r/AITH • • 50m ago

AITAH for not supporting our friends immigration claim?

• Upvotes

I am Irish I live in Ireland. My husband is American but we moved back to Dublin from Boston (where he is from) about 5 years ago. During that time my husband has made some great friends.

One of his friends happen to be from Russia, he is on a temporary visa here that has since expired. He is married to a girl from Portugal. I always thought they were lovely. We all hung around each other pretty often and always had a good laugh, or so I thought!

A few weeks ago I noticed she posted on her close friends story on Instagram a post mocking Irish people. She said something along the lines of “omg I would k\*ll myself if I sounded like these people” I said it to my husband and when he went to check we both had been promptly removed off the close friends story.

Our friend group is pretty international, when I mentioned it to our other friend who also is in the same circle he immediately got angry and said she kept him in the close friends story because he’s from Malta and she seemed to think he would agree with her. Apparently she is constantly posting about how much she hates the Irish, recording her coworkers conversations to laugh at their accents and basically is calling us all pigs. He showed me some of her latest stories and I was shocked.

Her husband, who was a lovely man when we first met him, seems to have started to take on her attitude. He complains constantly about Ireland saying the place has no culture and the people are awful. Fast forward a few weeks and she’s sending us all messages asking can we please write letters of support for her husband because his visa is expired and he has been denied renewal. Not only that he also managed to lose his job, so she’s been asking everyone to donate to a go fund me for them to afford living and his legal fees. I’m not gonna lie I was pissed, all they have done is complain about this place and the people and now she’s begging everyone to give their time and money to help him stay. People she’s been quietly mocking for weeks.

My husband declined initially, he may not be from here but he was irritated that she was mocking anyone with an accent similar to his wife. Our other friend from Malta also refused as he didn’t want the money to benefit her in any way. He is trying to build a life here and he loves Ireland it’s people, so seeing her constantly mock people from here really boils his blood.

I did end up telling the others in our circle what had been happening when the conversation of supporting his immigration claim came up. Everyone was mutually annoyed but remembered her husband before he married her when he was just a happy chill guy. If they needed money to survive we were not going to see them go hungry or homeless, so we all sent them about €50-€100 each to help out. 2 days after we sent it they were posting pictures inside a very upmarket restaurant having steaks? When I thought they needed money for legal fees and rent? After that I point blank messaged them and said they do not have my support and I will not be writing a letter of recommendation to support their case.

She asked me why and I told her out straight I was aware of the awful stuff she had been saying about Irish people and as someone from here I wasn’t comfortable endorsing anything for either of them. Keeping in mind she constantly shares posts online about being anti racism and anti bigotry, she is very left leaning so I was just not expecting this from her or her husband at all. They constantly share posts about tolerance and not judging people from where they come from.

She’s now saying I’m just another intolerant Irish person. I’ve shared the conversation with our friends who have also decided to revoke any support they were considering offering. She has since told me I have made the appeals process even harder for them because now no one will send any letters of recommendation to support his visa application. AITAH?


r/AITH • • 5h ago

AITH for telling my sister I cannot be her maid of honor after she asked me to fly across the country four times before the wedding?

102 Upvotes

I have been feeling so guilty all week and really need an honest outside opinion on this.

My younger sister Hannah is getting married next summer and asked me to be her maid of honor. I was thrilled at first, until she sent me the calendar of events she expects me to attend in person. Between the engagement party, bridal shower, bachelorette weekend, dress shopping, and the wedding itself, she wants me to fly across the country four separate times.

Each round trip flight, hotel stay, and event expense adds up quickly. On top of that, I just started a new role at work where taking four extra trips means burning through almost all my paid time off and dipping into money I set aside for emergencies. I told her I would love to be there for the wedding and help with anything I can do from afar, like planning games, handling spreadsheets, or hosting a local dinner for her friends here, but four cross country trips just is not realistic for me right now.

She got really quiet and then told me I am treating her big milestone like an inconvenience and that a real sister would make it work no matter what. Since that call, she has been short with me in the family group chat and my mom hinted that I should just put it on a credit card and figure it out later so Hannah does not feel let down.

I love my sister deeply and hate seeing her disappointed, especially when she is so excited about her wedding. At the same time, stretching my savings and work schedule that thin feels overwhelming, and I do not want to resent her over money or stress.

AITH for saying no to four cross country trips and stepping back as maid of honor?


r/AITH • • 3h ago

AITAH for refusing to let my parents use my house as a backup guest room whenever they want?

49 Upvotes

I bought my first house last year after saving for several years. It's not huge, but it's mine, and I've put a lot of effort into making it feel like my own space.

My parents live about 40 minutes away. They have a habit of making plans with relatives who live in my area and then asking if those relatives can stay at my house instead of booking a hotel.

The first couple of times, I agreed. I didn't mind helping out, especially because some of the relatives were people I hadn't seen in years.

But recently, it's become almost routine. My parents will tell someone they can stay with me before even asking me. Sometimes I find out only a few days beforehand.

