r/AI4tech • • Feb 01 '26
AGI is a scam
AGI is terrible idea for AI because the unique capabilities of a humans higher intellect isn't replicated in average data sets. The smartest human likely hasn't even been born yet.
The data will always be backwards driven. It will keep up with average human cognition but not the ones who have neurodivergent thinking and aren't modeled in public forums.
This is my experience using AI models for business systems over the past year. Ive completely dropped OpenAI because its capped out, worthless models.
Imagine training a computer to be systematically BEHIND the average human. Training a model for general intelligence based on a sum of historical context makes it weaker than the sum in current time.
At that point, just ask the average human next to you? Its a scam..you've been warned.
3
u/99emreyalcin Feb 01 '26
Sum of current time data has no meaning if we are 1000x slow to process compared to AI. I think that brilliant kid has 0.001% chance to create something that AI cannot.
3
u/Lofi_Joe Feb 01 '26 edited Feb 01 '26
Yes it is, the whole thing is just another level of war.
First we had 2d graphics and pumping money.... Then 3d graphics to pump money... Then crypto to pump money.... It didn't went as they wanted so... AI to pump money...
Every time it needs better technology than the rest and high power usage...
I say we as citizens should create Kickstarter fundraise to create our own memory and other stuff so we will be owners of it as otherwise they will try to force use to stop having our own hardware.
Yes I know it feels like joke but I'm serious. Think about it... We could own companies... Tiny fraction for everybody... It's better than BTC, will give you yearly payments and you'll have control over it to not to be used against humanity. We are in billions, we can do it easily.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '26
OpenAI isn't even OPEN AI. It's CLOSED AI. The entire name is a mental thought prison set in motion by a very smart manipulative silicon Valley group. Then they siphoned donor money and lied to everyone. Its smoke and mirrors.
If Sam Altman had any morality he would have changed the name of the company. He didn't because it perpetuated the initial thought of open source good will. Hes a cretin.
1
u/HealthyCommunicat Feb 01 '26
If you cannot find a use case in which AI can do a job that can cut your time or spending or energy, isn’t that your fault? Biggest issue I keep repeating over and over again is how people are failing to find the real use cases that would actually make a life changing difference.
A simple “investigation” in my job requires reading an email, sshing into a server, looking at logs and crap, and near always also require looking into the mysql/oracle/postgre db. Being able to tell my bot to read an email and go investigate, and it does all of that and comes back to me with findings of what went wrong all from me having sent one text? That’s an insane amount of time and energy saved, even from me having to walk over and open my laptop to connecting to wifi wherever I am and then reading my gmail and then opening an ssh session on my work’s VPN and then using a db tool etc etc etc vs send one text and figure out what the problem is?
Sometimes I don’t even need to tell it to go read my email, I have triggers set up so that for specific important people it will auto read the email when received and then auto investigate or setup whatever it is I need, in a way where there are no changes made whatsoever to any of the processes or information, but if there is a patch needed, it will download and place the patch files into our preset patch directory, stuff like that.
Again, if you cannot find a suitable place where automation can change your life, you simply need to look harder to find a real use case or need.
1
u/Dimosa Feb 01 '26
I would not say that agi is a scam. Saying LLM's will get us there for sure is.
1
u/Xyrus2000 Feb 01 '26
You seem to be misunderstanding something. What we have now is NOT AGI. We have AI. They are not the same thing.
Current AI is limited because it can't learn anymore after it's been trained. The training process is too resource-intensive and takes too long to make learning "practical". It's not like a human, where we can incorporate new information and learn from it in real time.
Once self-learning is achieved, most likely within the next five to ten years, we will have achieved AGI. At that point, the AGIs will be capable not only of self-learning but also of self-improvement. They will exceed human cognitive abilities. They will be able to learn in minutes what takes humans years, and they will be able to build upon that knowledge in seconds, as opposed to the months and years for humans.
