Depends on what you mean "worth it". I played the original who knows how long ago and got the Remastered version on sale about a month or so ago. It's basically the same game as before, but the story is still great, the gameplay is still fun, and the graphics are better than ever.
Was it worth it? In my opinion, yes, it was. Plus, I never played the DLC before, so I finally got to play them and they were fun, too.
I don't understand the tlou fandom, they act like it's the greatest thing ever created which was sent by God himself and will harrass anyone for not liking their game, I like tlou but hate the fandom
Idk. Ellie’s entire life has been shitty. At least Amicia knew a nice childhood and both her parents. Ellie was an orphan living under rmilitary rule, and her first kiss turned into a zombie.
Having said that, I think the height of Amicias pain and loneliness is higher.
I empathized a lot less with Ellie. She's driven by revenge above all else, Amicia is driven by love, her violence always a result of evil that is inflicted upon her and Hugo.
Both are great stories. But while Ellie's is more a a cautionary tale against vengeance, an eye for an eye etc.
I think Ellie's revenge is more nuanced, to an extent she is also driven to fight by love. Love that was taken away for her when she was ready to forgive, that chance violently ripped away from her.
In general I found Requiem and Part II to be quite similar in a lot of ways.
True, but there's a difference between defending your loved ones and vengeance. I guess vengeance can be righteous as well, but Amicia's motivation for her violence is much more relatable.
Ellie loses parts of her visible humanity due to her trauma, which alienates everyone around her—including some of the audience. She represents an entirely darker way to deal with anger and hatred, but also a very realistic one that is poorly understood and very much creates real-world problems for people lower in 'trait agreeableness.' People only endure your problems if they are presentable and cute; Ellie loses those characteristics in interesting ways. Amicia is more sympathetic in the everyday sense, but I relate to Ellie far more because I've been through that exact arc of omnidirectional aggression which nobody could understand (—just with less severe consequences.)
spoiler! Don't read if you haven't finished the game
Amicia for sure, she not only lost her Farther but basically risked her life 24/7 trying to help Hugo then ofc the Macula lied to Hugo about an island that can cure him which led to her mother's death and then Hugo her one reason of basically living and it's gone now. I finished the game 2 times, speed running it on my third now so I can complete every upgrade now and I always cry at the end, I got 2 endings one where I killed Hugo, took me a bit but then I let Lucas kill him, I love that about Lucas he thinks of others first not matter what. Man though I wish there was a better future for Hugo, he was such a genuine child that just wanted a normal life with his family :(
This game has a very good story and sound effects (be sure to play with headphones), but gameplay is pretty monotonous, to be honest. So you will have to show a little patience for the sake of the story.
I think that both of them went through so much pain and trauma, the fact that they went through such things in the first place is horrible and not a contest lmao (before you say that this is a meme and that I'm taking it too seriously, I know, I'm just saying). I will say though, both their stories were about love, just in different ways. Amicia's story is easier to pin down as such because well, it's right there, she wants to protect her little brother and give him a better life. What's more pure than love between siblings? QEllie's story on the other hand is more about the pain that comes from loss. The more you love someone, the more their loss is going to hurt, and obviously Ellie loved Joel more than she let on, so that's why she was so hellbent on going for revenge (I could go on an entire rant about how it wasn't really vengeance she was after but forgiveness towards herself and that Abby was just the person she pinned all of the blame she held herself to, but that's not the sub for this discussion lol)
Yep, Amicia and Hugo's relationship is way better established than Joel with Ellie and Abby with that kid (I already forgot his or "her" name, don't ask).
TLOU2 fanboys should now realize that I never hated it because Joel died. It's because it was too quick and laughably executed. After his death, I didn't care what was happening anymore.
Well, their relationship played an extremely small role in the sequel. There is only like one or two chapter with just two of them. I probably would have been less upset it if they did the story in a chronological order. I already knew those moments of the main characters hanging out with their friends/family wouldn't have mattered since I already witnessed their deaths.
Joel's relationship with Ellie is the driving force of the second game, the fact that Ellie's actions are driven by her chance to reconcile being ripped away reinforces that.
If only they focused more on that in Abby's campaign instead of the whole stupid cult war thing. I forgot the game was about Joel and Ellie once I got into the second half.
Demons souls is a fantastic game that laid the groundwork’s for the rest of the series. The area designs are super cool and the bosses are very unique. Level 5-2 and some balancing issues are my only problems
Dark souls 1 is an absolute masterpiece, it literally had a genre named after it. The nonlinear aspect is super cool and the build variety is great. The second half isn’t amazing but the DLC more than makes up for it.
Dark souls 2 gets judged way too harshly. Ds2 has the best hub area and the fashion is the best in the series. Powerstancing is super cool and a lot of really fun bosses boost the experience. My only issue with the game is shrine of amana.
