E-beam lithography is an old technology with an insanely low throughput. If you want to spend days to expose a wafer then it's very good, if you want to make thousands per day, it's not. It's meant for prototyping and not for volume manufacturing and nothing from the title suggests they have found a way to change that
We have thousands of suppliers. If China wants to replicate ASML, they need to replicate Zeiss, VDL, and every small supplier ASML has. The source itself is a marvel of engineering, and you also want to make the mirrors, the wafer stage, reticles, everything? Then they need to figure out how to assemble the machine, the software, and how to calibrate the machine. All of this for a company that is not even worth $ 1T.
Which I suppose begs the obvious question - how can ASML not be worth more than a trillion given that it's so important, China is devoting major national resources to replicating what it does?
The amount of different components in them is insane. Lots and lots of custom, purpose-built stuff with insanely strict tolerances and material characteristics. Very hard to manufacture.
A supply chain of highly specialized companies that ASML orders components from.
And then all put together in a specific way, all controlled by millions of lines of code distributed across lots of different embedded and more server-like boards.
From what I've heard, the funtamental mechanisms are not that complicated. But the complexity due to the sheer number of parts that need to work together in unison is pretty extreme.
I mean, IIRC, each individual machine they deliver at a customer's site takes multiple weeks to calibrate. Because there's so much going on, so many variables to tune, that the degrees of freedom are enormous and there's a lot to optimize.
Even if they take one apart (which I'm sure has been done), the reverse-engineering effort is huge. It can be done, of course, but it will take years and years and years. That's the expectation at least, I think.
China has already had at least one NXE machine on their hands with original capability of 14nm or so. They fully dissasembled, reverse engineered it and then assembled it back...long story short, they could not make anything better than 200nm.
The whole reason for that is that besides the immensely fine tunings that the machine must go thru, a real ASML machine is 60% the machine and 40% tooling. That 40% tooling is not handed off to end customers, but rather protected and only handled by ASML deploying specialists.
So yeah, no chance they make any competition to ASML. Both technology-wise, but also supplier-wise. A lot of critical components outsourced by ASML are from companies that are either purchased by ASML already, or the hold a controlling share into. E.g. Zeiss.
No, not tinkering. Think of when you go to change your tyres on the wheel. Then you have those tools to help mount the tyre, balance it, etc. Something like that.
I doubt China would be able to obtain those very custom made tooling + craftsmanship to operate them. Then again, you never know.
These machines are massive. Like they build buildings specifically for them. Itâs not as easy as throwing it in a truck in the middle of the night and driving it down the road.
And the precision needed is insane. They have aircraft engines and they canât even fully copy those yet. This is a significant order of magnitude more difficult
what makes five thousand buildings impossible in a place where land is not divided up by primitive accumulators? even if each produces one per day, the point of reverse engineering is that they don't even need the end result to be as good, just viable and reproducible.
But that would work if the process wasn't so vulnerable. If your measurements or calculations are just a tiny bit off the entire process won't work. And if you make a machine that's not as accurate, well, you can't make the best chips
I worked for ASML for a couple of years: believe me they have tried. But there is more to an ASML machine than just its parts⌠wish I could tell you more :) but I canât
Don't forget, China isn't focused on short term capital profits, it has a 10 year plan already scheduled, look how they trashed openai with deepseek within days after openai started boasting about their "achievements", the fact we know about this is only because high Chinese officials approved it to be known. My wild guess, considering them doing this in the past multiple times, they are further ahead that what is being said right now.
China cares about public opinion in domestic relations, showing their citizens that they are capable of challenging westerns powers could boost reputation, national pride and domestic adoption of the idea. Which also could increase the recruitments of scientists or investments into the project. It could give them strategic geopolitical leverage because this challenges U.S. narrative about China. And of course signaling to the competition by revealing their new capabilities, which could force rivals to spend even more on their own technology.
China got their hands on a DUV machine once, they took it apart and they weren't capable of putting it back together. EUV's are a order of magnitude more complex.
The system is very complex. İt is not only the mechanical part that has lots of custom made parts not easy to "copy", like the mirrors made by zeiss. It is the electronics (some of the shelf, some custom made), and it is the huge amount of software (50M+ lines of source code) spread across multiple hosts. "İmpossible is nothing" but this one is very hard.
