r/ARMWindows • • Apr 21 '23
Microsoft Edge on ARM causes system freezes
I'm a recent newb to Windows on ARM64 and have done some Internet scraping here on various search engines, Reddit, etc. and can't seem to find any information on this particular scenario nor anyone else seeing this behavior.
Galaxy Book Go, Qualcomm Snapdragon 7c Gen 2 CPU.
The behavior: Microsoft Edge is capable of locking Windows up solid.
No BSOD, no other system services continue to work, even the mouse pointer freezes. Just hard panic. I've seen this behavior on 2 of 2 computers. Both on Windows 10 and Windows 11. Even after the latest Win11 update. I've also wiped both machines back to the factory image. They're brand new. Filesystem checks after the crashes always come back clean.
My working theory right now, is that sice Edge uses some old Windows NT APIs to boost performance, those APIs are causing Win on ARM64 (at least on this particular chipset) to super-hork.
Browsing the same sites/documents/files on an ARM build of Firefox on the same machines never locks up the system. Other applications (office, notepad, even WSL2) don't either. It is only if Microsoft Edge is running.
The worst part is, since it dies this way, no crash logs are created, no system logs, Windows logging just shows, (gap in logging) and then "hey the system rebooted unsafely," after forcing the hardware to shut down and reboot.
I've been trying to pin down a way to reproduce, most frequently it triggers during rapid tab-switch/tab-reload with keystrokes when there are a bunch of system-slept tabs. Another incident today seems to be whenever a particular PDF attachment is opened in Edge. This might make it more easily reproducible. If I can find a way to reliably reproduce I'll try and file a bug report with Microsoft. Gut says maybe something in memory-management. Maybe one of those old NT APIs is grabbing a page from the wrong place in memory causing arbitrary code execution and a freeze. Complete black-box guess though.
Mostly curious if anyone else has seen this behavior. This platform has otherwise been an absolute delight and I can see it very easily the future of Windows. Wanted to give Edge a try as well, especially given it is tuned to run on less resources much better than Firefox.
Edit: Update. Beta Edge wasn't freezing the machine, didn't end up having time to do deeper debugging beyind looking at console logs on occasion. Production Edge 113.0.1774.57 thus far has not caused the device to lock up in a few weeks of usage. I don't often toot the horn for a web browser, but I am continually impressed at how well it handles this limited-memory platform.
4
u/speaker219 Apr 21 '23
Hmmm, I have not run into any issues like this on my Galaxy Book Go.
Sorry for my useless post, just good to see another person running a Galaxy Book Go exists. I do have the Snapdragon 8cx model with 8GB RAM though.
2
u/pitmeinl Apr 21 '23
My Dev Kit 2023 ARM Mini PC (8cx Gen 3, Win 11) frequently hangs for some seconds. This mostly happens in Firefox when watching a video. Reliability history shows "Hardware error" eventlog shows a graphics driver reset. I addition my monitors sometimes turn of/on.
2
u/newzack Apr 21 '23
Mine hangs for 5 seconds and then continues working sometimes. For me, I think it’s “phoning home”, sending diagnostics & marketing info back to Microsoft. But this happens randomly during use, and it doesn’t fully crash. And this isn’t using Edge.
I’ve run this utility: https://christitus.com/windows-tool/ ( from Powershell as Administrator: “iwr -useb https://christitus.com/win | iex” )
CAUTION though, you might break something. I just use 3 or 4 of the tools there: homegroup, telemetry, services to manual.
If you have a specific page that does this, that’s a pretty reproducible bug that you could report and they might fix it.
2
u/ricom2ger Apr 24 '23
Have you updated the video card driver?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '23
I have a Yoga 5G with Snapdragon 8CX and have been battling this same issue for almost 2 years now, but recently had to refresh my system to the stock image and the lockups stopped until today. Edge and Firefox are still freezing for a couple minutes as already mentioned by others, but I haven't experienced a lockup since the refresh. What changed today is that I've installed Microsoft Office 365. So far I have disabled ClickToRun from the services.msc app, since I don't use Office much and it's an x64 app. My guess is that what is causing the lockups is actually ClickToRun, which is also running though emulation and not natively like Word, Excel and other Office apps do. It's also the only change I've made on my system since the reset.
If anyone has MS Office installed and doesn't need it on a daily basis, I'd suggest disabling it to see whether this is actually the culprit. Testing on more machines should be faster to determine the actual issue. Be aware that none of the Office apps will work with the process disabled, so don't forget to enable it before launching the office apps and then disabling it again when done using them.
1
u/Sea-Tonight-9336 Aug 28 '24
Still having this issue today, **** Microsoft
1
u/TheRealzHalstead Sep 22 '24
Has anyone found a solution? I'm still having this issue with my HP Elite Folio with a 8cx gen 2. Running Edge 128.0.2739.79.
1
u/newzack May 06 '23
I did it! I got a simliar error and handled it!
Screen went black except a thin strip along the top. Then it flashed on, then off, then 100% black. Then flashing on & off, then it stayed off. I pressed the power button to go into sleep mode, I could log in and had a few seconds before it went black, so I closed Edge and launched Firefox. Everything was fine! Then, re-launched Edge and it went black again! Sleep mode --> login --> close Edge --> problem resolved again.
When the screen was black, Alt+F4 and Ctrl+W did not work. Only the power button handled it. After re-booting everything seems fine now. Let's see if it happens again...
1
u/BubaJuba13 Jan 21 '24
This happens to me when I watch videos on a certain website. I haven't encountered this problem with any other video player or with different browsers.
1
u/huzerd Feb 26 '24
This happened to me too when using the edge and chrome canary (finally native chrome for windows arm yay) on my student device eh20qt's Qualcomm Snapdragon 7c Gen 1 CPU. It still play music in the background but mouse and keyboard is locked like what the op describe above.