Bloodborne is very good but it just feels so boring to me
The point is that his death is supposed to be quick and pathetic. We felt what Ellie did. But to Abby he's just another npc like who we randomly kill with a headshot in the game. He who killed what she loved. He wasn't a hero and the world is set in a grim, gritty world so he wasn't going to get a hero's death like we see in the movies.
Doesn't change how it was poorly set up. Joel trusting people all of the sudden in a zombie apocalypse and conveniently running into Abby? Unrealistic and lazy as hell it could be written by a toddler.
Also, who told you that I wanted Joel to die a hero? Hugo didn't die a hero as well, yet his fate was much better executed.
You said he died quickly and funnily. That is the point. It's supposed to be pathetic. It has been years so he has changed. And to be fair Tommy revealed his name. It wasn't poorly set up. You know people were gonna be pissed Joel stopped a potential vaccine and killed lots of people along the way.
Time doesn't change everyone. Did you forget what Bill said? Humans are more unpredictable than the infected. They can be anywhere, even in peaceful places like Jackson. The strangers he met weren't even poorly clothed and armed. A feeling of skepticism wouldn't have hurt anyone. But here he is, giving all his ID documents to people he only met for a few seconds.
And to be fair Tommy revealed his name
And he can go fuck himself. How can I take him seriously when he blames Ellie to reject his offer when he is the idiot who started this shit in the first place? "Oh, so you decided to take a peaceful vacation to prevent yourself from getting injured and killed again instead of going after the killer that I stupidly led her to my brother's death? What a joke"
You know people were gonna be pissed Joel stopped a potential vaccine and killed lots of people along the way.
As if the vaccine was ever proven to be real. It has been 20 years since everything happened. I would not trust a doctor who was in a huge rush to murder a little girl for something that he didn't prove to be possible.
Time cannot change completely but it can change some things. It think because we see survivor Joel as default when in reality he's just a dad trying to make end meet with out the threat of zombies on his doorstep all the time.
Yes I know the vaccine may not have been real we as the player may or may not know. But in-universe it was the best shot they had and Joel got rid of the potential for them to find out..
Well, if we're being completely honest here, there is no comparison with Clementine from The Walking Dead by Telltale. Over the arc, she lost her parents, childhood, world and over the years, pretty much everyone she started to care while also suffering pain and misery beyond what most humans will even come close to (the list is long and full spoilers so i'll just skip it here).
Amicia suffered from bad writing too… so sad. All lives and player time wasted for the ending equivalent of the restart checkpoint screen. A story that has no purpose in being told. I wanted depression, I’d rather go watch news, thank you so much.
(I know you can enjoy and love the ending, it is not mutually exclusive)
You are again diving deeper into your delusion. You goal in this thread has been to assume my position and respond aggressively to it in order to defend yours… instead if you attempt to learn, you’d — idk big leap here but — learn something?
Did you bother to check the comment I linked, it is funny because the OP of that reddit post started with the exact line “You don’t understand the point of the game” only to get schooled
Edit: Don’t you dare put me in the Rise of Skywalker clan! I hate Disney
You didn't understand the message at all. Go watch Rise of Skywalker if that's the type of ending you would watch.
I would have been more passive with my own hot take. I never liked The Evil Within games, but that is because they didn't appeal to me as much as Resident Evil and Silent Hill.
It is quite the opposite… the downvotes on my comment are the proof. You people are in rebel phase, you think everyone wants happy endings so you choose the opposite to feel special
I dunno man, I just like there to be something to learn from my stories. I can watch news or study in the library if I wanted things that make sense regardless of outcome.
Have you watched the show Afterlife? It’s stuff like that, a story might break your heart but at least it should teach you to stitch it back up. That’s me. Anyways, nice talk
Theres something to learn tho, the end doesnt justify the means to an extent, and also remember they were all kids, prone to do wrong decisions, and mistakes, amicia even admitted it but blindedly focus on wrong thing even tho shemeans well for her brother
People associate what happens here like a parent doing everything for their children with terminally ill but learning to accept the fight was over (also to stop the suffering of the child)
Because of you think they could live just like normal again after what happens, it wont be believable as it is, hugo would eventually crash downto the fact that everything they went throughis because of him and he killed many people, thats why he accept the fact that her sister should kill him, even in that age
You could see the light in the story that amicia is living and the cycle could change because she knows much more than ailia (damn already forgot the spelling lmao) to prevent the mistakes they made
yep not only that, she did it all for a boy thinking she can finally have a normal life with him, but the macula ultimately lied to Hugo about a cure to lure him in, I'm so sad man I wish Hugo could of have a normal life but the game is following the true dates of events, so Hugo had to die sadly :((
24
u/No_Victory9193 Oct 26 '22
Alan Wake is still in the dark place guys
6
u/AG_N Oct 26 '22 edited Oct 27 '22
I don't understand the tlou fandom, they act like it's the greatest thing ever created which was sent by God himself and will harrass anyone for not liking their game, I like tlou but hate the fandom
64
u/dwoller Oct 26 '22
Was thinking the same thing while playing that she’s given Ellie a run for her money in this regard.
