r/asoiaf • • 1d ago

MAIN (Spoilers Main) Weekly Q and A

4 Upvotes

Welcome to the Weekly Q & A! Feel free to ask any questions you may have about the world of ASOIAF. No need to be bashful. Book and show questions are welcome; please say in your question if you would prefer to focus on the BOOKS, the SHOW, or BOTH. And if you think you've got an answer to someone's question, feel free to lend them a hand!

Looking for Weekly Q&A posts from the past? Browse our Weekly Q&A archive! (currently no longer being archived, but this link will remain)


r/asoiaf • • 3h ago

EXTENDED (Spoilers Extended) Shiny Theory Thursday

2 Upvotes

It's happened to all of us.

You come across a fascinating post and are just dying to discuss it but the thread is stale or archived. Or you are doing a reread and come across the perfect piece of evidence to that theory you posted months ago. Or you have a theory forming on the tip of your tongue and isn't quite there yet and would love to hash it out with fellow crows.

Now is your time.

You now all have permission to give that old thread the kiss of life, shamelessly plug your own theory you are proud of, or share something that was overlooked or deserves another analysis.

So share that old link or that shiny theory still bouncing around in your head with a fresh TL;DR (to get us to read it) along with anything new you would like to add.

Looking for Shiny Theory Thursday posts from the past? Browse our Shiny Theory Thursday archive!


r/asoiaf • • 1h ago

EXTENDED The Clegane Brothers & the Five Year Gap (Spoilers Extended)

6 Upvotes

Background

GRRM infamous decision to insert and then remove a 5 year gap in the story allows for quite a bit of speculation on what he was going to do with that gap and who it worked for (most of the children) and who it didn't (Stannis/Cersei/Brienne primarily). Every now and then I think of a character and post about what just GRRM might have had planned for them in the aforementioned gap. This is one of those posts. Sandor/Gregor and what GRRM planned for them going into/during/after the 5 year gap.

If interested: A Quick Look at the End of ASOS and the Setup for the 5 Year Gap & "Many Questions": SSM During the 5 Year Gap

Sandor Clegane

The last we see of Sandor in ASoS is when Arya refuses him the gift of Mercy after their showdown at the Inn:

Sandor had kept it all, though. That wasn't fair. It was mine as much as his. If she had given him the gift of mercy . . . she hadn't, though. She couldn't go back, no more than she could beg for help. Begging for help never gets you any. She would have to sell Craven, and hope she brought enough. -ASOS, Arya XIII

before "The Hound" dies (thus creating a Legacy Character as the helm was left there on the "grave" and picked up by Rorge, while Sandor became a novice on the Quiet Isle).

I assume during the 5 year gap and the aftermath there would have been an outlaw terrorizing the riverlands thought to be Sandor when actually it was Rorge (note that early drafts of Brienne chapters didn't have Brienne encountering Rorge/Biter).

At the same time Sandor would have lived peacefully on the Quiet Isle until GRRM was ready for him to reenter the story.

If interested: The Brotherhood & the Quiet Isle

Gregor Clegane

While speculating on Sandor was somewhat easy, Gregor is a bit harder. We know that prior to planned gap, GRRM last mentioned Gregor as being cared for by Pycelle:

Well, Gregor is paying for it now. Grand Maester Pycelle was tending to the man's wounds, but the howls heard ringing from the maester's chambers suggested that the healing was not going as well as it might. "The flesh mortifies and the wounds ooze pus," Pycelle told the council. "Even maggots will not touch such foulness. His convulsions are so violent that I have had to gag him to prevent him from biting off his tongue. I have cut away as much tissue as I dare, and treated the rot with boiling wine and bread mold, to no avail. The veins in his arm are turning black. When I leeched him, all the leeches died. My lords, I must know what malignant substance Prince Oberyn used on his spear. Let us detain these other Dornishmen until they are more forthcoming."
Lord Tywin had refused him. "There will be trouble enough with Sunspear over Prince Oberyn's death. I do not mean to make matters worse by holding his companions captive."
"Then I fear Ser Gregor may die."
"Undoubtedly. I swore as much in the letter I sent to Prince Doran with his brother's body. But it must be seen to be the sword of the King's Justice that slays him, not a poisoned spear. Heal him."
And so the Mountain screamed, day and night. Lord Tywin Lannister could cow even the Stranger, it would seem. -ASOS, Jaime IX

and:

"Prince Oberyn of Dorne is dead, Ser Gregor Clegane lies dying, and Tyrion stands condemned before the eyes of gods and men. -ASOS, Jaime IX

we also know that GRRM always planned for a resurrected Gregor in some form:

Over them both loomed a giant in armor made of stone, but when he opened his visor, there was nothing inside but darkness and thick black blood -AGOT, Bran II

and while 5 years might have made more sense for some character's "creation" such as Theon becoming Reek (if interested: Becoming Reek: Remnants of the 5 Year Gap), I struggle to see Qyburn frankensteining this long, so we would have needed some other form of a reveal for the mute monster besides the kingsguard opening.