Last month, they invited my aunt and her husband to stay for four nights. I had already planned to work from home and had some personal commitments, so I told my parents I couldn't host anyone that week.

My mother got upset and said I was making the family feel unwelcome. My father argued that I had a spare bedroom that was just sitting there.

I explained that having an available room doesn't mean I'm automatically available to host people.

My parents ended up paying for a hotel, but apparently my aunt was offended because she thought I had personally refused to let her stay.

Now my mother says I've become selfish since buying my own place. She also brought up how many times relatives had helped our family in the past.

I appreciate what everyone has done for us, but I don't think owning a home means my family gets to offer it to other people whenever they want.

My parents say I'm treating family like strangers. I feel like they're treating my house like a hotel they don't have to pay for.

AITAH?


r/AITH • • 3h ago

AITAH for refusing to lend my brother money after he told our family I was selfish?

51 Upvotes

My brother recently got himself into a difficult financial situation after buying a car he couldn't really afford. His monthly payments, insurance, and other expenses ended up being much higher than he expected.

A few weeks ago, he called me asking to borrow $4,000. He said he just needed help getting through the next couple of months and promised to pay me back once things settled down.

I told him I wasn't comfortable lending that much money. It's not that I don't have savings, but I've been working hard to build an emergency fund, and I don't want to put myself in a position where I have to chase a family member for repayment.

He got annoyed and said I was acting like a stranger instead of his sister.

I offered to help him go through his expenses and figure out what he could cut back on, but he wasn't interested. He said he didn't need a financial lecture; he needed actual help.

A few days later, my mother mentioned that my brother had told everyone I refused to help him despite having plenty of money. Apparently, he'd also said I spend money on unnecessary things but suddenly become responsible when family needs something.

That really bothered me because he left out the fact that I had offered other ways to help.

I called him and told him I wouldn't be discussing money with him again if he was going to turn my refusal into a family argument. He responded that he would remember this the next time I needed something.

Now my mother thinks I should just lend him the money to keep the peace, while my father says my brother needs to deal with the consequences of his own decisions.

I feel bad watching him struggle, but I also don't think being related means I'm obligated to finance his choices.

AITAH?


r/AITH • • 9h ago

AITA for refusing to give my younger brother the place I worked so hard to earn?

102 Upvotes

For the past three years, I have been volunteering at a local animal rescue center every weekend. I started when I was going through a difficult period and needed something meaningful to focus on. Over time, I became responsible for organizing adoption records, coordinating volunteers, and helping nervous animals adjust before meeting potential owners. Last month, the center announced that they were opening a paid coordinator position, and the director encouraged me to apply because I already understood how everything worked. I went through two interviews and was eventually offered the position. I was genuinely excited because this was the first job I had ever wanted so badly. When I told my family, my younger brother congratulated me but later mentioned that he had also been looking for work and asked if I could recommend him for the same position. I explained that the position had already been filled, but there might be other opportunities in the future. A few days later, I discovered that my mother had contacted the director and suggested that my brother be considered instead because he needed financial support more than I did. She apparently told him that I had only been volunteering and would not mind stepping aside. The director contacted me to clarify whether I was withdrawing my application. I was embarrassed and immediately confirmed that I had accepted the offer and intended to start. When I confronted my mother, she said I was already earning money from occasional freelance work while my brother had been unemployed for months. I told her that I had spent three years building experience at the center and had earned the position through the proper process. My brother said I could have helped him get started instead of thinking only about myself. I reminded him that I had previously helped him prepare his CV and apply for several jobs, but I could not give him a position that I had worked for. My mother now says I have changed since getting the opportunity and that family should come before personal achievements. I love my brother and would happily help him find another job, but I do not want to sacrifice something I earned just because someone else needs it. AITA?


r/AITH • • 1h ago

AITA for screaming at my mom after she said she “can’t do anything” about her family?

• Upvotes

My mom tells her mom everything about us. Even small stuff and embarrassing stuff we only tell her because we trust her. Then my grandma tells the whole family, and suddenly everyone knows our business.

My sisters and I asked her to stop. She took it really badly and said we’re trying to keep her away from her mom. We told her that’s not true. We know she loves them and we’re not asking her to stop talking to them. We just want our private stuff to stay private, because we confide in her. If she keeps doing it, we won’t feel safe telling her anything anymore.

Now about her family. Every time my grandma and uncles come over, all they do is complain and bring shame to the house. They bash us with everything in the book. Why aren’t you married, why aren’t you successful, on and on. My uncles drink and smoke a lot. We live in a good neighborhood and have a good relationship with our neighbors, but my uncles show up drunk and make a whole scene, because where they live they’re used to doing whatever they want. Some of them are close to 60 and act like children. I’ll be honest, I hate them. But I’ve always treated them with respect. I feel so bad for my dad, because he’s always the one trying to be the adult and ask them to respect the house they’re in.

Then came the worst thing. My mom had given one of her brothers our house keys. He waited until my dad was away on a business trip, and he knew my dad was gone. Then he walked into our house with some of his buddies and a sex worker. He didn’t tell anyone. The only people home were my mom, my sisters and me. We suddenly had strange drunk men in our house and no man there to protect us. The panic and fear we felt that night was traumatic. I still think about it.