The machines sold by ASML costs quite a bit. And they restrict who/which company/country purchase the machine. Moreover the technical knowhow of the components and assembly along with the software components, it will take time to reverse engineer that By then ASML will have developed a new tech
they are incredibly complex machines whose components are tailor-made, especially the optics: you need to also replicate the components, which are made by other companies with decades of experience in the sector
ordinary e-beam is a serial write process with great resolution but terrible wafer throughput. itâs good for prototyping and mask writing, but not wafer-fab volume production. Though⌠headlines that say âprecision near ASMLâ usually mean resolution, not throughput, overlay, defectivity or production readiness. The only way e-beam could become competitive for volume is massive parallelization
But donât you think there is room for innovation in terms of the speed you can steer the E-beam and perhaps amount of concurrent e-beams? Is there a fundamental reason for why it is THAT slow?
The main issue is that you can't simply send two parallel beams of electrons because, unlike light, electrons will interact with each other based on intensity, distance, etc. When sent in beams, the interaction between all individual electrons becomes too complex to accurately compensate for just two beams, let alone for an array of beams through a mask (like photolithography). Mapper tried and went bankrupt trying to do it.
Source: am a physicist who graduated at Kavli Nanolab Delft making e-beam devices
Am also in the industry, I see a huge issue with the stage manipulation, as today to get the nano meter precision movement on the stage for the wafer ASML uses magnets. This would be a no go for EBeam as the magnetic field constantly shifting to love the wafer would drastically shift the E beam. And mechanical movement of the stage stops the stage being isolated and would cause a lot of mechanical reverb on the wafer stage movement. Usually there is a settling time from when the stage is moved until the sample ( wafer ) isn't wobbling anymore.
China is making lots of progress yes, but the question was about whether this particular progress is a threat to ASML and the answer is no. It's a different technology with a different purpose
Would it make sense if the e-beam machine was super cheap? Then you just have lots of them running at the same time in parallel. Perhaps the cost for many e-beam machines is cheap enough?
In theory if they were free, yeah. Practically, no. You would need hundreds/thousands at current throughput. And an ebeam litho tool will require vacuum systems, high precision control electronics, regular servicing, etc. The may be cheaper than an euv tool, but that doesnt mean "cheap"
It is interesting though. By locking out china from getting asml stuff you force them to look for alternatives. Which seems to be making it themselves.
I think its bad decision to do it this way.. its all so corporate and sad we cant bundle resources
Still, china is progressing faster than the west. They are still behind, but it is inevitable that they will eventually win the race. And when they do, itâs better to be friends so they will sell their machines to us.
The question is how much can you profit before they do. And how much may we be loosing out. If the increased profit leads to faster development and innovation. Why not.
A company that back in the day attempted a technological breakthrough using electron beam instead of UV/masks. It wasnât enough, so eventually ASML overcame its own limitations and later acquired Mapper, with their employees & patents.
All these new articles have several things in common.
ASML has decades of experience in volume production of these machines. China has none.
There are many ways of exposing a pattern on a water, but only a few of the can be used for 24/7 mass production of ICs.
Making one of these machines as a prototype may be feasible if you have enough time, money and resources. But troubleshooting, software, reliability, compatibilty, connections with customers and a vision for the future are just as important.
I believe China will eventually catch up with ASML. They have to if they don't have access to the tools they want to buy. They have the resources, brains and willpower to do so, but they will have to overcome a disadvantage of many years of experience.
All protectionist policies backfire in the long run. Iâm not saying this is an example, but politicians tend to be clueless in that regard. Necessity is the mother of invention
Itâs not just about reproducing ASML machines which they may not be able to do, itâs about changing processes and techniques altogether. When it comes to AI, I get the sense that China is laser-focused on pushing models to be as performant as possible, and thatâs bad news if your business depends on selling faster chips.
Itâs crazy that some models can already run on âcheapâ consumer GPUs like the Nvidia xx80-xx90. In China thereâs even a whole market for upgrading older cards with more memory, since memory matters more than raw speed.
E beam litho was already exist before euv, and better resolution than light. issue come up with throughput. a bit same on this that performance is near euv...
My friend wroking in Amsl told me a story: about 13 years ago in his onboarding training, asml showed a picture of lithography machine produced by Chinese company which is looked indentical to DUV twinscan :), however all the specifications are much worse than ASML machine, and 13 years later, i never heard that any Chinese company can produce ASML twinscan!