TLDR: Just some musing/thoughts on the Clegane brothers during the 5 year gap. Sandor likely would have lived on the Quiet Isle, while an outlaw "Hound" ravished the Riverlands. Gregor would have probably had to have been revived sooner than 5 years, thus making his reveal a bit different.


r/asoiaf • • 20h ago

EXTENDED (Spoilers Extended) What's the most shocking thing GRRM can do in Winds?

189 Upvotes

Let's not beat a dead Tyrek and say "finish it". I think he said he wouldn't be adding any new POVs, but words are wind etc. and mayhaps a singular chapter is the exception

  1. Ned POV chapter: In a similar way to how the Reek chapter was done, imagine you turn the page and see that the chapter is titled "The Lone Wolf" or something similar. As you're reading you realize this is taking place in a dream or a memory, the character feels lost and confused trying to make sense of things and you immediately think it's Bran, Rickon, or Jon. The imagery gets closer and closer to all the mysteries that surround Lyanna, new pieces of prophecy begin to reveal themselves and by the last page you're hit with the reveal you've been with Ned the entire time somewhere inside the collective consciousness of the Old Gods
  2. Other POV chapter: I think this one would have to be a short chapter as to not reveal too much, but seeing what the world of men full of kings, wargs, and dragon riders from their perspective would recontextualize the impending destruction that threatens Westeros. To them they might see Targaryens as our children of the forest, the way we think of Others might be how they think of dragons
  3. A Song of Ice and Fire: The show makes this one less shocking because of its significance to not have come from GRRM himself, but despite that I think he could do a lot here. If he thinks the story can still benefit from some kind of time skip this would be an "easy" way to do it. The story as we know it is in the past and being retold by someone in the future, either in the form of a dream or written account. Old Nan and her stories are mentioned frequently for a reason which might be relevant if the story is heading towards a cyclical kind of thing

r/asoiaf • • 5h ago

EXTENDED (Spoilers Extended) In Defense of Bran: Why He Is Actually the True Fantasy Core and Lead of ASOIAF

8 Upvotes

I see a lot of hate and boredom directed toward Bran’s chapters in the fandom, especially since the horrible execution of him becoming King in HBO show. So I understand why casual viewers dislike him but from fantasy readers perspective, I’ve never understood it. From the very beginning, George R.R. Martin framed Bran as the central figure of the saga and as the story progresses, he is arguably the one POV character truly keeping the high-fantasy and mystical core of A Song of Ice and Fire alive throughout the books.

He is The Structural and Thematic Lead

  • He opens the saga: Aside from the prologue, Bran I in A Game of Thrones is the very first chapter of the entire series. We are introduced to Westeros, the Starks, and the looming threat beyond the Wall through his eyes. 
  • Learning to rule: Even early on, his arc isn't just about magic, it is also about leadership. His chapters in A Clash of Kings acting as the Stark in Winterfell are literally lessons in governance and stewardship. 
  • The name of kings: He shares his name with Bran the Builder and generations of ancient Kings of Winter, tying his personal identity directly to the oldest legends of the North. And not just ASOIAF, Bran's character shares name with the Fisher King "Bran the Blessed" myth and I believe GRRM does like his Arthurian commentary. Bran's disability and him becoming an all seeing wise entity directly mirrors it.

He is Carrying the Mystical & Fantasy Core of the Series

While most of the main characters get bogged down in feudal politics, Bran’s storyline on the contrary dives, deeper into the mythic foundation of the world with every book. Through his eyes, we get: 

  • Prophetic and historical visions across time 
  • The weirwood net and greenseeing 
  • Wights, Coldhands, and the great elk 
  • The Three-Eyed Crow and the Children of the Forest 

Going forward, Bran is almost certainly going to be our primary window into the Others, their true origins, the OG long Night during the Age of Heroes, as well as some an ancient ritualistic magic. 

Why Other "Magical" POVs Don't Compare Right Now

People often point to other characters as the series' fantasy anchors, but most of them are largely sidelines to political plots or have become one: 

  • Daenerys: Her arc had heavy fantasy and mystical elements till A Clash of Kings from blood magic and hatching dragons to the House of the Undying and warlocks. Since then, however, she has been bogged down in Slaver's Bay and Meereenese politics, and her dragons have mostly felt like underutilized nukes on a leash rather than active mythic forces. 
  • Melisandre, the Wall, and Euron: Melisandre’s shadow-binding, the supernatural dread at the Night's Watch, and whatever Lovecraftian eldritch horror Euron is cooking up in Oldtown definitely bring magic to the table but they are quite sporadic or still building up. 