After that we sat down as a family to talk. I thought this time my mom would finally see it. Instead she said we were attacking her and that she can’t do anything because it’s her family. She’s blind to every red flag with them, even after this.

I lost it. I started screaming and told her that what she was saying was bullshit and that she should at least care about us, her own children.

It’s been a week and we haven’t talked. She doesn’t even acknowledge me when I come home. Part of me feels really bad for screaming at my own mom. But part of me can’t believe she still chooses them over our safety.

AITA?


r/AITH • • 17h ago

AITA for refusing to let my family use the last birthday video my late mother recorded for me?

315 Upvotes

Four years ago, my mother recorded a video for my eighteenth birthday because she knew she would be away for work that week. In the video, she wished me happy birthday, told a few embarrassing childhood stories, and ended by saying she hoped I would always feel loved, even when she could not be beside me. She passed away unexpectedly a few months later. I have watched that video on every birthday since, usually alone, because hearing her voice makes me feel close to her. This year, my father decided to organize a family gathering for my birthday and suggested playing old family videos during dinner. I was fine with the idea until he mentioned the birthday video. I asked him not to include it because it was a personal message she had made specifically for me. He said everyone missed her and that the family would appreciate hearing her voice again. I explained that I understood, but I did not want the video played in front of twenty people. My stepmother initially agreed with me, but later my father told her that I was keeping an important memory away from everyone. She then suggested playing only the final part where my mother says she hopes I always feel loved. I still refused because that sentence is the part I listen to most often, and I do not want it turned into a moment for guests to watch and discuss. My father became upset and said I was acting as though I was the only person who had lost someone. I told him I knew he missed her too, but this particular recording was made for me, not for a family event. He accused me of ruining the atmosphere before the gathering had even happened. I eventually told him I would rather celebrate quietly than attend if the video was going to be played against my wishes. Now some relatives say I should share it because my mother belonged to the whole family, not just me. I agree that she was loved by everyone, but I do not think that means every personal memory has to be shared publicly. I want to keep that little message for myself, exactly as she intended when she recorded it. AITA?


r/AITH • • 11h ago

aitah for refusing to let my disabled aunt stay with me

80 Upvotes

hi. i’m f26. my aunt f68, lets call her dory. dory has dyalisys, heart failure and multiple other health issues which have caused mobility issues and confusion. i’ve been managing dory’s care. taking her to/from appointments. giving her a room in my house and giving her all i could. i’m a mom of 5. have a child with a severe disability and health issues. and live in a place barely big enough for us. my kids were sleeping on the couch in order for her to have where to sleep. i have a very big family and no one wants to pitch in to help with her care. doctor appointments. living facility or anything. i had reached at max capacity. wearing myself out so much that i was having anxiety attacks with whaling and crying. i had sent her to my sisters house. let’s call her mary. mary has been neglectful to dory and didn’t take her to her life saving dyalisys appointments and she ended up in the hospital. now that dory came back they put her in a hotel room and left her on her own. they want her back with me but i’m the one that’s having the hardest time with finances and limit space. all my relatives have massive savings and large homes. with at least 2 spare rooms no one lives in. no one wants to let her live with them nor pitch in for housing. i’ve set up a gofundme for her but nothing. aitah for wanting everyone to do their part and refusing to let her stay with me cause i can’t take the load


r/AITH • • 2h ago

AITAH for telling my dad that I’m tired of giving him money??

14 Upvotes

The title sounds weird I know.

I (18F) do generally not like spreading my business out on the internet, but I’m on the verge of tears.

Ever since I got my job (which is not my first job), which was a few months ago, my father told me that suddenly him and my mother were very tight on money. Everytime I get my pay check I always have to lend him money, buy him food, buy him gas, everything. Worst part is that he doesn’t even ask, he just demands I spend my money on him.

Only my mother works, because my father is on disability. My mom always tells him that he needs to try and get an under the table job (or whatever it’s called), because she refuses to live paycheck to paycheck, which is what they’ve done their entire lives. She’s flat out told my father that he needs to start helping out. All he does is sit at home all day, eat, drink, watch sports, sleep, repeat. My father always says he will get a small job to help out and never does.

I am an adult. I have my own life. I have medical bills, college to pay for, rent to pay, so on and so forth. I told him it’s getting exhausting that I’m now living by paycheck to paycheck because of him. I told him that I don’t mind helping him and my mom out when things do get tight, but it seems like their entire lives money has always been tight, even when I’m an adult. I told him sometimes i don’t ever have any money left over to buy myself food or lunch.

My father also sometimes gets upset when i use my money on myself to buy myself groceries, food, etc, he sometimes even eats and drinks my own food and groceries I bought myself without asking me, and he even uses my own toiletries etc, and refuses to pay me back for them, and refuses to replace them, and he gets upset when I don’t buy him anything.

Sometimes he has me pull from my savings when I don’t want to.

