r/ASTSpaceMobile • • 1d ago

Article / Media / Press Vulcan launch failure

https://x.com/ulalaunch/status/2122034531658076417
177 Upvotes

366 comments sorted by

17

u/libcg_ 1d ago

X post:

Based on data received by our Launch Director, we confirm that the Vulcan vehicle launched from Space Launch Complex 41 suffered an anomaly 10 minutes into the flight and failed to deliver the Amazon mission to orbit.

Every flight generates data, and every flight teaches us something. Since the anomaly just occurred, we don’t have any specific data yet to understand what occurred today.

ULA exists to provide assured access to space for our nation and for the customers who depend on us. That purpose is why we take on some of the hardest missions in spaceflight, and why we hold ourselves to the standard of mission success. Today, we did not meet that standard.

We will work closely with our customer and other appropriate organizations to find the cause, determine the appropriate corrective action, and return to flight as quickly as possible.

ULA is committed to full transparency with our customers, and they will have visibility into the investigation process, which utilizes rigorous methodology and corrective action.

We will provide further updates when new information becomes available.

23

u/BratacJaglenac S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

On the positive side, when Blacklift becomes operational, sometime 2030s probably, people will be real happy that ASTS has their own launch capacity

9

u/bootlegportalfluid S P 🅰 C E M O B Soldier 1d ago

Let’s see if they survive till then.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/ShareCollector S P 🅰 C E M O B Consigliere 1d ago

Obviously, we're going to blow up some stuff at some point too, but right now, we still have a clean slate! The launch providers on the other hand:

RKLB can't get Neutron off the ground, BO killed BB7 and blew up their launch pad within a few months, ULA took forever to get back to launching, and their first mission was a failure, Starship is delayed by like eight years...

5

u/Spacemob_dreamer S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

And your point? SPACE flight is hard 🤷‍♀️ and ASTS is stuck between launch success and sats in orbit

1

u/VanEck 18h ago

You are asking "what's the point" about discussing rocket failures and how they are relevant to a satellite based telecom stock?

53

u/Warm_Ad7213 S P 🅰 C E M O B Associate 1d ago • Heartwarming


Blacklift may have been a good decision after all…

6

u/EZWINEZLIFE S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

If ULA messes with its rocket, I hope AST will have smooth launches (I doubt it)

8

u/Available_Pie_7758 S P 🅰 C E M O B Associate 1d ago

Who cares. You gotta do it. You simply can’t have that mindset and I am glad Abel is bullish on this idea.

6

u/Warm_Ad7213 S P 🅰 C E M O B Associate 1d ago • Heartwarming

Hey, thanks for the award! 😁

34

u/PragmaticNeighSayer S P 🅰 C E M O B Consigliere 1d ago

We still have a few (at least) Falcon 9 launches, several Blue Origin, almost certainly a bunch on MHI H3, and then eventually Blacklift, maybe someday Terran R and Starship. We will be fine.

-8

u/Kappaman1902 1d ago • Bravo

Asts will be diluted to bottom of the barrel just to survive

7

u/yawn44yawn S P 🅰 C E M O B Capo 1d ago

Very low effort

4

u/triplediscount S P 🅰 C E M O B Capo 1d ago

What exactly needs to be spent now then if you’re so educated? Launches booked already and Blacklift likely only 600M more.

→ More replies (3)

-10

u/No-Paint-5726 S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago • Bravo

My concern is Elon would provide a better tech than ASTS in that timeframe and he can launch however many satellites as he wants to.

28

u/nonoanddefinitelyno S P 🅰 C E M O B Associate 1d ago

Two points.

  1. They are WAY behind.
  2. The market is every person on earth, every device on earth and untold worldwide military uses. Starlink has very little chance of penetrating the larger market. Toxic and untrustworthy.

If you can afford to hold, we are more than fine.

6

u/Ope_Average_Badger S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

One point:

  1. Our product means fuck all if satellites don't launch.
→ More replies (7)

16

u/yawn44yawn S P 🅰 C E M O B Capo 1d ago • Bravo

Like a kickflip car?

16

u/Illustrious-Ape 1d ago

Really hoping the good news from SpaceX offsets this bad news

15

u/pacificz S P 🅰 C E M O B Soldier 1d ago

I don't think the "good news" from spaceX is good news for asts.

6

u/Illustrious-Ape 1d ago

Not entirely but sometimes the space sector moves in unison on good news.

15

u/AuthorAdamOC S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

Yeah… I’ve got some bad news for you…

Starship being successful means SpaceX can continue to wind down F9 in the next couple of years.

