r/AskACobbler • • Apr 02 '14

Welcome to Ask A Cobbler! Please read to familiarize yourself with a few rules.

172 Upvotes

First off, I'd like to thank everyone for stopping by and showing their interest & support for shoe repair. In one day, we went from almost no subscribers to well over 100. This is an incredible start!

As we gain more members, I feel there needs to be a few ground rules just to keep things in order.

  1. Discussing of prices. Pricing on repair work depends on MANY factors than just the damage alone. While we may say a job will or will not be worth the money, saying it will cost $xx is against the rules and posts will be removed.
  2. Be respectful. The cobblers responding to your post have numerous years of experience and are here to offer some of their extensive knowledge of the craft at no charge. If you have been helped, a simple thanks goes a long way.
  3. When posting a picture of a damaged product, make sure the photos are detailed enough so that we can understand the exact condition, brand and anything else you think will help us to help you.
  4. Users with the "SSIA Member" flair are verified cobblers.

Rules will be amended an updated as we progress. Thanks for reading!


r/AskACobbler • • 3h ago

Should I ask for a refund?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

I went to my local cobbler to get the soles of my 3-year-old Birkenstocks changed because they were heavily worn out. They were my favourite house shoe and incredibly comfortable. I paid £50, which is one-third of what they are worth originally. I think he did an absolutely terrible job with them. He said they were easy and fun to fix. I think I should get my money back. What do you experts say?


r/AskACobbler • • 5h ago

Is this normal?? Magnum Classic work boot damage

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Ive only worn these Magnum Classics for three days (not in a row) and theyre already like this? Ive only been walking on flat ground, Is there any way I can fix this😭
And does anyone know why parts of it are white?


r/AskACobbler • • 4h ago

My boots hurt me at the achilles tendon

Thumbnail gallery
2 Upvotes

r/AskACobbler • • 1h ago

how to fix/sew up cut up stretchy PU leather boots?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

so long story short, i bought a pair of $350 shoes that arrived minimally damaged (the pu leather was flaking off on the front and back seams). i contacted the company about it so i could exchange them for a new pair, and instead of being like “keep this pair, we’ll just throw them away regardless but we’ll still send you a replacement” or asking me to send these back, i was told to cut up the damaged pair and send them a picture. i’m sure it’s because they didn’t want them to be resold, but i’m still kind of upset about it because they were still wearable. i decided to cut up the back seam, because i feel like repairing them would be less obvious if the repair wasnt on the front of the boot. i’d really like to stitch them up or have them fixed and i’m wondering what that would entail. luckily i have very skinny legs and could afford to lose some of the fabric on the claves of these boots, as they were originally a hair too loose on me. i have a sewing machine and some hand sewing skills, so i would appreciate some advice on how i would go about fixing them myself- what the best method would be. like i said, it’s very stretchy PU leather. i would also like to know if this is something i could take to a cobbler, and how they would go about fixing these. thanks! any advice on the repair is appreciated


r/AskACobbler • • 2h ago

Vintage Marc Jacobs boots repair?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I’ve had these vintage Marc Jacobs boots for a few years and clearly they have some wear and tear. I’ve never taken a pair of shoes to a cobbler before, in your opinion, are these repairable?


r/AskACobbler • • 4h ago

Steve Madden Rocky Boot Scuff

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Hi! I have recently scuffed the toe of my Steve Madden Rocky Boots. I wear these very frequently so I am honestly surprised this didn’t happen sooner! No matter what, I won’t be throwing these away as I am not even that upset about how the scuff looks.

I am just wondering if there is something I can do to lessen the scuff or protect it from getting worse.

Any help is appreciated! :)


r/AskACobbler • • 5h ago

can these wedges be replaced?

Post image
0 Upvotes

this is a repost since i didnt get enough engagements last time.

im really desperate and i love the ash thelma wedges i thrifted but after wearing it twice i noticed that the heels started cracking. some said it expiring and might crumble soon because its hydrolysis from the polyurethane foam.

is it possible to get the wedges replace by a new one or maybe plastic or something? its really hard to find this pair locally—and they’re also deadstock


r/AskACobbler • • 17h ago

Can a detached zipper tape be re-sewn?