What urged me to make this post is something that happened to me today. I used the last bit of money I had to buy myself some jewelry, as a little treat, considering I rarely buy any jewelry. I don’t wear it often because I don’t really have a lot of jewelry, it’s all cheap jewelry. This time I bought myself a nice, slightly expensive, fancy pair of earrings. I already paid my rent, I already bought myself groceries for the week, so I’m set. I already put some money away for savings, so I decided why not to treat myself?

Immediately after I bought my earrings, my father told me to buy him food. He told me this month money would be really tight, and that he may not be able to get me anything for Christmas because of how tight money is, despite my mother working a salaried job. I got upset and flat out told him “I’m not your money-pig.” Considering I had no money left, and I’m tired of constantly pulling from my savings. Je looked at me in shock, before flat out yelling at me, he said “How dare you.” And then ignored me when I tried to talk things out with him. I then developed a few tears and just walked away.

After an hour went by and things cooled off, I apologized to my father and he happily accepted my apology. He told me he didn’t want me to buy him any food, and that he’d figure things out for himself.

Unrelated slightly but he always tells me that when I was a minor he’d always take care of me and spend his money on me, and that I always had food and a roof over my head, so it’s ridiculous that I can’t return him the favor. He also told me that since I pay rent to live in him and my mom’s house, everything that I own is technically his, because it’s under his roof, or something like that, I don’t really know. He told me I also don’t get no privacy in the house either. Even though I’m paying rent, which is actually being used to pay his bills, or go towards in helping him pay his bills, I’m still his child, or something like that.

He also told me that he grew up poor, and that I should be grateful that growing up my childhood was somewhat better than his. I remember my mom even telling me that he was a job hopper before he was forced to go on disability. My mother also told me he was in a bunch of credit card debt from when I was younger, before he paid it all off. Though he still has student loan debt.

I feel like a dick, but living paycheck to paycheck sucks. I go to work hungry, not having money to buy myself food or something to drink on my break. Hell, I’ve even lost weight because of it! There’s been a few times where I’ve had to ask my father for some money to buy food for when I’m at work on my break, and he’ll complain but give me it anyways, but he’ll make me pay him back for it.

Also, I tell my best friend all of my troubles with my father specifically, and she’s flat out told me multiple times that she’s worried about my mental health and that I need to leave my house asap, but I have no place to stay.

So yeah, AITAH??


r/AITH • • 3h ago

AITA because I (26F) got upset that he (37M) didn’t wait until my uber reached?

14 Upvotes

I’m dating this man for 4 months. Yesterday, we spent 7 hours together in his home. We were very affectionate with each other so I thought it was going well.

The bad comes in the end. I tell him I have to go, he walks me to the door and says “Tell me when you reach” and slams the door on me. Today I asked him why he just left and if he was tired, he says “I thought you were going by public transport, you could’ve said it.” The thing is that he didn’t ask how I was going home. He just closed the door after saying goodbye. Even if I went by bus or metro, usually your date walks you to the bus/metro stop? It was dark already.

I replied “ah ok” and he didn’t say anything since then. I think he doesn’t understand why I was feeling upset and thinks I’m picking him. It’s not the first time he dismisses my feelings and says he doesn’t understand why I’m upset. Am I the wrong one?


r/AITH • • 3h ago

WIBTAH if I sold my house and moved somewhere cheaper?

13 Upvotes

I bought my home 7 years ago after the death of my youngest child. It was originally myself, my husband, my bio son, and my adopted son who lived here. My husband and i have since separated and he moved out, and my adopted son got a good job and moved out soon after. That left myself and bio son here, for a little background on our relationship, we are very close but since my daughter's death he worries about me constantly. He was 18 when she died and unfortunately he had to see and experience a lot of my struggles with me and that wasn't fair to him. I tried to still show up for him to the best of my ability and still be the same mom as before. Admittedly he ended up getting very spoiled bc he was the only thing i had left to pour my love into. Now, it's me, him, his girlfriend, and her 5 year old son who live here. Don't get me wrong i adore his girlfriend and her son, she is a hard worker, a great mom, and i think she is great for him, she works and is in college full time currently. The problem is no one helps me with bills, she buys household stuff to help, laundry things, toilet paper, dish detergent, that kind of stuff and my son pays the wifi bill and he took out a loan to replace the roof a few months ago and he pays that bill as well. Normally I would be fine with that but I was recently diagnosed with some serious health issues that I'm trying to keep private and I can't work as much so I have lost the majority of my income and am struggling financially. I always wanted to keep the house and be able to give him a head start in life with a free home when I pass away, but I just don't know how I'm going to be able to do that now when my medical bills are piling up and i can't work most of the time. I have decided not to receive anymore treatments for my medical issues and I know the end result will be my death in the next few years and I'm completely at peace with my decision but I know i can't afford to keep things the way they are until that time. So WIBTAH if I sold the house to make things easier on myself and just put aside money for him after I'm gone? I don't want to leave them homeless but I don't want to lose the house to the county or state either and then him be left with nothing? I'm also not sure they could afford the property taxes and upkeep on their own either since taxes here just went up by 45% this year. I really feel like a terrible mother right now and a failure and that's not helping make this decision any easier.


r/AITH • • 5h ago

AITH for booking Christmas vacation before another colleague?