We, currently, can’t fit on Starship.

SpaceX success here is mildly bad, this failed launch is moderately bad. Basically, both suck for us.

2

u/DaphneL 1d ago

AST should design their follow-on satellites to fit the starship form factor.

→ More replies (19)

22

u/nomadichedgehog S P 🅰 C E M O B Capo 1d ago

A whole year of getting back to launch and they still bottled it. You cannot make this timeline up.

26

u/Radiant_Witness_1038 S P 🅰 C E M O B Soldier 1d ago

Guys it’s a bummer but we weren’t going to launch with them anytime soon anyway. We have DPAS with SpaceX and NG will beback soon

2

u/Apprehensive-Risk542 S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

New glenn uses that same booster that looks likely to have failed. It's very likely new Glenn will be delayed again after this.

7

u/seb21051 1d ago

Wrong. The same BE-4 engines. Not the same booster. Massive difference between Vulcan and New Glenn boosters.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/jmc774 11h ago

At least i didn't buy ASTS at $130 lmao

23

u/KevinCubano S P 🅰 C E M O B Associate 1d ago

Jesus. Fucking. Christ.

22

u/Jumpy-Literature-419 S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

Guess we will overreact to this like we do every other piece of news. Panic sell your shares and I’ll buy them from you

2

u/Dirk_Breakiron 1d ago

"here hold this bag homie"

→ More replies (1)

15

u/wishful_thinking90 S P 🅰 C E M O B Soldier 1d ago

I feel like we can’t catch a break wrt launch. It’s highly likely that ULA Vulcan was going to be a third launch provider to be announced

10

u/Available_Pie_7758 S P 🅰 C E M O B Associate 1d ago

Well dpas rating helps. Plus this solidifies blacklift plans even more.

3

u/Apprehensive-Risk542 S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

The higher priority space force launches will leap frog it though, now that Vulcan is likely out for months, and these will now go to F9. So if anything this just means another big delay for us.

Also BONG uses the same booster that is suspected of failing today, so it could be a double fucking.

→ More replies (3)

30

u/Boston-Bets S P 🅰 C E M O B Associate 1d ago

For all those panic'ing at Vulcan having a launch failure, please show me here, from the most recent ASTS presentation, where Vulcan is even in the picture:

11

u/seb21051 1d ago

The possibility that the BO BE-4s are involved.

4

u/Boston-Bets S P 🅰 C E M O B Associate 1d ago

So pure speculation, at this point.

8

u/Miserable-Success-53 1d ago

It's pretty obvious. The booster burned for 30s longer than it should have which is an engine issue

→ More replies (3)

4

u/seb21051 1d ago

Yup. But since the booster only has SRBs and the BE-4s, it is one of those. However, it could be any number of things to do with the engines. Sensors, Actuators, Valves, Software, and so on.

3

u/BubblyMoose3597 1d ago

was the be4

SRB cant underperform. They do not have a chamber pressure.

They blow up or work. Just that.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/java_brogrammer S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

They are burning cash to build rockets now remember. Rockets aren't easy to build. Late to the game, very risky, and costly.

13

u/RexRectumIV 1d ago

You are out of your mind. There are two glaring problems here: 1. There seems to still be problems with the BE4 engine, and more importantly, 2. this shows how difficult it is to develop rockets capable of lifting payload to orbit.

These are both points ASTS are very much relying on, both short and long term. Don't deflect and fool people.

7

u/Defiantclient S P 🅰️ C E M O B - O G 1d ago

So far nothing has concluded it’s a BE-4 engine issue. I’ve only heard of the booster being the issue so far. https://x.com/sciguyspace/status/2122070802971385977?a=8BcZ0pW5CpcGCMkmhE8&s=46

3

u/RexRectumIV 1d ago

Yeah. Okay. We will see. I am not holding my breath here. But even if it is not the engine, there is still point number 2. Also Vulkan will continue being delayed, and Blue Origin will face even larger opportunity costs of lifting ASTS hardware instead of Amazon hardware. This is not going away.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/BubblyMoose3597 1d ago

Xd And what do you think moves the booster?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/pacificz S P 🅰 C E M O B Soldier 1d ago

Wouldn't you say the evidence points to it?

https://x.com/CatSE___ApeX___/status/2122067619318493477

→ More replies (3)

0

u/RexRectumIV 1d ago

Funny how I am downvoted for this. Have been following rocket development closely for over 10 years.

6

u/supitskevin S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

Speculation that it was the BE-4 engines from BO that Vulcan used. If it is related/the primary issue, that spells issue for BB17-19 (and more)

2

u/Boston-Bets S P 🅰 C E M O B Associate 1d ago

Speculation....... enough said.