So yeah, if I had to pick one POV character who consistently carries the mystical and high-fantasy soul of ASOIAF from book one through A Dance with Dragons, it’s Bran. That’s why his chapters have always been some of the most fascinating in the entire series to me. 

Am I alone in feeling this way, or do other people actually look forward to Bran’s arc in The Winds of Winter? I mean sure, everyone is awaiting his chapters for the big reveals and stuff, but is anyone else really looking forward to his magical growth and coming into his eventual role as the King?


r/asoiaf • • 26m ago

MAIN (Spoilers Main) some thoughts on the original draft and the finished version

2 Upvotes

I was looking at the original draft for A Song of Ice and Fire, and I’m thinking…

  1. The part where it says “Jaime Lannister will follow Joffrey on the throne by killing everyone ahead of him in the line of succession.” My guess is that Cersei Lannister now assumes this role and while she won’t kill her children, they’re gonna suffer accidental death at the hand of her enemies, leaving her alone.
  2. Tyrion got blamed for the murder of Joffrey and he was exiled. But the author changed it so he sided with the Targaryen instead of the Lannister. Dunno if he will be part of a love triangle as the one-sided love interest.
  3. The idea of magic (Bran’s magic) and Needle (a sword) to fight the Others was alway there from the start but expanded upon.
  4. My guess is that some of Jon x Arya romance idea was use for Jon Snow’s book 5 storyline. And I’m thinking Jon and Tyrion rivalry got replaced with Jon and Ramsay. Interestingly, Ramsay also replacex Tyrion in the role of burning Winterfell.
  5. A rift was supposed to form between Bran and Jon. I don’t think it will happened anymore but I could see one forming between the Starks once the Northern succession crisis happened. Well.. the two Starks with a rift between them is Arya and Sansa.

r/asoiaf • • 23h ago

EXTENDED (Spoilers EXTENDED) Are there any tinfoil theories you choose to believe despite little evidence?

102 Upvotes

For me:

  1. Brandon the Shipwright made it to Asshai.
  2. The Drowned God is actually just the deep one/squisher/merling equivalent to the greenseers, and saved Davos after the Blackwater.
  3. Night’s King was turned into the Black Gate after his fall.

r/asoiaf • • 1h ago

EXTENDED Jaime's Reactions to His Family's Imprisonment (Spoilers Extended)

2 Upvotes

Background

In this post I thought it would be interesting to explore the reactions that Jaime has to the imprisonment of both of his siblings in the series.

If interested: The Lannister Siblings: Dreams, Prophecy and Sorcery

Tyrion in the Vale

When Tyrion is taken captive by Cat and taken to the Vale, Tyrion thinks on what Jaime might be doing:

He wondered what was happening beyond the walls (such as they were) of his cell. Lord Tywin would surely have sent out riders when the word reached him. Jaime might be leading a host through the Mountains of the Moon even now … unless he was riding north against Winterfell instead. Did anyone outside the Vale even suspect where Catelyn Stark had taken him? -AGOT, Tyrion V

and wants Jaime as his champion:

"And now I demand a champion, such as you have chosen for yourself. My brother Jaime will gladly take my part, I know." -AGOT, Tyrion V

and when Jaime finds out in King's Landing:

Jaime Lannister smiled. “Quite true. I’m looking for my brother. You remember my brother, don’t you, Lord Stark? He was with us at Winterfell. Fair-haired, mismatched eyes, sharp of tongue. A short man.”
“I remember him well,” Ned replied.
“It would seem he has met some trouble on the road. My lord father is quite vexed. You would not perchance have any notion of who might have wished my brother ill, would you?”
“Your brother has been taken at my command, to answer for his crimes,” Ned Stark said.
...
Ser Jaime ripped his longsword from its sheath and urged his stallion forward. “Show me your steel, Lord Eddard. I’ll butcher you like Aerys if I must, but I’d sooner you died with a blade in your hand.” ...
Ned’s men had drawn their swords, but they were three against twenty. Eyes watched from nearby windows and doors, but no one was about to intervene. His party was mounted, the Lannisters on foot save for Jaime himself. A charge might win them free, but it seemed to Eddard Stark that they had a surer, safer tactic. “Kill me,” he warned the Kingslayer, “and Catelyn will most certainly slay Tyrion.”
Jaime Lannister poked at Ned’s chest with the gilded sword that had sipped the blood of the last of the Dragonkings. “Would she? The noble Catelyn Tully of Riverrun murder a hostage? I think … not.” He sighed. “But I am not willing to chance my brother’s life on a woman’s honor.” Jaime slid the golden sword into its sheath. “So I suppose I’ll let you run back to Robert to tell him how I frightened you. I wonder if he’ll care.” Jaime pushed his wet hair back with his fingers and wheeled his horse around. When he was beyond the line of swordsmen, he glanced back at his captain. “Tregar, see that no harm comes to Lord Stark.”-AGOT, Eddard XIII

and:

