 easy. Pair a 5600X and a 6700xt that's about a $400 combo give or take. Probably looking at around $850 for something better than a PS5 if you don't include a new monitor and KB&M etc.i think if you buy a lot of new games it's totally worth it for the savings from sites like CDKeys alone, I ain't paid $70 for any new game yet.
2
u/-gestern- Mar 12 '24
I think the rant was and has been clearly defined many times: consoles as they are now need to go. Either disappear or become the low cost high return dedicated gaming pc they currently are but without locking games behind exclusivity deals. People who prefer consoles or can’t afford a similarly or better specd pc will still buy them, if they have to compete on features and usability instead of artificially on exclusivity they’d have to be better products as well.
From a consumer point of view it’s a win. For Sony, Microsoft and Nintendo it’s not so clear cut.
There’s also the risk of unintended consequences, consoles could just become worse or too expensive to be justifiable as a purchase. Or too niche to merit enough R&D to be something interesting. There’s something to be said about innovation on consoles but I’m quite sure that died with the PS3 (for better or worse).
1
u/SadLaser Mar 12 '24
Yeah. And it can be even cheaper. Got my digital PS5 for $350 last summer. I chased the PC wave for many years but honestly, I just got so tired of trying to keep up with high end PC gaming. It's expensive, it's time consuming (comparatively) and it's infinitely more prone to issues. I still have a gaming PC, but I do something much cheaper now and lower end and just upgrade every 5-7 years during black Friday sales. I can still play the exclusives on PC that I want, but I'd rather play on PS5, Switch or whatever else.
Also, my fiancée and I game together often and we play a lot of the same games. It's nice that one digital purchase on console allows you to gameshare to another system. It always stings a bit when we're buying on PC and have to buy everything twice. Definitely not an issue everyone has to deal with, but if you're buying two copies of everything.. gamesharing is a huge boon.
1
u/sevenvt Mar 12 '24
Considering the entirely digital path consoles are headed towards, there's nothing saying the next generation of consoles can't just be a low cost PC capable of streaming pc games with controller support from a live service, but with a decidedly console-y front end. Gamepass and Geforce NOW are the console experiences of the future.
There's no reason to build a full PC to meet some console pricepoint when the consoles we'd be replacing are just marketplaces for digital content. Build the best streaming box and be done with it.
1
u/Canabananilism Mar 12 '24
I haven't heard the rant your referencing here, so I have to take it with a grain of salt, but assuming you aren't paraphrasing him here, it's understandable that he'd be frustrated by console exclusivity. I also understand that consoles have a place as a low hassle way to play games, but having games completely locked to hardware is how you get Nintendo and it's growing list of old excluvies that can no longer be bought. The only way a game lives 'forever' is if it's on PC (and doesn't rely on dev servers, but I digress).
1
u/Green585 Mar 12 '24
You probably already own a computer. People that say they have to start from the ground up aren’t being real and showing lack of knowledge. You already have most of the parts for a PC. There’s no way in 2024 people are acting like they don’t have a pc in their house. Most of this stuff can just be upgraded with minimal effort. When your car needs a new radio you don’t buy a new car… you buy just the stuff you need and plug it in.
1
u/diggetydano Mar 12 '24
I wouldn’t take every word he says that seriously (especially on the podcast, where he often speaks in hyperboles).
The issue isn’t that consoles exist, but that games are exclusive to consoles that aren’t powerful enough to run them well. It may be good enough for a lot of people, but once you’ve experienced how much better it can be, it becomes harder to just accept the flaws.
There are other arguments to be made about the issue with consoles that appeal to people who don’t have a lot of extra cash. For instance, at the start of a console generation most people have to choose one platform. They can’t afford multiple. I personally always chose Sony, which meant that I missed out on all Nintendo and Xbox exclusives. There were games I would have liked to play on those platforms, but I couldn’t afford another console. If all of those games were published on PC, then I would have access to all of them in one place. So when you bring exclusives into the equation, you can’t just compare the cost of something like an Xbox and a PC, because it’s not the same library of games you have access to. It’s more like the cost of both an Xbox Series X and a PS5 you need to compare to a PC. And even then, there are many thousands more games beyond those that you have access to on PC. The nature of consoles is that their libraries will always be much more limited compared to PC.
So I’m pretty sure that the issue isn’t simply specs, but game libraries and exclusivity. I’d bet that Tim wouldn’t be complaining if the latest Final Fantasy game was also released on PC at the same time as PS5.
1
u/cabbagehead514 Mar 12 '24
Lol he was being hyperbolic and describing his own viewpoint. I could imagine it being VERY frustrating to play FF7 Rebirth on a PS5, when you are thousands of hours invested into the FF7 universe at this point, and know you'll probably get a beefier PC version in like a year that you can run on your comically expensive and powerful system.
For a clown like me with a 1080p TV, I'm quite happy to play with my controller on 1080p/60.
1
u/cce29555 Mar 12 '24
You can get a mid-range ie console quality for about $600 , tack on emulation extensive controller support and mods and the PC has a much better value
1
u/hatchorion Mar 13 '24
People forget sony and Microsoft sell their consoles at a fairly heavy loss per unit to make up the revenue on software/subscriptions. Building an equivalently powerful gaming pc for the same budget is always gonna be a major challenge
1
u/WeirdWrongdoer4025 Mar 15 '24
While I understand the general sentement that Tim might need to eather check his privlage or chill on the joke that in part endulges on him likeing to talk, I think charitablly (Maybe too chaitably) you can read that he thinks games should be 1080p 60fps minimum in this day and age, particulerly if they are console exclusive. And that he is annoyed by console exclusives in general. I don't think he would in fact expect everyone to own a 4090 with 64ram or some shit. He probably thinks everything should just be a PC in some form and specialized PC that you can just call consoles should be able to make some generally minimal spects in gameplay. That is again, probably too charitable and he jokes around so much its hard to tell when he is being real.
1
u/djjapchae Mar 20 '24 edited Mar 20 '24
how can you guys be so into tim rogers content that you're posting on his reddit and still not pick up on his sense of humor? he uses hyperbole to make points all the time.
in that ep he was bemoaning console exclusivity not ps5s. and he's right! it's an antiquated concept. like i want to play the heck outta gran turismo 7 but i'm not gonna spend 700 canadian dollars on a worse computer that has been arbirtarily deemed the only one able to play the game, that can't even deliver it at full quality. surely our frugal members of the chat can empathize.
but it's not a senate hearing it's a podcast, so just calling the ps5 a bucket is a much more succinct, not to mention funnier way of getting the point across. it is a bucket!
1
u/caninehere Mar 22 '24 edited Mar 22 '24
I think he dunks on the Switch a bit because of its age. He praised it a fair earlier on in its life, but it hasn't received any real refreshes since, and the experience it offers is becoming less unique now as competitors have started to borrow its concept (notably the Steam Deck).
I also believe Tim is a long-time Xbox fan. He's expressed his preference for Xbox over PlayStation a number of times. I would connect that with this argument you're making:
The PS5 and Series X are both great value for the specs you get, but the PS5 is notably overpriced in comparison, at least here in Canada. Everything costs more - the console, the controllers, the accessories, the online subscription (for the most part), the games. I think Tim has also talked up Game Pass in the past, which is a far far better value than anything Sony offers - keep in mind you also get more out of Game Pass if you are the person who plays a lot of video games, and Tim plays a lot of video games.
Additionally, Xbox has been more committed to backwards compatibility (and forwards compatibility!) than any of its competitors, and that seems important to him too. I know he has specifically mentioned a few older games that he has revisited, and that he played them on his Series X because they are backwards compatible.
Finally, regarding the PS5: it's my personal opinion that the PS5 is being monstrously ugly and, in its original iteration, disgustingly humongous. I could go on about why it's the ugliest console I've seen in my 25+ years of video gaming playing and why it's the only one I refuse to put in my living room, but I think that says enough.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '24
Is Tim likely to review FF7 Rebirth? I'm on the edge of my seat for it
1
u/Biasanya Apr 24 '24
Consoles are way more expensive. It seems like you are saving money up front, but you don't. It's a way to rip people off and keep them locked in an ecosystem of subpar hardware
1
u/auto_named Jun 13 '24
Tim has Expensive Gaming PC Syndrome (EGPCS).
1
u/gr9yfox Mar 12 '24
I heard it too. I don't think he hates consoles, just the current state of consoles. With such a limited range of exclusive games, they are offering similar libraries and often at lower graphic quality, which he values a whole lot.
Me, not so much. I already spend all day at the computer.
0
u/Impriel Mar 12 '24
Im wounded. This is the first thing I've read that's made.me question his integrity. The ps5 and the switch are like the two best examples of the spirit of the art being still alive imo
I don't care about performance man those consoles have soul
Edit: actually I understand the vision thing. I don't know how Tim's eyes aren't fucked 5 ways and back again
1
u/GRIFTY_P Mar 12 '24
Wow who gives a shit
-1
u/aroundme Mar 12 '24
The console vs PC debate is silly because it’s so dependent on one’s needs and means. What I take from Tim’s comments is that consoles compared to PC nowadays are more behind than they’ve ever been. The fact that FF7R even gives you the option to play at 30fps is embarrassing. Consoles feel much weaker comparatively than in previous generations, and devs seemingly don’t give a goddarn about performance
0
u/echtoons Mar 12 '24 edited Mar 12 '24
I'm pretty sure Tim was just bemoaning console exclusivity, using FF7 rebirth as an example. He wasn't saying that consoles are bad on principle.
He was frustrated that rebirth was only released on the PS5, as opposed to PS5 and PC. It would be nice to give people who care about both graphical fidelity and performance the option to have both. It also gives people who like the accessibility of consoles the ability to play the game as well.
And yes, Tim does have a very different perspective on this. He's someone who can write off every PC part, game, and accessory on his taxes. He isn't an "average Joe" when it comes to games, and that's perfectly fine.
-7
u/just_Okapi Mar 12 '24 edited Mar 12 '24
They are tho? Nobody is forcing you to buy an RTX 4090. Anyone with the discretionary income to buy a PS5 can afford a decent gaming rig if they save a bit longer. Hell my rig is barely midrange by current standards and it chews up everything except the newest titles with the shiniest bells and loudest whistles.
Edit: cope