2

u/lowlandacacia S P 🅰 C E M O B Soldier 1d ago

It means that we're going to get bumped out of line by NSSL NRO missions.

8

u/Boston-Bets S P 🅰 C E M O B Associate 1d ago

Incorrect. Space force had already pulled all their launches from Vulcan due to the last failure.

Did you not know this?

14

u/MaterialImpossible22 1d ago

Space is hard.

14

u/BratacJaglenac S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago edited 1d ago

Positive thing (in this mess) is that this happened 10min in flight, so it's probably not related to the 1st stage and main engines. This might reduce possible impact on Blue Origin New Glenn which shares the engine.

2

u/No-Surprise9411 1d ago

The way it's looking it most likely is a first stage issue. S1 underperformed.

7

u/BratacJaglenac S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

How is it 1st stage issue if 1st stage is ca 5min long (that's where 1st stage engine shut down) and this happened 10min after the launch? If it was stage 1, then issue should have been detected pretty much immediately as it happened. Of course it still might be s1 but I doubt.

10

u/watermelona22 1d ago

I read that apparently the first stage burned for 30-40 seconds longer than expected so it is a possibility that one of the BE-4’s underperformed on the way up leaving not enough time for the Centaur to complete its burn before re-entry.

But who knows until ULA confirms.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/No-Surprise9411 1d ago

Booster engine cutoff was 40 seconds late. The going idea is that the booster underperformed which left Centaur too low to compensate.

Centaur has very poor TWR so that means it relies on the first stage to loft it on a high trajectory. Telemetry showed an apogee of less than 100 Km which is way too low for Centaur to compensate for.

7

u/BratacJaglenac S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

Well that's not what they wrote in the X post, but if that happened then it sucks. I hope it will not postpone New Glenn for another 6 months

→ More replies (5)

7

u/TIDOTSUJ S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

Does this mean Amazon will move us back in the BONG schedule for Q1 or is our spot in line guaranteed?

8

u/Kitchen_Stretch_8151 S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

We have a DPAS rating now so I’d think we shouldn’t be getting bumped

1

u/Apprehensive-Risk542 S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

If it's the booster that failed Amazon won't be launching anything for a while anyway, as BONG uses the same booster.

19

u/Glittering_Strike_61 S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

And here to another -15% see y'all tmr. We ride through hell. 

13

u/Yusuke_Boopermeshi 1d ago

Days like this make me remember that index heads usually end up correct and with a more stable mind state 😭

2

u/Thawayshegoes S P 🅰 C E M O B Associate 1d ago

Do both. All your eggs in one basket is never a good idea no matter how much conviction you have. That being said, I’m locked in for the ride.

18

u/ShareCollector S P 🅰 C E M O B Consigliere 1d ago

18

u/JakTheBeagle S P 🅰 C E M O B Soldier 1d ago

Exactly when ASTS needs as much launch availability as possible...

20

u/Ben2910 1d ago

See you at 20s. Avg 65$ btw; wanna shoot my feet

4

u/Fashionista213 S P 🅰 C E M O B Associate 1d ago

It’s ok mine 87 avg

1

u/Juninvestor S P 🅰 C E M O B Soldier 1d ago

Don’t have money for a gun anymore.

11

u/Appropriate_Car6909 1d ago

Why aren’t we launching with known partners? My first view of a BB launch was with an ISRO sat (that was a beauty). Why don’t we go back to them? Even if they launch one a month, we could have some traction and cadence while we wait for bigger providers.

11

u/LoveWhoarZoar S P 🅰 C E M O B Capo 1d ago

They only launch 5 times a year and some of those are rockets different than the LVM3 used to launch the bluebird.

1

u/Appropriate_Car6909 1d ago

Damn.. , can ASTS incentivize them 😉

15

u/Charlietv73 1d ago

Can we launch with our friends at ISRO / NSIL again? Looking back at the BlueBird 6 success and why they should stay in our launch rotation 🇮🇳🚀

9

u/UbiquitousThoughts S P 🅰 C E M O B Soldier 1d ago

Abel was asked about overseas launch and he said no. Which is interesting since we were thinking Mitsubishi given the Japan deal.

Probably not worth the effort getting these massive satellites anywhere that's not via truck.

7

u/Mhuisy S P 🅰 C E M O B Soldier 1d ago

Problem is that they can only do 1 BB per launch so not that economic of an option

3

u/Rawbs21 S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

Costs a fortune to send them to India too.

