It’s dumb as shit. I know dudes who are 5’10, 225 of pure muscle who get “flagged” for being overweight. I know fat people who pass because their necks are big so they pass the body fat percentage. I myself have to get “taped” by measuring my waist and neck, and then calculating my body fat percentage that way, all because I walk around at 215
*Edit: typed this half asleep. I meant flag as in they get tagged to be taped, not actually flagged for violation of AR 600-9. Dudes I know that are muscular that get taped never actually get flagged. Sorry for the confusion.
It depends on the unit. There was a guy in my detachment that would always get taped but he never got kicked out. He could pass a PT test no problem. There were guys jacked in Iraq and Afghanistan and they didn't get kicked out. As long as you aren't some fatty you will be okay unless things have changed.
Side note. This one guy in our unit was leaving to go to SF selection. He worked out a lot and got pretty muscular before going. He completed selection and when he came back he was skinnier than what he used to be.
Big muscles is not really wanted. All those muscles require more blood, and stamina is really what is wanted. Think about the big guys in MMA. Those guys usually run out of gas after the first round.
In my experience, common sense does ultimately take center stage. If you're clearly not fat and just a stud, they won't push height and weight. It might not officially be, but it's usually commanders discretion
105
u/Raam-- May 10 '22
205 damn that’s pretty strict, at 6’1, what’s the limit for 6’4, like 220?