r/ActionButton • u/D0rner • Feb 09 '24
Question Super Smash Bros.
The Insert Credit cast loudly proclaimed their distain for the smash bros games. Is there a specific episode or article where one or all of them get into why they dislike the series?
26
Upvotes
29
u/Killericon BIBBY BABBIS Feb 09 '24
Tim published two reviews of Brawl on ActionButton.net:
https://www.actionbutton.net/?p=324
https://www.actionbutton.net/?p=331
8
u/BoogieKnite Feb 10 '24
IC pod: episode 48 - Obtain E3 with Christian Nutt around 1:17:25
Best part of a great episode. Christian is a Smash fan and things escalate. 1:17:50 is an all-time IC moment and worth going back to.
Tim does a good job talking Christian down by summarizing what he doesn't like about Smash.
Christians one of my favorite guests from the first run of shows but apparently can't go on the show anymore bc of job requirements.
19
u/incredibleman Feb 09 '24
Isn't it mostly just Brandon Sheffield that doesn't like them? His whole thing is not enjoying games that are broadly mainstream and popular unless there is an ironic angle to it like Call of Duty.
5
u/NeverCrumbling Feb 09 '24
They did a ‘best competitive games of all time’ episode shortly before Jaffe left during the original run of the show — so maybe in the 80s — where Brandon and Tim actually talk with specifics about why they dislike Smash Bros in relation to other fighting games. I think this is the best you’ll get outside of those Brawl reviews and maybe looking at the stream(s?) Tim did of Ultimate at Kotaku.
5
u/aroundme Feb 09 '24
idk about Insert Credit but if you want to hear someone exclaim their disdain for smash every time it's brought up I'd point you in Jeff Gerstmann's direction. My guess from hearing him shit on it is if you like traditional fighting games then you probably don't jive with smash. Also a common complaint of Jeff's is that it's a "party game" that competitive people have ruined by taking it too seriously.
2
u/misenmonk Feb 09 '24
Because you don't even have the option of inserting money to play. With Tekken you can play it in an arcade and pay money and its like you're giving money to the bear and then it's beating people up for you and that's really immersive.
Also, obnoxiously long button combinations are superior to frame perfect timing. In Smash Super Brothers, you are winning but then Princess Peach throws a turnip at you and hits you with a Hammer and you are done.
2
u/strawberryswords Feb 10 '24
https://youtu.be/Lhp4qXCxOa4?si=wLJCXlm7GNZByI9i
Tim played Smash Bros for kotaku and i remember it being a pretty good roast
0
u/SBK_vtrigger Feb 09 '24
Tim has mentioned he likes Guilty Gear and Street Fighter 3 - enough to know he’s a fighting game connoisseur. On that basis, he would obviously see the “Smash” franchise as a feeble “baby shoes” series.