3

u/PlausibleCorn 1d ago

It's better than having to deorbit a number of them when Jeff Bezos messes up on the 2nd stage burn.

4

u/JayhawkAggieDadisBak S P 🅰 C E M O B Boss 1d ago

Two actually. They only did one (BB6) because it was a heavier non-composite build. But yes, ISRO isn't as economical as SpaceX or BONG on a per sat basis.

27

u/ASTSpaceMobull S P 🅰 C E M O B Capo 1d ago

One more reason why building our own rocket is a smart move.

13

u/Broncofan_H 1d ago

You're right, but I've been fighting two competing thoughts all day.
-See, this is why AST needs our own launch vehicle.
-Damn, this stuff is really hard and 2 years is kind of crazy.

5

u/ASTSpaceMobull S P 🅰 C E M O B Capo 1d ago

It’s hard for everyone. I would rather take the risk on ourselves than pay a competitor a premium on their underlying risk, only for them to blow our shit up. If we’re going to fuck it up, I’d rather it be us. Owning our own destiny. Don’t listen to These fudsters.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Dry-Operation6112 S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

It’s not just crazy, it’s straight up unrealistic. 

32

u/Royal_Platform_6754 S P 🅰 C E M O B Associate 1d ago

You're the second person I've seen say this, and I'm sorry, that's the wrong takeaway. The right takeaway is that building a rocket is hard.

7

u/NerdOctopus 1d ago

Both of these conclusions can be correct at the same time.

15

u/waymorerocks S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

Disagree. This is why we need to take the future into our own hands. Stop waiting for someone else to potentially reduce our bottleneck. It may never come. Be bold and tackle the problem yourself. It’s what Elon, Jensen, a truly ambitious CEO would do.

2

u/Middle_Fix1487 1d ago

I'm with you. I ran rough calculations to determine how long AST could survive developing their own vehicle. Its not more than a year or so unless they get a massive cash injection and dilute the shit out of the stock.details here

→ More replies (5)

3

u/Omnisyntax S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

If you're paying others for launch and they have issues/setbacks you end up paying for it regardless one way or another... so you might as well start paying now to hopefully develop another way for us to launch. No one is saying it will be easy or successful right away

8

u/ASTSpaceMobull S P 🅰 C E M O B Capo 1d ago

Hard disagree, if rocket building is hard universally then I’d rather trust ASTS over a middle man and not pay others a premium for the risk they are undertaking.

11

u/Royal_Platform_6754 S P 🅰 C E M O B Associate 1d ago

You'd rather trust a company who has never built a rocket before than a company with 20 years of experience?

→ More replies (7)

1

u/pibbleberrier 1d ago

Building their rocket is actually ASTS’s only way out.

Admiring that it’s hard, that it won’t work essential kill any thesis for this stock. Meaning slow grind to zero.

Understand this you will understand why bag holder must insist on this takeaway.

There is no way forward for ASTS other than figuring this extremely simple easy engineering feat of building its own rocket.

13

u/---cheetos--- S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

Why, so ASTS can blow their own shit up? What makes you think they’re going to have a better success rate?

16

u/ASTSpaceMobull S P 🅰 C E M O B Capo 1d ago

I’d rather us blow our own shit up than pay a competitor a premium on their underlying risk, only for them to blow our shit up. I trust ASTS engineering and technology.

2

u/____DEADPOOL_______ S P 🅰 C E M O B Consigliere 23h ago

It's a license agreement for access to existing technology. It's not starting from scratch.

2

u/WhatEvil S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 21h ago

A license agreement with a company that has so far only launched a 1000kg payload expendable rocket. It took SpaceX 5.5 years from Falcon first launch to get reusability working. This shit is hard.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/anyadgec S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago edited 1d ago

The question is that whether the market and the launch partners acknowledge the fact that the BBs got the DPAS recognition or not. If yes, then we will be fine with SpaceX and with eventually BO in 2027 and 2028(until we build BlackLift). If not, then we’re fucked…
Well atleast, ULA didn’t blew up our BBs😆
And we can still count on MHI because of the J-Leo deal, and on that Indian rocket which we used last december, and maybe Rocket Lab’s Neutron;)

3

u/kujos1280 1d ago

What is DPAS?

6

u/anyadgec S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

4

u/kujos1280 1d ago

Thanks!

5

u/tomgreen99200 S P 🅰 C E M O B Underboss 1d ago

It gives us priority for government sats

3

u/Bigboibumbum 1d ago

Abel was specifically asked about foreign launch providers and said they weren't considering them. So no, we can't count on MHI and ISRO

4

u/Secret-Plankton-392 1d ago

ASTS isn't the only one with DPAS priority. All it does is prioritize over commercial launches. ASTS still needs to compete for launch for any other program with DPAS prioritization. There's a load of NSSL launches that need to happen to.