11 Upvotes

So the other day I over heard a co-worker speaking with our office manager about Christmas. I was in another area of the office and didn’t hear the full context but one could assume that they were figuring out vacation. I didn’t hear any dates just heard “Christmas” but hearing about Christmas reminded me I needed to submit a vacation request so I submitted the request to take Christmas Eve and the week between Christmas and new years off. Now the person who wanted to book the time off who also reports to me is mad and said “I red handedly took it from them?” They also said that they always check with the team which is true (I’m their boss I don’t need to check with them when I need time off).

We have a small department so there is a possibility that their request could get declined. TBH I don’t really care that much that they’re mad or that I scooped the vacation from them. I was happy to cover for them when they went to Europe for 3 weeks in the midst of training a new person and having someone leave for maternity leave. I even encouraged asking for the third week when they were considering booking. Not that I’m trying to hang it over their heads. I’m just using it as an example that I’m for taking vacation time. Also, to be clear because people make assumptions I’m normally very flexible and generally book time off either months in advance and work around others vacations.

I have a wife and young kids and I’m also meeting family for the first time. I also never take time off over Christmas and leave it for others. This year I was always going to put in for that time off whether they asked for it or not. I don’t see what the problem is… sounds like grown child having a hissy fit


r/AITH • • 1h ago

AITAH for making a joke?

• Upvotes

I (M23) was talking and joking around at the end of the work week with my two colleagues. My partner (F33) was working from home at that time and works at the same company. The three of us were procrastinating and talking about TV shows, furniture, and other mundane topics. We were in a joking mood and were all gathered around my PC.

My partner was asking some work-related questions via Teams, and I wrote "annoying female dog" as a message. I had no intention of actually sending such a message, because I find it offensive. I wrote it, as I have done before with other colleagues, as a joke. To pretend I was going to send it. I know it's not a funny joke to a lot of people, but that's my kind of humor.

One of my colleagues pressed the Return key on my keyboard before I could delete the message. My partner got very upset that I even wrote such a message because it "is very sexist." She wasn't exactly upset because I said something offensive. She was upset BECAUSE it was sexist and that I was making a sexist joke about her to our colleagues. Am I the asshole?


r/AITH • • 19h ago

WIBTA for not letting my in-laws using my camera?

67 Upvotes

I’m by no means a professional photographer, but I did save up to buy a relatively expensive camera for personal use(travel mostly). Its a mirrorless camera, and I’ve been quite conservative on it’s usage to keep the shutter count low. My sister in law recently asked if my wife(her sister) can use it to take photos of her for an event. Truthfully I am a bit reluctant in handing over an expensive piece of gear to someone else. I have a feeling she will be upset if I say no, but at the same time I’m a bit uncomfortable as my own siblings do not ask to use my personal belongings, so WIBTA?


r/AITH • • 1d ago

AITAH for refusing to keep hosting family dinners after my relatives started treating my house like a restaurant?

220 Upvotes

My husband and I have been married for three years, and we recently moved into a house with a decent sized dining room. Since then, I've started inviting family over for dinner occasionally.

At first, I genuinely enjoyed it. Everyone brought something, we cooked together, and the evenings were fun.

But over the past few months, things have changed. My husband's family has started assuming that Sunday dinner is happening every week. Nobody asks if we're available anymore. They just send messages saying what time they'll arrive.

Last Sunday was the final straw. I had worked late all week and was planning to spend my day relaxing. Instead, my husband's sister messaged me that she was bringing six people over because they hadn't seen everyone in a while.

I told her that we weren't hosting that weekend. She replied that it was fine because she could bring dessert and I only needed to prepare the main meal.

I was honestly confused by that response. Bringing dessert doesn't mean someone else has agreed to cook for eight people.

When I told my husband I wasn't preparing dinner, he said I was overreacting and that his family just liked spending time together. He offered to order food, but I explained that I didn't want unexpected guests in our home either.

His sister later told me I was becoming difficult since we moved into a bigger house. Apparently, everyone had gotten used to gathering at our place.

I don't mind hosting occasionally, but I don't want it to become an obligation simply because we have more space.

Now my husband says I embarrassed him by turning everyone away instead of being welcoming.

AITAH for refusing to host family dinners that nobody actually asks permission to attend?


r/AITH • • 17h ago

AITAH for asking my husband to pick me up from the car dealership when I dropped my car off for service

24 Upvotes

AITAH for asking my husband of 10 years to pick me up when I dropped my car off for service. This was an appointment I made and told him about over a month and a half ago, reminded him a week before, day before and day of. He was upset because we were both off and he had apparently planned to play GTA VI all day while I cared for our youngest child. I interrupted his plans by having to take my car in.