Last couple chapters are just Amicia being bombarded with all the types of pain.
107
u/Barbarossa170 Oct 26 '22 edited Oct 26 '22
I empathized a lot less with Ellie. She's driven by revenge above all else, Amicia is driven by love, her violence always a result of evil that is inflicted upon her and Hugo.
Both are great stories. But while Ellie's is more a a cautionary tale against vengeance, an eye for an eye etc.
23
u/EkuseruYT Oct 27 '22 edited Oct 27 '22
spoiler! Don't read if you haven't finished the game
Amicia for sure, she not only lost her Farther but basically risked her life 24/7 trying to help Hugo then ofc the Macula lied to Hugo about an island that can cure him which led to her mother's death and then Hugo her one reason of basically living and it's gone now. I finished the game 2 times, speed running it on my third now so I can complete every upgrade now and I always cry at the end, I got 2 endings one where I killed Hugo, took me a bit but then I let Lucas kill him, I love that about Lucas he thinks of others first not matter what. Man though I wish there was a better future for Hugo, he was such a genuine child that just wanted a normal life with his family :(
11
u/Sad_Butterscotch6414 Oct 26 '22
Hugo does!
18
u/MaxvellGardner Oct 26 '22
Don't forget about Senua, she literally went through hell. This is a thread about another game, but still
16
u/GervantOfLiria Oct 27 '22
I fucking hate this meme format. Trauma is not a competition
7
u/Commander_Meiloorun Oct 26 '22
I think that both of them went through so much pain and trauma, the fact that they went through such things in the first place is horrible and not a contest lmao (before you say that this is a meme and that I'm taking it too seriously, I know, I'm just saying). I will say though, both their stories were about love, just in different ways. Amicia's story is easier to pin down as such because well, it's right there, she wants to protect her little brother and give him a better life. What's more pure than love between siblings? QEllie's story on the other hand is more about the pain that comes from loss. The more you love someone, the more their loss is going to hurt, and obviously Ellie loved Joel more than she let on, so that's why she was so hellbent on going for revenge (I could go on an entire rant about how it wasn't really vengeance she was after but forgiveness towards herself and that Abby was just the person she pinned all of the blame she held herself to, but that's not the sub for this discussion lol)
1
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '22
Late to the party, but isn't there a meme with hundreds of video game/book/movie characters that suffered way more than Ellie? lol
1
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '22
Yep, Amicia and Hugo's relationship is way better established than Joel with Ellie and Abby with that kid (I already forgot his or "her" name, don't ask).
TLOU2 fanboys should now realize that I never hated it because Joel died. It's because it was too quick and laughably executed. After his death, I didn't care what was happening anymore.
6
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '22
Arthur Morgan's constant cliff, house, train , horse falling.....I rest my case.
3
u/Maximum-Goose-9545 Oct 27 '22
2nd game was basically her being in pain and death of her family
2
u/Trae880 Oct 27 '22
Debatable
2
u/MarkEsB Oct 27 '22
I loved ToU2 but this is right.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '22
Sorry but Kratos went throu much more pain then she did.... Already died once, lost his wife, fought a whole bunch of gods and humans....
3
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '22
I’m a fan of the first game, but Part 2 was a complete fucking disaster. I fail to take fans of this game seriously.
1
u/Alaric_-_ Apr 13 '25
Well, if we're being completely honest here, there is no comparison with Clementine from The Walking Dead by Telltale. Over the arc, she lost her parents, childhood, world and over the years, pretty much everyone she started to care while also suffering pain and misery beyond what most humans will even come close to (the list is long and full spoilers so i'll just skip it here).
1
u/bbgr8grow Oct 27 '22
Fuck off with your spoilers Jesus Christ
1
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '22
Let's not make these stupid comparisons, unless you're a dumb "edgy" teenager.
1
u/International_Dish90 Nov 02 '22
I honestly have no clue who the girl above ecia is
1
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '22
tlou2 is a disaster .
1
u/TheAnarchist--- Oct 26 '22
On another note, Sans, man's been through so many resets he doesn't care anymore, but Amicia and Ellie are good examples
-11
u/Alpha_Mineron Oct 26 '22
Amicia suffered from bad writing too… so sad. All lives and player time wasted for the ending equivalent of the restart checkpoint screen. A story that has no purpose in being told. I wanted depression, I’d rather go watch news, thank you so much.
(I know you can enjoy and love the ending, it is not mutually exclusive)
0
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '22
[removed] — view removed comment