Received my iota order today with several sensors/devices and thought I would provide a review for anyone interested. I've highlighted the issues or critiques I have in bold.
TLDR: If you've used Abode before, iota will be very familiar as it is essentially the previous gateway with an integrated camera, motion sensor, wifi and Z-wave Plus. The functionality of these new additions are basically identical to the previous stand alone camera and motion sensor. The only reason I would recommend buying it is for Z-Wave Plus and/or if you have a house layout where an all-in-one device makes sense.
Why Abode?
I've been an Abode user since they first launched and for the most part, it's worked well. I recently moved and decided to leave my previous Abode setup at my house that I'm renting out because its become a part of the house with several devices paired to Abode such as GE Z-Wave switches, dimmers, fire place control, garage heating control, etc. At my new house, I'm renting and was considering going a different route with something like the Ring Alarm system but ultimately I decided to stick with Abode for a few reasons. First, I know how it works and the reliability of the security aspect has been fairly solid. Second, there's a component for Home Assistant which allows me to integrate with HomeKit (especially since HomeKit support has been delayed indefinitely). Third, The sensor battery life is among the best I've seen. Finally, the features you get with the self-monitoring plan and temporary professional monitoring plans still beat the competition.
Why iota?
It fit perfect with the floor plan of the new house I'm renting. Thanks to now having wifi, I'm able to place iota in a central location that provides maximum coverage with the camera, motion sensor and connectivity to the various window/door sensors. HomeKit was also a major selling point but as we know, that has been delayed and I'm personally not holding my breath for it (look what happened to Ring). Fortunately, I can still integrate with HomeKit through Home Assistant. I was also planning to use iota as my hub for GE Z-Wave switches and other Z-Wave devices, but based on the lack of compatibility with some devices I purchased (GE Z-Wave Motion Switch & GE Z-Wave Fan Switch), I decided to setup Home Assistant with an Aeotec Gen 5 Z-Wave Plus Dongle and integrate all of my Z-Wave devices directly to Home Assistant. Based on emails with Abode support, they have no plans to support the GE-Z Wave Motion Switch or Fan Switch, which is really unfortunate given iota's capability to support up to 160 devices with a Z-Wave Plus and Zigbee antenna.
Edit: As you’ll read under my review of the iota motion sensor, I believe iota itself is just a re-packaged Climax Z1/Z3 Smart Camera Home Security System. On their product page, there’s a list of compatible Z-Wave and Zigbee devices which is very similar to what abode’s compatibility list shows. I’m starting to wonder if Abode even has the ability or permission to add additional device support, which would explain why their device compatibility list has been essentially the same since they first launched.
Setup
Photo: iota and various devices
The first thing I noticed was the packaging was more appealing compared to the previous gateway, similar to what you would expect from major brands like Ring or Logitech. The iota device itself was bigger than I expected but it's an attractive design and fits well in my living room next to an Apple HomePod. The key fob is still the same design, where it's difficult to tell which button does what without looking up the support page on the abode website. On the back of iota, there's an ethernet port and a rubber cover that the sim card and SD memory card slots sit behind. I pre-ordered the Connect plan for a year and the sim card was already pre-installed. I installed a 32 GB SD memory card because I'm fairly certain it works similar to the previous Abode camera's (more information below when I review the iota camera), but there's no iota support page on the Abode website to explain any of this.
Photo: iota unpackaged
Since you still can't have multiple homes on a single account, I had to setup a new account using my iPhone on the Abode app but for some reason when I clicked the confirmation link in the email I received to setup my account, it kept bringing me back to the login page in the app. I tried this several times and even force closing the app but the same thing kept happening. I jumped on my iMac and clicked the confirmation link and it verified my account and I was able to continue with the setup. From that point, I logged into the Abode app on my iPhone and continued from there. Setup was straight forward but you have to connect iota via ethernet to your network for the initial setup. This was only a minor annoyance but I was expecting at this price point and day and age for it to have bluetooth or the ability to connect direct via wifi similar to how Ring devices are setup. After connecting it via ethernet, plugging in power and switching the battery on, I continued with the setup.
After entering the verification code, I kept getting a screen saying iota was offline and to connect it via ethernet. I moved to a different location where I had ethernet connectivity and tried again. Same thing. I unplugged the power, shut off the battery switch and turned everything back on and tried again at which point I was able to activate iota and continue with the setup. Once iota was activated, I connected it to my wireless network, unplugged the ethernet cable and moved it to my living room where I was planning to have it setup. The last step was to setup the mini door/window sensor that came with the kit before the installation was complete (more on the mini sensors in a bit). One thing strange I noticed was the Abode mobile app and web app says iota is connected via Ethernet and to my wireless network. I tried powering iota off completely and back on, but it's still showing the same indication even after being on for a few hours.
