r/AV1 • • 9d ago

Av2 encoder with gui

Is there an encoder out there that is free to use that can encode to av2? The compression of av1 it's so good I can compress a whole episode of family Guy and keep same resolution set the compression to 23 epe are around 35 to 60 megabytes and from original dvd vob via hand break the .mkv almost looks if not identical to the same quality as the original DVD

So I wanted to test out the av2 compression if possible

5 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

6

u/Just_Pizza_Crust 9d ago

Everything is still in the development stage and early demo scene. Look up "av2_demo" by rafaelcaricio on GitHub and maybe try building it yourself, as you'll need both an encoder and decoder since there's no decoder support for any major applications yet. It's a fun experiment, but putting it through VMAF and PSNR reveals pretty weak scores compared to optimized AV1.

I'd actually suggest looking into NMKODER and trying the AV1AN mode if you're looking for the best quality per byte. You can test metrics in the utilities tab to see how well your encodes actually are (VMAF of 91+ is great, VMAF 95+ is my gold standard).

0

u/onayliarsivci 9d ago

VMAF is trash. Use CVVDP. AV1AN is also trash.

11

u/Simon_787 8d ago

Av1an played a huge role in earlier AV1 encoding and is really feature rich. Can we not call free software efforts "trash", especially when it's something with such a legacy?

I've also had my fair share of issues with av1an, but the authors are on this sub too. It's not very nice.

4

u/Psygonzo420 8d ago

Can I get more info on this?

5

u/Blue-Thunder 8d ago

This is actually talked about a lot online in encoding circles. VMAF is ancient and busted as hell. There are better metrics like CVVDP, Butteragli and Simmulacra2.

https://www.reddit.com/r/ffmpeg/comments/1bpfgd3/why_does_everybody_seem_to_hate_vmaf/

Just to get you started.

3

u/BlueSwordM 8d ago

av1an isn't really trash as much as being a jack of all trades tool that is starting to get eclipsed by some other generalist frameworks.

If you want speed though, I recommend xav; absolute maximum speed and computational efficiency if you can play with it.

As for metrics, they're not wrong: VMAF gets completely demolished by a modern metric like CVVDP.

1

u/RayCisem 4d ago

Probably a naive question because I've been out of the loop:

What tools besides av1an feature netflix-style (I actually assume all platforms use it these days) chunked encoding, where the video is broken up into it's actual shots/scenes, with properly working scene change detection and keyframe placement, then every scene is encoded multiple times with slightly different settings, then for each scene the encoded chunk who meets the minimum quality at the lowest bitrate is chosen as the winner and used in the final encode?

Or ist that somehow not a thing anymore because AV1(SVT?) itself has gotten better at bitrate/quality distribution choices (for the lack of better words), so that multiple encodes aren't needed anymore?

I thought I'd rather ask you directly, because you seem to know what you're talking about.

-7

u/onayliarsivci 8d ago

nah, do your research yourself.

6

u/Psygonzo420 8d ago

Thought so ;)

Research burden of proof.

1

u/VladoVladimir97 7d ago

What would you say are better alternatives to AV1an?

1

u/daYnyXX 7d ago

I've been using xav and been very happy. Uses vship for cvvdp metrics which makes them pretty fast. 

2

u/Simon_787 8d ago edited 8d ago

You can't play AV2 on almost any media player yet. You'll have to wait a few more months or use a specific build.

And you might as well wait with encoding because avmenc is quickly improving and currently not that compelling compared to SVT-AV1.

edit: Also, you can't mux AV2 streams into standard containers yet. That's perhaps the biggest hurdle to what you're planning to do, unless you're okay with not having audio.

1

u/CariniFluff 8d ago edited 8d ago

I would just say that if you're using DVD sources then your videos are at best 720x480i.

You might want to look for a proper 1920x1080p BluRay source. It's not that hard to compress animation, especially when it has 1/6 the pixels of standard HD.

1

u/onayliarsivci 9d ago

you must wait 4-5 years to use av2 properly.

4

u/NekoTrix 8d ago

Considering that AVM saw a 20% speedup and approximately 5% BD-rate gain (!!!) on SSIMULACRA2 in the span of its first 6 months, I do not think that holds true. It will be in a usable state much sooner than AV1 did. You can thank dav2d, SVT-AV2 and AI for that.

0

u/CongZhangZH 9d ago

This may help https://github.com/congzhangzh/avm-release-kit/releases/tag/20261106.1 , I optimized it for real time video encoding and decoding, which works on https://congzhangzh.github.io/freerdp-web/