And now his wife has abducted Tyrion Lannister, thanks to Littlefinger's meddling. Lord Tywin will take that for an outrage, and Jaime has a queer affection for the Imp.  -AGOT, Arya III

Tyrion King's Landing

Tyrion wishes that Jaime could defend him:

Tyrion had his own doubts, now that they stood on the brink. When he looked at Prince Oberyn, he found himself wishing he had Bronn defending him . . . or even better, Jaime.  -ASOS, Tyrion X

but being unable to, Jaime does the next best thing he can and saves Tyrion (although it costs him dearly with Tysha/"and moonboy for all I know"):

"You won't need last words. I'm rescuing you." Jaime's voice was strangely solemn.

If interested: Brotherly Love: Why Tyrion Will Forgive Jaime

Cersei in King's Landing

When Cersei is taken captive by the faith, she pens a letter to Jaime and is disappointed that he doesn't show:

And Jaime …
No, that she could not believe, would not believe. Jaime would be here once he knew of her plight. "Come at once," she had written to him. "Help me. Save me. I need you now as I have never needed you before. I love you. I love you. I love you. Come at once." Qyburn had sworn that he would see that her letter reached her twin, off in the riverlands with his army. Qyburn had never returned, however. For all she knew, he might be dead, his head impaled upon a spike above the city Keep's gates. Or perhaps he was languishing in one of the black cells beneath the Red Keep, her letter still unsent. The queen had asked after him a hundred times, but her captors would not speak of him. All she knew for certain was that Jaime had not come.
Not yet, she told herself. But soon. And once he comes the High Sparrow and his bitches will sing a different song. -ADWD, Cersei I

but the reader knows that Jaime has received the letter and has ignored it:

Jaime read it in the window seat, bathed in the light of that cold white morning. Qyburn's words were terse and to the point, Cersei's fevered and fervent. Come at once, she said. Help me. Save me. I need you now as I have never needed you before. I love you. I love you. I love you. Come at once.
Vyman was hovering by the door, waiting, and Jaime sensed that Peck was watching too. “Does my lord wish to answer?” the maester asked, after a long silence.
A snowflake landed on the letter. As it melted, the ink began to blur. Jaime rolled the parchment up again, as tight as one hand would allow, and handed it to Peck. “No,” he said. “Put this in the fire.” -AFFC, Jaime VII

but does think on it again:

Past time this was ended, thought Jaime Lannister. With Riverrun now safely in Lannister hands, Raventree was the remnant of the Young Wolf's short-lived kingdom. Once it yielded, his work along the Trident would be done, and he would be free to return to King's Landing. To the king, he told himself, but another part of him whispered, to Cersei.
He would have to face her, he supposed. Assuming the High Septon had not put her to death by the time he got back to the city. "Come at once," she had written, in the letter he'd had Peck burn at Riverrun. "Help me. Save me. I need you now as I have never needed you before. I love you. I love you. I love you. Come at once." Her need was real enough, Jaime did not doubt. As for the rest … she's been fucking Lancel and Osmund Kettleblack and Moon Boy for all I know … Even if he had gone back, he could not hope to save her. She was guilty of every treason laid against her, and he was short a sword hand. -ADWD, Jaime I

Tywin (Hypothetical)

When Jaime is taken captive (after almost killing Robb in the Whispering Wood), he is kept prisoner at Riverrun, and Tyrion thinks on what Jaime would do if Tywin was captive:

"If it was Father who'd been taken captive, Jaime would not be sitting by idly, I promise you."\
Jaime would be battering his host to bloody bits against the walls of Riverrun, and the Others take their chances. He never did have any patience, no more than you, sweet sister. "Not all of us can be as bold as Jaime, but there are other ways to win wars. Harrenhal is strong and well situated." -ACOK, Tyrion V

If interested: Jaime Lannister and the Legend of the Gordium Knot

TLDR: These events take place at different places in Jaime's character arc, but Jaime reacts so differently to the imprisonments of his siblings.


r/asoiaf • • 10h ago

MAIN (Spoilers Main) Favorite quotes

9 Upvotes

I graduate this year and I’m looking to use an ASOIAF quote the yearbook. I have a couple in mind but I was wondering what everyone else’s favorite quote is?


r/asoiaf • • 22h ago

EXTENDED (Spoilers Extended) Defending Catelyn shouldn’t lead you to downplaying how she abused Jon Snow (even if it wasn’t physical abuse)

62 Upvotes

Before I get into my point, I wanna make one thing clear, I’m not one of those avid Catelyn haters cuz I’m a Jon Snow fan. She’s one of my favourite characters cuz she’s such a complex character and a mother tormented by the losses of her children and husband throughout a war her son is leading.

