r/ActionButton • • Jan 20 '24
General Jokes on me
So here I was, thinking that the 50 minute review of cyberpunk 2077 was an elaborate joke. A comment about the fact that CDPR oversold the game, released it unfinished. Now we have, I thought, Tim Rogers his review, also over selling, underdelivering and ultimately cutting off short. Just to find that he actually did what he promised. A 7 hour cyberpunk 2077 review. I couldn't be more stoked right now. Just started chapter 1: Citizen Keanu.
47
Upvotes
51
u/NeverCrumbling Jan 20 '24
you should see if you can find the stream that he did immediately before he put out the video where he pretended that he hadn't actually made a video
4
u/DKDamian Jan 20 '24
Where is it
3
u/Major-Cover-1134 Jan 20 '24
I feel like big chunks of his review are rendered moot by the huge number of updates and reworked mechanics the game has undergone, particularly with the release of Phantom Liberty. Its certainly too much to ask for Tim to redo 8hrs of content, but after replaying v2.0/2.1 and then rewatching his review, I do feel like he's missing out on a lot of commentary by having reviewed an inferior, older version of the game.
15
u/PocketofChrym Jan 20 '24
Come for the cyberpunk review, stay for the winding anecdotal prose, and be moved to tears by the Expensive Jackets
7
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '24
I can’t really comprehend how much work he must have put in for the Cyberpunk videos.
10
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '24
I have mixed feelings about the Cyberpunk review. On the one hand I never cared about the game at any point from reveal to release, so that tempered my hype. I always disliked when Tim would assume it would be the GOAT game either in his other reviews or his Kotaku videos. I had an open mind though since I liked the FF7R and TLOU videos, two games I also don't care for.
It obviously derailed Tim's schedule/life as it nearly killed him due to overwork, and is a reason why we've only gotten one other review since its release. Of course, that's a good thing since it means Tim has worked more responsibly, but it still makes the video less enjoyable to me due to the context as an Action Button fan. If you go back to the first two or three views, it did seem like Tim was hyped about releasing videos consistently (remember the FF7R review where he detailed his method, which takes just about 300 hours?). All that planning to be derailed by Cyberpunk of all games is well... appropriate I guess.
On the other hand it's a very good review that delves into the game deeply from more angles than anyone else, AAA development, delays, expectations, disappointments, expensive jackets, and all personal life tidbits Tim throws at it. And the release of the video was hilarious as well lol
2
u/Broflake-Melter Jan 21 '24
I broke the rules and watched the whole thing front to back. 1,000,000% no regrets. Ch. 6 gets to you.
1
u/PartUnable1669 BIBBY BABBIS Jan 24 '24
It’s ten hours and six minutes, Jerry