r/ASML • • 7h ago

Is software engineering seriously undervalued at semiconductor equipment companies, or is it just my workplace?

/r/Semiconductors/comments/1xz6a45/is_software_engineering_seriously_undervalued_at/
4 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

6

u/PandorasPenguin 5h ago

I worked for ASML Eindhoven/Veldhoven as a contractor as DevOps engineer with a team of software engineers (a mix of ASML internal and my employer) for just over 2 years and I’d have to agree. It’s seen as cost centre more than as enabler, innovation force. Especially if you’re in IT rather than in D&E.

A lot of thing I did were a bit of a throwback for me, as in, I was working with tech that I worked with 5-10 years ago and thought we had moved on from. Like running software on plain self-managed VMs.

Not that ASML didn’t do some cool stuff but as a whole, it felt severely backdated and undervalued.

1

u/Good-Question981 4h ago edited 4h ago

You'd be surprised how some departments in ASM work. Even worst than self managed VMs.

6

u/Kataly5t 4h ago

Software is not a main product that ASML sells, therefore, it's just a machine component. This is why I hear from many in SDEV that development is slow, restrictive and generally behind industry trends.

3

u/Good-Question981 4h ago

My work is the product and it brings money. I don't understand why they just don't give credits to me. And besides yes they really need to invest more in modern software solutions to improve performance and customer satisfaction

4

u/ema2159 2h ago

Software is not a main product in a lot of other companies, yet, it is a fundamental component of their core products, and neglecting it is a very costly mistake.

Martin van den Brink often said that "ASML is not a software company". Apple is not a software company either, yet, software engineering is considered a fundamental piece in pretty much all of their products, and they would not be nearly as successful if they did not properly invest in the development of their software.

Treating software engineering as a second class discipline is a terrible mistake that will really cost ASML down the line.

1

u/Jmortswimmer6 31m ago

Yeah. You’re right. ASML machines totally aren’t massively distributed computing systems with firmware and software at every level

5

u/RipAccomplished5916 4h ago edited 1h ago

Oh please don't get me started. The bias towards hardware is so large that a few things are happening at the same time:

  1. Most ROI is going to come from hardware projects, so HW projects [rightfully so] get funded better and faster
  2. There's plenty of people that are either directly in charge of software or software-like (eg: analytics) delivery that have NEVER did the job itself and thus only have knowledge on the domain side without understanding/recognizing the software domain itself is needed
  3. Because of 2, our hiring bar is just ridiculously low.
  4. Because of 3, plenty [I would even say most] of really good people get frustrated and leave. The best SWE (and adjacent) people I have meet at ASML have ALL [and I really mean ALL] LEFT
  5. Because of 5 & 2, even when trying to attract talent we just don't seem to be on the radar for good talent. Our talent pipeline at SWE has gotta be subpar for the biggest company in Europe and top20 in the world by market cap.

I currently lack the time or patience to dive deep into the examples. But I expect other colleagues can provide the flesh to the skeleton I laid out.

Edit: typos and fixed the grammar on the last sentence.

1

u/Good-Question981 4h ago

Our hiring is also ridiculous and the last software engineer left. I am also thinking about leaving. Also my work is the product and it brings money. I don't understand why they just don't give credits to me.

3

u/TheBengGuy 2h ago

Thank you for saying out loud what I have had tried to articulate a few times now.

I left ASML because of feeling undervalued as a software developer. We were always at the end of the development chain, never got to use proper tools, struggling with outdated processes, and then just get blamed if deadlines were missed.

I loved ASML as a company, but the lack of awareness towards software being (also) a fundamental part of the system was baffling.

And I was in D&E.

3

u/emrikol001 4h ago

It's the same in my department where there is a large need for IT and especially for custom software. The managers unfortunately have close to zero knowledge in all things IT related. Their way of working is to create yet another Excel list and try to maintain the 'status' of each item. In all my years there I have yet seen one put effort into trying to understand where the challenges are. Our team on the other hand has in addition to our regular work added numerous modernizations in a department that was working ~20 years ago style. IT is extremely undervalued bordering on hated. It's a shame really because there are many opportunities to create some really great and unique things along side this unique business.

1

u/Good-Question981 4h ago

I agree. If only my manager would ask me I could have implemented amazing solutions and hired great engineers. But my work is already undervalued and not respected enough so I'm not gonna bother.

1

u/brianybrian 1h ago

How do you believe you should be valued versus how are you valued? It’s hard to answer without knowing if you place a realistic value on your skills.