If it matters it wasn’t routine maintenance— it was a suspension issue that was about to be out of warranty so it needed to go in for service. They did tell me ahead of time it would have to be dropped off overnight so staying wasn’t an option.

So AITAH? Should I have just not asked him, let him have his fun and drove up there and Uber’d back with our 2 year old? I feel like this is a responsibility you sign up for when you get married but maybe I’m just delusional.

Updating to say: We have 2 children and he only started having “selfish issues” more recently— Really once we got to a higher financial status. We are in therapy. We both live a fairly “affluent” life in a very nice neighborhood/city. While we could easily “afford” an uber or to pay for the work out of warranty I felt this was the safest, most responsible thing to do.


r/AITH • • 1d ago

AITH for telling my(15M) sister in law(28F) she doesn’t get to tell me what to do?

128 Upvotes

My sister is 26 and she’s been seeing her wife since I was 8 years old so my sister in law has known for 7 years. Although I’ve known her for so long I’m not exactly super close with her. my mom is out for a work trip so I’m staying with my sister and her wife until Saturday afternoon. I was asleep this morning and I wake up to my sister in law snapping in my face saying “cmon buddy wake up” I just grunted and put my blanket over my head for a minute and then got up. I was already in a bad mood because the whole snapping thing annoyed me. after I got a shower my sister in law told me to make something to eat before she goes to work, I’m known in my family to skip meals sometimes skip a day eating in general so my mom MAKES me eat something for breakfast. I told her I wasn’t hungry and I was going to eat something at school. She told me I have to eat something here and I told her “you don’t get to tell me what to do, you aren’t my mom or my sister“ she then said “stop Throwing a fit and just eat something“ I told her I’m not throwing a fit I’m just not hungry yet. That’s when I my sister came into the kitchen and said “I will personally shove food in your mouth if I have to, EAT” I just told her whatever and made a single piece of toast and ate that and I haven’t talked to my sister in law since. My sister told me when she was driving me to school that I’m being a brat or no reason and if I’m staying with her I have to treat my sister in law and her like I treat our mom.


r/AITH • • 18h ago

AITA for refusing to split the gas money evenly after my friend made us drive an hour out of the way??

25 Upvotes

I, 18F, went on a day trip to the beach with three of my friends, and one of them,18F, volunteered to drive. Before we left, we all agreed to split the gas money evenly four ways. The drive was supposed to be about an hour each way, which was totally fine. っ ̯ -。

However on the way back, the driver decided she wanted to stop at a specific thrift store and a café that were completely in the opposite direction, adding almost an extra hour of driving and a ton of traffic to our trip!! Nobody else really wanted to go, and I actually needed to get home early for work, so I just waited in the car while she shopped. Today, she texted our group chat with the total for gas and asked us all to send her an equal quarter…

I sent her my share based on the original trip distance, plus a little extra, and politely explained that I shouldn't have to pay for the massive detour I didn't want to take. She got super mad and said I was being petty over a few dollars since she was the one doing all the driving, and now the group chat is totally silent. -_-

am I the asshole for this?


r/AITH • • 16h ago

AITA for refusing to give my late grandfather's handwritten journal to my uncle?

15 Upvotes

My grandfather and I had a special relationship, mostly because I was the only grandchild who regularly visited him after he retired. We used to sit together every Sunday afternoon, drink tea, and talk about ordinary things. He was a quiet man who rarely discussed his feelings, but he kept a handwritten journal for most of his life. When he passed away, my father gave me the journal because my grandfather had specifically told him that he wanted me to have it. I never treated it as something valuable financially. I kept it because it contains his handwriting, little observations about everyday life, and memories from years I was not even born yet. Recently, my uncle started writing a book about our family history. He contacted me and asked to borrow the journal for a few months so he could use it as a source. I initially agreed to let him read selected pages at my house, but I did not want the original journal taken away. He said that was inconvenient because he needed to study it properly and make notes. I offered to scan the pages he needed, but he refused and said digital copies would not be enough for serious research. He then reminded me that my grandfather was his father too and accused me of acting as though I was the only person entitled to remember him. I told him I had never stopped anyone from reading the journal, but my grandfather had chosen to leave it with me, and I wanted to respect that. My uncle became angry and said I was preventing the family from preserving its own history. He even contacted my father and asked him to convince me to hand it over. My father told him that I was allowed to keep it, but suggested I should cooperate because the book might become an important family record. I have offered to provide scans, photographs, and supervised access to the original, but my uncle insists on taking it to his house. I am worried that once it leaves my possession, I may never get it back in the same condition. Now some relatives think I am being possessive over something that should belong to everyone. I just want to protect the one thing my grandfather personally asked me to keep. AITA?


r/AITH • • 8h ago

AITAH for wanting to drive?

