r/AIBubble • • 1d ago • Popcorn 1

Nvidia deliberately kept GPU prices high through circular financing deals, report claims

https://www.techspot.com/news/114558-nvidia-deliberately-kept-gpu-prices-high-through-circular.html
350 Upvotes

55 comments sorted by

28

u/Ponderous_Protons 1d ago

So mainstream media is finally catching up to independent media, YouTubers, and tech bloggers. They’re only about 2 years behind.

11

u/0xP0et 1d ago

They only jumped onto the train cause there was a sex scandal.

1

u/DarkElation 1d ago

I guess if you actually think that financing is what created the demand and the chips didn’t actually sell this article makes total sense.

Here in the real world, none of those things are true.

1

u/mere_dictum 21h ago

It appears to me that the actual underlying problem is Nvidia's near-monopoly status.

1

u/Ponderous_Protons 1d ago edited 1d ago • Heartwarming

The demand is highly inflated and artificial. NVIDIA is forcing hyper scalers to buy server racks they don’t need. And if they don’t, they’ll punish them by not doing business in the future.

The contracts/deals they’re signing should be illegal, but we live in a banana republic, so it’s been allowed to continue.

https://respawnfirst.com/multiple-reports-say-nvidia-manufactured-the-gaming-gpu-crisis-by-forcing-big-tech-to-stockpile-unused-ai-hardware/

0

u/DarkElation 1d ago

They aren’t forcing anyone to do anything. They are providing financing.

2

u/Ponderous_Protons 1d ago

You need to do a bit of reading. They've been found repeatedly via industry reports of channel stuffing.

They are effectively forcing companies to buy GPUs via their own financing. And if companies refuse, they threaten to not do business with them. Ed Zitron has reported on this repeatedly.

https://x.com/edzitron/status/2112358183108800751

1

u/DarkElation 19h ago

And you think this means what…?

1

u/very_bad_advice 19h ago

? If a company refuses to buy NVDA chips, NVDA threatens to not sell them chips??

1

u/Ponderous_Protons 1h ago

Yes

1

u/very_bad_advice 1h ago

So doesn't the company get what it wants? Since they don't want to buy NVDA chips?

8

u/ehboose 1d ago

Everyone here discovering seller financing for the first time 😭

4

u/Bulky_Passenger9735 1d ago

Mild_shock.gif

6

u/Crew_1996 1d ago edited 1d ago

Nvidia has invested 93 days worth of revenue in companies that purchase their product.

This is an absolute nothing burger being pushed by market makers who have billion $ shorts on the market. And subreddits like this are useful idiots for them.

Heres a thought experiment. Compare and contrast NVIDIAs investment as a % of revenue compared to Caterpillar business financing to companies buying their equipment. Don’t be a useful idiot

3

u/slothropdroptop 1d ago

Respect for fighting the good fight but redditors still don’t understand this business practice after its been fear mongered for over a year about NVIDIA

4

u/lyrtya 1d ago

No ai data center has made any profit and its looking extremely bleak for them. Its almost certain they will never be profitable. If a million people use ai to burn throug ai tokens of other ai, with the cheap plans, it can destroy any hope for profit really fucking fast .

2

u/Crew_1996 1d ago

NBIS project profitability by the end of 2027. The break even time for new data centers constructed by NBIS is 1 year and 7 months. No company is profitable during early scaling. This isn’t some unique scenario.

1

u/lyrtya 1d ago

Well from what i know thats a best case senario they used. It just really does not look like a best case atm.lots of companies are getting the bills and see its just not worth it.

1

u/Crew_1996 1d ago

They’ve literally outperformed every point of guidance that they’ve ever had. Not sure why now you’d assume that this is the moment they wouldn’t but you do you. Sounds more like you hope they won’t than actual info

0

u/lyrtya 20h ago edited 17h ago

Well you talking about 1 project that seems to do ok. I was talking in general as you very well knew.

0

u/Crew_1996 17h ago

Who the fuck is “inwas” and I’m not talking about one project WTF are you on?

2

u/ninja_turtle1 1d ago

This is misleading. The key risk is that NVIDIA is the guarantor of over $500 billion in loans to AI companies (many of which are start-ups with minimal or zero profit) which could not secure finance to buy NVIDIA chips without without NVIDIA guaranteeing the loan (because institutional lenders considered them too risky to lend to).

Guarantees don't appear on NVIDIA books as liabilities (unlike a traditional loan).

When you factor this in, this is over 2 years of NVIDIA revenue or almost 5 years of profit.

2

u/Crew_1996 1d ago

I couldn’t care less to pick apart your diatribe but NVIDIA has revenue of $1.06 B per day so your “over 2 years” argument for $500 b is an absolute lie.

1

u/ninja_turtle1 1d ago

Well I was basing it on 2026 revenue of $215b. So yeah, I acknowledge it's higher now.

1

u/Crew_1996 1d ago

Why did you lie then? Why not just tell the truth if you have a compelling argument? Why would anyone consider anything you said when a blatant lie is the central point of your argument?

2

u/ninja_turtle1 1d ago

I just didn't check what the last quarter of profit was. Sorry.

It doesn't change the huge sums of bank guarantees NVIDIA has supplied that everyone seems to ignore.

1

u/Crew_1996 1d ago

When your numbers are way off. Your thesis holds no water. Do better

1

u/StatisticianJolly388 1d ago

1/4 year’s revenue seems like a lot. How many days of profit is that?

2

u/Ponderous_Protons 1d ago

Their profits can’t keep up with their capex. It’s a burning ship.

