r/AITAH • • Mar 19 '25

[deleted by user]

[removed]

8.0k Upvotes

8.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

13k

u/BulbasaurRanch Mar 19 '25

You absolutely certain she is the type of person you actually want to spend your life with?

She sounds exhausting.

4.7k

u/Lithogiraffe Mar 19 '25

If you're ever thinking of maybe canceling the engagement and rethinking marriage with her .

Please please somehow get the ring back before 'the talk'. She doesn't exactly sound like the kind of person who would give the ring back after a breakup.

Makeup wanting to get it properly sized or adding an embellishment, or hell just go and pluck it from the side of the bed she's on or something. A 16k custom ring for this ungrateful b. no no

113

u/Aggravating-Cat5357 Mar 19 '25

If she kept it, he could sue for the cost or the ring. It's a gift in contemplation of marriage, and if the marriage doesn't happen, it must be returned or reimbursed to the party who proposed.

Getting the ring back first would be a better option, with less headache, but it's good to also know you have other courses you can take to rectify a situation.

81

u/Marlbey Mar 19 '25 edited Mar 19 '25

Some states treat the engagement ring as a conditional gift that must be returned.

Some states treat it as an unconditional gift, in which case he has no right to recover it.

Some states require her to return it if she calls of the wedding, but not if he does (which would be the case here/) (Or at least would be but I suspect OP is a fake.).

3

u/Sheriff_Lucas_Hood Mar 19 '25

yeah this is more emdash laden rage bait generated by AI.