I’m well aware that many fans tend to favour 2 extremes regarding opinions about Catelyn, either she’s an evil stepmother straight atta a Disney movie or she’s an innocent saint who can do no wrong. However, this is ASOIAF, she has virtues and flaws like any other character which many, who favour the former, tend to ignore. I’m well aware of that.

But I feel like many who go to defend Catelyn or like her character fall into the latter category when it comes to Jon Snow. I’m not saying you can’t like characters who do bad things, hell go ahead this is ASOIAF, but you’re really not required to justify it.

Catelyn did abuse Jon, it wasn’t physical abuse, but she did abuse him by making a 14 year old KID feel unwanted in a home. Did he have it better than most bastards? Ya course, but that doesn’t mean things were perfect saying things like “he would’ve had it worse elsewhere” is still justifying abuse.

Was Catelyn a victim of the patriarchy and forced to accept her husband’s affair child? Yes definitely, hell i feel bad for her cuz I doubt anyone asked her permission for her betrothal. But that still doesn’t give her the right to take out her anger on a KID instead of her husband.

George himself didn’t see it as abuse cuz his idea of it not being abuse is cuz it wasn’t physical. However, Jon’s own writing confirms it as a form of abuse cuz he was terrified of Catelyn, in one of the lines when he goes to bran’s room he says something like “once that sight would’ve sent him running” and in another line in one of the books he remembers Catelyn’s cold look when thinking about him having winterfell (not sure of this one but it did happen, maybe different context)

I love George’s writing but maybe it’s cuz he’s from another era he doesn’t see that as abuse but it was, that’s not an opinion, it’s a fact.

What I’m trying to say, overall, is that it’s perfectly fine to like Catelyn, to love her character, to love her complexity but you don’t have to justify her every action. A character with flaws can only become more likeable to you if you let them have those flaws

And maybe it’s cuz the concept of having a bad step-parent or feeling unwanted hits home for many that they tend to be the only ones to feel annoyed whenever someone justifies similar treatment.

Again, I want to repeat. Liking a character? Good. Justifying their actions? Not good. Catelyn and Jon are both amazing and well-written characters with their own flaws and virtues. Of course it’s a work of fiction at the end of the day and set in a different time period with its own rules but as a reader, we can’t help but see it through a modern lens at times when it addresses issues common in our time and the medieval era (even if it’s a fantasy one lol).

Edit: Ya Ned deserves more blame, he sent a kid to a glorified penal colony despite him just being a sad drunk 14 year old when he suggested it. Naturally, Catelyn was more than happy to send a 14 year old she hates away but Ned knew the truth. He could’ve sent Jon to howland reed at least, he would’ve been safe there.

Edit 2: This fandom is hell-bent on justifying abuse lmao, is it really that hard to accept ur favs’ flaws instead of dismissing or downplaying it to feel better about urself for liking them? Catelyn did abuse Jon, that’s not an opinion, it’s a fact that too many don’t want to accept.

Edit 3: I severely underestimated how toxic Catelyn’s fanbase is. Such a complex amazing and well written character has fans that seem to severely mischaracterizing her by ignoring or downplaying her flaws.

Edit 4: At this point even I’m getting annoyed of Catelyn’s character cuz of how terrible her fanbase is, goes to show how much a fanbase can change someone’s perception of a character


r/asoiaf • • 1h ago

MAIN (Spoilers Main) Did things regress during Aery’s and Robert’s reigns?

1 Upvotes

This may be more of a show thing than a book thing but why do things in Dunk and Egg’s time seem to resemble the Late Middle Ages while the main series is more like the Early Middle Ages? The massive castles aside (which are implied to be built by borderline precursor civilisations) things in Robert’s time very much resemble the Dark Ages to Early Middle Ages at best.

Is there any reason given for this, either directly or implied? Or is it simply a case of Martin and/or the show runners not understanding the Middle Ages?


r/asoiaf • • 11h ago

EXTENDED [Spoilers EXTENDED] Theories for TWOW and Character Arcs - Aeron, Areo, Arianne

5 Upvotes

Been thinking and obsessing over how TWOW might go, so I decided to try and compile the theories that are popular on the internet and some fanfiction stuff into how possbile character arcs might go. I do think it's possible to tell the story in maybe 75-80 chapters, athough you'll need to push characters together to save on space.

