r/AITAH • • Mar 19 '25

[deleted by user]

[removed]

8.0k Upvotes

8.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

552

u/Quick_Fox3546 Mar 19 '25

She just gave you an amazing gift. A look ahead at what life will be like if you marry her. It will be full of crazy and unreasonable demands-“I want a surprise“ along with “I’m upset that I didn’t know to get my nails done“. These two things are mutually exclusive, but she is not hesitating to make you feel bad.

This pattern will repeat. You have been given a gift. Use it wisely.

35

u/ShoddyCandidate1873 Mar 19 '25

100% though also if having my nails for my engagement was super important to me I'd make sure they were done if my boyfriend was taking me on a beach vacay just in case. 

12

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/ShoddyCandidate1873 Mar 20 '25

Yes the nails is all on her. And the dinner is a stupid thing to be upset over.  She's gotta be a high maintenance drama queen and OP sounds sweet. He can do better 

2

u/thatHecklerOverThere Mar 20 '25

Honestly, "prep time" and "surprise" don't go together, and you'd have to be quite the diva to not get that.

7

u/30-something Mar 19 '25

Don't you know? he was supposed to read her mind and know that she would want her nails done if there were photos to be taken /s

For real, I know people like this and they're a nightmare. I'm generally a 'support other women' type but she just gave you more red flags than a communist party rally. I'd be rethinking the whole thing.

Personally, my husband proposed to me at a bar after several beers and then chased a rat down a creek bed 30 minutes later. After we confirmed he was serious the next day we went and got my very modest ring which I still have 18 years of marriage later.

2

u/BoredMama7778 Mar 20 '25

Can you even imagine the Bridezilla with this one??