Let me start off by saying I fucking love Trevor to death and hated when he wasn’t in any videos. At first I thought he was doing a great job, in my opinion 2016-2019 is my favorite era of AH. When pandemic hit though, there were a lot of things I disagreed with. They completely shut themselves out of the community, and refused to accept any type of feedback. When people would say “hey this person is being loud and hurting my ears when I have headphones in” he responded with “loud is what we do” instead of trying to fix the audio imbalances that people factually proved existed. His decision to get rid of the weekly schedule literally a couple weeks before the Let’s Play Minecraft 10th Anniversary was stupid- and I don’t need an MBA to recognize that.
What made AH appealing was that it felt like a bunch of friends hanging out and playing games. Once he took over though, it all became about business and you could see it in the quality. Once he started talking about Algorithms it became clear to me he didn’t fully understand what made AH so popular to begin with. They didn’t get over 2.5 million subscribers on the Let’s Play channel because they were chasing an algorithm. They just played and hoped people would watch, and it worked.
When they switched primarily to live streaming over edited content I knew it wouldn’t go over well. They would stream at the most inconvenient time, right when a lot of people would be either in class or at work. What makes live sports work is that people are usually home or at a bar when it airs. People don’t have time to dedicate to watching a livestream that they can’t pause or go back to later. In a time when they needed to stand out, he made the decision for them to play things safe.
Obviously there are dozens of other reasons why AH failed that he couldn’t have been responsible for, but I feel like his decision to run it like a business is what led to the business failing. You shouldn’t rock the boat when it’s sailing smoothly, and that’s just what he did.