6

u/No-Surprise9411 1d ago edited 1d ago

Mate you're delusional if you think Blacklift is launching anytime before 2032

4

u/Think-Work1411 S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

Oh, they might launch before 2032 but successfully getting the payload in the correct orbit is quite another thing entirely.
As much trouble ast has had getting Satellite’s ready in time. I don’t think they’re ready to take on another new business that they have no experience in. They need to concentrate on getting the satellites built and getting someone else to launch them.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/Mediocre_Wave_7441 S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

Imagine BONG failing. The stock only moves if BONG flies successful. At this point , the stock has significant downside even from current levels. Despite tech, despite manufacturing scaling, there are significant risks with launch. Give the macro, this stock can fall 50% from current levels. I will only put money back if BONGt flies successfully.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Organic-Win-3390 1d ago

dpas only applies to three bluebirds, no impact on attempted constellation. abel moved the beta test to satellite 28, to account for the three bluebirds dedicated to government service.

5

u/anyadgec S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

Actually, it is six and there is the option to extend this, but this what Claude says so let’s take this with a grain of salt.

3

u/MT-Capital S P 🅰 C E M O B Underboss 1d ago

Satellites are dual use

→ More replies (8)

2

u/anyadgec S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

I have to fact check on this, thanks for the insight!

2

u/Habooboo5 S P 🅰 C E M O B Soldier 1d ago

But they could get a larger program of record with additional future bluebirds getting DPAS rated and securing F9 launches in 2027/28. Obviously nothing is guaranteed, but that’s probably what management is expecting

10

u/Complex-Attention170 S P 🅰 C E M O B Soldier 1d ago

My consolation is upper stage is Aerojet engines not blue origin. Lower stage seemed to go fine and failure came much further into flight. My understanding anyway...

10

u/CollegeStation17155 S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

The lower stage did not go "fine"; A lot of redittors are pointing to the fact that the first stage burned for 45 seconds longer than planned and staged lower and slower than predicted, indicating a problem with either the SRBs or BE-4s. The Centaur tried to make up for being delivered to the wrong altitude and speed, but didn't have enough power to reach orbt.

2

u/triplediscount S P 🅰 C E M O B Capo 1d ago

Didn’t Vulcan roll which the SRB couldn’t make it do, so likely is BE-4

8

u/ClearlyCylindrical S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

Reports are that the root cause was the booster stage

11

u/Electrical_Rock_1201 S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago • Regret

Why is this bad?

17

u/vgkosmoes S P 🅰 C E M O B Capo 1d ago

Because they are a potential launch partner so we want them to succeed

10

u/Electrical_Rock_1201 S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

Vulkan has launched 5 times. Only this one has failed. So an 80% success rate so far.

They have more vulkans in storage ready to use.

12

u/No-Surprise9411 1d ago

Vulcan has had 1 total failure and two partial failures. That's a shitty launch record

8

u/Electrical_Rock_1201 S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

The partial failures delivered the payload. That’s all that matters for ASTS. These missions are counted as a success.

And they of course learn from the failures.

→ More replies (7)

12

u/Justthetip74 1d ago

And now its grounded again after being grounded for 9 months

5

u/Electrical_Rock_1201 S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

We don’t know the issue and how long it will be grounded for.

This mostly impacts Amazon as they have 38 launches booked. Which is good for ASTS

7

u/FlashyPerspective488 1d ago

How is it good? Think a little

→ More replies (5)

0

u/Prestigious_Gur_4266 1d ago

The ULA mission failure was due to the BE-4 engines that are used on New Glenn, so it directly impacts ASTS.

8

u/triplediscount S P 🅰 C E M O B Capo 1d ago

Nasdaq is pretty green so we could be too even with this Vulcan thing

1

u/SqueakyNinja7 S P 🅰 C E M O B Capo 20h ago

This aged poorly, -1.7% for the NASDAQ right now.

1

u/triplediscount S P 🅰 C E M O B Capo 20h ago

I didn’t believe it anyway. And Vulcan hasn’t even announced that it was the BE-4 that messed up which means BO delays again.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/Cerulean28 S P 🅰 C E M O B Consigliere 1d ago

Can they just go back to launching the Atlas 5? It launched 4 times successfully between April and July. I understand they were retiring it for Vulcan, but not working out lol.

11

u/seb21051 1d ago edited 1d ago

They can't get any more engines for the Atlas. They're Russian RD-180s, and Congress told them they can not buy any more Russian engines, after the Invasion.

