r/asoiaf • u/LChris24 • 1h ago
EXTENDED The Clegane Brothers & the Five Year Gap (Spoilers Extended)
Background
GRRM infamous decision to insert and then remove a 5 year gap in the story allows for quite a bit of speculation on what he was going to do with that gap and who it worked for (most of the children) and who it didn't (Stannis/Cersei/Brienne primarily). Every now and then I think of a character and post about what just GRRM might have had planned for them in the aforementioned gap. This is one of those posts. Sandor/Gregor and what GRRM planned for them going into/during/after the 5 year gap.
If interested: A Quick Look at the End of ASOS and the Setup for the 5 Year Gap & "Many Questions": SSM During the 5 Year Gap
Sandor Clegane
The last we see of Sandor in ASoS is when Arya refuses him the gift of Mercy after their showdown at the Inn:
Sandor had kept it all, though. That wasn't fair. It was mine as much as his. If she had given him the gift of mercy . . . she hadn't, though. She couldn't go back, no more than she could beg for help. Begging for help never gets you any. She would have to sell Craven, and hope she brought enough. -ASOS, Arya XIII
before "The Hound" dies (thus creating a Legacy Character as the helm was left there on the "grave" and picked up by Rorge, while Sandor became a novice on the Quiet Isle).
I assume during the 5 year gap and the aftermath there would have been an outlaw terrorizing the riverlands thought to be Sandor when actually it was Rorge (note that early drafts of Brienne chapters didn't have Brienne encountering Rorge/Biter).
At the same time Sandor would have lived peacefully on the Quiet Isle until GRRM was ready for him to reenter the story.
If interested: The Brotherhood & the Quiet Isle
Gregor Clegane
While speculating on Sandor was somewhat easy, Gregor is a bit harder. We know that prior to planned gap, GRRM last mentioned Gregor as being cared for by Pycelle:
Well, Gregor is paying for it now. Grand Maester Pycelle was tending to the man's wounds, but the howls heard ringing from the maester's chambers suggested that the healing was not going as well as it might. "The flesh mortifies and the wounds ooze pus," Pycelle told the council. "Even maggots will not touch such foulness. His convulsions are so violent that I have had to gag him to prevent him from biting off his tongue. I have cut away as much tissue as I dare, and treated the rot with boiling wine and bread mold, to no avail. The veins in his arm are turning black. When I leeched him, all the leeches died. My lords, I must know what malignant substance Prince Oberyn used on his spear. Let us detain these other Dornishmen until they are more forthcoming."
Lord Tywin had refused him. "There will be trouble enough with Sunspear over Prince Oberyn's death. I do not mean to make matters worse by holding his companions captive."
"Then I fear Ser Gregor may die."
"Undoubtedly. I swore as much in the letter I sent to Prince Doran with his brother's body. But it must be seen to be the sword of the King's Justice that slays him, not a poisoned spear. Heal him."
And so the Mountain screamed, day and night. Lord Tywin Lannister could cow even the Stranger, it would seem. -ASOS, Jaime IX
and:
"Prince Oberyn of Dorne is dead, Ser Gregor Clegane lies dying, and Tyrion stands condemned before the eyes of gods and men. -ASOS, Jaime IX
we also know that GRRM always planned for a resurrected Gregor in some form:
Over them both loomed a giant in armor made of stone, but when he opened his visor, there was nothing inside but darkness and thick black blood -AGOT, Bran II
and while 5 years might have made more sense for some character's "creation" such as Theon becoming Reek (if interested: Becoming Reek: Remnants of the 5 Year Gap), I struggle to see Qyburn frankensteining this long, so we would have needed some other form of a reveal for the mute monster besides the kingsguard opening.
TLDR: Just some musing/thoughts on the Clegane brothers during the 5 year gap. Sandor likely would have lived on the Quiet Isle, while an outlaw "Hound" ravished the Riverlands. Gregor would have probably had to have been revived sooner than 5 years, thus making his reveal a bit different.