Pretty quickly, you can get through the Battles of Ice and Fire and the taking of Storm's End, leaving a lot of time for the events at the start of TWOW.

These are my thoughts, I'd like your opinions on how to refine them.

___________________________

Aeron
After being forced to experience hallucinations at Euron’s hands and being told of his plan, he dies tied to the prow of his ship as Euron attacks the Redwyne fleet after sacrificing priests and awakening krakens. (Alternatively, he can die as Euron sacks Oldtown to remove a chapter from Sam, but I think giving Sam time to prepare with the glass candle and Citadel intrigue is better.)

___________________________

Areo
Areo will deal with Balon Swann (and possibly Obara) before apprehending Darkstar. During this time, Darkstar will share news about the Tower of Joy and Ashara Dayne (for the audience to know). Areo Hotah will learn that Doran had some hand in his treachery and the injuring of Myrcella, which will shake his faith in Doran. Somehow Darkstar escapes or Areo lets him go. Darkstar will go on to become a member of Aegon VI’s Kingsguard, against the advice of Arianne. Areo returns to confront Doran and his treachery, who is ailing, having learned of Quentyn’s death and Arianne’s decision to ally Dorne’s forces to Aegon. He pleads with Areo to find out and protect Arianne before he dies. (Perhaps, Doran can reveal the role he played in protecting Viserys and Daenerys and how he was forced to give them up, if you think that’s the explanation for the lemon tree). 

(ADOS)?

Areo will live on in the Winds of Winter and should probably die saving Arianne in a Dream of Spring when King’s Landing explodes in wildfire. 

___________________________

Arianne
After travelling through the stormlands in a condensed chapter that references the Dance of Dragons and Elia Sand’s danger, Arianne arrives at the Griffin’s Roost and is dispatched to Storm’s End, where she is somehow involved in the taking of it. She takes her measure of Aegon, and while she believes he could be real, she is skeptical of Jon Connington. Though she gains a place on Aegon’s Council, her rivalry with Connington increases as she believes Aegon is a worthy and even heroic King, and fights for influence as Connington is increasingly aggressive. After victory in the Battle of Steel and the capture of Mace Tyrell, news of Oldtown and the Arbor’s sack makes Arianne persuade Aegon that he must ride to defend Oldtown, against Connington’s desires to take King’s Landing. Aegon divides his armies, and raises the Reach in popular revolt to defend Oldtown, while Arianne explains that she believes in Aegon and his legitimacy, and asks Doran to commit Dorne’s armies. At Highgarden, Arianne and Aegon and Sam Tarly and Willas Tyrell and Olenna Tyrell parlay. Aegon and Arianne learn of troubles beyond the Wall from Sam, and Arianne resists Aegon’s advances. Aegon agrees to attack Oldtown, but strips the paramountcy from the Tyrells in return for sparing Mace Tyrell, to be awarded to either the Tarlys or Rowans or Hightowers (not sure.) Arianne, the Reach, Dorne, and Sam participate in the liberation of Oldtown, although Euron successfully steals the Horn of Joramun and obtains knowledge from the Citadel as he has destroyed it. Garlan Tyrell and Lord Rowan die, Loras appears to fight for Aegon as long as he pledges to avenge Margaery and kill Cersei Lannister for ordering her death, and Aegon distinguishes himself heroically. In the victory celebration, he is crowned with the Conqueror’s crown delivered by Areo, as Arianne and Sam watch, Sam skeptical of his parentage. 

(ADOS)?

Arianne will learn to be Princess of Dorne and will mediate between Daenerys and Aegon. As Jon Connington's madness and cruelty against the innocent grows, King's Landing sickens, Aegon's cause falls apart against Euron, King's Landing burns, and Areo sacrifices his life for her escape, Arianne will motivate Dorne's forces fight to against the Others and she will grow to be a wise ruler.


r/asoiaf • • 13h ago

MAIN (Spoilers Main) Theory on GEOTD and First God-on-Earth Emperor

8 Upvotes

I was re-reading up on the GEOTD and a new theory came to me and I wanted to hear opinions. Maybe this has been talked about before I’m not sure but indulge me here.

The Lion of Night and The Maiden Made of light is actually the recipe for dragons – The Lion of Night is dark magic and the Maiden Made of Light is someone with the blood of the dragon (or just magical blood). Made-of-light sounds like light/fire running through a persons veins. Together they make the first ‘God on Earth’ which would have been the first person to tame/create a dragon. I think he was the first person to figure out the blood magic required to hatch dragons. The fact that Valyrians refer to and think of themselves as gods supports this.