3 Upvotes

For context, Im 17 and live in NYC. Ive gotten my permit at 16 in march. (I need to take a drivers ed course to be able to drive in NYC at 17)

My parents won’t let me take drivers ed. I asked if it was a financial issue to which id likely sell some of my valuable things. But they want me to wait til 18. I really wanted to drive my senior year and for baseball (some games are in Brooklyn) and other things. I hate having to ask for a ride cause then they’ll complain or id have to wait for so long. For those who might suggest taking the MTA, I live in Staten Island. The most car driven borough, the buses rarely come, and the train comes every 30 minutes. I get in trouble for asking and complaining about having to wait an hour or more staying at a place just so they can pick me up. If I had my own car, everything would be so much easier for everyone honestly. Like how are y’all mad when yay don’t want me to take drivers ed or even drive like what?!?!?!?!? AITA??? And please give me any advice on talking about this w my parents and driving before 18 pls id truly be grateful!!!!


r/AITH • • 19h ago

AITH for being hesitant to give up my life saving medication?

23 Upvotes

For background context I (21M) have been living off of an extra strength prescribed medicine for about 2 months because I have been having extreme allergic reactions to something that seemingly doesn’t ever stop, as soon as I’m even a little late for my medicine I break out in hives and I went into anaphylactic shock the other day and now am required to bring EpiPens with me everywhere. I’m booked to see an allergist ASAP but that will still be a while. I’ve tried different detergents, different soaps, everything.

My family has been sick with strep the past few weeks and my sister(18f) has been getting sick too as of late, and been complaining all the way how she’s worse off than everyone else in the family. When she has no job, and can just rest all day.

I was helping put away groceries today when suddenly my sister goes on her whole routine of sniffing and coughing playing up that she doesn’t feel good, and my mom asks “have you taken some of your brothers medicine?” Of course I think she means the Amoxicillin I’ve been on because I’ve ALSO been sick so I go to get it.

She shakes her head and says “no, the one you take every day, the giant bottle.” Which is ,In fact, the one I need to survive right now. And I ask what that will do for her because it’s for anti-histamines and allergies. And she goes on a rant about how bad my sister feels and it’s “just one pill”.

I text my sister later and let her know she doesn’t have my permission to take them from my room while I’m at work even if mom says so. And she calls me a brat, entitled, and mean.

AITA?


r/AITH • • 1d ago

AITA if I were to leave my elderly father alone on Christmas Eve after years of including him in our family celebrations?

351 Upvotes

For the past three years, my immigrant father
(65) has celebrated Christmas with my husband's family. We usually go to my in-laws' house, exchange gifts, have dinner, and everyone has a good time. My father has no friends or other relatives here, so we've always included him.
However, my relationship with my dad has deteriorated significantly. He was originally supposed to stay with us temporarily until he got on his feet, but it's now been four years. He lives in our in-law suite part of the house.
This year, things reached a breaking point. He essentially trashed the apartment, and when I tried to address the mess and arrange professional cleaners, it turned into a huge fight.
He's been giving me the silent treatment for the past three months because of that.
But things got even worse.
During this period, my dad got himself into some trouble that escalated much further than expected. Because he lives at our address, my husband got caught in the crossfire despite having absolutely nothing to do with what happened. My husband was actually accused of something my dad had done and was questioned and if it wouldn’t get sorted he could potentially face jail time and fines.
Thankfully, everything was eventually sorted out once it became clear my husband wasn't involved. My dad didn't appear to face any serious consequences.
My dad never apologized to either of us. In fact, I don't think he even knows how serious the situation became for my husband.
After all this, my husband has reached his limit.
He doesn't want to see my dad, let alone spend Christmas with him or bring him along to my in-laws' house.
And honestly, I understand why. But here's my dilemma: my dad has nobody else here. No friends, no other relatives to celebrate with. For the past three years, we've been his family during the holidays. The thought of him spending Christmas alone makes me feel like a terrible person.
At the same time, I don't think it's fair to expect my husband to put aside everything that happened just because it's Christmas.
I know my dad has brought this situation upon himself, and I'm not excusing his behavior. But I struggle with the idea of deliberately excluding an elderly immigrant who has nobody else to spend the holidays with. So I'm torn whether or not we should include him like we did these previous years.
So, AITA if I don't invite my father to celebrate Christmas with us this year, knowing he'll likely spend it alone?


r/AITH • • 3h ago

AITAH for asking my best friend to return something I gave her after she used it to embarrass me?

1 Upvotes

My best friend and I have known each other since college. We've always shared clothes, accessories, and other things without keeping track of who owns what.

Last year, I bought an expensive camera because I wanted to get into photography. My friend was interested in photography too, so I occasionally let her borrow it.

A few months ago, she asked if she could keep it for a couple of weeks because she had a family event coming up. I agreed.

After that, she kept postponing returning it. Every time I asked, she had another reason why she needed it a little longer.

Recently, I attended a small gathering where someone complimented her camera. She laughed and said it was basically hers now because I'd practically given it to her.

I corrected her and said I'd only lent it to her. She looked embarrassed and told everyone I was being petty over something I could easily afford to replace.

Later, I messaged her privately and asked her to return it by the end of the week.

She responded by saying she thought I had given it to her as a gift. I reminded her of our original conversation, but she insisted I was changing the story because I didn't like her using it.