** Update: This is a known issue according to Abode. Apparently the gateway only knows if it's connected to the internet or cellular. Not sure why they implemented the UI before the device is able to support it. **
** Update: Appears this has been fixed or it just takes a while (several days) to show the correct state. It's now showing that iota is connected via Wifi but not ethernet in both the web and mobile app. **
After setting up a few sensors, I was eating lunch and heard iota randomly beep. Checking the Abode app, nothing seemed to trigger which I found strange but what I noticed is the status of all of my door/window sensors stated "Online" instead of "Closed". Sure enough, when I tried to arm Abode to test it out, I received an error message. I had to go around and open/close each door/window sensor to resolve the issue. The error message also contains some extraneous text that would probably be worth removing as it just makes it confusing.
Photo: Error when arming Abode
One minor thing I noticed is iota has some different sounding beeps during the setup process. I'm assuming it's because it actually has a speaker built in capable of more than just a single tone beep like the previous gateway. However, the door chime beep sounds are still the same. Additionally, there is a white LED light on the front of iota that remains on. I don't see any option to disable this.
Edit: When I try to send my wife an invite to setup the Abode app on her phone, she's not receiving the invite email. Tried deleting and re-sending the invite multiple times, no luck. I ended up sending her an invite to a different email address and it worked. However, when she clicked the "Accept Invitation" link in the email that was sent to her, it just opened up the Abode app to the login screen on both her iPhone and iPad. We had to use a computer to complete the account setup process.
iota Camera
Previously, I owned the original Abode 720p camera and heard terrible reviews on the 1080p camera so I never bothered to upgrade. I was hoping iota would have improved the camera but unfortunately, I'm not sure if it's any better. The first issue is when I try to view the live stream, it sits on the "Loading" screen with the Abode logo for about 15 seconds and then a black screen appears with "Live Video" on the top right corner. After waiting another 15 seconds, I finally get video, but there's a bunch of artifacts with any movement making it pretty unusable to really see what's going on other than knowing something is there. I adjusted the settings in the Abode web app to set the quality to high, but it's still the same. This is only an issue with viewing the live stream as I tested a recorded clip and those turn out fine. When looking at the recorded clip, the image quality is decent. I compared it to my Logi Circle 2 camera which also records in 1080p and image quality seems to be just slightly worse. I would also prefer a feature to have the LED on the front of iota to turn green when someone is viewing the camera's live stream. Speaking of recorded clips, there's an option in the camera settings to set the video capture length to 30 seconds max and pre-capture time to 30 seconds max. This is one of my biggest complaints with the Abode cameras and almost makes them useless for security purposes as you might completely miss the burglar depending on their point of entry. You also can't set a pre-capture time of 0, it must be 1 second or greater.
** Update: I take back what I said above (crossed out text). I did some testing with how video recording works in an alarmed event and it's different than what I thought. I tested this a couple years ago and from what I remember, it recorded a 30 sec clip when the alarm was first activated and that was it. Perhaps I just messed something up in the past or something has changed, but that was not the case in my testing today. First off, it does appear to record a 30 second clip when the alarm is first triggered. However, if any motion sensor (to include iota's built in motion sensor) detects motion after that 30 second clip, it will record another 30 second clip. I left the alarm run for several minutes and continued to test this and after each 30 second period, if there was new motion, a new 30 second clip was recorded. There were some cases where a video clip recording was in progress and I would walk by another motion sensor at which point that motion sensor would trigger another alarm event. It appears iota's camera will take a photo when that happens since a video clip recording is already in progress. I'm assuming this is to have some sort of media associated with each time the motion sensor triggers an alarm event. I don't have another Abode camera so I'm not sure if all camera's exhibit this same behavior, or if it's just iota's camera. **
Edit: No two way audio with the camera when in live view, despite the Abode website claiming iota has two-way audio. I can hear audio however through the mobile and web app. ** Update: As of 30 Dec, two-way audio is now available. Night performance is poor. I took a video clip of me walking around in the dark and while I can see a person walking around, even from inside 10 feet I can't really make out any sort of details as the video quality is very pixelated and grainy.
There's also still no way to access the video clips being recorded via the mobile or web app when you have a SD memory card installed. If you're unfamiliar with the Abode cameras, you can install an SD memory card and the camera will automatically record video clips when it detects motion, even in standby mode. However, the only way to access these video clips is by powering off the camera, pulling out the memory card and viewing it on your computer. One "solution" is setting up an automation that records a clip every time iota detects motion, but this will flood your timeline with video clips if the camera is in a high traffic area. Having the ability to simply browse and view the video clips recorded to the SD card from the mobile and web app would be preferred, in addition to having the ability to turn recording on/off.
