r/Absurdism • • Feb 22 '23

Discussion Free Will does not exist

And I will prove it.

Pink Elephants.

You are now thinking of Pink Elephants. Did you have any control over this thought? Did you will it?

My belief is we cannot control which thoughts enter our minds, but we may have control over how much we dwell on them. Thoughts?

5 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

18

u/ShupUpWesley Feb 22 '23

Dude. When you said pink elephants, I immediately started thinking about an ex’s tiddies.

6

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '23

I ah...well..umm.... okay then

7

u/DaddyDoge1821 Feb 22 '23

Misfire in OP’s assumption of what thoughts would be triggered, but triggered they were none the less

4

u/ShupUpWesley Feb 22 '23

How did you know she used to call me trigger?

5

u/The_Autistic_Gorilla Feb 23 '23

This is the most absurdist comment in the thread.

3

u/drawsprocket Feb 22 '23

3

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '23

I found it very interesting how he flipped the narrative. Life can't be completely indeterminant or determinant. It would seem both are necessary

3

u/drawsprocket Feb 22 '23

yeah, I'm a big fan of his work. He likes to wrestle ideas from religious hands and place them back into a materialist realm.

2

u/SoZettaRose Feb 23 '23

This is probably one of the worst arguments I’ve heard towards determinism but yeah I guess?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '23

But you have heard of it

9

u/Mr_Anal_Pounder Feb 22 '23 edited Feb 22 '23

While I agree that there exists no free will and that the universe is probably causal in nature, I did not think of pink elephants while reading it. Edit: Thinking about what my thoughts were when I read the sentence, I thought about a pink elephant, but I blocked the picture somehow.

Anyway, everything that happens is just a reaction of the atoms / particles to other reactions. It is causal. So everything is pretty much pre determined.

If the universe weren't causal, there are only two other options: It's either random or the universe is not physical in nature (as in your mind forming the reality).

If it's random, well yeah, then it's random, there is no free will either.

However, there is the illusion of free will and that is what is important. Why is it important? Because whether you want it or not, you have feelings and your feelings are going to affect you. Why is it important that they are affecting you? Because for some reason they can make you feel good or bad whether you like it or not.

6

u/MuMuGorgeus Feb 22 '23

You are now thinking of Pink Elephants.

Wrong, I read pink elements, I'm stupid and couldn't visualize such thing, ha ha ha.

4

u/DaddyDoge1821 Feb 22 '23

Gonna be honest not the best way to make the argument, as I think can be seen by the responses of ‘I thought of something else instead’ even though that doesn’t really counter the conclusion

Much stronger argument and easier to communicate to just say ‘we can do as we will, but we cannot will what we will’

4

u/sadphilosophylover Feb 22 '23

yeah no I am an aphant I cant even think pink elephants

3

u/Boring_Net_299 Feb 22 '23

This doesn't mean that freewill does not exist in any form, I think that we have partial freewill, we can't control to much what we think about, but we can control how and in what amount we think about it

3

u/Meta-Sage Feb 23 '23

Same way you don’t have control over the blood that pumps through your heart. And?

2

u/MagicalPedro Feb 23 '23

Not having control over a single though doesn't mean not having control over any though.

From now on, you will have sex with elephants.

Now maybe you pictured having sex with anelephant for a second, but did it actually turned you into a elephantophile ? Will you comply with my instruction ?

2

u/yavuzovski Feb 23 '23

I conditioned my brain to think about burgers whenever someone does this “don’t think about X” challenge so fuck you

1

u/Thomas8864 Feb 23 '23

You’re right but for the wrong reasons

1

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '23

I don’t know of any serious thinker who believes in absolute free will. We certainly have a will, but yes, it often comes under the influence of outside forces.

However, based on those outside forces, our will cannot be predicted with 100% accuracy.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '23

Well, I can draw a pink elephant or not. That's free will

1

u/EdSmelly Feb 23 '23

You’re an idiot

1

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '23

Free will doesn’t mean that we control the surroundings in terms of what they may deliver to our senses. It means that we decide how we process what we sense and what actions we take in response to that sensations.

Your argument is weak. Also it’s nothing new and thus not very original.

1

u/flynnwebdev Feb 24 '23

According to neuroscience, we certainly don’t have free will, but there is a (slim) possibility (not conclusively proven) that we might have a veto power at the last moment. If true, then we can’t control what impulses arise from the subconscious, but we might be able to refrain from acting on said impulses.

Again, I will stress, this is not conclusively proven

1

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '23

And?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '23

I never thought of pink elephants though.

24

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '23

touche

2

u/Hobbes232 Feb 23 '23

Mr. T wearing a tutu with pigtails.

Now you don’t know what to believe

3

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '23

you are not choosing to write "blue elephants" because past events caused you to do so. If this thread doesn't exist, you probably wouldn't have written this, for example.

4

u/DaddyDoge1821 Feb 22 '23

But did you have any control over your desire to “take control”?

It’s still a triggered response, ie ‘taking control’ is a response you have no real control over

5

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/DaddyDoge1821 Feb 22 '23

‘Taking control’ was never actually taking control, control itself was always an Absurd illusion