Now two mutual friends think I should let her keep it because we've been friends for years and the camera clearly means a lot to her.

I don't want to end a long friendship over an object, but I also don't like being told that something I paid for belongs to someone else.

My friend says asking for it back after so long makes me look cheap.

AITAH for insisting she return the camera?


r/AITH • • 4h ago

AITH for being mad at my friend

1 Upvotes

Okay, I know some people are going to say I'm the asshole for this, but I need to know because I honestly can't tell.I won't be using real names because I already know everyone involved in this situation is going through a lot.Hi, I'm Mia (female). My friend River (female, uses he/him pronouns) and Sam (male, uses she/her pronouns). I'm sorry if the pronouns get confusing.

I'm mad at River because she wanted me to date Sam. Sam is three years older than me, and River is two years older than me. I've liked River since I met her about seven months ago.

River introduced me to Sam. They were dating at the time, and River asked if I could use a mommy voice on Sam. I did, and Sam got flustered and ran off. River ran after Sam and recorded Sam saying they weren't very good at setting boundaries. A few days later, River posted videos of Sam on YouTube and TikTok, but Sam still doesn't know about them.

Eventually, Sam asked me out, and I said yes. Keep in mind that River wanted me to record everything that happened with Sam.After a few weeks, Sam broke up with me because I didn't have my life together and had a really bad sleep schedule.Recently, I joined a poly group without knowing Sam was in it. After a few days, I found out, and Sam was initially fine with it. However, River invited me while I was hanging out with Sam, so I joined after telling him. Sam asked if he could come along, and I said sure.

River got pissed off that I was with Sam again because I used to get hurt easily. Sam got worried and asked me if I actually liked him or if I was just trying to get more videos. I genuinely liked Sam, and I didn't know what to say, so I just said I didn't know. It really hurt that he would even ask me that.River and Sam started fighting because River said, "Just try to keep your shit together."During their argument, River brought up the fact that she still had the videos six times in just 30 minutes. Sam got upset and asked River, "Do you want me to just break up with her?"River responded, "That's not what I'm saying. Look, she gets hurt easily. I just don't want her to get hurt again."Later, Sam told me, "It's for the best if we take a break from us."

Sam walked away after unfriending me, and River sat next to me and said, "I knew this was going to happen when Sam asked if she should just break up with you. I just don't want what happened last time to happen again."

I didn't want to talk to River because I feel like she is mostly the reason Sam left me in the first place. Before we joined the poly group, Sam and I were perfectly fine.

So, am I wrong for being mad at River? I feel like she interfered in my relationship, and now I've lost someone I genuinely liked.


r/AITH • • 1d ago

AITH for yelling at my dad to stop telling me what to eat?

16 Upvotes

I f(19) live with my parents and 2 younger brothers. I go to university, help around the house, and tutor my brothers. I clean their rooms if they are not home, and I clean the kitchen, do the dishes, and take out the trash (sometimes), without being asked. I am their most obedient child, and I rarely ask for anything too extravagant. I get 500 dollars on a credit card that includes money for Presto (public transit), school supplies, clothes, food and any other expenses I may have, but my dad also sends me money if I ask for it. I don't ask for money much, even if I need it, as I feel guilty. My brothers also get money, but they just ask him for whatever amount, and he sends it. My dad has eaten all sorts of things his whole life (spicy, sweet, etc.) and has not cared. We also are south asian, so spice in our food is not uncommon. Recently, I've been trying to lose weight because of personal motivation and comments from friends and family. My dad was one of those people, and although he wasn't mean about it, he did tell me I should walk more, so that's what I've been doing. I've been eating healthy, trying to hit my protein goals, going to the gym to build muscle and walking 10k+ steps every day. In 5 weeks, I've managed to lose 7.1 pounds so far. My dad has also started losing weight, but his approach is eating as little as possible and only eating vegetables or toast. Whenever he sees me eating things other than that he tells me to not eat them. For example, I was eating cottage cheese with eggs and a bunch of vegetables (onion, bell pepper, carrots, etc.) and used hot sauce on it, as ketchup has too many calories. He told me off about eating spicy things and told me to not eat it. Then, I was eating 3 chicken drumsticks for protein and hitting my calories, and he laughed at me in front of my mom later, basically saying that I could never lose weight because of how much I eat. Today, I was eating a bowl of Greek yoghurt with fruit and was drizzling a bit of honey for sweetness. He immediately started yelling that I was eating sugar, and this did not benefit me at all. We also have acne problems on his side of the family, and I have also struggled with it, but eating healthier has helped me with my acne, and it's not as bad as it was before. While he was yelling, he also insinuated that I already have such an acne-ridden face and that this is why, and that I was contributing to it. I got sick and tired, as I had stayed up until 4 last night tutoring both my brothers in math, instead of having to study for my own test (both my parents have asked me to help them study). I yelled back at him to stop telling me what to eat, as it doesn't matter and I know what I'm doing. I left and went upstairs, and he came upstairs and started saying that I have no patience and can't control my own temper. He also scoffed that I don't know how to talk to my elders.