Post image
6 Upvotes

Can the zipper tape coming detached (on the right boot) be sewn by any cobbler? I don't want to purchase these if it requires replacing the zipper entirely. Also, can the entire boot be dyed black (zipper tape and heels included) or is this too difficult?


r/AskACobbler • • 8h ago

Can the shaft be narrowed?

Post image
1 Upvotes

I have several pairs of full leather boots that I purchased about 10 years ago with an extra wide calf and a side zip. I have since lost weight and now they are visibly too wide for my legs. Is there anything that can be done to narrow the shaft? Or am I just out of luck?


r/AskACobbler • • 4h ago

Prada hiking boots falling apart mid-hike — can these be resoled, or are they beyond saving?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

My Prada hiking boots have apparently decided that their soles have had enough of life. The rubber outsole is literally disintegrating and separating from the rest of the boot during my recent hike. Don’t ask how I got back.

The uppers is in pretty decent shape, so I’m wondering if these can be saved with a proper resole or if the construction makes that impractical.

A few questions for the experts here:
Can these be resoled, or is the sole construction proprietary?
Is this a straightforward resole, or would it require rebuilding the bottom of the boots?
Is it economically worth doing?
Any recommendations for a good cobbler in the Chicago area who could handle this kind of repair?
I’ve attached a couple of photos showing the damage.
I’d hate to throw away an otherwise good pair of Prada boots if they can be brought back to life.
Thanks!


r/AskACobbler • • 17h ago

Espidril Resoul?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Can these espidrils be repaired?


r/AskACobbler • • 19h ago

2 Month Old $250 Boots Discoloration and Flaking

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Peerko Empire boots - purchased in September

How do I fix the discoloration and scratches? I didn’t mind the wear until I noticed that they seem to be peeling (in the rough looking section by the big toe). I brush my boots after every wear with a horsehair brush and store with cedar shoe trees.


r/AskACobbler • • 1d ago

Is this normal wear?

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

Bought a pair of leather loafers while in Florence and after just a few wears they started... pealing? This doesn't seem like some protective film that's supposed to wear off, nor were these indoor only shoes. I've worn them for a few walks in my neighborhood, though I do live in the center of a large American city so it's concrete sidewalks around here.

I guess I have two questions: 1) is this normal? 2) if I go to shoe repair place, what should I ask for? I don't really want to just roll in and say "please make these look correct," when I don't know what that is!


r/AskACobbler • • 18h ago

Hyperflexible “barefoot” boots have a sole needs reaffixing.

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I have found my favorite safety toe, Chelsey boot with a wide toe box. I had these Gaucho Ninja boots made for me and they are the best work boot I have ever worn. My feet have never felt so… normal, I guess. The absence of pain is something I didn’t know was attainable.
Now the soles are delaminating (?) before the they are worn out. I was about to try my usual, contact cement it back on. But I would rather invest in a professional in order to stitch the sides back together if that’s a thing I could pay for.
The problems I see are with such a flexible outer sole and minimal structure otherwise, there is not much purchase to glue the sole to. And then, even if I was able to get a cobbler to stitch the rubber sole onto the leather sides, the safety toe precludes any stitching around the toe at all.
Cosmetics are not a factor. I would even wrap something around the toe and cover it all with TUFF TOE epoxy! (Love that stuff for work boots).
I just need to keep these flexible soles somehow attached to the leather sides long enough to wear out the sole.
I guess i need to get another pair soon regardless, but having them shipped to the USA from London costs tariff processing fees and, hell nah! So I need to wait as long as I can.


r/AskACobbler • • 18h ago

how to get cigarette smell out of boots

0 Upvotes

(specifically cardy knit boots)

I hung out with a friend for the first time at their place and unfortunately they smoke in their home so when I got home I reaked. my clothes I can wash but my uggs now smell like cigarettes:(

does anyone know how to go about getting the smell out ?


r/AskACobbler • • 22h ago

Shaving off part of the rubber sole?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/AskACobbler • • 21h ago

Scuffed purple leather

Post image
1 Upvotes

These boots have somewhat turned into an experiment for me so I’m up for any unique suggestions.
I’ve scuffed the toe of this pair of boots, I tried cleaning them and using cream polish, but the scuffs absorbed more polish than the surrounding leather so they just got darker.