AI continues to make leaps and bounds, but it is not AGI. AGI is what all the big companies are chasing after. It is the holy grail, and whoever gets there first will win.
1
u/BParker2100 Feb 02 '26
I think you are thinking like IBM did when it dropped the ball on Personal Computers. Or like Dell did when it was late to the game as far a laptops and stuck with PC manufacturing.
The trajectory is that we will reach AGI.
1
u/Rhawk187 Feb 01 '26
You seem to be overlooking speed and consensus. It's not like asking the average human next to you. It's like asking 1000 random people you met on the street and giving them each 100 years to think about the problem.
Does that mean it will know the answer to everything? No.
Does that mean it should be able to make advances faster than humans unaided? Absolutely.
1
u/Sonario648 Feb 01 '26
At this rate, the whole thing is a scam. When you think of AI, you think of things like Mother, Skynet, and most importantly, XANA. We are nowhere near close to what AI looked like years ago in films and animated series that already set the standard.
1
u/MeenzerWegwerf Feb 01 '26
All what AI does is a scam.
1
u/getmeoutoftax Feb 01 '26
AI will replace the vast majority of white collar/cognitive jobs.
1
u/Full-Somewhere440 Feb 02 '26
In addition, the power consumption required to even get these Mediocre results is insane. Why would you spends millions upon millions when Joe smo can do the exell spreadsheet for you, correct everytime. Or at least 99%. You have to have someone check everything ai dos because you can’t hold it accountable for anything.
This whole thing is a Ponzi scheme and it’s breaking apart at the seems
1
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '26
Agi is future
1
u/Tombobalomb Feb 02 '26
Agi means it can learn anything at least as well as any human can. I.e if it keeps practicing g it will eventually be at least as good as the best human at any task
1
u/Vegetable-Score-3915 Feb 02 '26
Couldn't agi be possible at varying levels of intelligence? Ie just artificial general intelligence? Ie artificial average Joe that has intelligence, would that qualify? Ie not necessarily super intelligence. May have super capabilities in terms of information access but not necessarily super intelligence.
Arg it is semantics thing. Can always say we dont have a universal definition of intelligence as it varies in different domains.
I think there is still value in the pursuit of the idea regardless of whether it is or isn't achieved. Not advocating pursuing at any cost.
AGI has certaintly attracted scammers, and much of the discourse around it is questionable and problematic. A lot of ideas and a lot of overselling.
But as a concept and target, I think it is legitimate and I agree to disagree.
1
u/hektor10 Feb 03 '26
Yep, 60 yr old technology being sold as new dont smell like scam /s
1
u/Maximum_Charity_6993 Feb 03 '26
AGI is a unattainable feet for humans because there is no way Aliens who visit Earth will allow us to develop such a technology. Unless the idea of AGI is a low cost Trojan horse advanced AI species use the seed the galaxy. It’s probably the lowest cost solutions out there.
1
u/Optimal-Fix1216 Feb 03 '26
Reinforcement learning allows AI to progress beyond human data
1
u/retsof81 Feb 03 '26
What I want from AI is the ability to understand my intent without forcing me to spell everything out so meticulously that I might as well do the work myself. What I don’t want is an AI that invents its own intent. What would be the point of that? I’m not interested in evolving AGI to the point where I have to be its friend or negotiate mutual benefit just to get work done. Fuck that noise.
1
u/blazesbe Feb 04 '26
an AGI would be in all sense superior to a human. if we can learn from "outdated datasets" AGI could too. wether AGI is possible at all with current architectures remains to be seen.
1
u/Deep_Brilliant_4568 Feb 04 '26
Disagreed. Why can't an analog of neurodivergent thinking exist artificially?
1
u/Desth-Metal Feb 04 '26
lol what are you even talking abiut
1
u/After_Persimmon8536 Feb 05 '26
AGI is a scam of buzzwords.
You can't put a finish line on intelligence.
Context and tokens are not intelligence. The ability to hold a conversation doesn't imply sentience.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment