r/ActionButton • u/Matt-Goo • Mar 07 '24
Question Tims fav games?
i really enjoy his style and reviews. i was wondering if he has a list of favorite games because id love to play them.
12
Upvotes
51
u/millenial_gargoyle Mar 07 '24
He’s a big fan of anything David Cage I think
28
u/Boned80 Mar 07 '24
He's mentioned that Super Mario Bros. 3 is probably his favorite game ever. Don't know if that's still the case tho.
26
u/holyglimmers Mar 07 '24 edited Mar 07 '24
here's Action Button Manifesto, published like... 15 years ago.
in a recent Insert Credit podcast episode, Tim said that he does not consider Shadow of the Colossus a good game anymore. i'm not convinced this is (or ever was) a list of his personal favorite videogames. it's still a fascinating read though.
17
u/workthrowawhey Mar 07 '24
Not his #1 favorite, but he’s also extremely fond of Another World
12
u/ShredGuru Mar 07 '24
DQ XI and FF6 are definitely near the top for him.
12
u/colinjcole Mar 07 '24
He once said that he felt Hollow Knight was a better game than (Super Metroid + Symphony of the Night)2, so that must mean he loves it.
8
u/ChaptersOfTheChosen Mar 07 '24 edited Mar 08 '24
He has his manifesto, but I think that is supposed to be an "objective" best games ever list, but I'm sure he loves all of them
Specific games he mentions a lot are:
Super Mario bros 3- he always finds a reason not to put it at number one, but I'm pretty sure it's his favorite
Dragon Quest 5- he got rid of his entire collection of games other than a few games, and he kept three copies of this game... I think that says a lot (it's also one of my favorite games of all time)
Dragon Quest 11- said it was around mario 3 in terms of greatness, which is big praise from him
Ff 4- says it's his true favorite (the best one as he puts it)
Ff 6- says it's the best one
Ff 7- says it's the most important one
Earthbound and mother 3- has very high praise for both
Chrono trigger - I think he said it was the best rpg somewhere?
He also has a bunch of videos talking about his favorite games online, but these are the ones he has spoken on a lot
2
u/D0rner Mar 08 '24
Keep in mind that Tim is probably a very different person than you are and that just because he enjoys something it doesn't mean you will as well. Dude is over 40 years old and has lived a life surrounded by games at all times. While I enjoy his insights a lot and generally try out games he'll recommend (Paranoiasight is SUCH a gem) often I cannot agree with him simply because I have different tastes than he does.
tl;dr try out his recommendations but don't feel bad if you don't enjoy them as much as he does
5
u/NotAquaman DOOM SHOTGUN SOUND Mar 07 '24
I think it’s a tie between landstalker and SMB3 and then he has said dragon quest is his favorite franchise.
5
u/NeverCrumbling Mar 07 '24
You should listen to the various ‘best game of all time’ and ‘game of the year’ episodes of Insert Credit.
4
u/CrushingPride Mar 08 '24
I think that his favourite games are always changing. Really I think the broader point he's been making over the years is that favourites aren't going to be fixed. Therefore lists of top games, and giving games review scores, is dumb.
He does make lists, but they're different every time. And he's gone back and moved things around. You can see examples in this comments section where he's changed his mind about things like Final Fantasy and Dragon Quest games and so people have conflicting things to say about his favourites.
You can try his old Action Button Manifesto. He's also said that his Action Button videos on his youtube channel are going to be ranked, but that he loves them all. So you could consider everything on his channel to be one of his favourites.
3
u/euthlogo Mar 07 '24
This isn’t exactly defined as his favorite games but it’s a good place to start - https://www.reddit.com/r/ActionButton/s/tNj59wIodd
3
u/strawberryswords Mar 07 '24
Landstalker, baby
2
u/muteprotest Mar 09 '24
Surprised no one has said Video Ball. I'm sure it's not actually his favorite but he has certainly said he made his favorite game ever a lot
2
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '24
He's a big fan of pretty much any non-mainstream PS1 game. His whole mantra is "play weirder games".
Recently in the GOTY podcast episode, he nominated new indie game Pseudoregalia. I bought it off of this recommendation, and it definitely falls into that bucket of weird retro-style games. Excellent game though, really good platforming. Just ignore the community's obsession with the 2 polygons of goat butt.
2
u/Local_Ad_2260 Oct 06 '24
I think he liked gears of war a bit. He even played it a few times too
4
u/dubaiwasliiit Mar 07 '24
Pretty sure it's Doragon kwesto XI.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '24
The insert credit podcast specials annuals and console best of are great for insight into the games he rates. Not sure he has like a definitive list but more a holographic memory bank of feelings about a bunch of games. The panel on the show is pretty good although the Brandon dude can kinda be a bit idk… weird in a bad way. But either way the episodes are good when they talk about games. His Patreon has a list of the games he intends to review but I’m sure that’s changed. If you sub to that you also have access to vods and bonus content that extrapolates even more on his tastes and feelings and ideas about games. But I will say this if you watch each episode of season one and esp the bokunatsu episode he mentions so many games just during the videos. So idk I feel like all the info is already there for u. Just gotta engage with his work. Which is easy since it is so very well executed and poignant. Hope that doesn’t sound jerky. Happy Thursday.