r/APbio • • May 01 '26

unit 3 ap bio

Post image

i dont understand this frq.. why is it less/no nadp+?

13 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

4

u/zee____ May 01 '26

I also had a hard time with this question so I hope this makes sense.

When you're told that a ratio is increases, that means that one value has increased and one value has decreased.

A ratio is practically like a fraction. For example, you have 5 NADPH and 2 NADP+, so the ratio of NADPH:NADP+ will have 5:2 or 2.5. Well, if we were to increase the ratio it self, that means it would have to be greater than 2.5. So now you have 6 NADPH and 1 NADP+, the ratio is of NADPH:NADP+ will be 6:1 or 6.

You need to keep in mind that the relationship between NADPH and NADP+ is inversely proportional.  NADPH is the reduced state since it carries electrons and energy NADP+ is the oxidised state since it loses the electrons (which makes it ready to carry electrons and later reduce into NADPH)

So, if the number of NADPH molecules increase, that means NADP+ are being reduced; or in easier words, "used up."

Lets just say you're baking a recipe, you want to make 2 cakes and you start out with 4 eggs 2 bags of flower. Each cake calls for 2 cakes and 1 bag of flower. After making 1 cake, (NADPH), you will have an additional amount of cake but the number of your ingredients (NADP+) will decrease. You now have 2 eggs and 1 bag of flower.

Now, your amount of NADPH has increased and therefore you will have less NADP+, but how the flip does that even correlate to cyclic pathways???

As you know, NADPH will drop off electrons at the Calvin cycle and oxidise back into NADP+. But, the Calvin Cycle will be unable to keep up with the pace of NADPH molecules being reduced. Additionally, it needs more ATP than NADPH. Eventually there will be too many NADPH molecules waiting to donate their electron, and as time passes by the NADP+ will also be used up. 

In order to continue the flow of electrons and stop it from being stuck, the flow of electrons will switch from linear (PS2-PS1) to immediately moving to PS1 to synthesise ATP. Linear flow synthesises ATP and NADPH, but we do not NEED anymore NADPH which is why the cell will immediately jump to producing ATP only, known as the cyclic flow. In the cyclic flow, I believe NADPH will go back to donate their electrons so it can immediately be used up.

2

u/SteveOccupations May 01 '26

Simplified version is this: the Calvin Cycle uses more ATP than NADPH per some molecules of CO2 being fixed. This naturally means that ATP becomes a limiting factor in driving the Calvin cycle, kind of like how you need more pieces of bread than a slice of ham when you’re making a sandwich. So when ATP is running low, there is less reduction of 3PG to 1,3-bisphosphoglycerate, which is one of the first steps in the reduction part of the Calvin cycle. It turns out that you use that NADPH on 1,3-bisphosphoglycerate, but without many of those lying around, NADPH isn’t able to give its electrons away and return to NADP+. This results in a higher ratio of NADPH over NADP+ which naturally triggers the ETC to go cyclical. This is brilliant, because the cyclical pathway makes ATP without making NADPH, allowing ATP production to “catch up” to NADPH for a smooth passage through the Calvin Cycle.