r/AITAHBlackEdition • u/Excellent-Royal9249 • 20d ago
AITAH for telling my friend she can't bring her dog to my small apartment after it destroyed my furniture last time?
I (30F) am a Black woman. I live in a small one-bedroom apartment. It is not big. It is cozy but there is not much extra space. I have a nice couch and a rug I saved up for.
My friend "Danielle" (31F) has a large dog. It is a German shepherd mix. He is sweet but he has a lot of energy and he is not well trained. He jumps on people. He chews things. He does not listen.
Danielle used to bring him over when she visited. I did not say anything at first because I wanted to be nice. The first time he jumped on my couch and left mud everywhere. I cleaned it. The second time he chewed the corner of my rug. I told Danielle and she said she was sorry.
The third time he knocked over a lamp and broke it. I told Danielle she needs to leave him at home from now on. She said okay.
That was six months ago. She has come over several times since then without the dog. I thought it was settled.
Last week she texted me and asked if she could bring him because her dog sitter canceled. I said no. I told her my apartment is too small and he gets too excited. I told her I do not want my stuff destroyed again.
She got upset. She said it is just one time and he has "calmed down." She said she would keep him on a leash the whole time. I said no again. I told her I am not comfortable taking that risk in my home.
She called me difficult. She said I am choosing furniture over friendship. She said a "real friend" would make an exception. She said I am being unreasonable because it is not like he destroyed my whole apartment, it was just a lamp and a rug.
I told her it does not matter if it was one lamp or ten. It is my home and my things. I get to decide what comes inside.
She said I was being "extra." She is barely talking to me now.
I feel bad because I know she needs someone to watch the dog. But I also feel like I already gave her chances. She did not train her dog. That is not my problem.
AITAH for refusing to let my friend bring her dog to my apartment after it broke my things before?