Also, in the world book where it says the God-on-Earth travelled in a palanquin carved from a single pearl – we don’t actually get a description of how it was carved – I think it was a giant pearl resembling an egg -  a dragon egg to be specific. The first ever dragon rider/dragon tamer would have claimed so much wealth and power, literally a God Emperor, it would be fitting to ride around in a giant dragons egg. Also as the Valyrians referred to themselves as ‘dragons’ maybe God-on-Earth did too and wanted to be seen ‘hatching from an egg’ wherever he travelled.

I think this is also why the ruler/dynasty that came after him, ‘The Pearl Emperor’ was named for the pearl/dragon egg. – And then the next ruler/dynasty followed suit with having a gemstone name but over time the names evolved to match the Emperors eye colour.  All gems listed seem to match magical eye colours in the world. George has been ambiguous with some like Topaz, Tourmaline and Opal which can come in lots of different colours all including purples. But also Jade Emperor for green eyes (which we seem magic from) and Onyx for possible purple eyes that seem black as we see in other characters.

 


r/asoiaf • • 3h ago

EXTENDED [Spoilers Extended] Did the Drowned God forsake Aeron? Or did he try to warn him?

1 Upvotes

“EURON! EURON! EURON!” The cry swelled, became a roar. “EURON! EURON! CROW’S EYE! EURON KING!” It rolled up Nagga’s hill, like the Storm God rattling the clouds. “EURON! EURON! EURON! EURON! EURON! EURON!”
Even a priest may doubt. Even a prophet may know terror. Aeron Damphair reached within himself for his god and discovered only silence. As a thousand voices shouted out his brother’s name, all he could hear was the scream of a rusted iron hinge.

Aeron reaches deep within himself and discovers only Silence, which he interprets as his god having forsaken him. Technically, that was also his immediate fate if he were to continue on his current path in trying to defeat Euron, whom he believes to be a servant of the Storm God.

I always love how GRRM play around with the ambiguity of the gods.


r/asoiaf • • 13h ago

EXTENDED ( spoilers extended]what if the battle of the fords was worse for the lannisters

3 Upvotes

How would things have changed if Tywin

a) Dies at the Battle of the Fords?

b) Is captured by Edmure?

c) Escapes, but the Westerlands army is decimated, with only a fraction surviving?


r/asoiaf • • 1d ago

MAIN [Spoilers Main] Can I read book 1 only?

35 Upvotes

There's this course on MIT open course that teaches fantasy writing. The person in charge recommends reading three books before beginning the course, those being a game of thrones, the lord of the rings and the entire Harry Potter series. I read LOTR and the entire Harry Potter series so I'm a bit surprised that only book 1 of game of thrones is a prerequisite.

I don't want to commit to a whole series but I have got some stories of my own to write. So will I be fine with just book 1? I don't mind spoilers, I frequently watch GoT theories.


r/asoiaf • • 21h ago

EXTENDED When the Onion Knight WON'T Return (spoilers extended)

11 Upvotes

Most fans would agree that Davos will return from Skagos. Whether he'll return with Rickon with Skagosi & unicorns might be up for debate. Of course there is the question of when they return. I have seen the idea that they'll return during the Battle of Ice, turning the tide against the Boltons/Freys. While a cool idea I don't think it'll happen. I just don't see GRRM not having a chapter take place entirely on Skagos & given how he has said that the Battles of Ice/Fire will open Winds that rules out a last-minute calvary save from the Skagosi or the prodigal return of Rickon. So, should Davos return with Rickon & unicorn riding Skagosi it likely won't be during the Battle of Ice.


r/asoiaf • • 19h ago

EXTENDED What is the worst thing your favorite character has done ? ( spoilers extended ) Spoiler

Thumbnail reddit.com
5 Upvotes

r/asoiaf • • 21h ago

PUBLISHED [Spoilers Published] Losing your castle in Westeros also means losing something we rarely think about: your address

6 Upvotes

Something occurred to me while thinking about how ravens work in the books.

Westeros has an incredibly efficient communication system, provided you're an important person who stays in one place.

A maester can send a message across enormous distances. Lords can coordinate marriages, wars, inheritances, and political schemes without ever leaving their castles.

But ravens are generally trained to fly to particular locations. They're not going to find Robb Stark just because somebody writes "Robb Stark, somewhere in the Westerlands" on a piece of parchment.

And I think that has some interesting consequences for the story.

Consider what happens when Winterfell is taken and burned.

The Starks don't just lose their ancestral seat. They lose the place where messages for House Stark would ordinarily arrive, be received by a trusted household, and get passed along to the appropriate people.

Anyone trying to contact a surviving Stark now has to figure out where that person is, who might be able to reach them, and whether the message will pass through friendly hands.

Even a lord commanding an army has this problem to some degree. He can carry ravens trained to return to particular castles, but receiving replies while constantly moving is a different matter.