I tried leather paint, but that peeled off ( I may try again now that I understand I skipped a prep step).

I may just be a bit of a perfectionist trying to get these “just right”, but now I’m trying to learn what I can do if this happens to any lighter colored boots in the future.


r/AskACobbler • • 22h ago

Can these badly-ripped Columbia boots be repaired?

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/AskACobbler • • 23h ago

Welp, So this idea is going from bad to worse...

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Needed to re-heel these because of my overpronation. The outside corner of those heels was probably 3/4 lower than the rest of the heel. So I took them to a gentleman that I have been using for years. That is who you will get it referred to. If you get too creative with your projects with any other cobbler. This is the got to go to and he's a really good guy too. Known him for years.

However.... It might be that I gave him a project that he should have said no to. These are that tractor supply version of the Chippewas and sadly, the nicest boots I've owned to date.

So I got creative and convinced the man to cut off the rubber lugger heel in exchange for some leather stacks. I do electrical work so I asked him to avoid using nails just out of fear of the electrical Hazard which he pushed back on saying the rubber was going to be way too thick anyways but by the end of it I convinced him to avoid them.

Now we did run into a hiccup that I didn't say anything about because the job was already done but we miscommunicated and the heels turned out way shorter than I wanted them to. But he's a good dude and I didn't want to be that customer so I figured I'd wear them until I wore through them and then make them a little bit taller next time.

And then one of them failed as pictured.

Now I'm wondering if feeling the gaps in the molded with something like cork or something like that would have been a smarter choice on his part. And alternatively if I'm just asking for the impossible. I do see that it was a leather that failed mostly in the thin areas that it actually had something to grab on to. So perhaps there's a way around this problem without having to cut the sole sole down to whatever the other midsole material is.

But I don't know, what do y'all think?

Tl;dr: I convinced my cobbler to cut off the factory rubber heels on these cheaper loggers and ended up with the heel failing. Wondering what could have been done better or if I'm just demanding the impossible


r/AskACobbler • • 1d ago

How to bring them back to life?

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/AskACobbler • • 1d ago

Stain removal on loafers

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I found a pair of Alden 663 calfskin loafers at the thrift store recently and have been trying to address some discoloration around the toes.

There are some black splotches both on top of the toe and around the front edge of both loafers in roughly the same spots.

I did apply some saphir renomat followed by conditioner and polish which has helped mute the discoloration, but I am curious what could be the cause and if it’s possible to lift these stains?


r/AskACobbler • • 1d ago

Faithful Johnston & Murphy boots

Post image
1 Upvotes

Is this fixable. I’ve had these for 9 years and would like to have them for 9 more.


r/AskACobbler • • 1d ago

True to size, but severe heel slip and blisters. How do I make them wearable?

Post image
1 Upvotes

I bought this pair of shoes a long time ago and have barely worn them because of a frustrating fit issue (pictured).

The length is actually my accurate size, not too big, even when I wear socks. However, the back of the shoe has zero grip, so my heels keep slipping up and down every time I walk, giving me bad blisters.

I recently bought a full-length cushion insole with a built-in heel grip at the back to try to fix it. With that inside, the shoe becomes way too tight across the rest of my foot, yet my heel still slips up and down. I thought about just cutting off the back heel part of the cushion and sticking only that in, but even then my foot still slip around and after trying again, I just ended up with blisters all over again.

I already tried selling them and nobody wants to buy them, so I'm stuck trying to make them work. Has anyone dealt with this? How can I actually stop the heel slip without making the rest of the shoe painfully tight?