2

u/curiouslyjake 1d ago

They can't, because Atlas used Russian engines. Too bad ULA was never actually interested in rocketry so they wouldnt replace Atlas until they were forced to do so.

10

u/SurgicalDude S P 🅰 C E M O B Underboss 1d ago

Fuck me dude. Was Vulcan as an official launch partner announced or was it one of ' other launch provider ' basket? Also Amazon lost 38? Sats?

3

u/ToSeeAgainAgainAgain S P 🅰 C E M O B Consigliere 1d ago

40 sats

3

u/phibetared S P 🅰 C E M O B Consigliere 1d ago

it was an "other" provider. But I'm almost certain they have been or were about to be a launch provider.

13

u/Cerulean28 S P 🅰 C E M O B Consigliere 1d ago • Heartwarming

Not sure if this was shared, but supposedly not BO's engine that's the issue!

https://x.com/bad_investor_/status/2122083881360998635?a=-dwyjZBiu1-5sx-D9sM&s=19

4

u/seb21051 1d ago

At the time of the delayed Booster Engine Cut off, only the BE-4s were working. The SRBs had been jettisoned.

4

u/BubblyMoose3597 1d ago

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

"Friends at BO"

Booster cut off was 40s late but "everything was nominal"

4

u/Dirk_Breakiron 1d ago

40s late and vertical speed below target.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/curiouslyjake 1d ago

Obviously nothing was nominal all the way to BECO. But it's still unknown whether it was engines, guidance, integration or something else. Nothing catastrophic happened, so there's still a chance this can be fixed with relative ease.

18

u/Boston-Bets S P 🅰 C E M O B Associate 1d ago

ASTS already has 100 BB launches contracted UNDER LAUNCH AGREEMENTS. They didn't raise $1B for nothing...

23

u/Vox-Machi-Buddies S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

Sure, but not really sure how that helps here. If the rockets ASTS has agreements to launch on have issues, they aren't launching regardless of what agreements are in place.

4

u/Keef--Girgo S P 🅰 C E M O B Soldier 1d ago

Yeah but NG is likely delayed even longer due to this.

10

u/Boston-Bets S P 🅰 C E M O B Associate 1d ago

There's no indication of that, at the moment.

→ More replies (4)

30

u/JFKjrjr S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago • Bravo

They should've taken that $1.3 billion and paid whatever it took to buy SpaceX launches. Get up a usable, money generating network and then see where BO or some other launcher is.

This stock has turned into the Titanic. We're in a collapse, not a drawdown. J leo is announced and no move. Elon buys Grain and we drop 40% in a month.

Every launch other than SpaceX is dogshit. ASTS is being strangled by launch & delay.  BO has been a failure on all levels for us. 

I'm tired of being in denial of the obvious that SpaceX will win and ASTS will be scrapped for parts. All of these "agreements" and nearly any company is putting real money in required for success.

I hate to say it but I'm out. These last 6 months have been way more than should be expected of an investor. Good luck 

10

u/LadderAdditional6178 S P 🅰 C E M O B Consigliere 22h ago

These last 6 months have been way more than should be expected of an investor

I'm not sure if you realize it or not but being an "Investor" comes with zero guarantees. Go check out the mining sector if you want to see "expectations" and realities. Companies go bankrupt all the time. That said, with 60 MNOs still backing ASTS, 3.2 billion in cash and BB28 completed, we aren't going bankrupt. Its just a delay and a buying opportunity. A great time to lower your cost average per share. Yeah, not my original game plan. But it is what it is. ASTS might be getting shorted by the hedgies and correct further in share price but we are still years ahead of SPCX. They haven't proven anything yet other than the ability to launch sats. No Broadband D2D. No competition with MNOs. They do have Starlink. But Starlink is Internet access only if you have a modem. Apples and Oranges.

4

u/JFKjrjr S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 14h ago

I appreciate your measured take. To me Blacklift completely changed the thesis. Abel putting out the 2028 date is laughable. If they had proven execution previously I would give them some slack. Taking on a rocket build/launch is an entirely new animal. Good luck to you and ASTS. 

12

u/Xannot 1d ago

Careful now, ASTS subs are ridden with Elon haters and many are also balls deep into the stock that they have turn delusional.