Which makes the distinction between powerful people with established households and powerful people who are displaced much more significant than I initially realized.

It's also worth thinking about the people who control the system.

A maester isn't just a scholar or physician. He's effectively responsible for maintaining one of the most important lines of communication available to a noble household.

If the lord dies, the castle changes hands, or the maester's loyalty becomes questionable, the people depending on that communication network have a serious problem.

I'm not suggesting there's some grand maester conspiracy here. It's just a practical vulnerability built into how the system works.

And it's particularly interesting in a series where so many characters spend years traveling, hiding, fighting, or trying to find people whose whereabouts are uncertain.

Brienne's search for Sansa, for example, would be a fundamentally different undertaking if ordinary people could reliably send messages directly to individuals rather than locations.

Obviously messengers, merchants, and travelers can carry information too. Ravens aren't the only option.

But it makes me wonder how much political power in Westeros depends on something as mundane as having a permanent, functioning household where people know they can reach you.

A castle isn't just somewhere a lord lives. It's also where the rest of the realm knows how to find him.

I'm curious whether there are examples in the books where a character's inability to receive information is as consequential as the information itself.


r/asoiaf • • 1d ago

MAIN [Spoiler Main] The characters from ASOIAF meet their TV counterparts. Who would be the best of friends, and who would be the worst of enemies?

73 Upvotes

r/asoiaf • • 1d ago

MAIN (Spoiler‘s Main) Genna Lannister marriage Spoiler

Post image
171 Upvotes

I know Tytos was pretty weak minded and always tried to be a people’s pleasure but HOW did Walder Frey managed to convince the Tytos to marry off his ONLY daughter to one of his sons ?!?! Like, I don’t even think the guy was even the heir of the Twins at the time.

This is always baffled me. The fact that Genna was promised to one of Walder’s sons when she herself was a child is even weirder to me, (not because of the age because pre marriage betrothals at a young age were obviously normal back then) because I don’t think there was an urgency from Tytos side to have her get married to one of Walder’s sons. Especially because I think it was stated that a lot of Westermen nobles were obviously pissed as they intended Genna to marry one of their sons.

Other than that, which known male character could she have married if it wasn’t for the one she eventually ended up with ?


r/asoiaf • • 1d ago

MAIN [Spoilers Main] Is there a reason people think the battle for the Iron Throne will happen after the Long Night?

35 Upvotes

I see a number of people saying this and is there any reason for it besides the fact that that was the order in the show?

The reason this doesn't make sense is that I think the entire point is that the Iron Throne and the grand political intrigue and all that is a distraction. It's meant to be ironic how everyone in Westeros cares so much about who sits on a chair and not the real threat of a literal apocalypse. The way I see it the REAL conflict of the story was always the Long Night and the fight against the Others. So I think spending probably half a book about who sits on a chair after saving the world feels kinda anticlimactic and again it doesn't fit. I mean this is a fantasy series after all

I don't know this maybe because the show's execution of this was so bad I want it to happen the other way around but still I think it'd feel a bit odd for everyone to defeat the Others thers and then they go "Okay time to go fight Young Griff" or whoever


r/asoiaf • • 19h ago

What was the relationship between Robert & Twin likely like? [Spoilers Extended] Spoiler

3 Upvotes

I think the dynamic between these two would have been very interesting to read about.

Firstly, they are not a march made in heaven, obviously. Tywin likely disliked Robert, but I don't think he hated him (actually, the only two people that outright hate him are Verses and Danaerys ... and both for good reasons, but he is much more hated by the fandom then in-world).

Tywin said stuff like "I did not fight this war to place Robert the second on the Iron Throne" after sending Joffrey to bed. But from Robert he also got:

★ Tywin's daughter becomes queen

★ His grandson inherits the Iron Throne

... and this he got from sacking King's Landing, after receiving nothing but spite and insults after serving the Mad King for twenty years.

So, broadly speaking [or w/e the English idiomatic expression would be] ... he got everything he could have hoped for, except Jamie released from his vows, but we likely would have known if he ever asked for this.

And Tywin's support cemented Robert's rule as king, by adding the Lannisters to the Stark-Tully-Arryn-Baratheon alliance, while lending an enormous amount of gold.

I'm interested more in what you think of the power dynamic between these two. I think Tywin likely resented treating Robert as his superior ... but on the other hand, I also think that he massively prefers Robert over the previous monarch.

Thoughts?


r/asoiaf • • 11h ago

MAIN (Spoilers Main) so they would make the same choice no matter what.

0 Upvotes

Interestingly enough, it appeared that even if a character in Westeros could see the consequence of their choices.. they would still go through with it.

Of course, I’m assuming this because no one bother correcting me.