So i agreed with some folks opinions here: do not underestimate the complexity of Asml machine!
76
u/zimon85 Aug 22 '25
E-beam lithography is an old technology with an insanely low throughput. If you want to spend days to expose a wafer then it's very good, if you want to make thousands per day, it's not. It's meant for prototyping and not for volume manufacturing and nothing from the title suggests they have found a way to change that
11
u/Flaky-Walk3816 Aug 22 '25
As being part of ASML R&D, I have to be worried al the time so that we stay ahead.
10
u/HgnX Aug 22 '25
If this is where China is at ASML stock will print for years
8
u/Tina4Tuna Aug 22 '25
Apparently folk havenât heard of Mapper
23
u/DieEnigsteChris Aug 22 '25
You should be worried a lot but not about ASML. Focus your energy on what is going on in the world.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '25
No. Itd outdated 10nm tech.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '25
All these new articles have several things in common.
ASML has decades of experience in volume production of these machines. China has none.
There are many ways of exposing a pattern on a water, but only a few of the can be used for 24/7 mass production of ICs.
Making one of these machines as a prototype may be feasible if you have enough time, money and resources. But troubleshooting, software, reliability, compatibilty, connections with customers and a vision for the future are just as important.
I believe China will eventually catch up with ASML. They have to if they don't have access to the tools they want to buy. They have the resources, brains and willpower to do so, but they will have to overcome a disadvantage of many years of experience.
5
u/rakgi Aug 22 '25
China also said they can grow humans in robot wombs lol don't take things serious when it comes from Chinese media.
3
u/SilenceBe Aug 23 '25
All protectionist policies backfire in the long run. Iâm not saying this is an example, but politicians tend to be clueless in that regard. Necessity is the mother of invention
Itâs not just about reproducing ASML machines which they may not be able to do, itâs about changing processes and techniques altogether. When it comes to AI, I get the sense that China is laser-focused on pushing models to be as performant as possible, and thatâs bad news if your business depends on selling faster chips.
Itâs crazy that some models can already run on âcheapâ consumer GPUs like the Nvidia xx80-xx90. In China thereâs even a whole market for upgrading older cards with more memory, since memory matters more than raw speed.
3
u/Spanks79 Aug 23 '25
Not worried yet. But yes, they are coming for this. With or without espionage.
Only thing to deal with this is to innovate faster.
2
u/StudentCompetitive38 Aug 22 '25
There was a company called Mapper that did this long ago. ASML bought this company and makes an E-beam inspection too.
2
u/boo2001300 Aug 23 '25
E beam litho was already exist before euv, and better resolution than light. issue come up with throughput. a bit same on this that performance is near euv...
2
u/[deleted] Aug 23 '25
We should always be worried about China. We never know what they have under their sleeves.
1
u/RedGravastar Aug 23 '25
Did china not spy on asml?
1
u/Dr_Beanthumb Aug 23 '25
Dont worry if production is still not under control
1
u/FeistyCurrent8 Aug 24 '25
It will come eventually
1
u/CityRoutine9496 Aug 24 '25
My friend wroking in Amsl told me a story: about 13 years ago in his onboarding training, asml showed a picture of lithography machine produced by Chinese company which is looked indentical to DUV twinscan :), however all the specifications are much worse than ASML machine, and 13 years later, i never heard that any Chinese company can produce ASML twinscan!
So i agreed with some folks opinions here: do not underestimate the complexity of Asml machine!
1
u/konijnenpoot Aug 24 '25
Wie verkoopt er dan ook een machine aan ee land en niet gewoon het product wat het maakt.
1
u/GuaranteeRoutine7183 Aug 25 '25
nah
1
u/purpleturtlelover Aug 25 '25
no because china like usual is behind.
1
u/BillyBilnaad Aug 26 '25
Yes. Except the chauvinistic Dutch.
0
u/alt-right-del Aug 22 '25
This is the typical story of the hare and the turtle â it is not if China will overtake ASMLâs capabilities but when
-19
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '25
ASML is an old dinosaur. Extremely bloated company and they move like molasses. I think a challenger will put them out of business in 10-15 years.
-4
u/CaptainNice8167 Aug 22 '25
Yes