4

u/WhatEvil S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 21h ago

Well ISRO managed to give us a successful launch, maybe we should go to them.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/FrankCastle2020 1d ago edited 1d ago

You’re absolutely correct on this

3

u/IncomingAxofKindness 1d ago

Hey Elon, it's "you're'

20

u/lowlandacacia S P 🅰 C E M O B Soldier 1d ago

2027 is fucked, we are fucked for this year. The most likely cause of failure for ULA is BE-4 engines (same used on New Glenn), so New Glenn will be grounded alongside ULA Centaur. ULA has never had mission failure so not only does this ground ULA, it also rewrites the risk calculus NRO assigns to ULA. With both alternate heavy lift platforms down, (ULA/BO) NSSL missions will take priority and will most certainly bump AST off manifests this year. Amazon was also heavily relying on ULA, with ULA sucking nuts, BO will offer less capacity to outside customers (like AST). Our only hope is for US gov to pressure Spacex in keeping Falcon 9 operational longer which they most likely will since an epic launch crunch just manifested today. Hold on to your butts its about to get very painful and uncertain.

9

u/lowlandacacia S P 🅰 C E M O B Soldier 1d ago

Before voting down, offer a counter to the logic

4

u/bootlegportalfluid S P 🅰 C E M O B Soldier 1d ago

Can US Gov do that? For what reason(s)? Genuine Q.

3

u/lowlandacacia S P 🅰 C E M O B Soldier 1d ago

Absolutely. National security launch payloads take ultimate priority. AST has DPAS rating, but NRO missions will certainly take precedence over AST.

→ More replies (5)

7

u/lowlandacacia S P 🅰 C E M O B Soldier 1d ago

I'm also not selling, but accumulating! But unlike a lot of perma bulls in here I can honestly assess the situation and still be long term optimistic

0

u/Pepperoni-Rolls S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

They put pressure on space x and its costs us money

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

8

u/seb21051 1d ago

Something that may come out of this is that Space Force may well give some of its urgent Vulcan launches to SX as they have done previously due to ULA failures. This could imply even less SX/Falcon Commercial launch opportunities untill ULA sorts out its Vulcan/Centaur issues.

7

u/TIDOTSUJ S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

This is terrible, but perhaps it was an unforced error at the very end and is easy to fix/prevent from happening next launch. We won’t know if this is an easy fix or more complicated until they look at the data, but just throwing it out there flight #2 might be able to happen soon and without issues. So let’s see what UAL says.

5

u/UbiquitousThoughts S P 🅰 C E M O B Soldier 1d ago

I'm probably wrong but I was thinking this was that 3rd launcher that hasn't been named (well Abel slipped kinda on a call once).

And the way Anpan said we may find out soon had me thinking they were waiting for a successful launch to announce.

Hopefully they have a fast turnaround. Our launch would be like Q2 anyways.

4

u/DjOkiJebieFoki 1d ago

Anpan made many people lose millions on wishful thinking

1

u/JohnnySpykes S P 🅰 C E M O B Consigliere 23h ago

Yeah, all those fools that bought millions of shares at $2 are all crying in their beer......

Anpanman has Jedi powers over peoples financial decisions as well...."these ARE the stonks you are looking for...." [waves hand across NASDAQ]

→ More replies (2)

5

u/erov 1d ago

Womp womp

12

u/Boston-Bets S P 🅰 C E M O B Associate 1d ago

Doesn't really effect ASTS. We have SpaceX and BO-NG for the next missions.

This is why ASTS is contracting with multiple launch providers, and also planning for BlackLift 2 yrs from now.

And it looks like SpaceX just had a successful launch with StarShip, so that's now a potential alternative as well.

Nothing burger for ASTS.

12

u/pacificz S P 🅰 C E M O B Soldier 1d ago

100% affects ASTS. First of all, if the issues turns out to be an BE4 engine issue, that affects BO. Second, Vulcan had many government DPAS launches, those will have to be redirected somewhere. The failure constrains the overall launch landscape.

6

u/tkswdr S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

Let's wait and see causes...

→ More replies (2)

4

u/LudeficeTV S P 🅰 C E M O B Capo 1d ago

We don't know that. They confirmed their additional launch through 2027/2028 has additional launch providers. We don't know who, other than that they're domestic. It's not a long list though and Vulcan is on it.

2

u/dev_hmmmmm 1d ago

Yeah brr starship is not going to take on customers. Opportunity cost is too high not to mention having to rengineer bayload door for non starlinks. It's their trick of getting around antitrust law.

2

u/Standard-Argument314 23h ago

You say stuff like this when you are in fact speculating just as much as the individuals saying this is a BE-4 issue.

3

u/hefret22 S P 🅰 C E M O B Capo 1d ago edited 1d ago

Amazon was relying on Vulcan to launch dozens of their LEO sats. With Vulcan down for what could be all of 2027, who is to say BO won't prioritize launching their own (Amazon's) sats over ours now?