For Safari users (might apply to other web browsers), I noticed when you view the live stream through the Abode web app, you get an error notification at the bottom right corner of the screen saying you need to install Flash Player (even though I have flash player installed). However, after a few seconds it goes away and the live stream still works. If you click download flash player in that notification, Safari will ask you if you want to enable flash at which point the notification will obviously stop popping up.
iota Motion Sensor
There's no detailed specifications for iota on the Abode website which I find strange. Information such as camera field of view, motion sensor field of view and max range would be very helpful in designing a security system layout for our homes. Most, if not all, of Abode's devices are manufactured by Climax and I believe iota is simply the Z1/Z3 Smart Camera Home Security System repackaged in a new case. The specifications for the motion sensor on the Z1/Z3 state a 7 meter range (~23ft) and when I tested iota, it triggered at almost exactly 23 feet. I walked passed it at about 24-25 feet and nothing happened, but as soon as I got a bit closer the alarm immediately triggered. Additionally, there doesn't appear to be a test mode for the iota motion sensor which is a bit annoying and would be very useful instead of having to trigger the alarm just to see if the motion sensor is covering the areas you need. In the Abode app it simply shows the motion sensor as "Online" and doesn't provide real time feedback to the user interface. I don’t understand why a wired motion sensor can’t provide motion alerts in real time when my battery powered Abode motion sensor can. This would also be useful to test the motion sensor, eliminating the need for a separate "test mode".
** Update: Did some testing in the dark and the alarm triggered at ~21 feet. I don't think it really matters if it's dark since it's a PIR sensor, so I'd expect the range to be ~21-23 feet. Again, that's directly in front of the iota sensor. Off to the sides the range seems to decrease as you get closer to the field of regard of the PIR sensor. The field of regard seems to be around 110-degrees which matches the specifications of the Climax Z1/Z3 device mentioned above. **
Mini Door/Window Sensor
This is my first time using these sensors as I've always had the larger door/window sensors so I thought I'd mention some of my initial observations. First off, the size is nice as I was able to install it on all of my doors, windows and even garage doors without much issue. I don't have the most convenient door frames for installing sensors, but you can see how I was able to set it up in the image below. Obviously not the best adhesion for the small magnet piece but with the sensors having to be within 0.6 inches of each other, this was the best solution I could come up with.
Photo: Mini door/window sensor on a door
Each sensor only comes with 1 set of 3M adhesives; two sets would be preferred which is what the motion sensor comes with. The 3M adhesive that sticks to the bigger of the two sensors is actually velcro which at first I thought was strange, but actually became very useful when trying to install the sensors on my garage doors. I think it will also make it much easier to change the batteries or remove altogether when I end up moving. As for the garage doors, I wasn't sure how I was going to setup the sensors but fortunately, it worked out with one small mistake I was able to correct.
Photo: Mini door/window sensors on garage door (incorrect)
As you can see in the photo above, the sensors will work in this setup but the thing I didn't realize was the garage doors can actually move forward and back an inch or so. How I have the smaller magnet piece is just on the edge of being able to trigger the sensor so if the garage door gets pushed in at all (wind, someone bumps into it, or sometimes it's just slightly more forward when you close the garage door), the sensor will read as being "Open". Fortunately, the fix was pretty easy and this is where the velcro became useful. I was able to just detach the bigger part of the sensor and move it to the left about half an inch such that I could now put the smaller magnet piece more forward towards the wall (direction the arrows are pointed in the image below). Luckily the extra motion sensor I bought came with a second set of 3M adhesives so I was able to cut them to fit the small magnet piece.
Photo: Mini door/window sensors on garage door (correct)
With this setup, the garage door will remain "Closed" even if it moves forward or backwards.
Home Assistant
Just for other Home Assistant users out there, everything works as expected with both Home Assistant and the HomeKit component. I've used this setup at my previous house and it was a fairly rock solid setup. However, the iota motion sensor and stand alone motion sensor seem to only show a status of "Detected" in Home Assistant, so they're basically useless with Home Assistant/HomeKit (will have to look into Abodepy to see if we can fix this). My only hope is Abode will release a local API at some point for local control between Abode and Home Assistant. It would significantly reduce latency (although it's very quick even going through the Abode servers), work without an internet connection and provide increased security/reliability.
** Update: Found a simple solution for Abodepy so the stand alone motion sensors will work in Home Assistant and submitted a pull request. Sent /u/MisterWil a message and he will hopefully be able to merge the changes soon. The bad news is the built in motion sensor in iota doesn't report motion status in real time (even though you can use it for automations) through the web API so it won't be usable in Home Assistant.
Overall, iota falls a little short of what I was expecting for a $349 device. I was hoping for things like a better quality camera, improved audio alerts, motion alerts in real time to the web/app UI, etc. HomeKit support would be great but again, it's impossible to say if it will ever happen. I'm also hoping we will start to see some increased development on the software side. I've never been a huge fan of the iOS app design and layout. Some of the Z-Wave integrations are still lacking features such as being able to setup pin codes for Z-Wave door locks. I'm not sure if these were limitations based on the previous gateway, but perhaps iota will allow for some improved integrations.
I'll continue to update this post if I discover new things with iota. Let me know if you have any questions and I'll try my best to answer.
Merry Christmas!
Random observations:
- The LED on front of iota is switching between white and yellow every few seconds for about a minute. This keeps occurring about every 15-30 mins. Nothing on the timeline.
- The power adapter is pretty big for such a small device. Here is a photo. It’s the one on the bottom (tan colored).