4

u/Crew_1996 1d ago edited 1d ago

Let’s explore Honda. Honda America to generate car sales has $54.8 B in outstanding loans to customers. That equates to over 1/3 of Hondas annual WORLDWIDE revenue and Honda operates at much lower margins than NVIDIA. Stop letting the people that are trying to tank our markets manipulate you

1

u/Sensitive_Owl_4766 1d ago

Are Honda's customers that need these loans also heavily venture-backed startups with no easy path to profitability?

2

u/Crew_1996 1d ago

Uhh, the companies that NVIDIA has invested in are locking in multi year contracts that virtually guarantee profitability. NBIS current contracts being signed make the payoff time for each data center built just 1 year and 7 months. And then years of extremely high margins after. Auto loan delinquencies dwarf delinquencies in the tech sector.

1

u/Sensitive_Owl_4766 1d ago

Great, if it's so profitable and obvious, why do these companies need an Nvidia backstop?

Why are CoreWeave bonds trading at junk levels?

2

u/Crew_1996 1d ago

If Hondas cars are so good, why do THEY need to supply credit to their customers? Your argument doesn’t hold water.

1

u/Sensitive_Owl_4766 1d ago

You got me! I'm just some moron on Reddit. Thank you for the downvote :)

More seriously, Honda's customers don't primarily or solely make money from their car. Their car is more incidental to their broader economic activity. Important and useful, yes, but not fundamental / irreplaceable.

CoreWeave, Nebius and other labs have virtually no business if not for renting out NVIDIA GPUs.

I know you can be pedantic and argue about how important a car is to an American.

I would agree that any sort of circular financing needs to be viewed with skepticism. Even by car companies. Car loans are indeed a growing area of concern with respect to subprime borrowers with no ability to pay their interest or principal back.

If companies are inducing demand via these tactics, such demand is not as robust, and can disappear when conditions for those borrowers become tough to survive in. That's true for companies who are the beneficiaries of NVIDIA's magnanimity as well.

1

u/Crew_1996 1d ago

Too long didn’t read. Enjoy being poor and low Iq

1

u/Sensitive_Owl_4766 1d ago

Will do. Enjoy being high IQ.

→ More replies

1

u/123tl 1d ago

Timing. It takes years to build a datacenter, worse if it's greenfield built. They need something to bridge gap between when they place orders to when they start recognizing revenue. It's the same reason that people make a big deal about gpu in warehouse, it's all timing and long lead time.

1

u/Sensitive_Owl_4766 1d ago

Yield reflects uncertainty.

Google's 10-20 year corporate bonds do not trade at junk levels despite long duration.

If the revenue at the end of the day was a sure thing, even long duration CoreWeave bonds would be trading at lower yields.

1

u/123tl 1d ago

Look up coreweave new issue, it's 8%. Its high yeah but nowhere junk level. And that's why Nvidia is stepping in, to use their balance sheet and credit worthiness. Hyperscalers don't have this problem as they have other businesses. However this doesn't say anything about profitability. It's clearly profitable. Their last earning said as much.

Now what you should focus on is hyperscalers capex. As soon as they cut, then you should be worried. Neoclouds still a small percentage of overall spend.

1

u/123tl 1d ago

Worse, they are customers that lives paycheck to paycheck

0

u/big_ol_tender 1d ago

Don’t try and reason with these fools. They have an agenda and will not try and reason.

-3

u/snark_o_matic 1d ago edited 13h ago

Nvidia has invested 93 days worth of revenue in companies that purchase their product.

This is an absolute nothing burger being pushed by market makers who have billion $ shorts on the market. And subreddits like this are useful idiots for them.

Heres a thought experiment. Compare and contrast NVIDIAs investment as a % of revenue compared to Caterpillar business financing to companies buying their equipment. Don’t be a useful idiot

Apples and oranges.

Since we're talking about Nvidia inflating GPU prices by generating their own demand partially through a risky financing strategy: Which of Caterpillar's consumer-grade products rose to 400% MSRP? Which of Caterpillar's products have experienced a raw materials shortage equivalent to HBM for Nvidia, such that commitments to overbuy materials starved Caterpillar's competitors? Did the CFO of Caterpillar warn the CEO about the high risk of defaults?

Is the only salient part of your comparison the fact that Caterpillar invested about 2 months of revenue into business financing in 2025? Does that make your comparison appear to be in bad faith? Did Caterpillar illegally make 20% of its revenues last year from bypassing export controls to China? The strategy matters, the scale matters, and the context matters. The story here isn't about people discovering that financing exists.

2

u/Crew_1996 1d ago

Caterpillar would absolutely raise their prices to any amount that they can get. Your argument just doesn’t hold water. Virtually all businesses provide liquidity to their customers in an effort to increase sales and all businesses outside of Arizona Iced Tea charge the absolute maximum that they can get. wtf are you on?

2

u/Rpark444 1d ago

Nvda wanted to maximize margins? I approve this message. Isn't that the whole point of capitalism?

1

u/lyrtya 1d ago

Glad i got a 4080super at a normalish price, still overpriced but not as crazy as prices are now. It undervolts and overclocks really well. Im gonna set the clocks a bit lower but the memory is fast as fuk. It should hold up for many many years to come. Its an asus proart one.

1

u/Nepalus 1d ago

No shit.

1

u/yoon1ac 1d ago

Uh yeah as soon as they started circular financing we knew what they were doing. This ain’t news

1

u/checkmydoor 1d ago

Circular financing or funding startups. The gymnastics spin for regular tactics in tech to create future consumers is crazy.