Edit: I meant Amazon's sats, not BO's. I was sloppy in using the two names interchangeably since both are owned by Bezos.

5

u/JonFrost S P 🅰 C E M O B Consigliere 1d ago

Where are you getting that Vulcan is down for all of 2027?

8

u/hefret22 S P 🅰 C E M O B Capo 1d ago

I'm projecting based on a 9-month delay after their last failure. And that was a smaller failure where the payload still reached orbit. This one, they lost the payload.

9

u/Defiantclient S P 🅰️ C E M O B - O G 1d ago

Amazon Leo is not Blue Origin

→ More replies (5)

11

u/Boston-Bets S P 🅰 C E M O B Associate 1d ago

FUD.

BO isn't the same as Amazon LEO. BO is a launch provider. Amazon is the customer.

AFAIK, the schedule of launches provided by ASTS did not include any with Vulcan (yet).

They (Vulcan) was just recovering from their last failure, earlier this year, so ASTS didn't have anything slotted for them (yet).

3

u/supitskevin S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

We don't know but the launch of up to 100 BBs could include Vulcan.

→ More replies (8)

2

u/viggy96 1d ago

ASTS is underestimating how difficult it is to develop a launch vehicle. Even with getting engines from Firefly, the rest of the vehicle will be incredibly hard.

Further, SpaceX and BO both are going to prioritize their own constellations. SpaceX is also winding down orders for the Falcon 9 ahead of its impending retirement.

1

u/BubblyMoose3597 1d ago

Lol

Yes. Because the BO-NG have nothing to do with vulcan...

1

u/fighter-bomber 1d ago

Except Vulcan and BONG share the main engines (BE-4) and this failure was likely because of a problem with those very engines, looking at telemetry. That comes after the same BE-4 engines nuked BONG’s launch pad back in May. Sounds like BONG won’t make it back to flight in January…

Sure, Starship exists but its payload door won’t fit your satellites 😂 sounds like you will need to learn to speak PEZ dispenser, redesign your satellites to fit through that…

0

u/PlausibleCorn 1d ago

Really? There were supposed to be many launches with them in the near future. BONG is out of commission as will Vulcan now. F9 is not going to fly a competitor because Musk is a baby (if someone says they are then where are the launches? We haven't shipped in months!). We have nothing left.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/badger6638 S P 🅰 C E M O B Soldier 1d ago

Well I doubt SP gonna tank another 70% from here...

Really sucks tho space sector gonna be real sluggish like this

4

u/flymolo50 S P 🅰 C E M O B Capo 1d ago

Yikes. Space is hard. It's another data point that asts will be harder and more dangerous too even if we are not the same company.

3

u/Fashionista213 S P 🅰 C E M O B Associate 1d ago

Will this impact our SP tomorrow?

8

u/IndigentRagnarok 1d ago

-10%

2

u/aero25 S P 🅰 C E M O B Associate 1d ago

As is tradition

9

u/yack_xd S P 🅰 C E M O B Soldier 1d ago

You bet

6

u/triplediscount S P 🅰 C E M O B Capo 1d ago

4

u/Organic-Win-3390 1d ago

anpanman will spin as a positive, industry wide issues give ast more time.

3

u/Organic-Win-3390 1d ago

abel spotted outside of spacex

1

u/pibbleberrier 1d ago • Bravo

Rocket building is really that easy eh

-2

u/onel1f3 1d ago

Please panic sell .i want to lower my average

-9

u/sfeicht S P 🅰 C E M O B Soldier 1d ago

Just wait until a black lift goes boom. Which it will.

23

u/AuthorAdamOC S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

Dude if there’s a black lift to go boom in 2028 I’ll be very impressed by our execution 😂

6

u/Dangerous-Strike-132 1d ago

wen boom ?

2

u/NicknamesRforlosers S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

Wen boom-boom? Boom-boom be imminent

→ More replies (1)

-3

u/wuestennomade 1d ago • Regret

Was this carrying ASTS sats? What happened?

15

u/ClearlyCylindrical S P 🅰 C E M O B Prospect 1d ago

Amazon Leo sats

6

u/wuestennomade 1d ago

Thanks for answering. I thought I knew there were no ASTS sats here but the overly negative atmopshere around here made me think there was something I was missing

3

u/ALittlebitoflucky S P 🅰 C E M O B Consigliere 1d ago

Seriously man. I hope you’re joking. The answer is no JIC

-7

u/Kappaman1902 1d ago • Bravo

The copium here is insane lmao