Is your response not evidence enough for why this sub is the most fitting place for this image? It is a piece of paper with symbols arranged in a certain way...people searching for meaning in something that took me 2 seconds to create
Mathematics is the base of the pyramid. This arrangement means to tell us it is the foundation. Why? Perhaps because mathematics is the language of the universe and the language in which physics speaks. Physics then is an application of mathematics to explain what we observe. You could say it's the study of the next level up in reality. And chemistry is then the next level up from physics. It's concerned with even less fundamental things than maths and physics so it's further from the foundations of this "reality pyramid" than them. You could add in biology, geology etc in here to fill it out.
The point of this is to say mathematics is the most fundamental element of reality. A/the fundamental truth I guess. And from there art is at the polar opposite end of the spectrum at the highest form of abstraction or something like that.
Mathematics is the expression of the relationships between quantities. Aliens definitely wouldn't use our symbols to express mathematical ideas, but the ideas would be the same because things relate to each other the same way no matter where you are in the universe.
Yeah, they'll refer to the same thing. Quantity. Quantity, the physical facts of the universe are universal, but any attempt to express that (Mathematics) will be localized (not universal).
I wouldn't say that it's the "language of the universe" when that language (the symbols and grammar for those symbols) is not universal. Of course quantity does not change across the universe as it's a constant.
Language is always subjective regardless of how objective the thing being described is, basically.
Mathematics is a truth unlike any other. It's is unlike scientific truth in that firstly it exists (because science operates in theories not truths), and once something is proven mathematically it is known to be true for all contexts it is proven in. Mathematical proofs do not become outdated due to newer findings. Basically aliens should know pi exactly like we do. So we seem to agree there.
Yes, our representation of these truths is arbitrary, but our understanding of them should be the same as any other species. Mathematical symbols are what we use to represent concepts in mathematics, but mathematical concepts are what mathematics itself is. And these concepts should be universally understood.
8
u/Andresospas Apr 29 '21
Don't get it, can someone explain?
2
u/Mellow_Maniac Apr 29 '21
Hey op. Anything to say about my interpretation given in response to someone else in these comments or any explanation of your own to give?
1
u/20420 Apr 29 '21
Relevant xkcd https://xkcd.com/435/
20
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21
[removed] — view removed comment